Distillation for Multilingual Information Retrieval

Read original: arXiv:2405.00977 - Published 5/3/2024 by Eugene Yang, Dawn Lawrie, James Mayfield

👀

Overview

This paper proposes a new training approach called Multilingual Translate-Distill (MTD) for multilingual information retrieval (MLIR) tasks.
MLIR is more challenging than cross-language information retrieval (CLIR) because the model must assign comparable relevance scores to documents in different languages.
The authors show that ColBERT-X models trained with MTD outperform previous state-of-the-art approaches by significant margins.
The model is also shown to be robust to how languages are mixed in training batches.

Plain English Explanation

Information retrieval is the process of finding relevant documents, articles, or webpages in response to a user's query. When the query and the documents are in different languages, this is known as cross-language information retrieval (CLIR). Previous research has shown that a training approach called Translate-Distill can be effective for CLIR, where a neural network model is trained using both translation and knowledge distillation.

However, Translate-Distill only supports a single document language. Multilingual information retrieval (MLIR) is more challenging, as the model must be able to assign comparable relevance scores to documents in different languages. This means the model needs to understand the content of the documents, not just the language they are written in.

The researchers in this paper have extended the Translate-Distill approach to create a new training method called Multilingual Translate-Distill (MTD). They show that models trained with MTD, like ColBERT-X, outperform previous state-of-the-art MLIR approaches by a significant margin, improving performance by 5-25% on one metric and 15-45% on another.

Importantly, the researchers also find that the MTD-trained models are robust to how the different languages are mixed together in the training data. This means the models can handle real-world scenarios where users may search for information in a variety of languages.

Technical Explanation

The paper builds on the Translate-Distill framework for CLIR, which trains a cross-language neural dual-encoder model using both translation and knowledge distillation. However, Translate-Distill is limited to a single document language.

To address this, the authors propose Multilingual Translate-Distill (MTD), an extension of Translate-Distill for MLIR tasks. MTD trains a multilingual dual-encoder model that can handle documents in multiple languages.

The key aspects of the MTD training approach are:

Multilingual data: The training data includes documents in multiple languages, rather than just a single language.
Multilingual translation: The model is trained to translate queries and documents between languages, in addition to the distillation objective.
Batch mixing: The authors experiment with different ways of mixing the multilingual data in training batches, and find the model is robust to these variations.

The authors evaluate the MTD-trained ColBERT-X models on standard MLIR benchmarks. They show these models outperform previous state-of-the-art approaches, such as Multilingual Translate-Train, by 5-25% in nDCG@20 and 15-45% in MAP.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a strong contribution by extending the successful Translate-Distill framework to the more challenging MLIR task. The authors thoroughly evaluate their proposed MTD approach and demonstrate significant performance improvements over previous methods.

However, the paper does not address some potential limitations or areas for further research. For example, it would be interesting to understand how the MTD-trained models perform on low-resource languages, or how they handle query-document pairs with large language differences (e.g., English queries and Chinese documents).

Additionally, the paper could have provided more insight into the inner workings of the MTD-trained models. For instance, how do the translation and distillation objectives interact, and what are the relative contributions of each to the model's final performance?

Overall, this is a compelling piece of research that advances the state-of-the-art in multilingual information retrieval. The authors have clearly demonstrated the benefits of the MTD approach and have made their implementation publicly available, which should spur further exploration and refinement of these techniques.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel training approach called Multilingual Translate-Distill (MTD) for tackling the challenging problem of multilingual information retrieval (MLIR). By extending the successful Translate-Distill framework to support multiple document languages, the authors have shown significant performance improvements over previous state-of-the-art methods.

The key insights from this research are the effectiveness of the MTD approach, which combines multilingual translation and knowledge distillation, as well as the model's robustness to different ways of mixing languages in the training data. These findings have important implications for building practical MLIR systems that can handle real-world queries and documents in a variety of languages.

