Digitalization in Infrastructure Construction Projects: A PRISMA-Based Review of Benefits and Obstacles
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Examines the benefits and obstacles of adopting Building Information Modeling (BIM) in infrastructure construction projects
- Conducts a systematic literature review using the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) methodology
- Identifies key themes and trends in the adoption and implementation of BIM in infrastructure projects
Plain English Explanation
This research paper takes a close look at the advantages and challenges of using digital technologies, specifically Building Information Modeling (BIM), in infrastructure construction projects. BIM is a powerful tool that allows construction teams to create and manage digital models of buildings and infrastructure throughout the entire project lifecycle.
The researchers conducted a thorough review of the existing academic literature on this topic, following a well-established systematic review methodology called PRISMA. This approach ensures a comprehensive and unbiased analysis of the available evidence.
The study identifies the main benefits of BIM adoption, such as improved project coordination, enhanced information management, and better visualization of design concepts. These advantages can lead to more efficient construction processes, cost savings, and higher-quality final products. However, the paper also highlights the various obstacles that organizations may face when implementing BIM, including the need for specialized skills, technological compatibility issues, and cultural resistance to change.
By synthesizing the findings from multiple studies, the researchers provide a comprehensive understanding of the current state of BIM adoption in infrastructure projects. This knowledge can help inform decision-makers and practitioners in the construction industry as they navigate the opportunities and challenges of digital transformation.
Technical Explanation
The researchers conducted a systematic literature review using the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) methodology to investigate the benefits and obstacles of BIM adoption in infrastructure construction projects. They searched various academic databases to identify relevant peer-reviewed articles and then applied a rigorous screening process to select the final set of studies for analysis.
The review focused on identifying the key themes and trends in the adoption and implementation of BIM in infrastructure projects. The researchers categorized the identified benefits into several areas, such as improved project coordination, enhanced information management, and better visualization of design concepts. These advantages can lead to more efficient construction processes, cost savings, and higher-quality final products.
However, the paper also highlights the various obstacles that organizations may face when implementing BIM, including the need for specialized skills, technological compatibility issues, and cultural resistance to change. These challenges can hinder the successful adoption and integration of BIM in infrastructure projects.
The findings of this study provide valuable insights for decision-makers and practitioners in the construction industry as they navigate the opportunities and challenges of digital transformation. The systematic review approach ensures a comprehensive and unbiased analysis of the available evidence, enabling a deeper understanding of the current state of BIM adoption in infrastructure projects.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and well-structured review of the existing research on the benefits and obstacles of BIM adoption in infrastructure construction projects. By using the PRISMA methodology, the researchers have followed a rigorous and transparent process, which enhances the credibility and reliability of the findings.
One potential limitation of the study is the scope of the literature review, as it may have overlooked some relevant publications that were not included in the selected databases or did not meet the inclusion criteria. Additionally, the study does not delve into the specific contextual factors that may influence the success or failure of BIM implementation in different types of infrastructure projects or geographical regions.
It would be valuable for future research to explore these contextual factors in more depth, as they can provide a richer understanding of the complex ecosystem in which BIM is deployed. Incorporating a wider range of stakeholder perspectives, including those of policymakers, industry associations, and end-users, could also shed light on the broader societal and organizational impacts of BIM adoption.
Conclusion
This systematic literature review offers a comprehensive overview of the benefits and obstacles associated with the adoption of Building Information Modeling (BIM) in infrastructure construction projects. The findings highlight the potential advantages of BIM, such as improved project coordination, enhanced information management, and better visualization of design concepts, as well as the various challenges organizations may face during implementation, including the need for specialized skills, technological compatibility issues, and cultural resistance to change.
By synthesizing the available research, this study provides valuable insights for decision-makers and practitioners in the construction industry as they navigate the opportunities and challenges of digital transformation. The systematic review approach ensures a rigorous and unbiased analysis, contributing to a deeper understanding of the current state of BIM adoption in infrastructure projects.
