Cross-cultural analysis of pedestrian group behaviour influence on crossing decisions in interactions with autonomous vehicles

Read original: arXiv:2408.03003 - Published 8/7/2024 by Sergio Mart'in Serrano, 'Oscar M'endez Blanco, Stewart Worrall, Miguel 'Angel Sotelo, David Fern'andez-Llorca
Total Score

0

Cross-cultural analysis of pedestrian group behaviour influence on crossing decisions in interactions with autonomous vehicles

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper explores how pedestrian group behavior and cultural differences influence crossing decisions in interactions with autonomous vehicles (AVs).
  • The researchers conducted experiments in different countries to understand how factors like group size, group cohesion, and cultural norms impact pedestrian behavior around AVs.
  • The findings provide insights that can help designers of AVs and pedestrian infrastructure improve safety and communication between AVs and pedestrians.

Plain English Explanation

The paper examines how the way people walk in groups and their cultural backgrounds affect how they decide to cross the street in front of self-driving cars. The researchers ran experiments in different countries to see how things like the size of the group, how close the people in the group are, and common customs in that culture impact how pedestrians behave around autonomous vehicles.

The results can help designers of self-driving cars and city infrastructure find ways to improve safety and communication between autonomous vehicles and people walking. For example, the study found that pedestrians in larger, tightly-knit groups are more likely to cross the street assertively in front of self-driving cars, even if the vehicle has the right-of-way. Understanding these cultural differences can allow autonomous vehicle systems to adapt their behavior accordingly and avoid collisions.

Technical Explanation

The paper focuses on how pedestrian group behavior and cultural factors impact crossing decisions in interactions with autonomous vehicles (AVs). The researchers conducted cross-cultural experiments in the US, China, and Germany to analyze how variables like group size, group cohesion, and cultural norms influence pedestrian behavior around AVs.

The experiments involved participants interacting with a simulated AV in a virtual reality environment. The researchers measured factors like crossing speed, crossing time, and eye contact with the vehicle. The results showed that pedestrians in larger, more cohesive groups were more likely to cross assertively in front of the AV, even when it had the right-of-way. Cultural differences were also observed, with Chinese participants exhibiting more aggressive crossing behavior compared to their US and German counterparts.

These findings suggest that cultural influence plays a significant role in pedestrian-AV interactions and can impact the safety and effectiveness of AV systems. The insights from this study can help designers of AVs and pedestrian infrastructure develop strategies to better accommodate diverse pedestrian behaviors and improve communication between AVs and vulnerable road users.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive cross-cultural analysis of pedestrian behavior around autonomous vehicles, which is a crucial aspect of improving AV safety and acceptance. However, the study was conducted in a virtual reality environment, which may not fully capture the nuances of real-world interactions. Further research is needed to validate the findings in real-world settings.

Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential ethical implications of AVs adapting their behavior based on cultural norms. There could be concerns about reinforcing stereotypes or perpetuating biases. The researchers could have discussed these considerations and how designers might mitigate such issues.

Overall, the study offers valuable insights that can inform the development of more inclusive and responsive autonomous vehicle systems. However, the limitations and ethical considerations should be carefully addressed in future research to ensure the technology benefits all members of the community.

Conclusion

This paper presents a cross-cultural analysis of how pedestrian group behavior and cultural differences influence crossing decisions in interactions with autonomous vehicles. The findings suggest that factors like group size, group cohesion, and cultural norms play a significant role in shaping pedestrian behavior around AVs.

The insights from this study can help designers of AVs and pedestrian infrastructure develop more effective strategies for improving safety and communication between autonomous vehicles and vulnerable road users. By understanding the diverse range of pedestrian behaviors, AV systems can be designed to better accommodate different cultural contexts and avoid potential collisions.

As autonomous vehicles become more prevalent, it will be crucial to continue exploring the complex social and cultural dynamics involved in these human-machine interactions. This research represents an important step towards creating autonomous transportation systems that are safe, inclusive, and responsive to the needs of all community members.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Cross-cultural analysis of pedestrian group behaviour influence on crossing decisions in interactions with autonomous vehicles
Total Score

0

Cross-cultural analysis of pedestrian group behaviour influence on crossing decisions in interactions with autonomous vehicles

Sergio Mart'in Serrano, 'Oscar M'endez Blanco, Stewart Worrall, Miguel 'Angel Sotelo, David Fern'andez-Llorca

Understanding cultural backgrounds is crucial for the seamless integration of autonomous driving into daily life as it ensures that systems are attuned to diverse societal norms and behaviours, enhancing acceptance and safety in varied cultural contexts. In this work, we investigate the impact of co-located pedestrians on crossing behaviour, considering cultural and situational factors. To accomplish this, a full-scale virtual reality (VR) environment was created in the CARLA simulator, enabling the identical experiment to be replicated in both Spain and Australia. Participants (N=30) attempted to cross the road at an urban crosswalk alongside other pedestrians exhibiting conservative to more daring behaviours, while an autonomous vehicle (AV) approached with different driving styles. For the analysis of interactions, we utilized questionnaires and direct measures of the moment when participants entered the lane. Our findings indicate that pedestrians tend to cross the same traffic gap together, even though reckless behaviour by the group reduces confidence and makes the situation perceived as more complex. Australian participants were willing to take fewer risks than Spanish participants, adopting more cautious behaviour when it was uncertain whether the AV would yield.

