Digital Diagnostics: The Potential Of Large Language Models In Recognizing Symptoms Of Common Illnesses
2405.06712
0
0
💬
Abstract
The recent swift development of LLMs like GPT-4, Gemini, and GPT-3.5 offers a transformative opportunity in medicine and healthcare, especially in digital diagnostics. This study evaluates each model diagnostic abilities by interpreting a user symptoms and determining diagnoses that fit well with common illnesses, and it demonstrates how each of these models could significantly increase diagnostic accuracy and efficiency. Through a series of diagnostic prompts based on symptoms from medical databases, GPT-4 demonstrates higher diagnostic accuracy from its deep and complete history of training on medical data. Meanwhile, Gemini performs with high precision as a critical tool in disease triage, demonstrating its potential to be a reliable model when physicians are trying to make high-risk diagnoses. GPT-3.5, though slightly less advanced, is a good tool for medical diagnostics. This study highlights the need to study LLMs for healthcare and clinical practices with more care and attention, ensuring that any system utilizing LLMs promotes patient privacy and complies with health information privacy laws such as HIPAA compliance, as well as the social consequences that affect the varied individuals in complex healthcare contexts. This study marks the start of a larger future effort to study the various ways in which assigning ethical concerns to LLMs task of learning from human biases could unearth new ways to apply AI in complex medical settings.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Recent developments in large language models (LLMs) like GPT-4, Gemini, and GPT-3.5 offer significant potential in healthcare, particularly in digital diagnostics.
- This study evaluates the diagnostic abilities of these models by assessing their performance in interpreting user symptoms and determining appropriate diagnoses for common illnesses.
- The study demonstrates how these LLMs could significantly improve diagnostic accuracy and efficiency.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) like GPT-4, Gemini, and GPT-3.5 have advanced rapidly in recent times. These models have the potential to transform healthcare, especially in the area of digital diagnostics.
The study in question evaluates the diagnostic capabilities of these LLMs. It does this by giving the models a series of prompts describing common symptoms, and then seeing how accurately the models can determine the appropriate diagnoses for the given symptoms.
The results show that GPT-4, with its deep and comprehensive training on medical data, demonstrates the highest diagnostic accuracy. Gemini, on the other hand, performs with high precision as a tool for disease triage, suggesting it could be a reliable model for making high-risk diagnoses. Even the slightly less advanced GPT-3.5 is found to be a useful tool for medical diagnostics.
The study highlights the need to further investigate the use of LLMs in healthcare and clinical settings, ensuring that any such systems protect patient privacy and comply with relevant regulations like HIPAA. It also suggests exploring how to address potential biases in the way these models learn from human data.
Technical Explanation
The study evaluates the diagnostic capabilities of three prominent LLMs: GPT-4, Gemini, and GPT-3.5. Through a series of diagnostic prompts based on symptoms from medical databases, the researchers assess the models' ability to interpret user symptoms and determine appropriate diagnoses for common illnesses.
The results show that GPT-4, with its deep and comprehensive training on medical data, demonstrates the highest diagnostic accuracy. Gemini, on the other hand, performs with high precision as a tool for disease triage, suggesting it could be a reliable model for making high-risk diagnoses. Even the slightly less advanced GPT-3.5 is found to be a useful tool for medical diagnostics.
The study highlights the need to further investigate the use of LLMs in healthcare and clinical settings, ensuring that any such systems protect patient privacy and comply with relevant regulations like HIPAA. It also suggests exploring how to address potential biases in the way these models learn from human data.
Critical Analysis
The study provides valuable insights into the potential of LLMs in healthcare, particularly in the area of digital diagnostics. However, it also raises important considerations and potential limitations that warrant further examination.
While the study demonstrates the impressive diagnostic capabilities of the LLMs, it is crucial to consider the implications of relying on these models in high-stakes medical settings. The researchers rightly emphasize the need to ensure patient privacy and compliance with regulations like HIPAA. Additionally, the potential for these models to perpetuate or amplify existing biases in medical data and decision-making is an area that requires deeper investigation and mitigation strategies.
Furthermore, the study focuses on a limited set of common illnesses, and it would be beneficial to expand the evaluation to a broader range of medical conditions to fully assess the models' capabilities and limitations. Additionally, the study does not address the potential challenges of integrating LLMs into existing healthcare workflows and the potential impact on the role of human healthcare providers.
Overall, the study marks an important step in understanding the potential and limitations of LLMs in healthcare. However, continued research, ethical considerations, and a holistic approach to implementation are necessary to ensure that these technologies are deployed in a responsible and beneficial manner.
Conclusion
This study highlights the transformative potential of large language models like GPT-4, Gemini, and GPT-3.5 in the field of digital diagnostics. By demonstrating the models' ability to interpret user symptoms and provide accurate diagnoses for common illnesses, the research suggests that these LLMs could significantly enhance diagnostic accuracy and efficiency in healthcare settings.
While the study's findings are promising, it also underscores the need for careful consideration of the ethical implications and practical challenges associated with integrating LLMs into clinical practice. Ensuring patient privacy, addressing potential biases, and seamlessly integrating these technologies into existing healthcare workflows are critical considerations that require further exploration.
As the field of healthcare continues to evolve, the responsible development and deployment of LLMs in digital diagnostics hold the potential to transform the way medical professionals approach patient care. This study marks an important step in this direction, paving the way for future research and advancements that can harness the power of these advanced language models to improve patient outcomes and the overall quality of healthcare.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤿
Can Public LLMs be used for Self-Diagnosis of Medical Conditions ?
