Non-Federated Multi-Task Split Learning for Heterogeneous Sources
2406.00150
0
0
Abstract
With the development of edge networks and mobile computing, the need to serve heterogeneous data sources at the network edge requires the design of new distributed machine learning mechanisms. As a prevalent approach, Federated Learning (FL) employs parameter-sharing and gradient-averaging between clients and a server. Despite its many favorable qualities, such as convergence and data-privacy guarantees, it is well-known that classic FL fails to address the challenge of data heterogeneity and computation heterogeneity across clients. Most existing works that aim to accommodate such sources of heterogeneity stay within the FL operation paradigm, with modifications to overcome the negative effect of heterogeneous data. In this work, as an alternative paradigm, we propose a Multi-Task Split Learning (MTSL) framework, which combines the advantages of Split Learning (SL) with the flexibility of distributed network architectures. In contrast to the FL counterpart, in this paradigm, heterogeneity is not an obstacle to overcome, but a useful property to take advantage of. As such, this work aims to introduce a new architecture and methodology to perform multi-task learning for heterogeneous data sources efficiently, with the hope of encouraging the community to further explore the potential advantages we reveal. To support this promise, we first show through theoretical analysis that MTSL can achieve fast convergence by tuning the learning rate of the server and clients. Then, we compare the performance of MTSL with existing multi-task FL methods numerically on several image classification datasets to show that MTSL has advantages over FL in training speed, communication cost, and robustness to heterogeneous data.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Proposes a non-federated multi-task split learning approach for training models on heterogeneous data sources
- Aims to address challenges in federated learning, such as data heterogeneity and communication overhead
- Introduces a novel model architecture and training procedure to enable effective multi-task learning without federated coordination
Plain English Explanation
The research paper presents a new technique called "Non-Federated Multi-Task Split Learning for Heterogeneous Sources" to train machine learning models when the training data is spread across different organizations or devices, and the data has varying characteristics.
Federated learning is a popular approach for training models in this scenario, as it allows models to be updated without the raw data being shared. However, federated learning can be challenging when the data sources are very different, and there is a lot of communication required between the devices or organizations.
This new technique avoids the need for federated coordination by using a "split learning" approach, where part of the model is trained locally on each data source, and the rest of the model is trained centrally. This allows the model to learn from the diverse data sources without the overhead of coordinating a federated system.
The paper introduces a specific model architecture and training procedure to enable effective multi-task learning in this non-federated setting. By avoiding the federated aspects, the approach can be more efficient and practical in real-world scenarios with heterogeneous data.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a "Non-Federated Multi-Task Split Learning" (NFMT-SL) approach to train machine learning models on data from heterogeneous sources. This builds on the concept of split learning, where the model is divided into a local and a global component, and training is performed in a distributed manner.
Unlike traditional federated learning approaches, NFMT-SL does not require coordination between the different data sources. Instead, each data source trains its own local model component, while a central server coordinates the training of the global model component.
The paper introduces a novel model architecture that consists of multiple local model heads, each trained on a specific data source, and a shared global model backbone. This allows the model to learn task-specific features while also capturing common patterns across the heterogeneous data.
The training procedure alternates between local updates of the model heads and global updates of the shared backbone. This enables effective multi-task learning without the need for explicit coordination or data sharing between the data sources, as required in federated multi-task learning approaches.
The authors evaluate their NFMT-SL approach on several benchmark datasets, demonstrating its ability to outperform traditional federated learning and multi-task learning techniques in terms of model performance and communication efficiency.
Critical Analysis
The NFMT-SL approach presented in the paper addresses important challenges in federated learning, such as data heterogeneity and communication overhead. By avoiding the need for federated coordination, the technique can be more practical and scalable in real-world scenarios with diverse data sources.
However, the paper does not discuss potential limitations or drawbacks of the proposed approach. For example, it is unclear how the method would perform in the presence of unbalanced or non-i.i.d. data distributions across the data sources, which can be a common issue in federated settings.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the impact of the model architecture design choices on the overall performance. It would be valuable to understand how the specific configuration of the local model heads and global backbone affects the model's ability to capture task-specific and cross-task features.
Further research could also investigate the applicability of NFMT-SL to more complex or diverse task domains, beyond the benchmarks presented in the paper. Exploring the scalability of the approach as the number of data sources or tasks increases would also be an important area for future work.
Conclusion
The "Non-Federated Multi-Task Split Learning for Heterogeneous Sources" paper presents a novel approach to training machine learning models on data from diverse sources without the need for federated coordination. By leveraging a split learning architecture and training procedure, the technique can effectively capture task-specific and cross-task features while avoiding the challenges associated with federated learning.
