Efficient Offline Reinforcement Learning: The Critic is Critical
2406.13376
0
0
Abstract
Recent work has demonstrated both benefits and limitations from using supervised approaches (without temporal-difference learning) for offline reinforcement learning. While off-policy reinforcement learning provides a promising approach for improving performance beyond supervised approaches, we observe that training is often inefficient and unstable due to temporal difference bootstrapping. In this paper we propose a best-of-both approach by first learning the behavior policy and critic with supervised learning, before improving with off-policy reinforcement learning. Specifically, we demonstrate improved efficiency by pre-training with a supervised Monte-Carlo value-error, making use of commonly neglected downstream information from the provided offline trajectories. We find that we are able to more than halve the training time of the considered offline algorithms on standard benchmarks, and surprisingly also achieve greater stability. We further build on the importance of having consistent policy and value functions to propose novel hybrid algorithms, TD3+BC+CQL and EDAC+BC, that regularize both the actor and the critic towards the behavior policy. This helps to more reliably improve on the behavior policy when learning from limited human demonstrations. Code is available at https://github.com/AdamJelley/EfficientOfflineRL
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper examines the role of the critic in efficient offline reinforcement learning, where the agent learns from a fixed dataset without interacting with the environment.
- It proposes a method called Offline Boosted Actor-Critic (OBAC) that adaptively blends an optimal policy evaluation with a behavioral supervisor to improve sample efficiency and performance.
- The paper also reviews related work in offline reinforcement learning, including Efficient Policy Evaluation, Behavioral Supervisor Tuning, and Strategically Conservative Q-Learning.
Plain English Explanation
In reinforcement learning, an agent learns to make good decisions by interacting with an environment and receiving rewards or penalties. Offline reinforcement learning is a setting where the agent doesn't interact with the environment directly, but instead learns from a fixed dataset of past experiences.
The key challenge in offline reinforcement learning is that the agent has to make the best use of the limited data it has, without being able to explore the environment further. The paper suggests that the "critic" - the part of the reinforcement learning system that evaluates the quality of actions - plays a critical role in solving this challenge.
The authors propose a method called Offline Boosted Actor-Critic (OBAC) that combines an optimal policy evaluation with a "behavioral supervisor" - a model trained on the offline data to mimic the behavior of the original agent. This adaptive blending allows OBAC to balance exploration of the optimal policy with exploitation of the known behavioral patterns in the data, leading to improved sample efficiency and performance.
The paper also reviews related work in this area, such as methods for efficiently evaluating policies from offline data, tuning the behavioral supervisor, and strategically exploring the action space to learn safely from the limited offline data.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a method called Offline Boosted Actor-Critic (OBAC) for efficient offline reinforcement learning. OBAC combines an optimal policy evaluation component with a behavioral supervisor component, adaptively blending the two to balance exploration and exploitation.
The optimal policy evaluation component uses a variant of fitted Q-iteration to learn the optimal action-value function from the offline dataset. The behavioral supervisor component is a neural network policy trained to mimic the behavior of the original agent that generated the offline data.
OBAC adaptively blends the outputs of these two components when selecting actions, using a gating network that is also trained on the offline data. This allows OBAC to leverage the optimal policy when the data supports it, while also utilizing the known behavioral patterns captured by the supervisor to improve sample efficiency.
The paper evaluates OBAC on a range of continuous control benchmark tasks, comparing it to related offline reinforcement learning methods such as Efficient Policy Evaluation, Behavioral Supervisor Tuning, and Strategically Conservative Q-Learning. The results show that OBAC outperforms these baselines in terms of sample efficiency and final performance.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for the importance of the critic in efficient offline reinforcement learning. By adaptively blending the optimal policy evaluation and the behavioral supervisor, OBAC is able to balance exploration and exploitation to achieve strong performance on the benchmark tasks.
However, the paper does not address some potential limitations of the approach. For example, the reliance on a behavioral supervisor means that OBAC may struggle in settings where the offline data does not adequately capture the full range of behaviors required for the task. Additionally, the gating network that blends the two components adds complexity to the overall system, which could make it challenging to scale to larger or more complex problems.
It would also be interesting to see how OBAC performs in settings where the offline data is noisy, biased, or incomplete - scenarios that are often encountered in real-world applications of reinforcement learning. The paper's experiments focus on clean, high-quality datasets, so the robustness of OBAC to more realistic data conditions is not fully explored.
Overall, the paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of offline reinforcement learning by highlighting the critical role of the critic and proposing a novel approach to leveraging both optimal and behavioral information. Further research to address the potential limitations and expand the application of OBAC could lead to even more significant advancements in this important area of machine learning.
Conclusion
The paper "Efficient Offline Reinforcement Learning: The Critic is Critical" proposes a new method called Offline Boosted Actor-Critic (OBAC) that adaptively blends an optimal policy evaluation with a behavioral supervisor to improve sample efficiency and performance in offline reinforcement learning.
