Event prediction and causality inference despite incomplete information

2406.05893

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 6/11/2024 by Harrison Lam, Yuanjie Chen, Noboru Kanazawa, Mohammad Chowdhury, Anna Battista, Stephan Waldert
Event prediction and causality inference despite incomplete information

Abstract

We explored the challenge of predicting and explaining the occurrence of events within sequences of data points. Our focus was particularly on scenarios in which unknown triggers causing the occurrence of events may consist of non-consecutive, masked, noisy data points. This scenario is akin to an agent tasked with learning to predict and explain the occurrence of events without understanding the underlying processes or having access to crucial information. Such scenarios are encountered across various fields, such as genomics, hardware and software verification, and financial time series prediction. We combined analytical, simulation, and machine learning (ML) approaches to investigate, quantify, and provide solutions to this challenge. We deduced and validated equations generally applicable to any variation of the underlying challenge. Using these equations, we (1) described how the level of complexity changes with various parameters (e.g., number of apparent and hidden states, trigger length, confidence, etc.) and (2) quantified the data needed to successfully train an ML model. We then (3) proved our ML solution learns and subsequently identifies unknown triggers and predicts the occurrence of events. If the complexity of the challenge is too high, our ML solution can identify trigger candidates to be used to interactively probe the system under investigation to determine the true trigger in a way considerably more efficient than brute force methods. By sharing our findings, we aim to assist others grappling with similar challenges, enabling estimates on the complexity of their problem, the data required and a solution to solve it.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper presents an analytical, simulation, and machine learning approach to event prediction and causality inference despite incomplete information.
  • The researchers tackle the challenge of making accurate predictions and inferring causal relationships when data is incomplete or uncertain.
  • The proposed methods combine analytical modeling, simulation, and machine learning techniques to address this problem.

Plain English Explanation

The paper explores ways to make accurate predictions and uncover causal relationships between events, even when the available information is incomplete or uncertain. This is an important challenge in many real-world scenarios, such as forecasting soccer matches through language or extracting causality from nuclear event reports.

The researchers use a combination of analytical modeling, computer simulation, and machine learning to tackle this problem. They develop mathematical models to describe the underlying processes, run simulations to test their approaches, and apply machine learning techniques to learn patterns from the available data.

By using this multi-pronged approach, the researchers aim to make more accurate predictions and better understand the causal relationships between events, even when the data is incomplete or uncertain. This could have important applications in fields like event prediction, causal discovery, and learning individual interactions from population dynamics.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a comprehensive approach to event prediction and causality inference in the face of incomplete information. The researchers formulate the problem and introduce relevant terminology, including the concepts of "events," "causes," and "causal relationships."

They then describe their analytical modeling approach, which involves developing mathematical models to capture the underlying processes and dependencies. These models are designed to handle incomplete or uncertain data, allowing for more accurate predictions and causal inference.

Alongside the analytical modeling, the researchers also employ simulation techniques to test and validate their methods. By running computer simulations with varying levels of data completeness, they can assess the performance of their approaches and identify any limitations or areas for improvement.

Finally, the paper explores the use of machine learning techniques to complement the analytical and simulation-based methods. The researchers investigate how different ML algorithms can be leveraged to learn patterns and relationships from the available data, further enhancing the accuracy and robustness of their event prediction and causality inference capabilities.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a well-rounded and thorough approach to the challenging problem of event prediction and causality inference under incomplete information. The combination of analytical modeling, simulation, and machine learning techniques is a strength of the research, as it allows the researchers to leverage the unique strengths of each methodology.

One potential limitation mentioned in the paper is the computational complexity and resource requirements of the proposed methods, particularly the analytical modeling and simulation components. This may limit the scalability of the approach in real-world scenarios with large-scale data.

Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the specific data sources, preprocessing techniques, or feature engineering strategies employed in the machine learning portion of the research. Further details on these aspects could help readers better understand the strengths and limitations of the ML-based approaches.

Overall, the paper presents a compelling and multi-faceted solution to a challenging problem, with a strong emphasis on both theoretical and practical considerations. The researchers' willingness to acknowledge limitations and areas for future work adds to the credibility of the research and encourages readers to think critically about the presented methods.

Conclusion

This paper offers a comprehensive approach to event prediction and causality inference in the face of incomplete information. By combining analytical modeling, simulation, and machine learning techniques, the researchers have developed a robust and flexible framework for addressing this important challenge.

The findings from this research have the potential to significantly impact a wide range of applications, from forecasting events in soccer matches to extracting causal relationships from nuclear event reports. The ability to make accurate predictions and uncover causal insights despite incomplete data can be transformative in many fields, and the methods presented in this paper represent an important step forward in this direction.

