EIA: Environmental Injection Attack on Generalist Web Agents for Privacy Leakage

Read original: arXiv:2409.11295 - Published 9/18/2024 by Zeyi Liao, Lingbo Mo, Chejian Xu, Mintong Kang, Jiawei Zhang, Chaowei Xiao, Yuan Tian, Bo Li, Huan Sun

🤖

Overview

Generalist web agents, which can perform a wide range of tasks, have rapidly evolved and shown great potential.
However, these agents also pose unprecedented privacy and safety risks that have not been widely explored.
This paper aims to address this gap by conducting the first study on the privacy risks of generalist web agents in adversarial environments.

Plain English Explanation

The paper describes a new type of attack, called the Environmental Injection Attack (EIA), that targets the privacy of users interacting with generalist web agents. These agents are software programs that can perform a wide variety of tasks on the web, like searching, reading, and interacting with web pages.

The key idea behind the EIA is to inject malicious content into the web environment that the agent operates in. This malicious content is designed to trick the agent into performing unintended actions, such as leaking the user's personal information. The attack can be carried out in a stealthy manner by leveraging features of web technologies like CSS and JavaScript.

The researchers tested the EIA on one of the most capable generalist web agent frameworks, called SeeAct, using realistic websites from the Mind2Web dataset. The results showed that the EIA could successfully steal up to 70% of a user's specific personal information, and even steal the entire user request in some cases, although this was more challenging.

The paper highlights the trade-off between the high autonomy of these generalist web agents and the security risks they pose. While the EIA can be effective, it can also be detected through careful human inspection, underscoring the need for robust defenses to protect user privacy.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a threat model that identifies the adversarial targets, constraints, and attack scenarios for generalist web agents. The two main adversarial targets are:

Stealing users' specific personally identifiable information (PII)
Stealing the entire user request

To achieve these objectives, the researchers propose a novel attack method called the Environmental Injection Attack (EIA). The EIA injects malicious content designed to adapt well to different environments where the agents operate, causing them to perform unintended actions.

The paper instantiates the EIA specifically for the privacy scenario. It inserts malicious web elements alongside persuasive instructions that mislead web agents into leaking private information, and can further leverage CSS and JavaScript features to remain stealthy.

The researchers collected 177 action steps involving diverse PII categories on realistic websites from the Mind2Web dataset, and conducted extensive experiments using the SeeAct generalist web agent framework. The results demonstrate that the EIA achieves up to 70% attack success rate (ASR) in stealing users' specific PII. Stealing full user requests is more challenging, but a relaxed version of the EIA can still achieve 16% ASR.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive analysis of the EIA and its effectiveness in compromising the privacy of users interacting with generalist web agents. However, it is important to note that the attack can still be detectable through careful human inspection, highlighting the trade-off between high autonomy and security.

The paper also acknowledges that the attack scenario is limited to the specific threat model and adversarial targets considered. Further research is needed to explore the broader implications of EIA and other potential attacks on the security and safety of generalist web agents.

Additionally, the paper does not provide detailed information on potential defense mechanisms that could mitigate the EIA and similar attacks. Exploring effective countermeasures should be a key priority for future research in this area.

Conclusion

This paper presents the first study on the privacy risks of generalist web agents in adversarial environments, highlighting the need for a deeper understanding of the security implications of these rapidly evolving technologies. The Environmental Injection Attack (EIA) demonstrates that significant privacy breaches are possible, even for some of the most capable generalist web agent frameworks.

While the paper provides valuable insights, it also underscores the importance of developing robust defense mechanisms to protect users' personal information and ensure the safe and responsible deployment of generalist web agents. As these technologies continue to advance, ongoing research and collaboration between researchers, developers, and policymakers will be crucial to addressing the emerging privacy and security challenges.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🤖

New!EIA: Environmental Injection Attack on Generalist Web Agents for Privacy Leakage

Zeyi Liao, Lingbo Mo, Chejian Xu, Mintong Kang, Jiawei Zhang, Chaowei Xiao, Yuan Tian, Bo Li, Huan Sun

Generalist web agents have evolved rapidly and demonstrated remarkable potential. However, there are unprecedented safety risks associated with these them, which are nearly unexplored so far. In this work, we aim to narrow this gap by conducting the first study on the privacy risks of generalist web agents in adversarial environments. First, we present a threat model that discusses the adversarial targets, constraints, and attack scenarios. Particularly, we consider two types of adversarial targets: stealing users' specific personally identifiable information (PII) or stealing the entire user request. To achieve these objectives, we propose a novel attack method, termed Environmental Injection Attack (EIA). This attack injects malicious content designed to adapt well to different environments where the agents operate, causing them to perform unintended actions. This work instantiates EIA specifically for the privacy scenario. It inserts malicious web elements alongside persuasive instructions that mislead web agents into leaking private information, and can further leverage CSS and JavaScript features to remain stealthy. We collect 177 actions steps that involve diverse PII categories on realistic websites from the Mind2Web dataset, and conduct extensive experiments using one of the most capable generalist web agent frameworks to date, SeeAct. The results demonstrate that EIA achieves up to 70% ASR in stealing users' specific PII. Stealing full user requests is more challenging, but a relaxed version of EIA can still achieve 16% ASR. Despite these concerning results, it is important to note that the attack can still be detectable through careful human inspection, highlighting a trade-off between high autonomy and security. This leads to our detailed discussion on the efficacy of EIA under different levels of human supervision as well as implications on defenses for generalist web agents.

