Evaluating the Generalization Ability of Spatiotemporal Model in Urban Scenario
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper evaluates the generalization ability of a spatiotemporal model in an urban traffic forecasting scenario.
- The model is tested on different cities to understand how well it can adapt to new data distributions.
- Experiments compare the model's performance on in-distribution and out-of-distribution test sets.
- The research provides insights into the model's strengths, weaknesses, and potential for domain generalization.
Plain English Explanation
In this paper, the researchers looked at how well a traffic forecasting model that uses spatial and temporal information can work in different cities. They wanted to see if the model could adapt and make accurate predictions even when the data from a new city is different from the data it was trained on.
The researchers tested the model on data from multiple cities, including both the cities it was originally trained on (in-distribution) and new cities it had not seen before (out-of-distribution). By comparing the model's performance in these different settings, they could evaluate how well it can generalize to new urban environments.
The findings provide insights into the model's strengths and limitations when it comes to handling variations in traffic patterns across different cities. This information is valuable for understanding the potential and the challenges of using this type of spatiotemporal model for traffic forecasting in diverse urban scenarios.
Technical Explanation
The paper focuses on evaluating the domain generalization capability of a spatiotemporal model for traffic forecasting in an urban computing context. The model is tested on both in-distribution and out-of-distribution test sets to understand how well it can adapt to new data distributions.
The experiments compare the model's performance on different cities, some of which were used during training (in-distribution) and others that were completely new (out-of-distribution). This allows the researchers to assess the model's ability to generalize its learned representations and make accurate predictions in unfamiliar urban environments.
The results provide insights into the strengths and limitations of the spatiotemporal model when faced with variations in traffic patterns across cities. This information is crucial for understanding the potential and the challenges of deploying such models in diverse real-world urban scenarios.
Critical Analysis
The paper acknowledges that the model's performance may be affected by differences in data distribution, road network structures, and other contextual factors across cities. While the experiments explore the model's ability to generalize, the researchers note that further research is needed to understand the specific factors that influence the model's generalization capability.
Additionally, the paper does not provide a comprehensive analysis of the model's robustness to different types of distributional shifts, such as changes in traffic patterns over time or unexpected events. Exploring these aspects could further strengthen the understanding of the model's practical applicability in dynamic urban environments.
Conclusion
This research provides valuable insights into the generalization ability of a spatiotemporal model for traffic forecasting in diverse urban settings. By evaluating the model's performance on both in-distribution and out-of-distribution test sets, the study offers a nuanced understanding of the model's strengths and limitations when adapting to new data distributions.
The findings highlight the importance of considering domain generalization when developing and deploying traffic forecasting models in real-world urban scenarios, where variations in traffic patterns and contextual factors can significantly impact model performance. This knowledge can inform the design of more robust and adaptable urban computing solutions.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Evaluating the Generalization Ability of Spatiotemporal Model in Urban Scenario
Hongjun Wang, Jiyuan Chen, Tong Pan, Zheng Dong, Lingyu Zhang, Renhe Jiang, Xuan Song
Spatiotemporal neural networks have shown great promise in urban scenarios by effectively capturing temporal and spatial correlations. However, urban environments are constantly evolving, and current model evaluations are often limited to traffic scenarios and use data mainly collected only a few weeks after training period to evaluate model performance. The generalization ability of these models remains largely unexplored. To address this, we propose a Spatiotemporal Out-of-Distribution (ST-OOD) benchmark, which comprises six urban scenario: bike-sharing, 311 services, pedestrian counts, traffic speed, traffic flow, ride-hailing demand, and bike-sharing, each with in-distribution (same year) and out-of-distribution (next years) settings. We extensively evaluate state-of-the-art spatiotemporal models and find that their performance degrades significantly in out-of-distribution settings, with most models performing even worse than a simple Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP). Our findings suggest that current leading methods tend to over-rely on parameters to overfit training data, which may lead to good performance on in-distribution data but often results in poor generalization. We also investigated whether dropout could mitigate the negative effects of overfitting. Our results showed that a slight dropout rate could significantly improve generalization performance on most datasets, with minimal impact on in-distribution performance. However, balancing in-distribution and out-of-distribution performance remains a challenging problem. We hope that the proposed benchmark will encourage further research on this critical issue.
