Efficient Ensembles Improve Training Data Attribution
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a new method called "Efficient Ensembles" that can improve the attribution of training data for machine learning models.
- The method combines efficient ensemble techniques, such as Split Ensemble and LoRA Ensemble, to efficiently estimate model uncertainty and leverage that information for better training data attribution.
- The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on various tasks and datasets, showing improved performance compared to existing methods like Unrolled Differentiation and Distilled DataModel.
Plain English Explanation
The paper describes a new way to improve how machine learning models determine which training data examples were most important in making their predictions. This is called "training data attribution." The researchers developed a method called "Efficient Ensembles" that combines several existing techniques to estimate the uncertainty in the model's predictions more efficiently. By understanding the model's uncertainty, they can then better identify which training data examples were most influential in the model's decision-making process.
This is useful because it allows us to understand how machine learning models arrive at their conclusions and which data was most important. This can help improve the transparency and interpretability of these models, which is important as they are increasingly used in high-stakes applications like healthcare and finance.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation in this paper is the use of efficient ensemble techniques to improve training data attribution. The authors leverage methods like Split Ensemble and LoRA Ensemble to estimate model uncertainty more efficiently than previous approaches like Unrolled Differentiation and Distilled DataModel.
The authors conduct experiments on various tasks and datasets, demonstrating that their Efficient Ensembles method outperforms these existing techniques in terms of training data attribution performance. They show that by leveraging efficient uncertainty estimation, their approach can provide more accurate and interpretable insights into which training data examples were most influential for the model's predictions.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thorough evaluation of the Efficient Ensembles method, with experiments across multiple tasks and datasets. However, the authors acknowledge some limitations, such as the potential for the method to be computationally intensive for very large models or datasets.
Additionally, while the paper focuses on improving training data attribution, it would be interesting to see further exploration of how this information could be used to enhance model interpretability or to identify and mitigate potential biases in the training data. The authors also do not delve deeply into the theoretical underpinnings of their approach or how it compares to other recent advances in model explainability and interpretability.
Overall, the Efficient Ensembles method represents a promising step forward in the important problem of training data attribution, and the paper provides a solid foundation for future research in this area.
Conclusion
This paper introduces an efficient ensemble-based approach for improving training data attribution in machine learning models. By leveraging techniques like Split Ensemble and LoRA Ensemble to estimate model uncertainty more effectively, the authors demonstrate that their Efficient Ensembles method can outperform existing state-of-the-art approaches on a variety of tasks and datasets.
The ability to better understand which training data examples were most influential in a model's decision-making is a crucial step towards improving the transparency and interpretability of these powerful AI systems. As machine learning models become increasingly ubiquitous in high-stakes applications, tools like Efficient Ensembles will be essential for building trust and accountability in these technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Efficient Ensembles Improve Training Data Attribution
Junwei Deng, Ting-Wei Li, Shichang Zhang, Jiaqi Ma
Training data attribution (TDA) methods aim to quantify the influence of individual training data points on the model predictions, with broad applications in data-centric AI, such as mislabel detection, data selection, and copyright compensation. However, existing methods in this field, which can be categorized as retraining-based and gradient-based, have struggled with the trade-off between computational efficiency and attribution efficacy. Retraining-based methods can accurately attribute complex non-convex models but are computationally prohibitive, while gradient-based methods are efficient but often fail for non-convex models. Recent research has shown that augmenting gradient-based methods with ensembles of multiple independently trained models can achieve significantly better attribution efficacy. However, this approach remains impractical for very large-scale applications. In this work, we discover that expensive, fully independent training is unnecessary for ensembling the gradient-based methods, and we propose two efficient ensemble strategies, DROPOUT ENSEMBLE and LORA ENSEMBLE, alternative to naive independent ensemble. These strategies significantly reduce training time (up to 80%), serving time (up to 60%), and space cost (up to 80%) while maintaining similar attribution efficacy to the naive independent ensemble. Our extensive experimental results demonstrate that the proposed strategies are effective across multiple TDA methods on diverse datasets and models, including generative settings, significantly advancing the Pareto frontier of TDA methods with better computational efficiency and attribution efficacy.
