Detecting Throat Cancer from Speech Signals using Machine Learning: A Scoping Literature Review

Overview

• Throat cancer cases are increasing globally, and early detection is crucial for improving survival rates.
• Artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) have the potential to detect throat cancer from patient speech, enabling earlier diagnosis and reducing healthcare system burdens.
• However, no comprehensive review has explored the use of AI and ML for detecting throat cancer from speech.
• This review aims to evaluate the performance of these technologies and identify issues that require further research.

Plain English Explanation

This research paper examines how artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) can be used to detect throat cancer from a patient's speech. The number of throat cancer cases is increasing around the world, and catching the disease early is crucial for improving a person's chances of survival.

The researchers wanted to see how well AI and ML technologies could identify throat cancer by analyzing a patient's voice. This could lead to earlier diagnoses and reduce the strain on healthcare systems. However, no previous studies had thoroughly reviewed the research in this area.

The researchers reviewed studies from three different scientific databases to find articles that used machine learning to classify speech data, and specifically included throat cancer patients in their data. They looked at how the studies performed in terms of binary classification (healthy vs. cancer) and multi-class classification (different types of cancer).

The findings showed that there is no single method or feature that consistently outperforms others in detecting throat cancer from speech. The researchers also noted a lack of open-source code and data, which is important for other researchers to validate and build upon the results.

Technical Explanation

The researchers conducted a scoping literature review across three major databases (Scopus, Web of Science, and PubMed) to identify studies that used machine learning to classify speech data and included throat cancer patients.

They found 27 relevant articles, 12 of which performed binary classification (healthy vs. throat cancer), 13 that performed multi-class classification (differentiating between various types of throat cancer), and 2 that did both. The most common machine learning method used was neural networks, and the most frequently extracted speech feature was mel-spectrograms.

The researchers also documented the pre-processing methods and classifier performance reported in the studies. When they compared the articles against the TRIPOD-AI checklist, which evaluates the reporting quality of AI studies, they found a significant lack of open science, with only one article sharing code and three using open-access data.

Critical Analysis

The review highlights the need for more standardized methodologies and improved reproducibility in this field of research. The lack of open-source code and data is a significant limitation, as it prevents external validation and further development of the techniques.

Additionally, the review did not identify a single method or speech feature that consistently outperforms others in detecting throat cancer. This suggests that more research is needed to determine the most effective approach and to understand the specific speech characteristics that differentiate healthy individuals from those with throat cancer.

The researchers also note that future studies should focus on improving the generalizability of the models, as many of the current studies have been conducted on relatively small and homogeneous datasets. Larger, more diverse datasets would help ensure the robustness and real-world applicability of the AI and ML-based throat cancer detection methods.

Conclusion

This review highlights the potential of AI and ML to facilitate earlier diagnosis of throat cancer by analyzing patient speech. However, the field currently lacks standardized methodologies, open-source code and data, and a clear consensus on the most effective approach.

Future research should prioritize improving the reproducibility and generalizability of the techniques, as well as exploring the specific speech characteristics that are most indicative of throat cancer. By addressing these gaps, the research community can work towards developing AI and ML-based tools that can significantly improve early detection and, ultimately, patient outcomes for those with throat cancer.