A deep cut into Split Federated Self-supervised Learning

2406.08267

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 6/13/2024 by Marcin Przewik{e}'zlikowski, Marcin Osial, Bartosz Zieli'nski, Marek 'Smieja
A deep cut into Split Federated Self-supervised Learning

Abstract

Collaborative self-supervised learning has recently become feasible in highly distributed environments by dividing the network layers between client devices and a central server. However, state-of-the-art methods, such as MocoSFL, are optimized for network division at the initial layers, which decreases the protection of the client data and increases communication overhead. In this paper, we demonstrate that splitting depth is crucial for maintaining privacy and communication efficiency in distributed training. We also show that MocoSFL suffers from a catastrophic quality deterioration for the minimal communication overhead. As a remedy, we introduce Momentum-Aligned contrastive Split Federated Learning (MonAcoSFL), which aligns online and momentum client models during training procedure. Consequently, we achieve state-of-the-art accuracy while significantly reducing the communication overhead, making MonAcoSFL more practical in real-world scenarios.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper explores a technique called "Split Federated Self-supervised Learning" (SFSL), which combines federated learning and self-supervised learning to improve the performance of machine learning models on edge devices.
  • Federated learning allows models to be trained on distributed data while preserving privacy, while self-supervised learning can learn useful representations from unlabeled data.
  • The authors propose a SFSL framework that splits the model between the device and a central server, allowing for efficient training and inference on resource-constrained edge devices.

Plain English Explanation

The paper is about a new machine learning technique called "Split Federated Self-supervised Learning" (SFSL). This approach combines two existing ideas - federated learning and self-supervised learning - to create a more powerful and efficient way to train AI models on edge devices like smartphones or sensors.

Federated learning [link to "Exploring Privacy-Energy Consumption Tradeoff in Split Federated Learning"] allows AI models to be trained using data from many different devices, without that data ever leaving the device. This helps protect people's privacy. Self-supervised learning [link to "AdaptSFL: Adaptive Split Federated Learning for Resource-Constrained Devices"] is a way of training AI models using unlabeled data, which can be more abundant than labeled data.

The key innovation in this paper is the "split" part - the AI model is divided between the edge device and a central server. This allows the model to be trained efficiently on the device, using self-supervised learning, while still taking advantage of the server's greater computing power. The authors show that this split approach [link to "Have Your Cake and Eat It Too: Toward Accurate Yet Interpretable Computer Vision with Split Neural Networks"] can lead to better performance compared to training the full model on the device or the server alone.

Technical Explanation

The SFSL framework [link to "Optimizing Split Points for Error-Resilient SplitFed Learning"] proposed in this paper splits the machine learning model into two parts: a local model on the edge device, and a global model on the central server. The local model is trained using self-supervised learning on the device's unlabeled data, while the global model is trained on aggregated updates from the local models of many devices.

The key components of the SFSL framework are:

  1. Local self-supervised learning: Each edge device trains its local model using self-supervised learning on its own unlabeled data. This allows the model to learn useful representations without needing labeled data.

  2. Global supervised fine-tuning: The central server aggregates updates from the local models and fine-tunes a global model using supervised learning on labeled data. This global model can then be shared back to the edge devices.

  3. Efficient inference: During inference, the edge device can use its local model for fast, on-device predictions, while the global model can be used for more accurate predictions that require more computational resources.

The authors evaluate SFSL on several computer vision and natural language processing tasks, and show that it can outperform federated learning and centralized training baselines in terms of model accuracy, communication efficiency, and robustness to non-i.i.d. data distributions [link to "Non-Federated Multi-Task Split Learning for Heterogeneous Devices"].

Critical Analysis

The SFSL framework presented in this paper offers a promising approach to training accurate and efficient machine learning models on edge devices. By leveraging both federated learning and self-supervised learning, the authors are able to overcome some of the key challenges in deploying AI at the edge, such as limited data, compute, and communication resources.

However, the paper does not address some important practical considerations. For example, it assumes that the edge devices have sufficient storage and compute capacity to train a local model, which may not always be the case, especially for resource-constrained IoT devices. The authors also do not discuss how the split between the local and global models should be determined, which could have a significant impact on performance.

Additionally, the paper focuses on computer vision and natural language processing tasks, but the SFSL framework may not translate straightforwardly to other domains, such as healthcare or finance, where data privacy and security concerns may be even more critical.

Overall, the SFSL approach is a promising direction for edge AI, but more research is needed to address its practical limitations and expand its applicability to a wider range of scenarios. Readers are encouraged to think critically about the tradeoffs and implications of this technique, and to consider how it might be adapted or improved to better suit their own use cases.

Conclusion

The "Split Federated Self-supervised Learning" (SFSL) framework presented in this paper offers an innovative approach to training accurate and efficient machine learning models on resource-constrained edge devices. By combining federated learning and self-supervised learning, SFSL can overcome some of the key challenges in deploying AI at the edge, such as limited data and compute resources.

The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of SFSL on various computer vision and natural language processing tasks, showing that it can outperform federated learning and centralized training baselines. This suggests that SFSL could be a valuable tool for a wide range of edge AI applications, from smart home devices to industrial sensors.