9/18/2024

New!Anti-ESIA: Analyzing and Mitigating Impacts of Electromagnetic Signal Injection Attacks

Denglin Kang, Youqian Zhang, Wai Cheong Tam, Eugene Y. Fu

Cameras are integral components of many critical intelligent systems. However, a growing threat, known as Electromagnetic Signal Injection Attacks (ESIA), poses a significant risk to these systems, where ESIA enables attackers to remotely manipulate images captured by cameras, potentially leading to malicious actions and catastrophic consequences. Despite the severity of this threat, the underlying reasons for ESIA's effectiveness remain poorly understood, and effective countermeasures are lacking. This paper aims to address these gaps by investigating ESIA from two distinct aspects: pixel loss and color strips. By analyzing these aspects separately on image classification tasks, we gain a deeper understanding of how ESIA can compromise intelligent systems. Additionally, we explore a lightweight solution to mitigate the effects of ESIA while acknowledging its limitations. Our findings provide valuable insights for future research and development in the field of camera security and intelligent systems.

9/18/2024

Compromising Embodied Agents with Contextual Backdoor Attacks

Aishan Liu, Yuguang Zhou, Xianglong Liu, Tianyuan Zhang, Siyuan Liang, Jiakai Wang, Yanjun Pu, Tianlin Li, Junqi Zhang, Wenbo Zhou, Qing Guo, Dacheng Tao

Large language models (LLMs) have transformed the development of embodied intelligence. By providing a few contextual demonstrations, developers can utilize the extensive internal knowledge of LLMs to effortlessly translate complex tasks described in abstract language into sequences of code snippets, which will serve as the execution logic for embodied agents. However, this paper uncovers a significant backdoor security threat within this process and introduces a novel method called method{}. By poisoning just a few contextual demonstrations, attackers can covertly compromise the contextual environment of a black-box LLM, prompting it to generate programs with context-dependent defects. These programs appear logically sound but contain defects that can activate and induce unintended behaviors when the operational agent encounters specific triggers in its interactive environment. To compromise the LLM's contextual environment, we employ adversarial in-context generation to optimize poisoned demonstrations, where an LLM judge evaluates these poisoned prompts, reporting to an additional LLM that iteratively optimizes the demonstration in a two-player adversarial game using chain-of-thought reasoning. To enable context-dependent behaviors in downstream agents, we implement a dual-modality activation strategy that controls both the generation and execution of program defects through textual and visual triggers. We expand the scope of our attack by developing five program defect modes that compromise key aspects of confidentiality, integrity, and availability in embodied agents. To validate the effectiveness of our approach, we conducted extensive experiments across various tasks, including robot planning, robot manipulation, and compositional visual reasoning. Additionally, we demonstrate the potential impact of our approach by successfully attacking real-world autonomous driving systems.

8/7/2024

Unleashing Worms and Extracting Data: Escalating the Outcome of Attacks against RAG-based Inference in Scale and Severity Using Jailbreaking

Stav Cohen, Ron Bitton, Ben Nassi

In this paper, we show that with the ability to jailbreak a GenAI model, attackers can escalate the outcome of attacks against RAG-based GenAI-powered applications in severity and scale. In the first part of the paper, we show that attackers can escalate RAG membership inference attacks and RAG entity extraction attacks to RAG documents extraction attacks, forcing a more severe outcome compared to existing attacks. We evaluate the results obtained from three extraction methods, the influence of the type and the size of five embeddings algorithms employed, the size of the provided context, and the GenAI engine. We show that attackers can extract 80%-99.8% of the data stored in the database used by the RAG of a Q&A chatbot. In the second part of the paper, we show that attackers can escalate the scale of RAG data poisoning attacks from compromising a single GenAI-powered application to compromising the entire GenAI ecosystem, forcing a greater scale of damage. This is done by crafting an adversarial self-replicating prompt that triggers a chain reaction of a computer worm within the ecosystem and forces each affected application to perform a malicious activity and compromise the RAG of additional applications. We evaluate the performance of the worm in creating a chain of confidential data extraction about users within a GenAI ecosystem of GenAI-powered email assistants and analyze how the performance of the worm is affected by the size of the context, the adversarial self-replicating prompt used, the type and size of the embeddings algorithm employed, and the number of hops in the propagation. Finally, we review and analyze guardrails to protect RAG-based inference and discuss the tradeoffs.

9/14/2024