Deep Weakly-Supervised Domain Adaptation for Pain Localization in Videos

Overview

• Automatic pain assessment can be valuable for populations unable to communicate their pain experiences.
• Facial expressions have been widely studied as a way to estimate pain intensity, but using state-of-the-art deep learning models poses challenges.
• This paper proposes a weakly-supervised domain adaptation (WSDA) technique to train 3D convolutional neural networks (CNNs) for spatio-temporal pain intensity estimation using weakly labeled videos.

Plain English Explanation

Automatically assessing pain can be very helpful for people who can't easily describe their pain, like young children or those with communication difficulties. Researchers have focused a lot on using facial expressions as a way to estimate how much pain someone is experiencing. However, using the latest deep learning models to do this in real-world situations is tricky.

The main problems are that people's facial expressions can vary a lot, the video recording conditions may not be perfect, and getting enough labeled training data is costly. To address this, the researchers developed a new weakly-supervised domain adaptation (WSDA) technique. This allows them to train 3D convolutional neural networks to estimate pain intensity levels using videos that only have partial, periodic labeling instead of full labeling for every frame.

The WSDA approach combines multiple instance learning with adversarial deep domain adaptation to train the 3D CNN model. This helps it accurately estimate pain levels even when the training data and real-world conditions are different. The results show this WSDA method outperforms other state-of-the-art approaches for both sequence-level and frame-level pain localization.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a weakly-supervised domain adaptation (WSDA) technique to train 3D convolutional neural networks (CNNs) for spatio-temporal pain intensity estimation. This addresses challenges in using state-of-the-art deep learning models for real-world pain assessment, such as subjective variations in facial expressions, imperfect recording conditions, and lack of fully labeled training data.

The WSDA approach integrates multiple instance learning into an adversarial deep domain adaptation framework to train an Inflated 3D-CNN (I3D) model. This allows the model to be trained on weakly labeled videos, where labels are only provided periodically rather than for every frame.

The training process optimizes the I3D model using a weak target loss, along with domain loss and source loss to adapt it to the target operational domain. Experiments were conducted using labeled source domain RECOLA videos and weakly-labeled target domain UNBC-McMaster videos. The results show the proposed WSDA approach achieves significantly higher sequence-level and frame-level pain localization accuracy compared to related state-of-the-art methods.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach to address the challenges of using deep learning for real-world pain assessment. The WSDA technique's ability to leverage weakly labeled data is a key strength, as acquiring fully annotated video data can be very costly and time-consuming.

However, the paper does not explore the performance limits or potential failure modes of the WSDA approach. For example, it is unclear how the method would scale to more diverse or noisier target domain data, or how robust it would be to variations in the quality or frequency of the weak labels.

Additionally, while the results show improvements over other state-of-the-art methods, the absolute performance levels are not reported. This makes it difficult to assess the practical viability of the approach for real-world deployment.

Further research could investigate the trade-offs between the degree of weak supervision and model performance, as well as strategies for source-free domain adaptation to reduce reliance on labeled source data. Evaluating the WSDA technique on a wider range of real-world pain assessment datasets would also help validate its broader applicability.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel weakly-supervised domain adaptation (WSDA) technique for training 3D convolutional neural networks to estimate pain intensity from facial expressions. By integrating multiple instance learning and adversarial deep domain adaptation, the WSDA approach can effectively leverage weakly labeled training data to achieve strong performance on pain localization tasks.

The ability to work with partially annotated videos is a significant advantage, as it reduces the cost and effort required to obtain training data. If the WSDA technique can be further refined and validated across diverse real-world scenarios, it could lead to more accessible and practical automatic pain assessment systems, with important applications for populations unable to easily communicate their pain experiences.