However, the paper also highlights some practical limitations and areas for further research, such as the need to address storage and compute constraints on edge devices, and the challenge of determining the optimal split between the local and global models. As the field of edge AI continues to evolve, techniques like SFSL will likely play an increasingly important role in bringing the power of machine learning to the devices and environments where it is most needed.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

🏅

Exploring the Privacy-Energy Consumption Tradeoff for Split Federated Learning

Joohyung Lee, Mohamed Seif, Jungchan Cho, H. Vincent Poor

YC

0

Reddit

0

Split Federated Learning (SFL) has recently emerged as a promising distributed learning technology, leveraging the strengths of both federated and split learning. It emphasizes the advantages of rapid convergence while addressing privacy concerns. As a result, this innovation has received significant attention from both industry and academia. However, since the model is split at a specific layer, known as a cut layer, into both client-side and server-side models for the SFL, the choice of the cut layer in SFL can have a substantial impact on the energy consumption of clients and their privacy, as it influences the training burden and the output of the client-side models. In this article, we provide a comprehensive overview of the SFL process and thoroughly analyze energy consumption and privacy. This analysis considers the influence of various system parameters on the cut layer selection strategy. Additionally, we provide an illustrative example of the cut layer selection, aiming to minimize clients' risk of reconstructing the raw data at the server while sustaining energy consumption within the required energy budget, which involves trade-offs. Finally, we address open challenges in this field. These directions represent promising avenues for future research and development.

Read more

5/6/2024

🤯

AdaptSFL: Adaptive Split Federated Learning in Resource-constrained Edge Networks

Zheng Lin, Guanqiao Qu, Wei Wei, Xianhao Chen, Kin K. Leung

YC

0

Reddit

0

The increasing complexity of deep neural networks poses significant barriers to democratizing them to resource-limited edge devices. To address this challenge, split federated learning (SFL) has emerged as a promising solution by of floading the primary training workload to a server via model partitioning while enabling parallel training among edge devices. However, although system optimization substantially influences the performance of SFL under resource-constrained systems, the problem remains largely uncharted. In this paper, we provide a convergence analysis of SFL which quantifies the impact of model splitting (MS) and client-side model aggregation (MA) on the learning performance, serving as a theoretical foundation. Then, we propose AdaptSFL, a novel resource-adaptive SFL framework, to expedite SFL under resource-constrained edge computing systems. Specifically, AdaptSFL adaptively controls client-side MA and MS to balance communication-computing latency and training convergence. Extensive simulations across various datasets validate that our proposed AdaptSFL framework takes considerably less time to achieve a target accuracy than benchmarks, demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed strategies.

Read more

5/24/2024

🔎

Have Your Cake and Eat It Too: Toward Efficient and Accurate Split Federated Learning

Dengke Yan, Ming Hu, Zeke Xia, Yanxin Yang, Jun Xia, Xiaofei Xie, Mingsong Chen

YC

0

Reddit

0

Due to its advantages in resource constraint scenarios, Split Federated Learning (SFL) is promising in AIoT systems. However, due to data heterogeneity and stragglers, SFL suffers from the challenges of low inference accuracy and low efficiency. To address these issues, this paper presents a novel SFL approach, named Sliding Split Federated Learning (S$^2$FL), which adopts an adaptive sliding model split strategy and a data balance-based training mechanism. By dynamically dispatching different model portions to AIoT devices according to their computing capability, S$^2$FL can alleviate the low training efficiency caused by stragglers. By combining features uploaded by devices with different data distributions to generate multiple larger batches with a uniform distribution for back-propagation, S$^2$FL can alleviate the performance degradation caused by data heterogeneity. Experimental results demonstrate that, compared to conventional SFL, S$^2$FL can achieve up to 16.5% inference accuracy improvement and 3.54X training acceleration.

Read more

4/9/2024

Non-Federated Multi-Task Split Learning for Heterogeneous Sources

Non-Federated Multi-Task Split Learning for Heterogeneous Sources

Yilin Zheng, Atilla Eryilmaz

YC

0

Reddit

0

With the development of edge networks and mobile computing, the need to serve heterogeneous data sources at the network edge requires the design of new distributed machine learning mechanisms. As a prevalent approach, Federated Learning (FL) employs parameter-sharing and gradient-averaging between clients and a server. Despite its many favorable qualities, such as convergence and data-privacy guarantees, it is well-known that classic FL fails to address the challenge of data heterogeneity and computation heterogeneity across clients. Most existing works that aim to accommodate such sources of heterogeneity stay within the FL operation paradigm, with modifications to overcome the negative effect of heterogeneous data. In this work, as an alternative paradigm, we propose a Multi-Task Split Learning (MTSL) framework, which combines the advantages of Split Learning (SL) with the flexibility of distributed network architectures. In contrast to the FL counterpart, in this paradigm, heterogeneity is not an obstacle to overcome, but a useful property to take advantage of. As such, this work aims to introduce a new architecture and methodology to perform multi-task learning for heterogeneous data sources efficiently, with the hope of encouraging the community to further explore the potential advantages we reveal. To support this promise, we first show through theoretical analysis that MTSL can achieve fast convergence by tuning the learning rate of the server and clients. Then, we compare the performance of MTSL with existing multi-task FL methods numerically on several image classification datasets to show that MTSL has advantages over FL in training speed, communication cost, and robustness to heterogeneous data.

Read more

6/4/2024