Cultural Reflections in Virtual Reality: The Effects of User Ethnicity in Avatar Matching Experiences on Sense of Embodiment
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
• This paper examines the effects of user ethnicity on the sense of embodiment experienced when using self-avatar matching in virtual reality (VR) experiences.
• The researchers conducted a study to explore how the visual realism and cultural representation of user-controlled avatars in VR can impact the user's subjective feelings of embodiment, agency, and presence.
• The findings provide insights into the importance of avatar customization and cultural representation in creating more inclusive and immersive VR experiences.
Plain English Explanation
When using virtual reality (VR), people often control a digital character or "avatar" that represents them in the virtual world. This research explores how the appearance and cultural representation of that avatar can affect the user's sense of being "inside" the virtual body.
Specifically, the researchers looked at whether matching the avatar's ethnicity to the user's own ethnicity impacted the user's feeling of being "embodied" in the virtual character. They wanted to understand how the realism and cultural representation of the avatar influenced the user's overall sense of presence and agency in the VR experience.
The results suggest that using a self-matched avatar - one that visually resembles the user - can enhance the user's subjective feelings of embodiment. This indicates the importance of allowing users to customize their avatars in ways that reflect their own identity and cultural background. Providing this level of personalization could lead to more immersive and inclusive VR experiences.
Technical Explanation
The study used a between-subjects experimental design, where participants were randomly assigned to one of two avatar conditions - either a self-matched avatar (matching the participant's ethnicity) or a mismatched avatar. All participants then completed a series of tasks in a virtual environment while their sense of embodiment, agency, and presence were measured using subjective questionnaires.
The researchers found that participants reported a significantly stronger sense of embodiment when using the self-matched avatar compared to the mismatched avatar. This suggests that the visual realism and cultural representation of the avatar played an important role in how participants experienced their virtual body.
Interestingly, the study also revealed that the level of avatar realism (i.e., photorealistic vs. stylized) did not have a significant impact on embodiment. This indicates that the cultural relevance of the avatar may be more important than pure visual fidelity in eliciting a strong sense of embodiment.
Critical Analysis
The study provides valuable insights into the importance of avatar customization and cultural representation in VR experiences. However, the research is limited in scope, as it only examined a binary comparison between ethnically matched and mismatched avatars. Future research could explore a more nuanced range of avatar representations to better understand the specific design factors that contribute to embodiment.
Additionally, the study relied on self-reported measures of embodiment, agency, and presence, which can be subjective and influenced by various biases. Incorporating more objective physiological or behavioral measures could strengthen the validity of the findings.
It would also be interesting to see how these results might apply to other aspects of identity, such as gender, age, or physical ability. Expanding the research to investigate the intersection of multiple identity factors could lead to a deeper understanding of the complex relationship between avatar representation and user experience in virtual environments.
Conclusion
This research highlights the significance of cultural reflections in virtual reality experiences. By demonstrating the positive impact of ethnically matched avatars on users' sense of embodiment, the study underscores the importance of providing VR experiences that are inclusive and representative of diverse user populations.
As virtual reality technology continues to advance and become more widespread, ensuring that VR environments and interactions are designed with cultural sensitivity and user personalization in mind will be crucial for creating truly immersive and engaging experiences. This research represents an important step towards that goal, laying the foundation for further exploration into the complex interplay between avatar representation and human experiences in virtual worlds.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Cultural Reflections in Virtual Reality: The Effects of User Ethnicity in Avatar Matching Experiences on Sense of Embodiment
Tiffany D. Do, Juanita Benjamin, Camille Isabella Protko, Ryan P. McMahan
Matching avatar characteristics to a user can impact sense of embodiment (SoE) in VR. However, few studies have examined how participant demographics may interact with these matching effects. We recruited a diverse and racially balanced sample of 78 participants to investigate the differences among participant groups when embodying both demographically matched and unmatched avatars. We found that participant ethnicity emerged as a significant factor, with Asian and Black participants reporting lower total SoE compared to Hispanic participants. Furthermore, we found that user ethnicity significantly influences ownership (a subscale of SoE), with Asian and Black participants exhibiting stronger effects of matched avatar ethnicity compared to White participants. Additionally, Hispanic participants showed no significant differences, suggesting complex dynamics in ethnic-racial identity. Our results also reveal significant main effects of matched avatar ethnicity and gender on SoE, indicating the importance of considering these factors in VR experiences. These findings contribute valuable insights into understanding the complex dynamics shaping VR experiences across different demographic groups.