As the researchers acknowledge, there are still areas for further exploration and improvement, such as addressing the computational complexity of the proposed approaches. Nevertheless, this work demonstrates the power of leveraging multiple analytical, simulation, and machine learning techniques to tackle complex real-world problems, and it serves as a valuable contribution to the ongoing efforts to advance the state of the art in event prediction and causality inference.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

🤔

Event Causality Is Key to Computational Story Understanding

Yidan Sun, Qin Chao, Boyang Li

YC

0

Reddit

0

Cognitive science and symbolic AI research suggest that event causality provides vital information for story understanding. However, machine learning systems for story understanding rarely employ event causality, partially due to the lack of methods that reliably identify open-world causal event relations. Leveraging recent progress in large language models, we present the first method for event causality identification that leads to material improvements in computational story understanding. Our technique sets a new state of the art on the COPES dataset (Wang et al., 2023) for causal event relation identification. Further, in the downstream story quality evaluation task, the identified causal relations lead to 3.6-16.6% relative improvement on correlation with human ratings. In the multimodal story video-text alignment task, we attain 4.1-10.9% increase on Clip Accuracy and 4.2-13.5% increase on Sentence IoU. The findings indicate substantial untapped potential for event causality in computational story understanding. The codebase is at https://github.com/insundaycathy/Event-Causality-Extraction.

Read more

4/3/2024

Forecasting Events in Soccer Matches Through Language

Forecasting Events in Soccer Matches Through Language

Tiago Mendes-Neves, Lu'is Meireles, Jo~ao Mendes-Moreira

YC

0

Reddit

0

This paper introduces an approach to predicting the next event in a soccer match, a challenge bearing remarkable similarities to the problem faced by Large Language Models (LLMs). Unlike other methods that severely limit event dynamics in soccer, often abstracting from many variables or relying on a mix of sequential models, our research proposes a novel technique inspired by the methodologies used in LLMs. These models predict a complete chain of variables that compose an event, significantly simplifying the construction of Large Event Models (LEMs) for soccer. Utilizing deep learning on the publicly available WyScout dataset, the proposed approach notably surpasses the performance of previous LEM proposals in critical areas, such as the prediction accuracy of the next event type. This paper highlights the utility of LEMs in various applications, including match prediction and analytics. Moreover, we show that LEMs provide a simulation backbone for users to build many analytics pipelines, an approach opposite to the current specialized single-purpose models. LEMs represent a pivotal advancement in soccer analytics, establishing a foundational framework for multifaceted analytics pipelines through a singular machine-learning model.

Read more

4/29/2024

🤷

Sample, estimate, aggregate: A recipe for causal discovery foundation models

Menghua Wu, Yujia Bao, Regina Barzilay, Tommi Jaakkola

YC

0

Reddit

0

Causal discovery, the task of inferring causal structure from data, promises to accelerate scientific research, inform policy making, and more. However, causal discovery algorithms over larger sets of variables tend to be brittle against misspecification or when data are limited. To mitigate these challenges, we train a supervised model that learns to predict a larger causal graph from the outputs of classical causal discovery algorithms run over subsets of variables, along with other statistical hints like inverse covariance. Our approach is enabled by the observation that typical errors in the outputs of classical methods remain comparable across datasets. Theoretically, we show that this model is well-specified, in the sense that it can recover a causal graph consistent with graphs over subsets. Empirically, we train the model to be robust to erroneous estimates using diverse synthetic data. Experiments on real and synthetic data demonstrate that this model maintains high accuracy in the face of misspecification or distribution shift, and can be adapted at low cost to different discovery algorithms or choice of statistics.

Read more

5/24/2024

⛏️

Causality Extraction from Nuclear Licensee Event Reports Using a Hybrid Framework

Shahidur Rahoman Sohag, Sai Zhang, Min Xian, Shoukun Sun, Fei Xu, Zhegang Ma

YC

0

Reddit

0

Industry-wide nuclear power plant operating experience is a critical source of raw data for performing parameter estimations in reliability and risk models. Much operating experience information pertains to failure events and is stored as reports containing unstructured data, such as narratives. Event reports are essential for understanding how failures are initiated and propagated, including the numerous causal relations involved. Causal relation extraction using deep learning represents a significant frontier in the field of natural language processing (NLP), and is crucial since it enables the interpretation of intricate narratives and connections contained within vast amounts of written information. This paper proposed a hybrid framework for causality detection and extraction from nuclear licensee event reports. The main contributions include: (1) we compiled an LER corpus with 20,129 text samples for causality analysis, (2) developed an interactive tool for labeling cause effect pairs, (3) built a deep-learning-based approach for causal relation detection, and (4) developed a knowledge based cause-effect extraction approach.

Read more

4/23/2024