A Data-Driven Analysis of Vulnerable Road User Safety in Interaction with Connected Automated Vehicles
2404.14935
0
0
⛏️
Abstract
According to the World Health Organization, the involvement of Vulnerable Road Users (VRUs) in traffic accidents remains a significant concern, with VRUs accounting for over half of traffic fatalities. The increase of automation and connectivity levels of vehicles has still an uncertain impact on VRU safety. By deploying the Collective Perception Service (CPS), vehicles can include information about VRUs in Vehicle-to-Everything (V2X) messages, thus raising the general perception of the environment. Although an increased awareness is considered positive, one could argue that the awareness ratio, the metric used to measure perception, is only implicitly connected to the VRUs' safety. This paper introduces a tailored metric, the Risk Factor (RF), to measure the risk level for the interactions between Connected Automated Vehicles (CAVs) and VRUs. By evaluating the RF, we assess the impact of V2X communication on VRU risk mitigation. Our results show that high V2X penetration rates can reduce mean risk, quantified by our proposed metric, by up to 44%. Although the median risk value shows a significant decrease, suggesting a reduction in overall risk, the distribution of risk values reveals that CPS's mitigation effectiveness is overestimated, which is indicated by the divergence between RF and awareness ratio. Additionally, by analyzing a real-world traffic dataset, we pinpoint high-risk locations within a scenario, identifying areas near intersections and behind parked cars as especially dangerous. Our methodology can be ported and applied to other scenarios in order to identify high-risk areas. We value the proposed RF as an insightful metric for quantifying VRU safety in a highly automated and connected environment.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Vulnerable Road Users (VRUs) account for over half of traffic fatalities globally
- Increased vehicle automation and connectivity may have uncertain impacts on VRU safety
- Collective Perception Service (CPS) allows vehicles to share information about VRUs, but awareness alone may not directly translate to improved safety
- This paper introduces a Risk Factor (RF) metric to better measure the risk level between Connected Automated Vehicles (CAVs) and VRUs
Plain English Explanation
Vulnerable road users, such as pedestrians and cyclists, are at high risk of being involved in traffic accidents, accounting for over half of all traffic fatalities worldwide. As vehicles become more automated and connected, there is uncertainty around how this technology will impact the safety of vulnerable road users.
One proposed solution is the Collective Perception Service (CPS), which allows vehicles to share information about vulnerable road users in their vicinity through vehicle-to-everything (V2X) communication. This increased awareness of vulnerable road users is generally seen as a positive development. However, the researchers argue that the awareness ratio, a common metric used to measure perception, is only indirectly related to the actual safety of vulnerable road users.
To address this, the researchers introduce a new metric called the Risk Factor (RF), which aims to more directly measure the risk level between connected automated vehicles (CAVs) and vulnerable road users. By evaluating the RF, the researchers can assess the impact of V2X communication on mitigating the risk to vulnerable road users.
Technical Explanation
The researchers evaluated the impact of V2X communication on vulnerable road user safety by using the proposed Risk Factor (RF) metric. The RF is designed to more directly measure the risk level between CAVs and VRUs, compared to the commonly used awareness ratio.
The study found that high V2X penetration rates can reduce the mean risk, as quantified by the RF, by up to 44%. However, while the median risk value showed a significant decrease, suggesting an overall reduction in risk, the distribution of risk values revealed that the mitigation effectiveness of the CPS was overestimated, as indicated by the divergence between the RF and awareness ratio.
Additionally, the researchers analyzed a real-world traffic dataset and identified high-risk locations within the scenario, such as areas near intersections and behind parked cars, as particularly dangerous for vulnerable road users. This methodology can be applied to other scenarios to identify high-risk areas for VRUs.
The researchers emphasize the value of the proposed RF metric as an insightful way to quantify vulnerable road user safety in highly automated and connected environments, where traditional metrics may not adequately capture the nuances of risk.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge that while the CPS and V2X communication can potentially improve the overall awareness of vulnerable road users, the actual impact on their safety may be more complex. The divergence between the RF and awareness ratio suggests that increased awareness alone does not necessarily translate to a proportionate reduction in risk.
The researchers also highlight the importance of considering the distribution of risk values, as the median risk reduction may mask the fact that the CPS's mitigation effectiveness is overestimated in certain situations. This underscores the need for more nuanced and comprehensive metrics, like the proposed RF, to accurately assess the safety implications of emerging automotive technologies.
Additionally, the identification of high-risk locations, such as areas near intersections and behind parked cars, provides valuable insights that can inform the development of safer transportation infrastructure and autonomous driving algorithms. However, further research may be needed to validate the generalizability of these findings across different traffic scenarios and urban environments.
Conclusion
This research highlights the importance of moving beyond traditional metrics, like awareness ratio, to more accurately assess the safety implications of connected and automated vehicle technologies for vulnerable road users. The introduction of the Risk Factor (RF) metric represents a valuable contribution to the field, as it provides a more direct and comprehensive way to measure the risk level between CAVs and VRUs.