Read more7/16/2024
🏅
0
Stepping into the Right Shoes: The Effects of User-Matched Avatar Ethnicity and Gender on Sense of Embodiment in Virtual Reality
Tiffany D. Do, Camille Isabella Protko, Ryan P. McMahan
In many consumer virtual reality (VR) applications, users embody predefined characters that offer minimal customization options, frequently emphasizing storytelling over user choice. We explore whether matching a user's physical characteristics, specifically ethnicity and gender, with their virtual self-avatar affects their sense of embodiment in VR. We conducted a 2 x 2 within-subjects experiment (n=32) with a diverse user population to explore the impact of matching or not matching a user's self-avatar to their ethnicity and gender on their sense of embodiment. Our results indicate that matching the ethnicity of the user and their self-avatar significantly enhances sense of embodiment regardless of gender, extending across various aspects, including appearance, response, and ownership. We also found that matching gender significantly enhanced ownership, suggesting that this aspect is influenced by matching both ethnicity and gender. Interestingly, we found that matching ethnicity specifically affects self-location while matching gender specifically affects one's body ownership.
Read more7/16/2024
0
Effects of Realism and Representation on Self-Embodied Avatars in Immersive Virtual Environments
Rafael Kuffner dos Anjos, Jo~ao Madeiras Pereira
Virtual Reality (VR) has recently gained traction with many new and ever more affordable devices being released. The increase in popularity of this paradigm of interaction has given birth to new applications and has attracted casual consumers to experience VR. Providing a self-embodied representation (avatar) of users' full bodies inside shared virtual spaces can improve the VR experience and make it more engaging to both new and experienced users . This is especially important in fully immersive systems, where the equipment completely occludes the real world making self awareness problematic. Indeed, the feeling of presence of the user is highly influenced by their virtual representations, even though small flaws could lead to uncanny valley side-effects. Following previous research, we would like to assess whether using a third-person perspective could also benefit the VR experience, via an improved spatial awareness of the user's virtual surroundings. In this paper we investigate realism and perspective of self-embodied representation in VR setups in natural tasks, such as walking and avoiding obstacles. We compare both First and Third-Person perspectives with three different levels of realism in avatar representation. These range from a stylized abstract avatar, to a realistic mesh-based humanoid representation and a point-cloud rendering. The latter uses data captured via depth-sensors and mapped into a virtual self inside the Virtual Environment. We present a throughout evaluation and comparison of these different representations, describing a series of guidelines for self-embodied VR applications. The effects of the uncanny valley are also discussed in the context of navigation and reflex-based tasks.
Read more5/7/2024
0
Am I the Odd One? Exploring (In)Congruencies in the Realism of Avatars and Virtual Others in Virtual Reality
David Mal, Nina Dollinger, Erik Wolf, Stephan Wenninger, Mario Botsch, Carolin Wienrich, Marc Erich Latoschik
Virtual humans play a pivotal role in social virtual environments, shaping users' VR experiences. The diversity in available options and users' preferences can result in a heterogeneous mix of appearances among a group of virtual humans. The resulting variety in higher-order anthropomorphic and realistic cues introduces multiple (in)congruencies, eventually impacting the plausibility of the experience. In this work, we consider the impact of (in)congruencies in the realism of a group of virtual humans, including co-located others and one's self-avatar. In a 2 x 3 mixed design, participants embodied either (1) a personalized realistic or (2) a customized stylized self-avatar across three consecutive VR exposures in which they were accompanied by a group of virtual others being either (1) all realistic, (2) all stylized, or (3) mixed. Our results indicate groups of virtual others of higher realism, i.e., potentially more congruent with participants' real-world experiences and expectations, were considered more human-like, increasing the feeling of co-presence and the impression of interaction possibilities. (In)congruencies concerning the homogeneity of the group did not cause considerable effects. Furthermore, our results indicate that a self-avatar's congruence with the participant's real-world experiences concerning their own physical body yielded notable benefits for virtual body ownership and self-identification for realistic personalized avatars. Notably, the incongruence between a stylized self-avatar and a group of realistic virtual others resulted in diminished ratings of self-location and self-identification. We conclude on the implications of our findings and discuss our results within current theories of VR experiences, considering (in)congruent visual cues and their impact on the perception of virtual others, self-representation, and spatial presence.
Read more6/28/2024