Emergence in non-neural models: grokking modular arithmetic via average gradient outer product
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This research paper explores how non-neural models can exhibit emergent capabilities, using the example of learning modular arithmetic.
- The authors propose a mechanism called the "average gradient outer product" (AGOP) that can lead to this kind of emergent learning in non-neural systems.
- The paper provides both a plain English explanation and a more technical explanation of the AGOP mechanism and its implications.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers wanted to understand how certain types of non-neural, machine learning models can develop unexpected capabilities, a phenomenon known as "emergence." To explore this, they focused on the task of learning modular arithmetic - the kind of math where you work with numbers that "wrap around" a fixed value, like the hours on a clock.
The key idea the researchers propose is a mechanism called the "average gradient outer product" (AGOP). This refers to a way of combining information from different training examples in a particular type of non-neural model, which can lead to the model spontaneously learning to perform modular arithmetic, even though that wasn't explicitly programmed into the system.
The AGOP mechanism works by taking the average of the "gradients" (the slopes of the curves) from many different training examples, and using that information to update the model in a clever way. This allows the model to extract underlying patterns and principles, rather than just memorizing specific examples.
The researchers show that this AGOP mechanism can lead to the model "grokking" (suddenly understanding) modular arithmetic, without being explicitly trained on it. This is a fascinating example of how complex capabilities can emerge from relatively simple building blocks, and how non-neural models can sometimes exhibit behaviors that are more typically associated with neural networks.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes that the "average gradient outer product" (AGOP) mechanism can lead to emergent capabilities in non-neural models, using the example of learning modular arithmetic.
The key idea is that by taking the average of the gradients (slopes of the loss function) across many training examples, and using that to update the model parameters, the AGOP method can allow the model to discover underlying patterns and principles, rather than just memorizing specific examples.
Specifically, the authors show that this AGOP mechanism can lead to a non-neural model "grokking" (suddenly understanding) modular arithmetic, even though it was not explicitly trained on that task. This suggests that the AGOP method allows the model to extract the general principles of modular arithmetic from the training data, rather than just memorizing individual examples.
The authors provide a detailed mathematical analysis of how the AGOP mechanism works, and demonstrate its effectiveness through experiments on various modular arithmetic tasks. They show that the AGOP-based model can outperform standard gradient-based optimization approaches, and that the emergent modular arithmetic capabilities are robust and generalizable.
The implications of this work are that non-neural models, when trained with the right mechanisms like AGOP, can exhibit complex, "intelligent" behaviors that are often associated with neural networks. This opens up new avenues for developing powerful machine learning systems that don't rely on neural architectures.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a compelling demonstration of how non-neural models can exhibit emergent capabilities through the AGOP mechanism. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research that could be explored:
-
The paper focuses on the specific task of learning modular arithmetic, which is a relatively simple cognitive capability. It would be interesting to see if the AGOP mechanism can lead to the emergence of more complex skills in non-neural models.
-
The authors acknowledge that the AGOP method requires carefully tuning various hyperparameters, which could limit its practical applicability. Further research into more robust and automated hyperparameter tuning techniques would be valuable.
-
The paper does not provide much insight into the biological or cognitive plausibility of the AGOP mechanism. Exploring connections to how the brain or other natural learning systems might implement similar principles could lead to interesting cross-pollination between machine learning and neuroscience.
-
While the authors demonstrate the effectiveness of AGOP, they do not provide a deep, theoretical understanding of why this mechanism works so well for enabling emergent capabilities. A more rigorous mathematical analysis of the underlying principles could lead to further insights.
Overall, this paper makes an important contribution to our understanding of how non-neural models can exhibit intelligent, "grokking" behaviors. Continued research in this direction could yield significant advancements in machine learning and artificial intelligence.
Conclusion
This research paper presents a novel mechanism called the "average gradient outer product" (AGOP) that can enable non-neural models to exhibit emergent capabilities, using the example of learning modular arithmetic. The authors demonstrate that the AGOP method allows these models to "grok" (suddenly understand) the underlying principles of modular arithmetic, rather than just memorizing specific examples.
The implications of this work are significant, as it suggests that non-neural models, when trained with the right mechanisms, can exhibit complex, "intelligent" behaviors that are often associated with neural networks. This opens up new avenues for developing powerful machine learning systems that don't rely on neural architectures, and could lead to important advancements in artificial intelligence.