Nikil Sharan Prabahar Balasubramanian, Sagnik Dakshit
0
0
Advancements in deep learning have generated a large-scale interest in the development of foundational deep learning models. The development of Large Language Models (LLM) has evolved as a transformative paradigm in conversational tasks, which has led to its integration and extension even in the critical domain of healthcare. With LLMs becoming widely popular and their public access through open-source models and integration with other applications, there is a need to investigate their potential and limitations. One such crucial task where LLMs are applied but require a deeper understanding is that of self-diagnosis of medical conditions based on bias-validating symptoms in the interest of public health. The widespread integration of Gemini with Google search and GPT-4.0 with Bing search has led to a shift in the trend of self-diagnosis using search engines to conversational LLM models. Owing to the critical nature of the task, it is prudent to investigate and understand the potential and limitations of public LLMs in the task of self-diagnosis. In this study, we prepare a prompt engineered dataset of 10000 samples and test the performance on the general task of self-diagnosis. We compared the performance of both the state-of-the-art GPT-4.0 and the fee Gemini model on the task of self-diagnosis and recorded contrasting accuracies of 63.07% and 6.01%, respectively. We also discuss the challenges, limitations, and potential of both Gemini and GPT-4.0 for the task of self-diagnosis to facilitate future research and towards the broader impact of general public knowledge. Furthermore, we demonstrate the potential and improvement in performance for the task of self-diagnosis using Retrieval Augmented Generation.
6/27/2024
A Survey on Medical Large Language Models: Technology, Application, Trustworthiness, and Future Directions
Lei Liu, Xiaoyan Yang, Junchi Lei, Xiaoyang Liu, Yue Shen, Zhiqiang Zhang, Peng Wei, Jinjie Gu, Zhixuan Chu, Zhan Qin, Kui Ren
0
0
Large language models (LLMs), such as GPT series models, have received substantial attention due to their impressive capabilities for generating and understanding human-level language. More recently, LLMs have emerged as an innovative and powerful adjunct in the medical field, transforming traditional practices and heralding a new era of enhanced healthcare services. This survey provides a comprehensive overview of Medical Large Language Models (Med-LLMs), outlining their evolution from general to the medical-specific domain (i.e, Technology and Application), as well as their transformative impact on healthcare (e.g., Trustworthiness and Safety). Concretely, starting from the fundamental history and technology of LLMs, we first delve into the progressive adaptation and refinements of general LLM models in the medical domain, especially emphasizing the advanced algorithms that boost the LLMs' performance in handling complicated medical environments, including clinical reasoning, knowledge graph, retrieval-augmented generation, human alignment, and multi-modal learning. Secondly, we explore the extensive applications of Med-LLMs across domains such as clinical decision support, report generation, and medical education, illustrating their potential to streamline healthcare services and augment patient outcomes. Finally, recognizing the imperative and responsible innovation, we discuss the challenges of ensuring fairness, accountability, privacy, and robustness in Med-LLMs applications. Finally, we conduct a concise discussion for anticipating possible future trajectories of Med-LLMs, identifying avenues for the prudent expansion of Med-LLMs. By consolidating above-mentioned insights, this review seeks to provide a comprehensive investigation of the potential strengths and limitations of Med-LLMs for professionals and researchers, ensuring a responsible landscape in the healthcare setting.
6/7/2024
💬
Large Language Models for Medicine: A Survey
Yanxin Zheng, Wensheng Gan, Zefeng Chen, Zhenlian Qi, Qian Liang, Philip S. Yu
0
0
To address challenges in the digital economy's landscape of digital intelligence, large language models (LLMs) have been developed. Improvements in computational power and available resources have significantly advanced LLMs, allowing their integration into diverse domains for human life. Medical LLMs are essential application tools with potential across various medical scenarios. In this paper, we review LLM developments, focusing on the requirements and applications of medical LLMs. We provide a concise overview of existing models, aiming to explore advanced research directions and benefit researchers for future medical applications. We emphasize the advantages of medical LLMs in applications, as well as the challenges encountered during their development. Finally, we suggest directions for technical integration to mitigate challenges and potential research directions for the future of medical LLMs, aiming to meet the demands of the medical field better.
5/24/2024
💬
A Comprehensive Survey of Large Language Models and Multimodal Large Language Models in Medicine
Hanguang Xiao, Feizhong Zhou, Xingyue Liu, Tianqi Liu, Zhipeng Li, Xin Liu, Xiaoxuan Huang
0
0
Since the release of ChatGPT and GPT-4, large language models (LLMs) and multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have garnered significant attention due to their powerful and general capabilities in understanding, reasoning, and generation, thereby offering new paradigms for the integration of artificial intelligence with medicine. This survey comprehensively overviews the development background and principles of LLMs and MLLMs, as well as explores their application scenarios, challenges, and future directions in medicine. Specifically, this survey begins by focusing on the paradigm shift, tracing the evolution from traditional models to LLMs and MLLMs, summarizing the model structures to provide detailed foundational knowledge. Subsequently, the survey details the entire process from constructing and evaluating to using LLMs and MLLMs with a clear logic. Following this, to emphasize the significant value of LLMs and MLLMs in healthcare, we survey and summarize 6 promising applications in healthcare. Finally, the survey discusses the challenges faced by medical LLMs and MLLMs and proposes a feasible approach and direction for the subsequent integration of artificial intelligence with medicine. Thus, this survey aims to provide researchers with a valuable and comprehensive reference guide from the perspectives of the background, principles, and clinical applications of LLMs and MLLMs.
5/15/2024