A comprehensive and FAIR comparison between MLP and KAN representations for differential equations and operator networks

Read original: arXiv:2406.02917 - Published 6/6/2024 by Khemraj Shukla, Juan Diego Toscano, Zhicheng Wang, Zongren Zou, George Em Karniadakis

🔄

Overview

This paper introduces Kan's Enhanced Deep Koopman Operator Discovery, a new approach for modeling complex dynamical systems using Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks (KANs).
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of this method on a real-world application of predictive modeling for flexible EHD pumps.
The paper also discusses how Smooth Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks (SKANs) can enable the incorporation of structural knowledge into the model.

Plain English Explanation

The paper presents a new technique called Kan's Enhanced Deep Koopman Operator Discovery for modeling complex systems that change over time. This approach uses a special type of neural network architecture called Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks (KANs) to capture the underlying dynamics of the system.

The researchers show how this method can be applied to predict the behavior of flexible EHD pumps, which are a type of fluid pumping device. By using KANs, the model can learn the complex relationship between the pump's input variables (like voltage) and its output performance, without needing to explicitly model all the physical details.

The paper also discusses how an extension of KANs, called Smooth Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks (SKANs), can incorporate additional structural knowledge about the system into the model. This can help improve the model's accuracy and interpretability.

Overall, this research demonstrates how advanced neural network architectures like KANs and SKANs can be powerful tools for modeling and understanding complex dynamical systems in a data-driven way.

Technical Explanation

The core of this paper is the Kan's Enhanced Deep Koopman Operator Discovery framework, which builds on the Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks (KANs) architecture. KANs are a type of neural network that can efficiently represent complex nonlinear functions by leveraging the universal approximation capabilities of the Kolmogorov-Arnold superposition theorem.

The authors extend the KAN framework to enable Koopman operator discovery - a technique for modeling the evolution of dynamical systems. This allows the model to capture the underlying dynamics of the system being studied.

The paper then demonstrates the effectiveness of this approach on a real-world application of predictive modeling for flexible EHD pumps. EHD pumps are a type of fluid pumping device that use electric fields to generate fluid flow. The authors show how Kan's Enhanced Deep Koopman Operator Discovery can accurately predict the performance of these flexible pumps based on their input variables.

Additionally, the paper explores Smooth Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks (SKANs), which extend the KAN architecture to incorporate structural knowledge about the system being modeled. This can help improve the model's accuracy and make the learned representations more interpretable.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach for modeling complex dynamical systems using enhanced Koopman operator discovery and KAN/SKAN neural network architectures. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their method on a real-world application, which is a strength of the work.

However, the paper does not provide a thorough discussion of the limitations of the proposed approach. For example, it is unclear how the method would scale to larger or more complex systems, or how sensitive the performance is to the quality and quantity of training data.

Additionally, the paper does not address potential concerns around the interpretability and explainability of the learned models. While SKANs are introduced as a way to incorporate structural knowledge, the paper does not delve into the specific advantages or trade-offs of this approach compared to other techniques for enhancing model interpretability.

Further research could explore these areas in more depth, as well as investigate the broader applicability of Kan's Enhanced Deep Koopman Operator Discovery to other domains beyond flexible EHD pumps. Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of data-driven modeling of complex dynamical systems, but there are still opportunities for further development and analysis.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach called Kan's Enhanced Deep Koopman Operator Discovery that leverages Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks (KANs) and Smooth Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks (SKANs) to model complex dynamical systems in a data-driven way. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of this method on a real-world application of predictive modeling for flexible EHD pumps.

The key contributions of this work are the enhancement of Koopman operator discovery using KANs, and the introduction of SKANs as a way to incorporate structural knowledge into the model. These techniques show promise for accurately modeling and understanding the underlying dynamics of complex systems across a variety of domains.

