Difference Autocorrelation: A Novel Approach to Estimate Shear Wave Speed in the Presence of Compression Waves

Read original: arXiv:2406.12714 - Published 6/19/2024 by Hamidreza Asemani, Jannick P. Rolland, Kevin J. Parker

📶

Overview

Presents a novel approach called the "difference autocorrelation estimator" to accurately measure the velocity of shear waves in the presence of unwanted compression waves and noise
Evaluates the effectiveness of the integrated difference autocorrelation (IDA) method through simulations and experiments using different imaging modalities
Demonstrates the robustness of IDA in estimating shear wave speed (SWS) across various scenarios, even with strong compression waves present

Plain English Explanation

The study aims to accurately measure the speed of shear waves, which can provide information about the stiffness of tissues. However, there are challenges in accurately measuring shear wave speed due to the presence of unwanted compression waves and other types of tissue motion, such as that caused by breathing. Conventional approaches often struggle to differentiate between shear and compression waves, leading to inaccurate shear wave speed estimates.

The researchers propose a new method called the "difference autocorrelation estimator" to address this issue. Unlike traditional techniques, this method computes the difference in velocity between neighboring particles, effectively minimizing the impact of long-wavelength compression waves and other wide-area movements. This allows for more accurate estimation of the shear wave speed, even in the presence of these unwanted signals.

The researchers evaluate the performance of the integrated difference autocorrelation (IDA) method using simulations, ultrasound elastography experiments on a breast phantom and in the human liver-kidney region, and magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) on a brain phantom. The results show that the IDA method can accurately estimate shear wave speed, with errors less than 2% in simulations and under 19% in the various experimental scenarios, even when the wave fields are contaminated by strong compression waves and noise.

Technical Explanation

The study presents a novel approach called the "difference autocorrelation estimator" to accurately measure the velocity of shear waves in the presence of unwanted compression waves and noise. Unlike conventional shear wave tracking methods that struggle to discriminate between shear and compression waves, the difference autocorrelation estimator computes the subtraction of velocity between neighboring particles, effectively minimizing the impact of long-wavelength compression waves and other wide-area movements.

The researchers evaluated the effectiveness of the integrated difference autocorrelation (IDA) method through the following experiments:

k-Wave simulations: A branching cylinder in a soft background was simulated to assess the IDA method's performance in the presence of compression waves and noise.
Ultrasound elastography on a breast phantom: The IDA method was applied to ultrasound elastography data collected from a breast phantom.
Ultrasound elastography in the human liver-kidney region: The IDA method was used to analyze ultrasound elastography data acquired from the liver-kidney region of human subjects.
Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) on a brain phantom: The IDA method was applied to MRE data collected from a brain phantom.

The results demonstrate that by applying the IDA method to the unfiltered, contaminated wave fields, the estimated shear wave speeds are in good agreement with the ground truth values, with less than 2% error for the simulation, 9% error for the ultrasound elastography of the breast phantom, and 19% error for the MRE of the brain phantom. These findings highlight the robustness and potential clinical utility of the IDA method in accurately estimating shear wave speed, even in the presence of strong compression waves and noise.

Critical Analysis

The study presents a promising approach to address the challenges in accurately measuring shear wave speed using conventional techniques. The researchers have thoroughly evaluated the performance of the integrated difference autocorrelation (IDA) method across different imaging modalities and excitation scenarios, demonstrating its consistency and robustness.

One potential limitation of the study is the use of relatively simple phantoms and simulations, which may not fully capture the complexity of real-world biological tissues. Further validation of the IDA method in more clinically relevant settings, such as in-vivo studies or more realistic tissue-mimicking phantoms, would be valuable to assess its performance and potential clinical utility.

Additionally, the study does not provide a detailed comparison of the IDA method with other advanced shear wave tracking techniques or phase retrieval algorithms that may also be capable of handling compression waves and noise. A more comprehensive comparative analysis could further highlight the unique strengths and limitations of the IDA method.

Overall, the study presents a novel and promising approach to improve the accuracy of shear wave speed estimation, which is an important parameter for assessing tissue stiffness and potentially detecting pathological conditions. The consistency and robustness of the IDA method across different modalities and scenarios suggest its potential for clinical applications, but further validation and comparisons would be valuable to fully assess its performance and identify any areas for improvement.

Conclusion

The study introduces a novel "difference autocorrelation estimator" approach to accurately measure the velocity of shear waves, even in the presence of unwanted compression waves and noise. The integrated difference autocorrelation (IDA) method demonstrated its effectiveness in estimating shear wave speed through simulations and experiments using various imaging modalities, including ultrasound elastography and magnetic resonance elastography.

The key strength of the IDA method is its ability to minimize the impact of long-wavelength compression waves and other wide-area movements, which often pose challenges for conventional shear wave tracking techniques. The consistent and robust performance of IDA across different scenarios highlights its potential clinical utility in applications that rely on accurate shear wave speed measurements, such as the assessment of tissue stiffness and the detection of pathological conditions.

