Effects of Multisensory Feedback on the Perception and Performance of Virtual Reality Hand-Retargeted Interaction
2404.03899
0
0
Abstract
Retargeting methods that modify the visual representation of real movements have been widely used to expand the interaction space and create engaging virtual reality experiences. For optimal user experience and performance, it is essential to specify the perception of retargeting and utilize the appropriate range of modification parameters. However, previous studies mostly concentrated on whether users perceived the target sense or not and rarely examined the perceptual accuracy and sensitivity to retargeting. Moreover, it is unknown how the perception and performance in hand-retargeted interactions are influenced by multisensory feedback. In this study, we used rigorous psychophysical methods to specify users' perceptual accuracy and sensitivity to hand-retargeting and provide acceptable ranges of retargeting parameters. We also presented different multisensory feedback simultaneously with the retargeting to probe its effect on users' perception and task performance. The experimental results showed that providing continuous multisensory feedback, proportionate to the distance between the virtual hand and the targeted destination, heightened the accuracy of users' perception of hand retargeting without altering their perceptual sensitivity. Furthermore, the utilization of multisensory feedback considerably improved the precision of task performance, particularly at lower gain factors. Based on these findings, we propose design guidelines and potential applications of VR hand-retargeted interactions and multisensory feedback for optimal user experience and performance.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper examines the effects of multisensory feedback, such as visual, auditory, and haptic cues, on the perception and performance of virtual reality (VR) hand-retargeted interaction.
- The researchers conducted a user study to explore how different combinations of sensory feedback influence users' subjective experiences and objective task performance in a VR environment.
- The findings provide insights into the role of multisensory integration in enhancing the realism and effectiveness of hand-based interactions in VR.
Plain English Explanation
In virtual reality (VR) systems, users often interact with the virtual environment using their hands. However, the virtual hands don't always perfectly match the user's real hands due to technical limitations. This paper investigates how providing different types of sensory feedback, such as sight, sound, and touch, can affect how users perceive and perform these hand-based interactions in VR.
The researchers set up an experiment where participants completed various tasks in a VR environment, with different combinations of sensory feedback. For example, they might see their virtual hands moving, feel vibrations from the controllers, and hear related sounds. By studying how users responded to these different feedback conditions, the researchers aimed to understand which combinations of senses work best to create a more natural and effective hand-based interaction in VR.
The findings from this study can help VR developers design more immersive and intuitive experiences for users, where the virtual hands feel and behave more like the user's real hands. This can be particularly important for applications like gaming, training, or collaborative work in VR, where realistic hand interactions are crucial for the user's experience and performance.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a user study that examines the effects of multisensory feedback, including visual, auditory, and haptic cues, on the perception and performance of virtual reality (VR) hand-retargeted interaction.
The researchers developed a VR system that allowed them to decouple the user's real hand movements from the corresponding virtual hand movements, creating a hand-retargeted interaction. They then tested different combinations of sensory feedback, including:
- Visual feedback: Displaying the virtual hand movements
- Auditory feedback: Providing related sound effects
- Haptic feedback: Simulating touch sensations through vibrations in the hand controllers
Participants were asked to perform various tasks in the VR environment, such as object manipulation and navigation, while experiencing different feedback conditions. The researchers measured the users' subjective experiences, such as perceived realism and ease of use, as well as their objective task performance.
The results of the study suggest that the integration of multisensory feedback, particularly the combination of visual, auditory, and haptic cues, can significantly enhance the perceived realism and effectiveness of hand-based interactions in VR. The findings provide valuable insights into the role of sensory integration in shaping user experiences and task performance in virtual environments.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a well-designed experiment that systematically examines the effects of multisensory feedback on VR hand-retargeted interaction. The researchers considered multiple sensory modalities and tested various combinations, which allowed them to draw meaningful conclusions about the importance of integrating these cues for enhancing the user experience.
One potential limitation of the study is the relatively small sample size, which may limit the generalizability of the findings. Additionally, the paper does not delve into the specific mechanisms underlying the observed effects, such as the cognitive and perceptual processes involved in multisensory integration. Further research could explore these underlying mechanisms in more depth.
The paper also acknowledges that the specific feedback implementations used in the study may not fully capture the complexity of real-world hand interactions. Exploring more naturalistic and sophisticated feedback techniques, such as those discussed in related work on haptic sensory prostheses or multimodal perception of soft robotic interactions, could provide additional insights.
Overall, this study contributes valuable empirical evidence to the growing body of research on the importance of multisensory feedback in enhancing the user experience and performance in virtual reality. The findings have implications for the design of more immersive and effective VR systems, as well as the broader understanding of human perception and interaction in digital environments.
Conclusion
This paper investigates the effects of multisensory feedback, including visual, auditory, and haptic cues, on the perception and performance of virtual reality (VR) hand-retargeted interaction. The results demonstrate that the integration of these sensory modalities can significantly enhance the perceived realism and effectiveness of hand-based interactions in VR.
The findings suggest that VR developers should prioritize the incorporation of multisensory feedback to create more immersive and intuitive user experiences. This is particularly relevant for applications that rely heavily on realistic hand interactions, such as gaming, training, and collaborative work in VR environments.
