Demonstrating PilotAR: A Tool to Assist Wizard-of-Oz Pilot Studies with OHMD
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents PilotAR, a tool designed to assist researchers in conducting Wizard-of-Oz pilot studies with optical see-through head-mounted displays (OST-HMDs) like augmented reality (AR) smart glasses.
- PilotAR allows researchers to quickly create interactive AR experiences and control them remotely during user studies, simplifying the setup and execution of these types of evaluations.
- The tool aims to reduce the technical complexity and time required to run pilot studies with AR interfaces, making it easier for researchers to explore new interaction techniques and user experiences.
Plain English Explanation
PilotAR is a tool that helps researchers run pilot studies with augmented reality (AR) smart glasses. Pilot studies are an important step in developing new AR applications, where researchers test early prototypes with real users to gather feedback and insights. However, setting up and controlling these pilot studies can be technically complex and time-consuming.
PilotAR simplifies this process by providing an easy-to-use interface for creating interactive AR experiences and remotely controlling them during user studies. Researchers can use PilotAR to quickly build AR prototypes and then seamlessly transition between different scenarios or "scripts" as participants interact with the system. This allows them to explore a variety of interaction techniques and user experiences without getting bogged down in the technical details.
By reducing the complexity of running AR pilot studies, PilotAR aims to make it easier for researchers to experiment with new ideas and get valuable feedback from users. This can ultimately lead to the development of more innovative and effective AR applications that enhance people's lives.
Technical Explanation
PilotAR is a software tool designed to assist researchers in conducting Wizard-of-Oz pilot studies using optical see-through head-mounted displays (OST-HMDs), such as augmented reality (AR) smart glasses. The tool provides an interface for rapidly creating interactive AR experiences and remotely controlling them during user studies.
The key features of PilotAR include:
- Rapid Prototyping: Researchers can use PilotAR to quickly build AR prototypes without extensive programming knowledge or resources.
- Remote Control: The tool allows researchers to seamlessly transition between different scenarios or "scripts" during a pilot study, enabling them to explore a variety of interaction techniques and user experiences.
- Data Capture: PilotAR automatically captures user interactions, system state, and other relevant data to support analysis and evaluation.
The architecture of PilotAR consists of a client-server model, where the client runs on the participant's AR device and the server is controlled by the researcher. This setup allows the researcher to remotely manage the AR experience and respond to participant actions in real-time, mimicking the functionality of a Wizard-of-Oz study.
By simplifying the technical complexity and setup required for AR pilot studies, PilotAR aims to lower the barriers to entry for researchers exploring new interaction paradigms and user experiences in the context of heads-up computing and augmented reality.
Critical Analysis
The PilotAR tool presented in this paper addresses an important challenge in the field of augmented reality (AR) research: the difficulty of conducting Wizard-of-Oz pilot studies with optical see-through head-mounted displays (OST-HMDs). The authors have identified a significant pain point for researchers and have developed a solution that can potentially streamline the process of running these types of user studies.
One of the key strengths of PilotAR is its ability to reduce the technical complexity and setup time required for AR pilot studies. By providing an easy-to-use interface for creating interactive AR experiences and remotely controlling them, the tool can help researchers focus more on the user experience and less on the technical implementation details. This can be especially valuable for researchers who may not have extensive programming expertise or resources.
However, the paper does not provide a comprehensive evaluation of PilotAR's performance or effectiveness. While the authors mention that the tool has been used in several pilot studies, more detailed information about its usability, reliability, and impact on research outcomes would be helpful to fully assess its merits. Additionally, the paper could have explored potential limitations or challenges that may arise when using PilotAR, such as technical constraints, scalability issues, or the need for specialized hardware or software configurations.
Further research and user testing could also investigate the long-term benefits of PilotAR, particularly in terms of its impact on the quality and efficiency of AR research. Tracking the adoption and usage of the tool within the research community would be valuable to understand its broader impact and identify areas for improvement.
Conclusion
The PilotAR tool presented in this paper represents an important step towards simplifying the process of conducting Wizard-of-Oz pilot studies with augmented reality (AR) smart glasses and other optical see-through head-mounted displays (OST-HMDs). By providing an easy-to-use interface for creating interactive AR experiences and remotely controlling them during user studies, the tool has the potential to lower the barriers to entry for researchers exploring new interaction techniques and user experiences in the context of heads-up computing.