While further validation in more clinically relevant settings would be valuable, this study presents a promising step forward in improving the reliability and accuracy of shear wave speed estimation, a critical parameter for a wide range of biomedical applications.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

📶

Difference Autocorrelation: A Novel Approach to Estimate Shear Wave Speed in the Presence of Compression Waves

Hamidreza Asemani, Jannick P. Rolland, Kevin J. Parker

In share wave elastography (SWE), the aim is to measure the velocity of shear waves, however unwanted compression waves and bulk tissue motion pose challenges in evaluating tissue stiffness. Conventional approaches often struggle to discriminate between shear and compression waves, leading to inaccurate shear wave speed (SWS) estimation. In this study, we propose a novel approach known as the difference autocorrelation estimator to accurately estimate reverberant SWS in the presence of compression waves and noise. Methods: The difference autocorrelation estimator, unlike conventional techniques, computes the subtraction of velocity between neighboring particles, effectively minimizing the impact of long wavelength compression waves and other wide-area movements such as those caused by respiration. We evaluated the effectiveness of the integrated difference autocorrelation (IDA) by: (1) using k-Wave simulations of a branching cylinder in a soft background, (2) using ultrasound elastography on a breast phantom, (3) using ultrasound elastography in the human liver-kidney region, and (4) using magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) on a brain phantom. Results: By applying IDA on the unfiltered contaminated wave fields of simulation and elastography experiments, the estimated SWSs are in good agreement with the ground truth values (i.e., less than 2% error for the simulation, 9% error for ultrasound elastography of breast phantom and 19% error for MRE). Conclusion: Our results demonstrate that IDA accurately estimates SWS, revealing the existence of a lesion, even in the presence of strong compression waves. Significance: IDA exhibits consistency in SWS estimation across different modalities and excitation scenarios, highlighting its robustness and potential clinical utility.

6/19/2024

An unsupervised learning-based shear wave tracking method for ultrasound elastography

Remi Delaunay, Yipeng Hu, Tom Vercauteren

Shear wave elastography involves applying a non-invasive acoustic radiation force to the tissue and imaging the induced deformation to infer its mechanical properties. This work investigates the use of convolutional neural networks to improve displacement estimation accuracy in shear wave imaging. Our training approach is completely unsupervised, which allows to learn the estimation of the induced micro-scale deformations without ground truth labels. We also present an ultrasound simulation dataset where the shear wave propagation has been simulated via finite element method. Our dataset is made publicly available along with this paper, and consists in 150 shear wave propagation simulations in both homogenous and hetegeneous media, which represents a total of 20,000 ultrasound images. We assessed the ability of our learning-based approach to characterise tissue elastic properties (i.e., Young's modulus) on our dataset and compared our results with a classical normalised cross-correlation approach.

4/29/2024

Robust CNN Multi-Nested-LSTM Framework with Compound Loss for Patch-based Multi-Push Ultrasound Shear Wave Imaging and Segmentation

Md. Jahin Alam, Ahsan Habib, Md. Kamrul Hasan

Ultrasound Shear Wave Elastography (SWE) is a noteworthy tool for in-vivo noninvasive tissue pathology assessment. State-of-the-art techniques can generate reasonable estimates of tissue elasticity, but high-quality and noise-resiliency in SWE reconstruction have yet to demonstrate advancements. In this work, we propose a two-stage DL pipeline producing reliable reconstructions and denoise said reconstructions to obtain lower noise prevailing elasticity mappings. The reconstruction network consists of a Resnet3D Encoder to extract temporal context from the sequential multi-push data. The encoded features are sent to multiple Nested CNN LSTMs which process them in a temporal attention-guided windowing basis and map the 3D features to 2D using FFT-attention, which are then decoded into an elasticity map as primary reconstruction. The 2D maps from each multi-push region are merged and cleaned using a dual-decoder denoiser network, which independently denoises foreground and background before fusion. The post-denoiser generates a higher-quality reconstruction and an inclusion-segmentation mask. A multi-objective loss is designed to accommodate the denoising, fusing, and segmentation processes. The method is validated on sequential multi-push SWE motion data with multiple overlapping regions. A patch-based training procedure is introduced with network modifications to handle data scarcity. Evaluations produce 32.66dB PSNR, 43.19dB CNR in noisy simulation, and 22.44dB PSNR, 36.88dB CNR in experimental data, across all test samples. Moreover, IoUs (0.909 and 0.781) were quite satisfactory in the datasets. After comparing with other reported deep-learning approaches, our method proves quantitatively and qualitatively superior in dealing with noise influences in SWE data. From a performance point of view, our deep-learning pipeline has the potential to become utilitarian in the clinical domain.

7/31/2024

A deep learning approach to wall-shear stress quantification: From numerical training to zero-shot experimental application

Esther Lagemann, Julia Roeb, Steven L. Brunton, Christian Lagemann

The accurate quantification of wall-shear stress dynamics is of substantial importance for various applications in fundamental and applied research, spanning areas from human health to aircraft design and optimization. Despite significant progress in experimental measurement techniques and post-processing algorithms, temporally resolved wall-shear stress dynamics with adequate spatial resolution and within a suitable spatial domain remain an elusive goal. To address this gap, we introduce a deep learning architecture that ingests wall-parallel velocity fields from the logarithmic layer of turbulent wall-bounded flows and outputs the corresponding 2D wall-shear stress fields with identical spatial resolution and domain size. From a physical perspective, our framework acts as a surrogate model encapsulating the various mechanisms through which highly energetic outer-layer flow structures influence the governing wall-shear stress dynamics. The network is trained in a supervised fashion on a unified dataset comprising direct numerical simulations of statistically 1D turbulent channel and spatially developing turbulent boundary layer flows at friction Reynolds numbers ranging from 390 to 1,500. We demonstrate a zero-shot applicability to experimental velocity fields obtained from Particle-Image Velocimetry measurements and verify the physical accuracy of the wall-shear stress estimates with synchronized wall-shear stress measurements using the Micro-Pillar Shear-Stress Sensor for Reynolds numbers up to 2,000. In summary, the presented framework lays the groundwork for extracting inaccessible experimental wall-shear stress information from readily available velocity measurements and thus, facilitates advancements in a variety of experimental applications.

9/9/2024