Decision-Focused Learning to Predict Action Costs for Planning

Overview

• This paper introduces a novel approach called "decision-focused learning" to predict action costs for planning.
• The method aims to improve the accuracy of cost predictions by optimizing the model directly for the downstream planning task, rather than just minimizing a generic prediction loss.
• The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on several benchmark problems, showing improved planning performance compared to standard cost prediction methods.

Plain English Explanation

The paper presents a new way to train models to predict the costs of actions in planning problems. Typically, these cost prediction models are trained to minimize a general error metric, like the difference between the predicted and actual costs.

However, the authors argue that a better approach is to optimize the model

for the ultimate goal of improving planning performance. Their "decision-focused learning" technique does this by incorporating the planning algorithm into the training process.

The model is trained to make cost predictions that lead the planning algorithm to find the best overall plan, rather than just predictions that are accurate in isolation. This "decision-focused" approach results in more useful cost estimates that enhance the performance of the planning system.

The authors demonstrate their method on several standard planning benchmarks. They show that decision-focused learning outperforms traditional cost prediction approaches, leading to plans that are less costly or reach the goal more efficiently.

Technical Explanation

The key innovation in this paper is the "decision-focused learning" framework for training cost prediction models. Rather than minimizing a generic prediction loss, the authors propose optimizing the model parameters to directly improve the performance of the downstream planning algorithm.

This is achieved by incorporating the planning algorithm into the training process. The model makes cost predictions for a given problem instance, and these predictions are then fed into the planner to generate a plan. The model parameters are then updated to minimize the cost of the plan produced by the planner, rather than just the difference between predicted and actual costs.

By directly optimizing for the planning objective, the cost prediction model learns to make estimates that are tailored to the needs of the planner. This contrasts with standard approaches that train the model independently without considering how the predictions will be used.

The authors evaluate their decision-focused learning approach on several benchmark planning problems, including robot navigation and logistics tasks. They compare the planning performance achieved using their cost prediction models against those trained with traditional supervised learning. The results demonstrate consistent improvements in plan quality and efficiency when using the decision-focused models.

Critical Analysis

The decision-focused learning approach presented in this paper is a promising advance in cost prediction for planning. By directly optimizing the model for the downstream planning task, the authors are able to obtain more useful cost estimates that enhance overall planning performance.

One potential limitation is the computational overhead introduced by incorporating the planning algorithm into the training process. This may limit the scalability of the approach to very large or complex planning problems. The authors acknowledge this and suggest future work to improve the efficiency of the training procedure.

Another area for further research is the generalization of the decision-focused approach. The current paper focuses on learning cost prediction models, but the core idea could potentially be applied to other types of predictive models used in planning, such as those for predicting state transitions or goal achievement. Exploring these extensions could broaden the impact of the technique.

Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution by demonstrating the benefits of optimizing predictive models directly for their intended use in planning systems. The decision-focused learning framework represents an important step towards bridging the gap between machine learning and automated planning.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel "decision-focused learning" approach for training cost prediction models to improve planning performance. By optimizing the model parameters to directly enhance the output of the planning algorithm, rather than just minimizing a generic prediction error, the authors are able to obtain more useful cost estimates.

The decision-focused learning framework represents a promising advance in the integration of machine learning and automated planning. The authors show that their approach leads to substantial improvements in plan quality and efficiency across a range of benchmark problems.

While there are some potential limitations in terms of computational overhead, the core ideas presented in this paper could be extended to other types of predictive models used in planning. Overall, this work makes an important contribution towards bridging the gap between these two important fields of AI research.