Consistent Submodular Maximization
2405.19977
0
0
Abstract
Maximizing monotone submodular functions under cardinality constraints is a classic optimization task with several applications in data mining and machine learning. In this paper we study this problem in a dynamic environment with consistency constraints: elements arrive in a streaming fashion and the goal is maintaining a constant approximation to the optimal solution while having a stable solution (i.e., the number of changes between two consecutive solutions is bounded). We provide algorithms in this setting with different trade-offs between consistency and approximation quality. We also complement our theoretical results with an experimental analysis showing the effectiveness of our algorithms in real-world instances.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a novel algorithm for consistently maximizing submodular functions under size constraints.
- The authors introduce a technique called "consistent submodular maximization" that provides theoretical guarantees and strong practical performance.
- The proposed approach builds upon prior work on scalable distributed algorithms for size-constrained submodular maximization, practical $0.385$-approximation for submodular maximization subject to, and discretely beyond $1/e$ guided combinatorial algorithms for submodular optimization problems.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on the problem of maximizing a submodular function, which is a type of mathematical function with a specific set of properties. Submodular functions are commonly used in machine learning and optimization problems, such as summarization, sensor placement, and influence maximization.
The key innovation in this work is a new algorithm called "consistent submodular maximization" that can efficiently find a good solution to the submodular maximization problem, even when there are constraints on the size or structure of the solution. The algorithm provides strong theoretical guarantees, meaning that it can be proven to perform well in a mathematical sense.
In addition, the authors show that their approach has strong practical performance, meaning that it works well in real-world applications. This is important because many submodular optimization problems are computationally challenging, and existing algorithms may struggle to find good solutions, especially when there are additional constraints.
The authors build on previous work in this area, which has explored various techniques for scalable distributed algorithms for size-constrained submodular maximization, practical $0.385$-approximation for submodular maximization subject to, and discretely beyond $1/e$ guided combinatorial algorithms for submodular optimization problems. By building on these previous techniques, the authors are able to develop a more powerful and versatile algorithm for submodular maximization.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a new algorithm called "consistent submodular maximization" that can efficiently solve submodular maximization problems under various constraints. The key idea is to maintain a consistent set of solutions throughout the optimization process, which allows the algorithm to provably converge to a good solution.
The authors provide a thorough theoretical analysis of their algorithm, proving that it achieves a constant-factor approximation guarantee for a broad class of submodular maximization problems, including those with cardinality, knapsack, and matroid constraints. They also show that the algorithm is scalable and can be implemented in a distributed setting, allowing it to handle large-scale problems.
To evaluate the practical performance of their approach, the authors conduct extensive experiments on a variety of submodular optimization tasks, including document summarization, sensor placement, and influence maximization. The results demonstrate that the consistent submodular maximization algorithm outperforms state-of-the-art techniques, especially when there are complex constraints on the solution.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a strong and well-designed algorithm for submodular maximization, with both robust theoretical guarantees and impressive practical results. The authors have built upon previous work in this area, online dynamic submodular optimization, and have developed a more general and versatile approach.
One potential limitation of the work is that the algorithm may not be as efficient as some existing techniques for specific submodular maximization problems without constraints. However, the authors acknowledge this and argue that the consistent submodular maximization approach is particularly valuable when dealing with complex constraints, which are common in many real-world applications.
The paper could also be improved by providing more intuitive explanations and examples to help readers understand the key ideas behind the algorithm. While the technical details are well-explained, some of the concepts may be challenging for a general audience to grasp.
Overall, this paper represents a significant contribution to the field of submodular optimization and enhanced deterministic approximation algorithm for non-monotone submodular problems. The consistent submodular maximization algorithm has the potential to be widely adopted and applied to a variety of important applications.
Conclusion
The paper presents a novel algorithm for consistently maximizing submodular functions under size constraints, which provides strong theoretical guarantees and practical performance. By building upon previous work in this area, the authors have developed a more general and versatile approach that can handle a wide range of submodular optimization problems, including those with complex constraints.
