Enhancing Radiological Diagnosis: A Collaborative Approach Integrating AI and Human Expertise for Visual Miss Correction
0
🤖
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This study aimed to develop a collaborative AI system, CoRaX, to enhance diagnostic accuracy in chest radiology by identifying and correcting perceptual errors.
- CoRaX integrates eye gaze data and radiology reports to pinpoint perceptual errors and refine the decision-making process.
- The system was evaluated on its referral-making process, the quality of referrals, and performance in collaborative diagnostic settings.
Plain English Explanation
Chest X-rays are a crucial tool for diagnosing various medical conditions, but radiologists can sometimes miss important details or make mistakes in their interpretations. This study explored a new way to address this problem by developing an AI system called CoRaX that works together with human radiologists.
CoRaX uses a combination of information to identify and correct these perceptual errors. It analyzes the images, looks at where the radiologist's eyes focused, and reviews the radiologist's written report. By putting all of this data together, CoRaX can pinpoint the areas where the radiologist may have missed something or made a mistake in their interpretation.
The researchers tested CoRaX on a dataset of chest X-rays where they had intentionally introduced errors to see how well the system could catch and fix them. The results showed that CoRaX was able to correct about 21% of the errors, leaving 7% unresolved. The system also proved useful in helping radiologists make more accurate diagnoses, with 84% of their interactions with CoRaX scoring above 0.40 on a measure of diagnostic accuracy.
Overall, this research suggests that AI systems like CoRaX have the potential to work alongside human radiologists to improve the accuracy of chest X-ray interpretation, which could lead to better patient care and outcomes. It could also be useful for training new radiologists by helping them identify and learn from common perceptual errors.
Technical Explanation
This study aimed to develop a collaborative AI system, CoRaX, which integrates eye gaze data and radiology reports to enhance diagnostic accuracy in chest radiology by pinpointing perceptual errors and refining the decision-making process.
Using public datasets REFLACX and EGD-CXR, the researchers retrospectively developed CoRaX, employing a large multimodal model to analyze image embeddings, eye gaze data, and radiology reports.
The system's effectiveness was evaluated based on its referral-making process, the quality of referrals, and performance in collaborative diagnostic settings. CoRaX was tested on a simulated error dataset of 271 samples with 28% (93 of 332) missed abnormalities. The system corrected 21% (71 of 332) of these errors, leaving 7% (22 of 312) unresolved.
The Referral-Usefulness score, indicating the accuracy of predicted regions for all true referrals, was 0.63 (95% CI 0.59, 0.68). The Total-Usefulness score, reflecting the diagnostic accuracy of CoRaX's interactions with radiologists, showed that 84% (237 of 280) of these interactions had a score above 0.40.
Critical Analysis
The study represents an important step in exploring human-AI collaboration for medical image analysis, which has not been extensively researched before. The use of eye gaze data and radiology reports to identify perceptual errors is a novel approach that could have significant implications for improving diagnostic accuracy and radiologist training.
However, the study does have some limitations. The simulated error dataset used for evaluation may not fully capture the complexity and diversity of real-world perceptual errors encountered in clinical practice. Additionally, the study did not report on the generalizability of CoRaX's performance across different types of chest abnormalities or the potential impact on clinical workflows and decision-making.
Further research is needed to explore the integration of these collaborative AI systems into routine clinical practice, assess their long-term effectiveness, and investigate their impact on patient outcomes. It will also be important to consider the ethical implications of these systems, such as ensuring transparency, accountability, and the appropriate distribution of decision-making responsibilities between AI and human clinicians.
Conclusion
This study presents a promising collaborative AI system, CoRaX, that aims to enhance diagnostic accuracy in chest radiology by identifying and correcting perceptual errors. By integrating eye gaze data and radiology reports, CoRaX has demonstrated the ability to pinpoint areas of missed abnormalities and improve the decision-making process for radiologists.
The findings suggest that human-AI collaboration in medical image analysis has the potential to improve patient care and outcomes, as well as support the training and education of novice radiologists. As this field continues to evolve, it will be crucial to address the technical, ethical, and practical challenges to ensure the safe and effective deployment of these collaborative systems in clinical practice.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤖
0
Enhancing Radiological Diagnosis: A Collaborative Approach Integrating AI and Human Expertise for Visual Miss Correction
Akash Awasthi, Ngan Le, Zhigang Deng, Carol C. Wu, Hien Van Nguyen
Human-AI collaboration to identify and correct perceptual errors in chest radiographs has not been previously explored. This study aimed to develop a collaborative AI system, CoRaX, which integrates eye gaze data and radiology reports to enhance diagnostic accuracy in chest radiology by pinpointing perceptual errors and refining the decision-making process. Using public datasets REFLACX and EGD-CXR, the study retrospectively developed CoRaX, employing a large multimodal model to analyze image embeddings, eye gaze data, and radiology reports. The system's effectiveness was evaluated based on its referral-making process, the quality of referrals, and performance in collaborative diagnostic settings. CoRaX was tested on a simulated error dataset of 271 samples with 28% (93 of 332) missed abnormalities. The system corrected 21% (71 of 332) of these errors, leaving 7% (22 of 312) unresolved. The Referral-Usefulness score, indicating the accuracy of predicted regions for all true referrals, was 0.63 (95% CI 0.59, 0.68). The Total-Usefulness score, reflecting the diagnostic accuracy of CoRaX's interactions with radiologists, showed that 84% (237 of 280) of these interactions had a score above 0.40. In conclusion, CoRaX efficiently collaborates with radiologists to address perceptual errors across various abnormalities, with potential applications in the education and training of novice radiologists.