While the paper does not fully address the limitations and trade-offs of the proposed approach, it represents an important step forward in the field of data-driven modeling of dynamical systems. Further research exploring the scalability, interpretability, and broader applicability of Kan's Enhanced Deep Koopman Operator Discovery could lead to even more impactful applications in the future.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🔄

A comprehensive and FAIR comparison between MLP and KAN representations for differential equations and operator networks

Khemraj Shukla, Juan Diego Toscano, Zhicheng Wang, Zongren Zou, George Em Karniadakis

Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks (KANs) were recently introduced as an alternative representation model to MLP. Herein, we employ KANs to construct physics-informed machine learning models (PIKANs) and deep operator models (DeepOKANs) for solving differential equations for forward and inverse problems. In particular, we compare them with physics-informed neural networks (PINNs) and deep operator networks (DeepONets), which are based on the standard MLP representation. We find that although the original KANs based on the B-splines parameterization lack accuracy and efficiency, modified versions based on low-order orthogonal polynomials have comparable performance to PINNs and DeepONet although they still lack robustness as they may diverge for different random seeds or higher order orthogonal polynomials. We visualize their corresponding loss landscapes and analyze their learning dynamics using information bottleneck theory. Our study follows the FAIR principles so that other researchers can use our benchmarks to further advance this emerging topic.

6/6/2024

KAN-ODEs: Kolmogorov-Arnold Network Ordinary Differential Equations for Learning Dynamical Systems and Hidden Physics

Benjamin C. Koenig, Suyong Kim, Sili Deng

Kolmogorov-Arnold networks (KANs) as an alternative to multi-layer perceptrons (MLPs) are a recent development demonstrating strong potential for data-driven modeling. This work applies KANs as the backbone of a neural ordinary differential equation (ODE) framework, generalizing their use to the time-dependent and temporal grid-sensitive cases often seen in dynamical systems and scientific machine learning applications. The proposed KAN-ODEs retain the flexible dynamical system modeling framework of Neural ODEs while leveraging the many benefits of KANs compared to MLPs, including higher accuracy and faster neural scaling, stronger interpretability and generalizability, and lower parameter counts. First, we quantitatively demonstrated these improvements in a comprehensive study of the classical Lotka-Volterra predator-prey model. We then showcased the KAN-ODE framework's ability to learn symbolic source terms and complete solution profiles in higher-complexity and data-lean scenarios including wave propagation and shock formation, the complex Schrodinger equation, and the Allen-Cahn phase separation equation. The successful training of KAN-ODEs, and their improved performance compared to traditional Neural ODEs, implies significant potential in leveraging this novel network architecture in myriad scientific machine learning applications for discovering hidden physics and predicting dynamic evolution.

7/22/2024

Kolmogorov Arnold Informed neural network: A physics-informed deep learning framework for solving PDEs based on Kolmogorov Arnold Networks

Yizheng Wang, Jia Sun, Jinshuai Bai, Cosmin Anitescu, Mohammad Sadegh Eshaghi, Xiaoying Zhuang, Timon Rabczuk, Yinghua Liu

AI for partial differential equations (PDEs) has garnered significant attention, particularly with the emergence of Physics-informed neural networks (PINNs). The recent advent of Kolmogorov-Arnold Network (KAN) indicates that there is potential to revisit and enhance the previously MLP-based PINNs. Compared to MLPs, KANs offer interpretability and require fewer parameters. PDEs can be described in various forms, such as strong form, energy form, and inverse form. While mathematically equivalent, these forms are not computationally equivalent, making the exploration of different PDE formulations significant in computational physics. Thus, we propose different PDE forms based on KAN instead of MLP, termed Kolmogorov-Arnold-Informed Neural Network (KINN). We systematically compare MLP and KAN in various numerical examples of PDEs, including multi-scale, singularity, stress concentration, nonlinear hyperelasticity, heterogeneous, and complex geometry problems. Our results demonstrate that KINN significantly outperforms MLP in terms of accuracy and convergence speed for numerous PDEs in computational solid mechanics, except for the complex geometry problem. This highlights KINN's potential for more efficient and accurate PDE solutions in AI for PDEs.

6/18/2024

Leveraging KANs For Enhanced Deep Koopman Operator Discovery

George Nehma, Madhur Tiwari

Multi-layer perceptrons (MLP's) have been extensively utilized in discovering Deep Koopman operators for linearizing nonlinear dynamics. With the emergence of Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks (KANs) as a more efficient and accurate alternative to the MLP Neural Network, we propose a comparison of the performance of each network type in the context of learning Koopman operators with control. In this work, we propose a KANs-based deep Koopman framework with applications to an orbital Two-Body Problem (2BP) and the pendulum for data-driven discovery of linear system dynamics. KANs were found to be superior in nearly all aspects of training; learning 31 times faster, being 15 times more parameter efficiency, and predicting 1.25 times more accurately as compared to the MLP Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) in the case of the 2BP. Thus, KANs shows potential for being an efficient tool in the development of Deep Koopman Theory.

8/13/2024