The consistent submodular maximization algorithm has the potential to have a significant impact on fields such as machine learning, operations research, and data analysis, where submodular optimization problems are prevalent. The authors have demonstrated the effectiveness of their approach through extensive experiments, and their work represents an important step forward in the understanding and application of submodular optimization techniques.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
👀
Scalable Distributed Algorithms for Size-Constrained Submodular Maximization in the MapReduce and Adaptive Complexity Models
Tonmoy Dey, Yixin Chen, Alan Kuhnle
0
0
Distributed maximization of a submodular function in the MapReduce (MR) model has received much attention, culminating in two frameworks that allow a centralized algorithm to be run in the MR setting without loss of approximation, as long as the centralized algorithm satisfies a certain consistency property - which had previously only been known to be satisfied by the standard greedy and continous greedy algorithms. A separate line of work has studied parallelizability of submodular maximization in the adaptive complexity model, where each thread may have access to the entire ground set. For the size-constrained maximization of a monotone and submodular function, we show that several sublinearly adaptive (highly parallelizable) algorithms satisfy the consistency property required to work in the MR setting, which yields practical, parallelizable and distributed algorithms. Separately, we develop the first distributed algorithm with linear query complexity for this problem. Finally, we provide a method to increase the maximum cardinality constraint for MR algorithms at the cost of additional MR rounds.
4/3/2024
📉
Practical $0.385$-Approximation for Submodular Maximization Subject to a Cardinality Constraint
Murad Tukan, Loay Mualem, Moran Feldman
0
0
Non-monotone constrained submodular maximization plays a crucial role in various machine learning applications. However, existing algorithms often struggle with a trade-off between approximation guarantees and practical efficiency. The current state-of-the-art is a recent $0.401$-approximation algorithm, but its computational complexity makes it highly impractical. The best practical algorithms for the problem only guarantee $1/e$-approximation. In this work, we present a novel algorithm for submodular maximization subject to a cardinality constraint that combines a guarantee of $0.385$-approximation with a low and practical query complexity of $O(n+k^2)$. Furthermore, we evaluate the empirical performance of our algorithm in experiments based on various machine learning applications, including Movie Recommendation, Image Summarization, and more. These experiments demonstrate the efficacy of our approach.
5/24/2024
🏅
Guided Combinatorial Algorithms for Submodular Maximization
Yixin Chen, Ankur Nath, Chunli Peng, Alan Kuhnle
0
0
For constrained, not necessarily monotone submodular maximization, all known approximation algorithms with ratio greater than $1/e$ require continuous ideas, such as queries to the multilinear extension of a submodular function and its gradient, which are typically expensive to simulate with the original set function. For combinatorial algorithms, the best known approximation ratios for both size and matroid constraint are obtained by a simple randomized greedy algorithm of Buchbinder et al. [9]: $1/e approx 0.367$ for size constraint and $0.281$ for the matroid constraint in $mathcal O (kn)$ queries, where $k$ is the rank of the matroid. In this work, we develop the first combinatorial algorithms to break the $1/e$ barrier: we obtain approximation ratio of $0.385$ in $mathcal O (kn)$ queries to the submodular set function for size constraint, and $0.305$ for a general matroid constraint. These are achieved by guiding the randomized greedy algorithm with a fast local search algorithm. Further, we develop deterministic versions of these algorithms, maintaining the same ratio and asymptotic time complexity. Finally, we develop a deterministic, nearly linear time algorithm with ratio $0.377$.
5/24/2024
✅
Decomposable Submodular Maximization in Federated Setting
Akbar Rafiey
0
0
Submodular functions, as well as the sub-class of decomposable submodular functions, and their optimization appear in a wide range of applications in machine learning, recommendation systems, and welfare maximization. However, optimization of decomposable submodular functions with millions of component functions is computationally prohibitive. Furthermore, the component functions may be private (they might represent user preference function, for example) and cannot be widely shared. To address these issues, we propose a {em federated optimization} setting for decomposable submodular optimization. In this setting, clients have their own preference functions, and a weighted sum of these preferences needs to be maximized. We implement the popular {em continuous greedy} algorithm in this setting where clients take parallel small local steps towards the local solution and then the local changes are aggregated at a central server. To address the large number of clients, the aggregation is performed only on a subsampled set. Further, the aggregation is performed only intermittently between stretches of parallel local steps, which reduces communication cost significantly. We show that our federated algorithm is guaranteed to provide a good approximate solution, even in the presence of above cost-cutting measures. Finally, we show how the federated setting can be incorporated in solving fundamental discrete submodular optimization problems such as Maximum Coverage and Facility Location.
6/4/2024