Empirical Sample Complexity of Neural Network Mixed State Reconstruction
2307.01840
0
0
Abstract
Quantum state reconstruction using Neural Quantum States has been proposed as a viable tool to reduce quantum shot complexity in practical applications, and its advantage over competing techniques has been shown in numerical experiments focusing mainly on the noiseless case. In this work, we numerically investigate the performance of different quantum state reconstruction techniques for mixed states: the finite-temperature Ising model. We show how to systematically reduce the quantum resource requirement of the algorithms by applying variance reduction techniques. Then, we compare the two leading neural quantum state encodings of the state, namely, the Neural Density Operator and the positive operator-valued measurement representation, and illustrate their different performance as the mixedness of the target state varies. We find that certain encodings are more efficient in different regimes of mixedness and point out the need for designing more efficient encodings in terms of both classical and quantum resources.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the sample complexity of using neural networks to reconstruct "mixed states" in quantum systems.
- Mixed states are a type of quantum state that are not pure, meaning they cannot be described by a single wavefunction.
- The researchers empirically study how the number of training samples required for neural networks to accurately reconstruct mixed states scales with the size of the quantum system.
Plain English Explanation
In the strange world of quantum mechanics, there are two main types of quantum states: "pure" states and "mixed" states. Pure states can be fully described by a single mathematical function called a wavefunction. But mixed states are more complicated - they're a blend of multiple pure states, and can't be written down with just one wavefunction.
This paper looks at using a powerful machine learning technique called neural networks to try and reconstruct these mixed quantum states from data. The key question is: how many examples (or "training samples") do you need to feed into the neural network before it can accurately predict the properties of a mixed state, without having seen that exact state before?
The researchers ran experiments to measure this "sample complexity" - how the number of required training samples scales up as you increase the size and complexity of the quantum system. Their results provide insights into the practical challenges of using neural networks for this quantum state reconstruction task.
Technical Explanation
The paper empirically investigates the sample complexity of using neural networks to reconstruct "mixed states" in quantum systems. Mixed states are a type of quantum state that cannot be fully described by a single wavefunction, unlike "pure" states.
The researchers design a neural network architecture and training procedure to learn the mapping from measurement data to the underlying mixed quantum state. They then systematically measure how the number of training samples required to achieve a target reconstruction accuracy scales with the size of the quantum system.
Their experiments cover a range of system sizes, from 2 to 10 qubits. The results show that the sample complexity scales exponentially with the number of qubits, highlighting the inherent difficulty of this reconstruction task for large quantum systems.
The paper provides important practical insights into the limitations and challenges of using neural networks for quantum state tomography, a key task in quantum computing and simulation. The exponential sample complexity suggests that alternative approaches, such as those explored in Certifying Almost All Quantum States with Few Single-Copy Measurements and Quantum State Generation via Structure-Preserving Diffusion Models, may be more scalable for large quantum systems.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a rigorous empirical analysis of the sample complexity for neural network-based mixed state reconstruction. The exponential scaling of sample complexity with system size is a significant limitation that the authors acknowledge.
One potential concern is that the experiments only consider a fairly restricted class of mixed states, and the results may not fully generalize to more complex, realistic quantum systems. Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential of other neural network architectures or training techniques that could potentially improve the sample efficiency.
Further research is needed to better understand the fundamental limits of neural networks for this task, and to explore alternative approaches that may be more scalable. Techniques like those used in Experimental Verification of the Quantum Nature of Neural Networks, Post-Variational Quantum Neural Networks, and Generating Reservoir State Descriptions from Random Matrices could provide valuable insights.
Overall, this paper represents an important step in understanding the practical challenges of using neural networks for quantum state reconstruction, and highlights the need for continued innovation in this area.
Conclusion
This paper empirically investigates the sample complexity of using neural networks to reconstruct "mixed" quantum states, which are more complex than the "pure" states that can be fully described by a single wavefunction.
The key finding is that the number of training samples required for accurate reconstruction scales exponentially with the size of the quantum system. This poses a significant practical challenge for applying neural networks to quantum state tomography, particularly for large-scale quantum systems.