The findings suggest that while increased awareness through V2X communication can help mitigate risk, the actual safety benefits may be more complex and uneven. By identifying high-risk locations and challenging the assumptions behind common metrics, this research encourages a critical and nuanced approach to evaluating the real-world impact of emerging automotive technologies on vulnerable road user safety.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔎
Vulnerable Road User Detection and Safety Enhancement: A Comprehensive Survey
Renato M. Silva, Greg'orio F. Azevedo, Matheus V. V. Berto, Jean R. Rocha, Eduardo C. Fidelis, Matheus V. Nogueira, Pedro H. Lisboa, Tiago A. Almeida
0
0
Traffic incidents involving vulnerable road users (VRUs) constitute a significant proportion of global road accidents. Advances in traffic communication ecosystems, coupled with sophisticated signal processing and machine learning techniques, have facilitated the utilization of data from diverse sensors. Despite these advancements and the availability of extensive datasets, substantial progress is required to mitigate traffic casualties. This paper provides a comprehensive survey of state-of-the-art technologies and methodologies to enhance the safety of VRUs. The study delves into the communication networks between vehicles and VRUs, emphasizing the integration of advanced sensors and the availability of relevant datasets. It explores preprocessing techniques and data fusion methods to enhance sensor data quality. Furthermore, our study assesses critical simulation environments essential for developing and testing VRU safety systems. Our research also highlights recent advances in VRU detection and classification algorithms, addressing challenges such as variable environmental conditions. Additionally, we cover cutting-edge research in predicting VRU intentions and behaviors, which is crucial for proactive collision avoidance strategies. Through this survey, we aim to provide a comprehensive understanding of the current landscape of VRU safety technologies, identifying areas of progress and areas needing further research and development.
6/17/2024
Mitigating Vulnerable Road Users Occlusion Risk Via Collective Perception: An Empirical Analysis
Vincent Albert Wolff, Edmir Xhoxhi
0
0
Recent reports from the World Health Organization highlight that Vulnerable Road Users (VRUs) have been involved in over half of the road fatalities in recent years, with occlusion risk - a scenario where VRUs are hidden from drivers' view by obstacles like parked vehicles - being a critical contributing factor. To address this, we present a novel algorithm that quantifies occlusion risk based on the dynamics of both vehicles and VRUs. This algorithm has undergone testing and evaluation using a real-world dataset from German intersections. Additionally, we introduce the concept of Maximum Tracking Loss (MTL), which measures the longest consecutive duration a VRU remains untracked by any vehicle in a given scenario. Our study extends to examining the role of the Collective Perception Service (CPS) in VRU safety. CPS enhances safety by enabling vehicles to share sensor information, thereby potentially reducing occlusion risks. Our analysis reveals that a 25% market penetration of CPS-equipped vehicles can substantially diminish occlusion risks and significantly curtail MTL. These findings demonstrate how various scenarios pose different levels of risk to VRUs and how the deployment of Collective Perception can markedly improve their safety. Furthermore, they underline the efficacy of our proposed metrics to capture occlusion risk as a safety factor.
4/12/2024
🧠
Cognitive Internet of Vulnerable Road Users in Traffic: Predictive Neural Modulations of Road Crossing Intention
Xiaoshan Zhou, Carol C. Menassa, Vineet R. Kamat
0
0
Vulnerable Road Users (VRUs) present a significant challenge for road safety due to the frequent unpredictability of their behaviors. In typical Intelligent Transportation Systems, vision-based approaches supported by networked cameras are often used to anticipate VRUs motion intentions and trajectories. However, several limitations posed by occlusions and distractions set a boundary for the efficacy of such methods. To address these challenges, this study introduces a framework that leverages data collected using wearable neurophysiological sensors on VRUs to integrate them seamlessly into the Vehicle-to-Everything communication framework. This integration empowers VRUs to autonomously broadcast their intended movements to other road agents, especially autonomous vehicles, thereby bridging a critical gap in current vehicular communication systems. To validate this concept, we conducted an experiment involving 12 participants, from whom EEG signals were collected as they engaged in road-crossing decisions within simulated environments. Employing Hidden Markov Models, we identified four cognitive stages intrinsic to a pedestrian's decision-making process. Our statistical analysis further revealed significant variations in EEG activities across these stages, shedding light on the neural correlates and cognitive dynamics underpinning pedestrian road-crossing behavior. We then developed a predictive cognitive model using dynamic time warping and K-nearest neighbors algorithms, optimized through a data-driven sliding window approach. This model demonstrated high predictive accuracy, evidenced by an Area Under the Curve of 0.91, indicating its capability to anticipate pedestrian road-crossing actions approximately 1 second in advance of any pedestrian movement. This research paves the way for a novel VRU-Vehicle interaction paradigm and signifies a shift towards a forward-thinking ecosystem.
5/24/2024
🔗
Vulnerable Road User Clustering for Collective Perception Messages: Efficient Representation Through Geometric Shapes
Edmir Xhoxhi, Vincent Albert Wolff, Yao Li, Florian Alexander Schiegg
0
0
Ensuring the safety of Vulnerable Road Users (VRUs) is a critical concern in transportation, demanding significant attention from researchers and engineers. Recent advancements in Vehicle-to-Everything (V2X) technology offer promising solutions to enhance VRU safety. Notably, VRUs often travel in groups, exhibiting similar movement patterns that facilitate the formation of clusters. The standardized Collective Perception Message (CPM) and VRU Awareness Message in ETSI's Release 2 consider this clustering behavior, allowing for the description of VRU clusters. Given the constraints of narrow channel bandwidth, the selection of an appropriate geometric shape for representing a VRU cluster becomes crucial for efficient data transmission. In our study we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of different geometric shapes used to describe VRU clusters. We introduce two metrics: Cluster Accuracy (CA) and Comprehensive Area Density Information (CADI), to assess the precision and efficiency of each shape. Beyond comparing predefined shapes, we propose an adaptive algorithm that selects the preferred shape for cluster description, prioritizing accuracy while maintaining a high level of efficiency. The study culminates by demonstrating the benefits of clustering on data transmission rates. We simulate VRU movement using real-world data and the transmission of CPMs by a roadside unit. The results reveal that broadcasting cluster information, as opposed to individual object data, can reduce the data transmission volume by two-thirds on average. This finding underscores the potential of clustering in V2X communications to enhance VRU safety while optimizing network resources.
4/24/2024