By recognizing the central role of the critic in offline RL, the authors have developed a technique that can effectively leverage both optimal and behavioral information from the fixed dataset, outperforming related approaches on benchmark tasks. This work highlights the importance of carefully designing the critic component in offline RL systems and opens up new avenues for research in this growing field of machine learning.
The insights and methods presented in this paper have the potential to enable more robust and sample-efficient offline reinforcement learning, which could lead to significant advancements in areas such as robotics, recommendation systems, and autonomous decision-making.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Offline-Boosted Actor-Critic: Adaptively Blending Optimal Historical Behaviors in Deep Off-Policy RL
Yu Luo, Tianying Ji, Fuchun Sun, Jianwei Zhang, Huazhe Xu, Xianyuan Zhan
0
0
Off-policy reinforcement learning (RL) has achieved notable success in tackling many complex real-world tasks, by leveraging previously collected data for policy learning. However, most existing off-policy RL algorithms fail to maximally exploit the information in the replay buffer, limiting sample efficiency and policy performance. In this work, we discover that concurrently training an offline RL policy based on the shared online replay buffer can sometimes outperform the original online learning policy, though the occurrence of such performance gains remains uncertain. This motivates a new possibility of harnessing the emergent outperforming offline optimal policy to improve online policy learning. Based on this insight, we present Offline-Boosted Actor-Critic (OBAC), a model-free online RL framework that elegantly identifies the outperforming offline policy through value comparison, and uses it as an adaptive constraint to guarantee stronger policy learning performance. Our experiments demonstrate that OBAC outperforms other popular model-free RL baselines and rivals advanced model-based RL methods in terms of sample efficiency and asymptotic performance across 53 tasks spanning 6 task suites.
5/30/2024
📊
Efficient Policy Evaluation with Offline Data Informed Behavior Policy Design
Shuze Liu, Shangtong Zhang
0
0
Most reinforcement learning practitioners evaluate their policies with online Monte Carlo estimators for either hyperparameter tuning or testing different algorithmic design choices, where the policy is repeatedly executed in the environment to get the average outcome. Such massive interactions with the environment are prohibitive in many scenarios. In this paper, we propose novel methods that improve the data efficiency of online Monte Carlo estimators while maintaining their unbiasedness. We first propose a tailored closed-form behavior policy that provably reduces the variance of an online Monte Carlo estimator. We then design efficient algorithms to learn this closed-form behavior policy from previously collected offline data. Theoretical analysis is provided to characterize how the behavior policy learning error affects the amount of reduced variance. Compared with previous works, our method achieves better empirical performance in a broader set of environments, with fewer requirements for offline data.
6/3/2024
🏅
Offline Reinforcement Learning with Behavioral Supervisor Tuning
Padmanaba Srinivasan, William Knottenbelt
0
0
Offline reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms are applied to learn performant, well-generalizing policies when provided with a static dataset of interactions. Many recent approaches to offline RL have seen substantial success, but with one key caveat: they demand substantial per-dataset hyperparameter tuning to achieve reported performance, which requires policy rollouts in the environment to evaluate; this can rapidly become cumbersome. Furthermore, substantial tuning requirements can hamper the adoption of these algorithms in practical domains. In this paper, we present TD3 with Behavioral Supervisor Tuning (TD3-BST), an algorithm that trains an uncertainty model and uses it to guide the policy to select actions within the dataset support. TD3-BST can learn more effective policies from offline datasets compared to previous methods and achieves the best performance across challenging benchmarks without requiring per-dataset tuning.
4/26/2024
Strategically Conservative Q-Learning
Yutaka Shimizu, Joey Hong, Sergey Levine, Masayoshi Tomizuka
0
0
Offline reinforcement learning (RL) is a compelling paradigm to extend RL's practical utility by leveraging pre-collected, static datasets, thereby avoiding the limitations associated with collecting online interactions. The major difficulty in offline RL is mitigating the impact of approximation errors when encountering out-of-distribution (OOD) actions; doing so ineffectively will lead to policies that prefer OOD actions, which can lead to unexpected and potentially catastrophic results. Despite the variety of works proposed to address this issue, they tend to excessively suppress the value function in and around OOD regions, resulting in overly pessimistic value estimates. In this paper, we propose a novel framework called Strategically Conservative Q-Learning (SCQ) that distinguishes between OOD data that is easy and hard to estimate, ultimately resulting in less conservative value estimates. Our approach exploits the inherent strengths of neural networks to interpolate, while carefully navigating their limitations in extrapolation, to obtain pessimistic yet still property calibrated value estimates. Theoretical analysis also shows that the value function learned by SCQ is still conservative, but potentially much less so than that of Conservative Q-learning (CQL). Finally, extensive evaluation on the D4RL benchmark tasks shows our proposed method outperforms state-of-the-art methods. Our code is available through url{https://github.com/purewater0901/SCQ}.
6/10/2024