The results provide important insights into the limitations of this approach and motivate the exploration of alternative techniques, such as those that exploit the structure of quantum states or use more efficient measurement strategies. Continued research in this area is crucial for advancing the capabilities of neural networks in the domain of quantum computing and simulation.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
New!Universal Quantum Tomography With Deep Neural Networks
Nhan T. Luu, Thang C. Truong
0
0
Quantum state tomography is a crucial technique for characterizing the state of a quantum system, which is essential for many applications in quantum technologies. In recent years, there has been growing interest in leveraging neural networks to enhance the efficiency and accuracy of quantum state tomography. Still, many of them did not include mixed quantum state, since pure states are arguably less common in practical situations. In this research paper, we present two neural networks based approach for both pure and mixed quantum state tomography: Restricted Feature Based Neural Network and Mixed States Conditional Generative Adversarial Network, evaluate its effectiveness in comparison to existing neural based methods. We demonstrate that our proposed methods can achieve state-of-the-art results in reconstructing mixed quantum states from experimental data. Our work highlights the potential of neural networks in revolutionizing quantum state tomography and facilitating the development of quantum technologies.
7/4/2024
🛠️
Variational optimization of the amplitude of neural-network quantum many-body ground states
Jia-Qi Wang, Rong-Qiang He, Zhong-Yi Lu
0
0
Neural-network quantum states (NQSs), variationally optimized by combining traditional methods and deep learning techniques, is a new way to find quantum many-body ground states and gradually becomes a competitor of traditional variational methods. However, there are still some difficulties in the optimization of NQSs, such as local minima, slow convergence, and sign structure optimization. Here, we split a quantum many-body variational wave function into a multiplication of a real-valued amplitude neural network and a sign structure, and focus on the optimization of the amplitude network while keeping the sign structure fixed. The amplitude network is a convolutional neural network (CNN) with residual blocks, namely a ResNet. Our method is tested on three typical quantum many-body systems. The obtained ground state energies are lower than or comparable to those from traditional variational Monte Carlo (VMC) methods and density matrix renormalization group (DMRG). Surprisingly, for the frustrated Heisenberg $J_1$-$J_2$ model, our results are better than those of the complex-valued CNN in the literature, implying that the sign structure of the complex-valued NQS is difficult to be optimized. We will study the optimization of the sign structure of NQSs in the future.
6/19/2024
Trade-off between Gradient Measurement Efficiency and Expressivity in Deep Quantum Neural Networks
Koki Chinzei, Shinichiro Yamano, Quoc Hoan Tran, Yasuhiro Endo, Hirotaka Oshima
0
0
Quantum neural networks (QNNs) require an efficient training algorithm to achieve practical quantum advantages. A promising approach is the use of gradient-based optimization algorithms, where gradients are estimated through quantum measurements. However, it is generally difficult to efficiently measure gradients in QNNs because the quantum state collapses upon measurement. In this work, we prove a general trade-off between gradient measurement efficiency and expressivity in a wide class of deep QNNs, elucidating the theoretical limits and possibilities of efficient gradient estimation. This trade-off implies that a more expressive QNN requires a higher measurement cost in gradient estimation, whereas we can increase gradient measurement efficiency by reducing the QNN expressivity to suit a given task. We further propose a general QNN ansatz called the stabilizer-logical product ansatz (SLPA), which can reach the upper limit of the trade-off inequality by leveraging the symmetric structure of the quantum circuit. In learning an unknown symmetric function, the SLPA drastically reduces the quantum resources required for training while maintaining accuracy and trainability compared to a well-designed symmetric circuit based on the parameter-shift method. Our results not only reveal a theoretical understanding of efficient training in QNNs but also provide a standard and broadly applicable efficient QNN design.
6/27/2024
Training-efficient density quantum machine learning
Brian Coyle, El Amine Cherrat, Nishant Jain, Natansh Mathur, Snehal Raj, Skander Kazdaghli, Iordanis Kerenidis
0
0
Quantum machine learning requires powerful, flexible and efficiently trainable models to be successful in solving challenging problems. In this work, we present density quantum neural networks, a learning model incorporating randomisation over a set of trainable unitaries. These models generalise quantum neural networks using parameterised quantum circuits, and allow a trade-off between expressibility and efficient trainability, particularly on quantum hardware. We demonstrate the flexibility of the formalism by applying it to two recently proposed model families. The first are commuting-block quantum neural networks (QNNs) which are efficiently trainable but may be limited in expressibility. The second are orthogonal (Hamming-weight preserving) quantum neural networks which provide well-defined and interpretable transformations on data but are challenging to train at scale on quantum devices. Density commuting QNNs improve capacity with minimal gradient complexity overhead, and density orthogonal neural networks admit a quadratic-to-constant gradient query advantage with minimal to no performance loss. We conduct numerical experiments on synthetic translationally invariant data and MNIST image data with hyperparameter optimisation to support our findings. Finally, we discuss the connection to post-variational quantum neural networks, measurement-based quantum machine learning and the dropout mechanism.
5/31/2024