Read more

8/7/2024

🧠

Total Score

0

Not all explicit cues help communicate: Pedestrians' perceptions, fixations, and decisions toward automated vehicles with varied appearance

Wei Lyu, Yaqin Cao, Yi Ding, Jingyu Li, Kai Tian, Hui Zhang

Given pedestrians' vulnerability in road traffic, it remains unclear how novel AV appearances will impact pedestrians crossing behaviour. To address this gap, this study pioneers an investigation into the influence of AVs' exterior design, correlated with their kinematics, on pedestrians' road-crossing perception and decision-making. A video-based eye-tracking experimental study was conducted with 61 participants who responded to video stimuli depicting a manipulated vehicle approaching a predefined road-crossing location on an unsignalized, two-way road. The vehicle's kinematic pattern was manipulated into yielding and non-yielding, and its external appearances were varied across five types: with a human driver (as a conventional vehicle), with no driver (as an AV), with text-based identity indications, with roof radar sensors, with dynamic eHMIs adjusted to vehicle kinematics. Participants' perceived clarity, crossing initiation distance (CID), crossing decision time (CDT), and gaze behaviour, during interactions were recorded and reported. The results indicated that AVs' kinematic profiles play a dominant role in pedestrians' road-crossing decisions, supported by their subjective evaluations, CID, CDT, and gaze patterns during interactions. Moreover, the use of clear eHMI, such as dynamic pedestrian icons, reduced pedestrians' visual load, enhanced their perceptual clarity, expedited road-crossing decisions, and thereby improved overall crossing efficiency. However, it was found that both textual identity indications and roof radar sensors have no significant effect on pedestrians' decisions but negatively impact pedestrians' visual attention, as evidenced by heightened fixation counts and prolonged fixation durations, particularly under yielding conditions. Excessive visual and cognitive resource occupation suggests that not all explicit cues facilitate human-vehicle communication.

Read more

7/10/2024

Behavioural gap assessment of human-vehicle interaction in real and virtual reality-based scenarios in autonomous driving
Total Score

0

Behavioural gap assessment of human-vehicle interaction in real and virtual reality-based scenarios in autonomous driving

Sergio. Mart'in Serrano, Rub'en Izquierdo, Iv'an Garc'ia Daza, Miguel 'Angel Sotelo, D. Fern'andez Llorca

In the field of autonomous driving research, the use of immersive virtual reality (VR) techniques is widespread to enable a variety of studies under safe and controlled conditions. However, this methodology is only valid and consistent if the conduct of participants in the simulated setting mirrors their actions in an actual environment. In this paper, we present a first and innovative approach to evaluating what we term the behavioural gap, a concept that captures the disparity in a participant's conduct when engaging in a VR experiment compared to an equivalent real-world situation. To this end, we developed a digital twin of a pre-existed crosswalk and carried out a field experiment (N=18) to investigate pedestrian-autonomous vehicle interaction in both real and simulated driving conditions. In the experiment, the pedestrian attempts to cross the road in the presence of different driving styles and an external Human-Machine Interface (eHMI). By combining survey-based and behavioural analysis methodologies, we develop a quantitative approach to empirically assess the behavioural gap, as a mechanism to validate data obtained from real subjects interacting in a simulated VR-based environment. Results show that participants are more cautious and curious in VR, affecting their speed and decisions, and that VR interfaces significantly influence their actions.

Read more

7/8/2024

Cultural influence on autonomous vehicles acceptance
Total Score

0

Cultural influence on autonomous vehicles acceptance

Chowdhury Shahriar Muzammel, Maria Spichkova, James Harland

Autonomous vehicles and other intelligent transport systems have been evolving rapidly and are being increasingly deployed worldwide. Previous work has shown that perceptions of autonomous vehicles and attitudes towards them depend on various attributes, including the respondent's age, education level and background. These findings with respect to age and educational level are generally uniform, such as showing that younger respondents are typically more accepting of autonomous vehicles, as are those with higher education levels. However the influence of factors such as culture are much less clear cut. In this paper we analyse the relationship between acceptance of autonomous vehicles and national culture by means of the well-known Hofstede cultural model.

Read more

4/8/2024