The insights provided by this study contribute to our understanding of human perception and interaction in virtual worlds, and pave the way for the development of more advanced and engaging VR systems that better accommodate the complexity of real-world hand movements and sensations.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏋️
Evaluating the efficacy of haptic feedback, 360{deg} treadmill-integrated Virtual Reality framework and longitudinal training on decision-making performance in a complex search-and-shoot simulation
Akash K Rao, Arnav Bhavsar, Shubhajit Roy Chowdhury, Sushil Chandra, Ramsingh Negi, Prakash Duraisamy, Varun Dutt
0
0
Virtual Reality (VR) has made significant strides, offering users a multitude of ways to interact with virtual environments. Each sensory modality in VR provides distinct inputs and interactions, enhancing the user's immersion and presence. However, the potential of additional sensory modalities, such as haptic feedback and 360{deg} locomotion, to improve decision-making performance has not been thoroughly investigated. This study addresses this gap by evaluating the impact of a haptic feedback, 360{deg} locomotion-integrated VR framework and longitudinal, heterogeneous training on decision-making performance in a complex search-and-shoot simulation. The study involved 32 participants from a defence simulation base in India, who were randomly divided into two groups: experimental (haptic feedback, 360{deg} locomotion-integrated VR framework with longitudinal, heterogeneous training) and placebo control (longitudinal, heterogeneous VR training without extrasensory modalities). The experiment lasted 10 days. On Day 1, all subjects executed a search-and-shoot simulation closely replicating the elements/situations in the real world. From Day 2 to Day 9, the subjects underwent heterogeneous training, imparted by the design of various complexity levels in the simulation using changes in behavioral attributes/artificial intelligence of the enemies. On Day 10, they repeated the search-and-shoot simulation executed on Day 1. The results showed that the experimental group experienced a gradual increase in presence, immersion, and engagement compared to the placebo control group. However, there was no significant difference in decision-making performance between the two groups on day 10. We intend to use these findings to design multisensory VR training frameworks that enhance engagement levels and decision-making performance.
4/16/2024
🖼️
Multisensory extended reality applications offer benefits for volumetric biomedical image analysis in research and medicine
Kathrin Krieger, Jan Egger, Jens Kleesiek, Matthias Gunzer, Jianxu Chen
0
0
3D data from high-resolution volumetric imaging is a central resource for diagnosis and treatment in modern medicine. While the fast development of AI enhances imaging and analysis, commonly used visualization methods lag far behind. Recent research used extended reality (XR) for perceiving 3D images with visual depth perception and touch but used restrictive haptic devices. While unrestricted touch benefits volumetric data examination, implementing natural haptic interaction with XR is challenging. The research question is whether a multisensory XR application with intuitive haptic interaction adds value and should be pursued. In a study, 24 experts for biomedical images in research and medicine explored 3D medical shapes with 3 applications: a multisensory virtual reality (VR) prototype using haptic gloves, a simple VR prototype using controllers, and a standard PC application. Results of standardized questionnaires showed no significant differences between all application types regarding usability and no significant difference between both VR applications regarding presence. Participants agreed to statements that VR visualizations provide better depth information, using the hands instead of controllers simplifies data exploration, the multisensory VR prototype allows intuitive data exploration, and it is beneficial over traditional data examination methods. While most participants mentioned manual interaction as best aspect, they also found it the most improvable. We conclude that a multisensory XR application with improved manual interaction adds value for volumetric biomedical data examination. We will proceed with our open-source research project ISH3DE (Intuitive Stereoptic Haptic 3D Data Exploration) to serve medical education, therapeutic decisions, surgery preparations, or research data analysis.
6/17/2024
💬
Pseudo-Haptics Survey: Human-Computer Interaction in Extended Reality & Teleoperation
Rui Xavier, Jos'e Lu'is Silva, Rodrigo Ventura, Joaquim Jorge
0
0
Pseudo-haptic techniques are becoming increasingly popular in human-computer interaction. They replicate haptic sensations by leveraging primarily visual feedback rather than mechanical actuators. These techniques bridge the gap between the real and virtual worlds by exploring the brain's ability to integrate visual and haptic information. One of the many advantages of pseudo-haptic techniques is that they are cost-effective, portable, and flexible. They eliminate the need for direct attachment of haptic devices to the body, which can be heavy and large and require a lot of power and maintenance. Recent research has focused on applying these techniques to extended reality and mid-air interactions. To better understand the potential of pseudo-haptic techniques, the authors developed a novel taxonomy encompassing tactile feedback, kinesthetic feedback, and combined categories in multimodal approaches, ground not covered by previous surveys. This survey highlights multimodal strategies and potential avenues for future studies, particularly regarding integrating these techniques into extended reality and collaborative virtual environments.
6/4/2024
Teaching Chinese Sign Language with Feedback in Mixed Reality
Hongli Wen, Yang Xu, Lin Li, Xudong Ru, Xingce Wang, Zhongke Wu
0
0
Traditional sign language teaching methods face challenges such as limited feedback and diverse learning scenarios. Although 2D resources lack real-time feedback, classroom teaching is constrained by a scarcity of teacher. Methods based on VR and AR have relatively primitive interaction feedback mechanisms. This study proposes an innovative teaching model that uses real-time monocular vision and mixed reality technology. First, we introduce an improved hand-posture reconstruction method to achieve sign language semantic retention and real-time feedback. Second, a ternary system evaluation algorithm is proposed for a comprehensive assessment, maintaining good consistency with experts in sign language. Furthermore, we use mixed reality technology to construct a scenario-based 3D sign language classroom and explore the user experience of scenario teaching. Overall, this paper presents a novel teaching method that provides an immersive learning experience, advanced posture reconstruction, and precise feedback, achieving positive feedback on user experience and learning effectiveness.
5/7/2024