Overall, this work represents an important step forward in multilingual information retrieval and provides a strong foundation for future research in this area, such as exploring the model's performance on low-resource languages or investigating the interplay between the translation and distillation objectives.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

👀

Distillation for Multilingual Information Retrieval

Eugene Yang, Dawn Lawrie, James Mayfield

Recent work in cross-language information retrieval (CLIR), where queries and documents are in different languages, has shown the benefit of the Translate-Distill framework that trains a cross-language neural dual-encoder model using translation and distillation. However, Translate-Distill only supports a single document language. Multilingual information retrieval (MLIR), which ranks a multilingual document collection, is harder to train than CLIR because the model must assign comparable relevance scores to documents in different languages. This work extends Translate-Distill and propose Multilingual Translate-Distill (MTD) for MLIR. We show that ColBERT-X models trained with MTD outperform their counterparts trained ith Multilingual Translate-Train, which is the previous state-of-the-art training approach, by 5% to 25% in nDCG@20 and 15% to 45% in MAP. We also show that the model is robust to the way languages are mixed in training batches. Our implementation is available on GitHub.

5/3/2024

Self-Distillation for Model Stacking Unlocks Cross-Lingual NLU in 200+ Languages

Fabian David Schmidt, Philipp Borchert, Ivan Vuli'c, Goran Glavav{s}

LLMs have become a go-to solution not just for text generation, but also for natural language understanding (NLU) tasks. Acquiring extensive knowledge through language modeling on web-scale corpora, they excel on English NLU, yet struggle to extend their NLU capabilities to underrepresented languages. In contrast, machine translation models (MT) produce excellent multilingual representations, resulting in strong translation performance even for low-resource languages. MT encoders, however, lack the knowledge necessary for comprehensive NLU that LLMs obtain through language modeling training on immense corpora. In this work, we get the best both worlds by integrating MT encoders directly into LLM backbones via sample-efficient self-distillation. The resulting MT-LLMs preserve the inherent multilingual representational alignment from the MT encoder, allowing lower-resource languages to tap into the rich knowledge embedded in English-centric LLMs. Merging the MT encoder and LLM in a single model, we mitigate the propagation of translation errors and inference overhead of MT decoding inherent to discrete translation-based cross-lingual transfer (e.g., translate-test). Evaluation spanning three prominent NLU tasks and 127 predominantly low-resource languages renders MT-LLMs highly effective in cross-lingual transfer. MT-LLMs substantially and consistently outperform translate-test based on the same MT model, showing that we truly unlock multilingual language understanding for LLMs.

6/19/2024

Intermediate Distillation: Data-Efficient Distillation from Black-Box LLMs for Information Retrieval

Zizhong Li, Haopeng Zhang, Jiawei Zhang

Recent research has explored distilling knowledge from large language models (LLMs) to optimize retriever models, especially within the retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) framework. However, most existing training methods rely on extracting supervision signals from LLMs' weights or their output probabilities, which is not only resource-intensive but also incompatible with black-box LLMs. In this paper, we introduce textit{Intermediate Distillation}, a data-efficient knowledge distillation training scheme that treats LLMs as black boxes and distills their knowledge via an innovative LLM-ranker-retriever pipeline, solely using LLMs' ranking generation as the supervision signal. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our proposed method can significantly improve the performance of retriever models with only 1,000 training instances. Moreover, our distilled retriever model significantly boosts performance in question-answering tasks within the RAG framework, demonstrating the potential of LLMs to economically and effectively train smaller models.

6/19/2024

🏋️

HLTCOE at TREC 2023 NeuCLIR Track

Eugene Yang, Dawn Lawrie, James Mayfield

The HLTCOE team applied PLAID, an mT5 reranker, and document translation to the TREC 2023 NeuCLIR track. For PLAID we included a variety of models and training techniques -- the English model released with ColBERT v2, translate-train~(TT), Translate Distill~(TD) and multilingual translate-train~(MTT). TT trains a ColBERT model with English queries and passages automatically translated into the document language from the MS-MARCO v1 collection. This results in three cross-language models for the track, one per language. MTT creates a single model for all three document languages by combining the translations of MS-MARCO passages in all three languages into mixed-language batches. Thus the model learns about matching queries to passages simultaneously in all languages. Distillation uses scores from the mT5 model over non-English translated document pairs to learn how to score query-document pairs. The team submitted runs to all NeuCLIR tasks: the CLIR and MLIR news task as well as the technical documents task.

4/15/2024