Correlated Noise Provably Beats Independent Noise for Differentially Private Learning

Overview

• Differentially private learning algorithms add noise to the learning process to protect privacy
• The most common algorithm, DP-SGD, uses independent Gaussian noise, but recent work has shown that introducing correlations in the noise can greatly improve utility
• This paper characterizes the asymptotic learning utility for any choice of the noise correlation function, providing precise analytical bounds for linear regression and general convex functions
• The analysis shows how correlated noise can provably improve upon vanilla DP-SGD, and provides an efficient way to compute the near-optimal correlation function

Plain English Explanation

Differentially private learning algorithms add a controlled amount of noise to the learning process to protect the privacy of the data used for training. The most common private learning algorithm, called DP-SGD, adds independent Gaussian noise to the updates in each iteration. However, recent research has found that introducing correlations in the noise can significantly improve the utility of the learning process.

This paper provides a mathematical analysis of how different choices of the noise correlation function affect the learning utility. It gives precise analytical bounds on the performance for linear regression problems, as well as a convex optimization approach for more general convex functions. The analysis shows that using the right noise correlations can provably outperform the standard DP-SGD approach, depending on problem characteristics like the effective dimension and condition number.

Importantly, the paper also provides an efficient way to compute the near-optimal noise correlation function, avoiding the high computational cost of previous approaches. This makes it practical to deploy these more advanced noise mechanisms in real-world applications, like private deep learning.

Technical Explanation

The key technical contribution of this paper is a characterization of the asymptotic learning utility for differentially private learning algorithms with correlated noise. Rather than using independent Gaussian noise like in standard DP-SGD, the paper considers the case where the noise is correlated across iterations.

For linear regression, the authors provide precise analytical bounds on the learning utility as a function of the noise correlation function. They show how to optimize this correlation function to provably outperform vanilla DP-SGD, as a function of problem parameters like the effective dimension and condition number.

For more general convex functions, the authors formulate the problem of finding the optimal noise correlations as a convex program, which can be efficiently solved. This avoids the high computational cost of previous approaches that relied on semi-definite programming to optimize the noise correlation matrix.

The paper validates the theoretical results through experiments on private deep learning tasks, demonstrating that the proposed approach can match or outperform prior work while being more efficient in terms of both computational and memory requirements.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a strong theoretical analysis and empirical validation of the benefits of using correlated noise in differentially private learning algorithms. However, it is important to note that the analysis assumes an asymptotic regime, where the number of training iterations goes to infinity. In practice, the performance may differ for finite-time learning, which is an area for further research.

Additionally, the paper focuses on the centralized setting, where a single entity controls the entire learning process. Extending these techniques to the decentralized, federated learning setting introduces additional challenges that are not addressed in this work.

It would also be valuable to better understand the robustness of these correlated noise mechanisms to model misspecification or distribution shift, as real-world applications may not perfectly match the assumptions made in the theoretical analysis.

Conclusion

This paper presents an important advance in the field of differentially private machine learning, by showing how the use of correlated noise can significantly improve the utility of private learning algorithms. The theoretical analysis and experimental results demonstrate that these techniques can outperform the standard DP-SGD approach, while remaining computationally efficient.

The insights from this work have the potential to unlock more accurate and privacy-preserving machine learning models, with applications in a wide range of domains where data privacy is paramount. As the field of differentially private learning continues to evolve, further research building on these ideas could lead to even more powerful and practical privacy-preserving techniques.