Read more10/10/2024
0
Robust Traffic Forecasting against Spatial Shift over Years
Hongjun Wang, Jiyuan Chen, Tong Pan, Zheng Dong, Lingyu Zhang, Renhe Jiang, Xuan Song
Recent advancements in Spatiotemporal Graph Neural Networks (ST-GNNs) and Transformers have demonstrated promising potential for traffic forecasting by effectively capturing both temporal and spatial correlations. The generalization ability of spatiotemporal models has received considerable attention in recent scholarly discourse. However, no substantive datasets specifically addressing traffic out-of-distribution (OOD) scenarios have been proposed. Existing ST-OOD methods are either constrained to testing on extant data or necessitate manual modifications to the dataset. Consequently, the generalization capacity of current spatiotemporal models in OOD scenarios remains largely underexplored. In this paper, we investigate state-of-the-art models using newly proposed traffic OOD benchmarks and, surprisingly, find that these models experience a significant decline in performance. Through meticulous analysis, we attribute this decline to the models' inability to adapt to previously unobserved spatial relationships. To address this challenge, we propose a novel Mixture of Experts (MoE) framework, which learns a set of graph generators (i.e., graphons) during training and adaptively combines them to generate new graphs based on novel environmental conditions to handle spatial distribution shifts during testing. We further extend this concept to the Transformer architecture, achieving substantial improvements. Our method is both parsimonious and efficacious, and can be seamlessly integrated into any spatiotemporal model, outperforming current state-of-the-art approaches in addressing spatial dynamics.
Read more10/2/2024
0
Benchmarking Out-of-Distribution Generalization Capabilities of DNN-based Encoding Models for the Ventral Visual Cortex
Spandan Madan, Will Xiao, Mingran Cao, Hanspeter Pfister, Margaret Livingstone, Gabriel Kreiman
We characterized the generalization capabilities of DNN-based encoding models when predicting neuronal responses from the visual cortex. We collected textit{MacaqueITBench}, a large-scale dataset of neural population responses from the macaque inferior temporal (IT) cortex to over $300,000$ images, comprising $8,233$ unique natural images presented to seven monkeys over $109$ sessions. Using textit{MacaqueITBench}, we investigated the impact of distribution shifts on models predicting neural activity by dividing the images into Out-Of-Distribution (OOD) train and test splits. The OOD splits included several different image-computable types including image contrast, hue, intensity, temperature, and saturation. Compared to the performance on in-distribution test images -- the conventional way these models have been evaluated -- models performed worse at predicting neuronal responses to out-of-distribution images, retaining as little as $20%$ of the performance on in-distribution test images. The generalization performance under OOD shifts can be well accounted by a simple image similarity metric -- the cosine distance between image representations extracted from a pre-trained object recognition model is a strong predictor of neural predictivity under different distribution shifts. The dataset of images, neuronal firing rate recordings, and computational benchmarks are hosted publicly at: https://bit.ly/3zeutVd.
Read more6/26/2024
0
OpenCity: Open Spatio-Temporal Foundation Models for Traffic Prediction
Zhonghang Li, Long Xia, Lei Shi, Yong Xu, Dawei Yin, Chao Huang
Accurate traffic forecasting is crucial for effective urban planning and transportation management, enabling efficient resource allocation and enhanced travel experiences. However, existing models often face limitations in generalization, struggling with zero-shot prediction on unseen regions and cities, as well as diminished long-term accuracy. This is primarily due to the inherent challenges in handling the spatial and temporal heterogeneity of traffic data, coupled with the significant distribution shift across time and space. In this work, we aim to unlock new possibilities for building versatile, resilient and adaptive spatio-temporal foundation models for traffic prediction. To achieve this goal, we introduce a novel foundation model, named OpenCity, that can effectively capture and normalize the underlying spatio-temporal patterns from diverse data characteristics, facilitating zero-shot generalization across diverse urban environments. OpenCity integrates the Transformer architecture with graph neural networks to model the complex spatio-temporal dependencies in traffic data. By pre-training OpenCity on large-scale, heterogeneous traffic datasets, we enable the model to learn rich, generalizable representations that can be seamlessly applied to a wide range of traffic forecasting scenarios. Experimental results demonstrate that OpenCity exhibits exceptional zero-shot predictive performance. Moreover, OpenCity showcases promising scaling laws, suggesting the potential for developing a truly one-for-all traffic prediction solution that can adapt to new urban contexts with minimal overhead. We made our proposed OpenCity model open-source and it is available at the following link: https://github.com/HKUDS/OpenCity.
Read more8/21/2024