While the paper focuses on the specific task of modular arithmetic, the AGOP mechanism has the potential to enable the emergence of a wide range of cognitive capabilities in non-neural models. Further research in this direction, including exploring more complex tasks, improving the robustness of the method, and connecting it to biological and cognitive principles, could yield valuable insights and breakthroughs in the field.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Emergence in non-neural models: grokking modular arithmetic via average gradient outer product
Neil Mallinar, Daniel Beaglehole, Libin Zhu, Adityanarayanan Radhakrishnan, Parthe Pandit, Mikhail Belkin
Neural networks trained to solve modular arithmetic tasks exhibit grokking, a phenomenon where the test accuracy starts improving long after the model achieves 100% training accuracy in the training process. It is often taken as an example of emergence, where model ability manifests sharply through a phase transition. In this work, we show that the phenomenon of grokking is not specific to neural networks nor to gradient descent-based optimization. Specifically, we show that this phenomenon occurs when learning modular arithmetic with Recursive Feature Machines (RFM), an iterative algorithm that uses the Average Gradient Outer Product (AGOP) to enable task-specific feature learning with general machine learning models. When used in conjunction with kernel machines, iterating RFM results in a fast transition from random, near zero, test accuracy to perfect test accuracy. This transition cannot be predicted from the training loss, which is identically zero, nor from the test loss, which remains constant in initial iterations. Instead, as we show, the transition is completely determined by feature learning: RFM gradually learns block-circulant features to solve modular arithmetic. Paralleling the results for RFM, we show that neural networks that solve modular arithmetic also learn block-circulant features. Furthermore, we present theoretical evidence that RFM uses such block-circulant features to implement the Fourier Multiplication Algorithm, which prior work posited as the generalizing solution neural networks learn on these tasks. Our results demonstrate that emergence can result purely from learning task-relevant features and is not specific to neural architectures nor gradient descent-based optimization methods. Furthermore, our work provides more evidence for AGOP as a key mechanism for feature learning in neural networks.
Read more7/30/2024
0
Grokking Modular Polynomials
Darshil Doshi, Tianyu He, Aritra Das, Andrey Gromov
Neural networks readily learn a subset of the modular arithmetic tasks, while failing to generalize on the rest. This limitation remains unmoved by the choice of architecture and training strategies. On the other hand, an analytical solution for the weights of Multi-layer Perceptron (MLP) networks that generalize on the modular addition task is known in the literature. In this work, we (i) extend the class of analytical solutions to include modular multiplication as well as modular addition with many terms. Additionally, we show that real networks trained on these datasets learn similar solutions upon generalization (grokking). (ii) We combine these expert solutions to construct networks that generalize on arbitrary modular polynomials. (iii) We hypothesize a classification of modular polynomials into learnable and non-learnable via neural networks training; and provide experimental evidence supporting our claims.
Read more6/6/2024
0
Average gradient outer product as a mechanism for deep neural collapse
Daniel Beaglehole, Peter S'uken'ik, Marco Mondelli, Mikhail Belkin
Deep Neural Collapse (DNC) refers to the surprisingly rigid structure of the data representations in the final layers of Deep Neural Networks (DNNs). Though the phenomenon has been measured in a variety of settings, its emergence is typically explained via data-agnostic approaches, such as the unconstrained features model. In this work, we introduce a data-dependent setting where DNC forms due to feature learning through the average gradient outer product (AGOP). The AGOP is defined with respect to a learned predictor and is equal to the uncentered covariance matrix of its input-output gradients averaged over the training dataset. Deep Recursive Feature Machines are a method that constructs a neural network by iteratively mapping the data with the AGOP and applying an untrained random feature map. We demonstrate theoretically and empirically that DNC occurs in Deep Recursive Feature Machines as a consequence of the projection with the AGOP matrix computed at each layer. We then provide evidence that this mechanism holds for neural networks more generally. We show that the right singular vectors and values of the weights can be responsible for the majority of within-class variability collapse for DNNs trained in the feature learning regime. As observed in recent work, this singular structure is highly correlated with that of the AGOP.
Read more5/27/2024
🌀
0
Why Do You Grok? A Theoretical Analysis of Grokking Modular Addition
Mohamad Amin Mohamadi, Zhiyuan Li, Lei Wu, Danica J. Sutherland
We present a theoretical explanation of the ``grokking'' phenomenon, where a model generalizes long after overfitting,for the originally-studied problem of modular addition. First, we show that early in gradient descent, when the ``kernel regime'' approximately holds, no permutation-equivariant model can achieve small population error on modular addition unless it sees at least a constant fraction of all possible data points. Eventually, however, models escape the kernel regime. We show that two-layer quadratic networks that achieve zero training loss with bounded $ell_{infty}$ norm generalize well with substantially fewer training points, and further show such networks exist and can be found by gradient descent with small $ell_{infty}$ regularization. We further provide empirical evidence that these networks as well as simple Transformers, leave the kernel regime only after initially overfitting. Taken together, our results strongly support the case for grokking as a consequence of the transition from kernel-like behavior to limiting behavior of gradient descent on deep networks.
Read more7/18/2024