However, the paper also identifies areas for further research, such as the exploration of contextual factors and the incorporation of wider stakeholder perspectives, which could enhance the understanding of the complex ecosystem in which BIM is deployed. Addressing these gaps could lead to more informed and effective strategies for the successful implementation of digital technologies in the infrastructure construction sector.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Digitalization in Infrastructure Construction Projects: A PRISMA-Based Review of Benefits and Obstacles
Mohammed Abdulsalam Alsofiani
The current study presents a comprehensive review of the benefits and barriers associated with the adoption of Building Information Modeling (BIM) in infrastructure projects, focusing on the period from 2013 to 2023. The research explores the manifold advantages offered by BIM, spanning the entire project life cycle, including planning, design, construction, maintenance, and sustainability. Notably, BIM enhances collaboration, facilitates real-time data-driven decision-making, and leads to substantial cost and time savings. In parallel, a systematic literature review was conducted to identify and categorize the barriers hindering BIM adoption within the infrastructure industry. Eleven studies were selected for in-depth analysis, revealing a total of 74 obstacles. Through synthetic analysis and thematic clustering, seven primary impediments to BIM adoption were identified, encompassing challenges related to education/training, resistance to change, business value clarity, perceived cost, lack of standards and guidelines, lack of mandates, and lack of initiatives. This review explores the benefits and barriers in the industry that are facing BIM adoption in infrastructure projects, giving an important perspective toward improving effective BIM adoption strategies, policies, and standards. Future directions for research and industry development are outlined, including efforts to enhance education and training, promote standardization, advocate for policy and mandates, and integrate BIM with emerging technologies.
Read more5/28/2024
0
Developing a Comprehensive Measurement Tool for Assessing the Rate of BIM Adoption in the Construction Industry
Mohammed Abdulsalam Alsofiani
Building Information Modeling (BIM) is a crucial technology in the construction industry, offering benefits such as enhanced collaboration, real-time decision-making, and significant cost and time savings. Despite its advantages, BIM adoption faces numerous barriers. This study aims to create a reliable tool to assess the Rate of BIM Adoption (RBA), drawing on Attributes of Innovation theory and empirical data from the literature. This research integrates theoretical insights with empirical data, providing quantitative items to measure BAR in the construction industry. The quantitative approach helps decision-makers and policymakers to mandate BIM and establish appropriate implementation standards. Its implications are significant for the construction industry, policymakers, and the academic community, offering a systematic approach to assess BIM adoption, identify barriers, and implement targeted strategies. The reliability of this approach is ensured through a solid theoretical foundation, item development, pilot testing, and statistical analysis, making it a valuable resource for improving BIM implementation and fostering innovation in the construction industry.
Read more5/31/2024
0
Towards Automating the Retrospective Generation of BIM Models: A Unified Framework for 3D Semantic Reconstruction of the Built Environment
Ka Lung Cheung, Chi Chung Lee
The adoption of Building Information Modeling (BIM) is beneficial in construction projects. However, it faces challenges due to the lack of a unified and scalable framework for converting 3D model details into BIM. This paper introduces SRBIM, a unified semantic reconstruction architecture for BIM generation. Our approach's effectiveness is demonstrated through extensive qualitative and quantitative evaluations, establishing a new paradigm for automated BIM modeling.
Read more6/4/2024
🚀
0
Enabling Building Information Model-Driven Human-Robot Collaborative Construction Workflows with Closed-Loop Digital Twins
Xi Wang, Hongrui Yu, Wes McGee, Carol C. Menassa, Vineet R. Kamat
The introduction of assistive construction robots can significantly alleviate physical demands on construction workers while enhancing both the productivity and safety of construction projects. Leveraging a Building Information Model (BIM) offers a natural and promising approach to driving robotic construction workflows. However, because of uncertainties inherent in construction sites, such as discrepancies between the as-designed and as-built components, robots cannot solely rely on a BIM to plan and perform field construction work. Human workers are adept at improvising alternative plans with their creativity and experience and thus can assist robots in overcoming uncertainties and performing construction work successfully. In such scenarios, it is critical to continuously update the BIM as work processes unfold so that it includes as-built information for the ensuing construction and maintenance tasks. This research introduces an interactive closed-loop digital twin framework that integrates a BIM into human-robot collaborative construction workflows. The robot's functions are primarily driven by the BIM, but it adaptively adjusts its plans based on actual site conditions, while the human co-worker oversees and supervises the process. When necessary, the human co-worker intervenes to help the robot overcome the encountered uncertainties. A drywall installation case study is conducted to verify the proposed workflow. In addition, experiments are carried out to evaluate the system performance using an industrial robotic arm in a research laboratory setting that mimics a construction site and in the Gazebo simulation. Integrating the flexibility of human workers and the autonomy and accuracy afforded by the BIM, the proposed framework offers significant promise of increasing the robustness of construction robots in the performance of field construction work.
Read more5/30/2024