Read more7/1/2024
0
AI-Assisted Diagnosis for Covid-19 CXR Screening: From Data Collection to Clinical Validation
Carlo Alberto Barbano, Riccardo Renzulli, Marco Grosso, Domenico Basile, Marco Busso, Marco Grangetto
In this paper, we present the major results from the Covid Radiographic imaging System based on AI (Co.R.S.A.) project, which took place in Italy. This project aims to develop a state-of-the-art AI-based system for diagnosing Covid-19 pneumonia from Chest X-ray (CXR) images. The contributions of this work are manyfold: the release of the public CORDA dataset, a deep learning pipeline for Covid-19 detection, and the clinical validation of the developed solution by expert radiologists. The proposed detection model is based on a two-step approach that, paired with state-of-the-art debiasing, provides reliable results. Most importantly, our investigation includes the actual usage of the diagnosis aid tool by radiologists, allowing us to assess the real benefits in terms of accuracy and time efficiency. Project homepage: https://corsa.di.unito.it/
Read more5/21/2024
🔮
0
Multimodal Learning and Cognitive Processes in Radiology: MedGaze for Chest X-ray Scanpath Prediction
Akash Awasthi, Ngan Le, Zhigang Deng, Rishi Agrawal, Carol C. Wu, Hien Van Nguyen
Predicting human gaze behavior within computer vision is integral for developing interactive systems that can anticipate user attention, address fundamental questions in cognitive science, and hold implications for fields like human-computer interaction (HCI) and augmented/virtual reality (AR/VR) systems. Despite methodologies introduced for modeling human eye gaze behavior, applying these models to medical imaging for scanpath prediction remains unexplored. Our proposed system aims to predict eye gaze sequences from radiology reports and CXR images, potentially streamlining data collection and enhancing AI systems using larger datasets. However, predicting human scanpaths on medical images presents unique challenges due to the diverse nature of abnormal regions. Our model predicts fixation coordinates and durations critical for medical scanpath prediction, outperforming existing models in the computer vision community. Utilizing a two-stage training process and large publicly available datasets, our approach generates static heatmaps and eye gaze videos aligned with radiology reports, facilitating comprehensive analysis. We validate our approach by comparing its performance with state-of-the-art methods and assessing its generalizability among different radiologists, introducing novel strategies to model radiologists' search patterns during CXR image diagnosis. Based on the radiologist's evaluation, MedGaze can generate human-like gaze sequences with a high focus on relevant regions over the CXR images. It sometimes also outperforms humans in terms of redundancy and randomness in the scanpaths.
Read more7/2/2024
0
Enhancing Human-Computer Interaction in Chest X-ray Analysis using Vision and Language Model with Eye Gaze Patterns
Yunsoo Kim, Jinge Wu, Yusuf Abdulle, Yue Gao, Honghan Wu
Recent advancements in Computer Assisted Diagnosis have shown promising performance in medical imaging tasks, particularly in chest X-ray analysis. However, the interaction between these models and radiologists has been primarily limited to input images. This work proposes a novel approach to enhance human-computer interaction in chest X-ray analysis using Vision-Language Models (VLMs) enhanced with radiologists' attention by incorporating eye gaze data alongside textual prompts. Our approach leverages heatmaps generated from eye gaze data, overlaying them onto medical images to highlight areas of intense radiologist's focus during chest X-ray evaluation. We evaluate this methodology in tasks such as visual question answering, chest X-ray report automation, error detection, and differential diagnosis. Our results demonstrate the inclusion of eye gaze information significantly enhances the accuracy of chest X-ray analysis. Also, the impact of eye gaze on fine-tuning was confirmed as it outperformed other medical VLMs in all tasks except visual question answering. This work marks the potential of leveraging both the VLM's capabilities and the radiologist's domain knowledge to improve the capabilities of AI models in medical imaging, paving a novel way for Computer Assisted Diagnosis with a human-centred AI.
Read more4/4/2024