Read more5/28/2024
0
Achieving More with Less: A Tensor-Optimization-Powered Ensemble Method
Jinghui Yuan, Weijin Jiang, Zhe Cao, Fangyuan Xie, Rong Wang, Feiping Nie, Yuan Yuan
Ensemble learning is a method that leverages weak learners to produce a strong learner. However, obtaining a large number of base learners requires substantial time and computational resources. Therefore, it is meaningful to study how to achieve the performance typically obtained with many base learners using only a few. We argue that to achieve this, it is essential to enhance both classification performance and generalization ability during the ensemble process. To increase model accuracy, each weak base learner needs to be more efficiently integrated. It is observed that different base learners exhibit varying levels of accuracy in predicting different classes. To capitalize on this, we introduce confidence tensors $tilde{mathbf{Theta}}$ and $tilde{mathbf{Theta}}_{rst}$ signifies the degree of confidence that the $t$-th base classifier assigns the sample to class $r$ while it actually belongs to class $s$. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time an evaluation of the performance of base classifiers across different classes has been proposed. The proposed confidence tensor compensates for the strengths and weaknesses of each base classifier in different classes, enabling the method to achieve superior results with a smaller number of base learners. To enhance generalization performance, we design a smooth and convex objective function that leverages the concept of margin, making the strong learner more discriminative. Furthermore, it is proved that in gradient matrix of the loss function, the sum of each column's elements is zero, allowing us to solve a constrained optimization problem using gradient-based methods. We then compare our algorithm with random forests of ten times the size and other classical methods across numerous datasets, demonstrating the superiority of our approach.
Read more8/13/2024
0
Training Data Attribution via Approximate Unrolled Differentation
Juhan Bae, Wu Lin, Jonathan Lorraine, Roger Grosse
Many training data attribution (TDA) methods aim to estimate how a model's behavior would change if one or more data points were removed from the training set. Methods based on implicit differentiation, such as influence functions, can be made computationally efficient, but fail to account for underspecification, the implicit bias of the optimization algorithm, or multi-stage training pipelines. By contrast, methods based on unrolling address these issues but face scalability challenges. In this work, we connect the implicit-differentiation-based and unrolling-based approaches and combine their benefits by introducing Source, an approximate unrolling-based TDA method that is computed using an influence-function-like formula. While being computationally efficient compared to unrolling-based approaches, Source is suitable in cases where implicit-differentiation-based approaches struggle, such as in non-converged models and multi-stage training pipelines. Empirically, Source outperforms existing TDA techniques in counterfactual prediction, especially in settings where implicit-differentiation-based approaches fall short.
Read more5/22/2024
📉
0
LoRA-Ensemble: Efficient Uncertainty Modelling for Self-attention Networks
Michelle Halbheer, Dominik J. Muhlematter, Alexander Becker, Dominik Narnhofer, Helge Aasen, Konrad Schindler, Mehmet Ozgur Turkoglu
Numerous crucial tasks in real-world decision-making rely on machine learning algorithms with calibrated uncertainty estimates. However, modern methods often yield overconfident and uncalibrated predictions. Various approaches involve training an ensemble of separate models to quantify the uncertainty related to the model itself, known as epistemic uncertainty. In an explicit implementation, the ensemble approach has high computational cost and high memory requirements. This particular challenge is evident in state-of-the-art neural networks such as transformers, where even a single network is already demanding in terms of compute and memory. Consequently, efforts are made to emulate the ensemble model without actually instantiating separate ensemble members, referred to as implicit ensembling. We introduce LoRA-Ensemble, a parameter-efficient deep ensemble method for self-attention networks, which is based on Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA). Initially developed for efficient LLM fine-tuning, we extend LoRA to an implicit ensembling approach. By employing a single pre-trained self-attention network with weights shared across all members, we train member-specific low-rank matrices for the attention projections. Our method exhibits superior calibration compared to explicit ensembles and achieves similar or better accuracy across various prediction tasks and datasets.
Read more5/24/2024