While the paper could have provided a more comprehensive evaluation and discussion of potential limitations, the core concept of PilotAR is a valuable contribution to the field of AR research. As the adoption and usage of AR technologies continue to grow, tools like PilotAR will become increasingly important in facilitating the development of innovative and user-centered AR applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Demonstrating PilotAR: A Tool to Assist Wizard-of-Oz Pilot Studies with OHMD
Nuwan Janaka, Runze Cai, Shengdong Zhao, David Hsu
While pilot studies help to identify potential interesting research directions, the additional requirements in AR/MR make it challenging to conduct quick and dirty pilot studies efficiently with Optical See-Through Head-Mounted Displays (OST HMDs, OHMDs). To overcome these challenges, including the inability to observe and record in-context user interactions, increased task load, and difficulties with in-context data analysis and discussion, we introduce PilotAR (https://github.com/Synteraction-Lab/PilotAR), a tool designed iteratively to enhance AR/MR pilot studies, allowing live first-person and third-person views, multi-modal annotations, flexible wizarding interfaces, and multi-experimenter support.
Read more7/18/2024
🤯
0
Display in the Air: Balancing Distraction and Workload in AR Glasses Interfaces for Driving Navigation
Xiangyang He, Keyuan Zhou
Augmented Reality (AR) navigation via Head-Mounted Displays (HMDs), particularly AR glasses, is revolutionizing the driving experience by integrating real-time routing information into the driver's field of view. Despite the potential of AR glasses, the question of how to display navigation information on the interface of these devices remains a valuable yet relatively unexplored research area. This study employs a mixed-method approach involving 32 participants, combining qualitative feedback from semi-structured interviews with quantitative data from usability questionnaires in both simulated and real-world scenarios. Highlighting the necessity of real-world testing, the research evaluates the impact of five icon placements on the efficiency and effectiveness of information perception in both environments. The experiment results indicate a preference for non-central icon placements, especially bottom-center in real world, which mostly balances distraction and workload for the driver. Moreover, these findings contribute to the formulation of four specific design implications for augmented reality interfaces and systems. This research advances the understanding of AR glasses in driving assistance and sets the stage for further developments in this emerging technology field.
Read more4/30/2024
🏷️
0
New!An Augmented Reality Interface for Teleoperating Robot Manipulators: Reducing Demonstrator Task Load through Digital Twin Control
Aliyah Smith, Monroe Kennedy III
Acquiring high-quality demonstration data is essential for the success of data-driven methods, such as imitation learning. Existing platforms for providing demonstrations for manipulation tasks often impose significant physical and mental demands on the demonstrator, require additional hardware systems, or necessitate specialized domain knowledge. In this work, we present a novel augmented reality (AR) interface for teleoperating robotic manipulators, emphasizing the demonstrator's experience, particularly in the context of performing complex tasks that require precision and accuracy. This interface, designed for the Microsoft HoloLens 2, leverages the adaptable nature of mixed reality (MR), enabling users to control a physical robot through digital twin surrogates. We assess the effectiveness of our approach across three complex manipulation tasks and compare its performance against OPEN TEACH, a recent virtual reality (VR) teleoperation system, as well as two traditional control methods: kinesthetic teaching and a 3D SpaceMouse for end-effector control. Our findings show that our method performs comparably to the VR approach and demonstrates the potential for AR in data collection. Additionally, we conduct a pilot study to evaluate the usability and task load associated with each method. Results indicate that our AR-based system achieves higher usability scores than the VR benchmark and significantly reduces mental demand, physical effort, and frustration experienced by users. An accompanying video can be found at https://youtu.be/w-M58ohPgrA.
Read more9/30/2024
🔍
0
MARVisT: Authoring Glyph-based Visualization in Mobile Augmented Reality
Chen Zhu-Tian, Yijia Su, Yifang Wang, Qianwen Wang, Huamin Qu, Yingcai Wu
Recent advances in mobile augmented reality (AR) techniques have shed new light on personal visualization for their advantages of fitting visualization within personal routines, situating visualization in a real-world context, and arousing users' interests. However, enabling non-experts to create data visualization in mobile AR environments is challenging given the lack of tools that allow in-situ design while supporting the binding of data to AR content. Most existing AR authoring tools require working on personal computers or manually creating each virtual object and modifying its visual attributes. We systematically study this issue by identifying the specificity of AR glyph-based visualization authoring tool and distill four design considerations. Following these design considerations, we design and implement MARVisT, a mobile authoring tool that leverages information from reality to assist non-experts in addressing relationships between data and virtual glyphs, real objects and virtual glyphs, and real objects and data. With MARVisT, users without visualization expertise can bind data to real-world objects to create expressive AR glyph-based visualizations rapidly and effortlessly, reshaping the representation of the real world with data. We use several examples to demonstrate the expressiveness of MARVisT. A user study with non-experts is also conducted to evaluate the authoring experience of MARVisT.
Read more5/14/2024