The proposed NFMT-SL method has the potential to enable more practical and scalable machine learning solutions in real-world scenarios where data is distributed across heterogeneous sources. While the paper demonstrates promising results, further research is needed to fully understand the limitations and explore the wider applicability of the approach.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
FedAuxHMTL: Federated Auxiliary Hard-Parameter Sharing Multi-Task Learning for Network Edge Traffic Classification
Faisal Ahmed, Myungjin Lee, Suresh Subramaniam, Motoharu Matsuura, Hiroshi Hasegawa, Shih-Chun Lin
0
0
Federated Learning (FL) has garnered significant interest recently due to its potential as an effective solution for tackling many challenges in diverse application scenarios, for example, data privacy in network edge traffic classification. Despite its recognized advantages, FL encounters obstacles linked to statistical data heterogeneity and labeled data scarcity during the training of single-task models for machine learning-based traffic classification, leading to hindered learning performance. In response to these challenges, adopting a hard-parameter sharing multi-task learning model with auxiliary tasks proves to be a suitable approach. Such a model has the capability to reduce communication and computation costs, navigate statistical complexities inherent in FL contexts, and overcome labeled data scarcity by leveraging knowledge derived from interconnected auxiliary tasks. This paper introduces a new framework for federated auxiliary hard-parameter sharing multi-task learning, namely, FedAuxHMTL. The introduced framework incorporates model parameter exchanges between edge server and base stations, enabling base stations from distributed areas to participate in the FedAuxHMTL process and enhance the learning performance of the main task-network edge traffic classification. Empirical experiments are conducted to validate and demonstrate the FedAuxHMTL's effectiveness in terms of accuracy, total global loss, communication costs, computing time, and energy consumption compared to its counterparts.
4/15/2024
🤯
AdaptSFL: Adaptive Split Federated Learning in Resource-constrained Edge Networks
Zheng Lin, Guanqiao Qu, Wei Wei, Xianhao Chen, Kin K. Leung
0
0
The increasing complexity of deep neural networks poses significant barriers to democratizing them to resource-limited edge devices. To address this challenge, split federated learning (SFL) has emerged as a promising solution by of floading the primary training workload to a server via model partitioning while enabling parallel training among edge devices. However, although system optimization substantially influences the performance of SFL under resource-constrained systems, the problem remains largely uncharted. In this paper, we provide a convergence analysis of SFL which quantifies the impact of model splitting (MS) and client-side model aggregation (MA) on the learning performance, serving as a theoretical foundation. Then, we propose AdaptSFL, a novel resource-adaptive SFL framework, to expedite SFL under resource-constrained edge computing systems. Specifically, AdaptSFL adaptively controls client-side MA and MS to balance communication-computing latency and training convergence. Extensive simulations across various datasets validate that our proposed AdaptSFL framework takes considerably less time to achieve a target accuracy than benchmarks, demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed strategies.
5/24/2024
Heterogeneous Federated Learning with Splited Language Model
Yifan Shi, Yuhui Zhang, Ziyue Huang, Xiaofeng Yang, Li Shen, Wei Chen, Xueqian Wang
0
0
Federated Split Learning (FSL) is a promising distributed learning paradigm in practice, which gathers the strengths of both Federated Learning (FL) and Split Learning (SL) paradigms, to ensure model privacy while diminishing the resource overhead of each client, especially on large transformer models in a resource-constrained environment, e.g., Internet of Things (IoT). However, almost all works merely investigate the performance with simple neural network models in FSL. Despite the minor efforts focusing on incorporating Vision Transformers (ViT) as model architectures, they train ViT from scratch, thereby leading to enormous training overhead in each device with limited resources. Therefore, in this paper, we harness Pre-trained Image Transformers (PITs) as the initial model, coined FedV, to accelerate the training process and improve model robustness. Furthermore, we propose FedVZ to hinder the gradient inversion attack, especially having the capability compatible with black-box scenarios, where the gradient information is unavailable. Concretely, FedVZ approximates the server gradient by utilizing a zeroth-order (ZO) optimization, which replaces the backward propagation with just one forward process. Empirically, we are the first to provide a systematic evaluation of FSL methods with PITs in real-world datasets, different partial device participations, and heterogeneous data splits. Our experiments verify the effectiveness of our algorithms.
4/22/2024
🔎
Have Your Cake and Eat It Too: Toward Efficient and Accurate Split Federated Learning
Dengke Yan, Ming Hu, Zeke Xia, Yanxin Yang, Jun Xia, Xiaofei Xie, Mingsong Chen
0
0
Due to its advantages in resource constraint scenarios, Split Federated Learning (SFL) is promising in AIoT systems. However, due to data heterogeneity and stragglers, SFL suffers from the challenges of low inference accuracy and low efficiency. To address these issues, this paper presents a novel SFL approach, named Sliding Split Federated Learning (S$^2$FL), which adopts an adaptive sliding model split strategy and a data balance-based training mechanism. By dynamically dispatching different model portions to AIoT devices according to their computing capability, S$^2$FL can alleviate the low training efficiency caused by stragglers. By combining features uploaded by devices with different data distributions to generate multiple larger batches with a uniform distribution for back-propagation, S$^2$FL can alleviate the performance degradation caused by data heterogeneity. Experimental results demonstrate that, compared to conventional SFL, S$^2$FL can achieve up to 16.5% inference accuracy improvement and 3.54X training acceleration.
4/9/2024