Emergent World Representations: Exploring a Sequence Model Trained on a Synthetic Task
2210.13382
3
0
📈
Abstract
Language models show a surprising range of capabilities, but the source of their apparent competence is unclear. Do these networks just memorize a collection of surface statistics, or do they rely on internal representations of the process that generates the sequences they see? We investigate this question by applying a variant of the GPT model to the task of predicting legal moves in a simple board game, Othello. Although the network has no a priori knowledge of the game or its rules, we uncover evidence of an emergent nonlinear internal representation of the board state. Interventional experiments indicate this representation can be used to control the output of the network and create latent saliency maps that can help explain predictions in human terms.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper investigates whether language models like GPT rely on memorizing surface statistics or develop internal representations of the underlying process that generates the sequences they see.
- The researchers applied a variant of the GPT model to the task of predicting legal moves in the board game Othello, even though the model had no prior knowledge of the game's rules.
- They found evidence that the model developed an emergent, non-linear internal representation of the board state, which could be used to control the model's output and create interpretable saliency maps.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores how language models like GPT work under the hood. Do they simply memorize patterns in the data they're trained on, or do they actually learn some internal understanding of the underlying processes that generate the sequences they see?
To investigate this, the researchers applied a language model to the game of Othello, even though the model had no prior knowledge of the game's rules. Othello is a simple board game, so it provides a controlled environment to study the model's behavior.
Despite its lack of domain knowledge, the model was able to accurately predict legal moves in the game. The researchers found that the model had developed its own internal representation of the board state - a kind of mental map of what was happening on the board. This representation was non-linear and complex, going beyond just memorizing patterns.
Further experiments showed that this internal representation could be used to control the model's output and create interpretable "saliency maps" that highlighted the key factors influencing the model's predictions. This suggests the model isn't just reciting memorized facts, but has built up an understanding of the underlying dynamics of the game.
Technical Explanation
The researchers used a variant of the GPT language model, which they trained on a large corpus of text data, but without any specific knowledge about the game of Othello. They then tested the model's ability to predict legal moves in Othello games.
Despite having no a priori knowledge of the game's rules, the model was able to accurately predict legal moves. To understand how it was able to do this, the researchers probed the model's internal representations using a technique called "interventional analysis."
This involved systematically perturbing different parts of the model's internal state and observing the effects on its output. The researchers found that the model had developed a complex, non-linear representation of the Othello board state, which went beyond simply memorizing patterns in the training data.
Further experiments showed that this internal representation could be used to control the model's output and create interpretable "saliency maps" that highlighted the key factors influencing the model's predictions. This suggests the model has learned an understanding of the underlying dynamics of the game, rather than just relying on surface-level statistics.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides an intriguing glimpse into the inner workings of language models, but it's important to note that the research is limited in scope. The experiments were conducted on a simple board game, which may not fully capture the complexity of real-world language use.
Additionally, the researchers acknowledge that their interventional analysis technique has limitations and may not fully reveal the model's internal representations. There could be other, more sophisticated methods for probing the model's understanding.
Furthermore, the paper does not address the potential pitfalls of using language models for tasks they were not designed for, such as the risk of overfitting to the specific task domain. Caution is warranted when extrapolating these findings to more complex real-world applications.
Conclusion
This research provides an interesting case study on the inner workings of language models, suggesting that they can develop sophisticated internal representations that go beyond simple pattern matching. The ability to control the model's output and create interpretable saliency maps is particularly promising for improving the transparency and explainability of these powerful AI systems.
However, the findings are limited to a specific task and model architecture, and further research is needed to fully understand the generalizability and limitations of these techniques. As language models continue to advance, ongoing efforts to probe their inner workings and understand their strengths and weaknesses will be crucial for ensuring their safe and responsible development.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
State Soup: In-Context Skill Learning, Retrieval and Mixing
Maciej Pi'oro, Maciej Wo{l}czyk, Razvan Pascanu, Johannes von Oswald, Jo~ao Sacramento
0
0
A new breed of gated-linear recurrent neural networks has reached state-of-the-art performance on a range of sequence modeling problems. Such models naturally handle long sequences efficiently, as the cost of processing a new input is independent of sequence length. Here, we explore another advantage of these stateful sequence models, inspired by the success of model merging through parameter interpolation. Building on parallels between fine-tuning and in-context learning, we investigate whether we can treat internal states as task vectors that can be stored, retrieved, and then linearly combined, exploiting the linearity of recurrence. We study this form of fast model merging on Mamba-2.8b, a pretrained recurrent model, and present preliminary evidence that simple linear state interpolation methods suffice to improve next-token perplexity as well as downstream in-context learning task performance.
6/13/2024
💬
Response: Emergent analogical reasoning in large language models
Damian Hodel, Jevin West
0
0
In their recent Nature Human Behaviour paper, Emergent analogical reasoning in large language models, (Webb, Holyoak, and Lu, 2023) the authors argue that large language models such as GPT-3 have acquired an emergent ability to find zero-shot solutions to a broad range of analogy problems. In this response, we provide counterexamples of the letter string analogies. In our tests, GPT-3 fails to solve simplest variations of the original tasks, whereas human performance remains consistently high across all modified versions. Zero-shot reasoning is an extraordinary claim that requires extraordinary evidence. We do not see that evidence in our experiments. To strengthen claims of humanlike reasoning such as zero-shot reasoning, it is important that the field develop approaches that rule out data memorization.
5/2/2024
New!Fine-tuned network relies on generic representation to solve unseen cognitive task
Dongyan Lin
0
0
Fine-tuning pretrained language models has shown promising results on a wide range of tasks, but when encountering a novel task, do they rely more on generic pretrained representation, or develop brand new task-specific solutions? Here, we fine-tuned GPT-2 on a context-dependent decision-making task, novel to the model but adapted from neuroscience literature. We compared its performance and internal mechanisms to a version of GPT-2 trained from scratch on the same task. Our results show that fine-tuned models depend heavily on pretrained representations, particularly in later layers, while models trained from scratch develop different, more task-specific mechanisms. These findings highlight the advantages and limitations of pretraining for task generalization and underscore the need for further investigation into the mechanisms underpinning task-specific fine-tuning in LLMs.
6/28/2024
Player-Driven Emergence in LLM-Driven Game Narrative
Xiangyu Peng, Jessica Quaye, Sudha Rao, Weijia Xu, Portia Botchway, Chris Brockett, Nebojsa Jojic, Gabriel DesGarennes, Ken Lobb, Michael Xu, Jorge Leandro, Claire Jin, Bill Dolan
0
0
We explore how interaction with large language models (LLMs) can give rise to emergent behaviors, empowering players to participate in the evolution of game narratives. Our testbed is a text-adventure game in which players attempt to solve a mystery under a fixed narrative premise, but can freely interact with non-player characters generated by GPT-4, a large language model. We recruit 28 gamers to play the game and use GPT-4 to automatically convert the game logs into a node-graph representing the narrative in the player's gameplay. We find that through their interactions with the non-deterministic behavior of the LLM, players are able to discover interesting new emergent nodes that were not a part of the original narrative but have potential for being fun and engaging. Players that created the most emergent nodes tended to be those that often enjoy games that facilitate discovery, exploration and experimentation.
6/5/2024