Evolving generalist controllers to handle a wide range of morphological variations
2309.10201
0
0
🌐
Abstract
Neuro-evolutionary methods have proven effective in addressing a wide range of tasks. However, the study of the robustness and generalizability of evolved artificial neural networks (ANNs) has remained limited. This has immense implications in the fields like robotics where such controllers are used in control tasks. Unexpected morphological or environmental changes during operation can risk failure if the ANN controllers are unable to handle these changes. This paper proposes an algorithm that aims to enhance the robustness and generalizability of the controllers. This is achieved by introducing morphological variations during the evolutionary training process. As a results, it is possible to discover generalist controllers that can handle a wide range of morphological variations sufficiently without the need of the information regarding their morphologies or adaptation of their parameters. We perform an extensive experimental analysis on simulation that demonstrates the trade-off between specialist and generalist controllers. The results show that generalists are able to control a range of morphological variations with a cost of underperforming on a specific morphology relative to a specialist. This research contributes to the field by addressing the limited understanding of robustness and generalizability and proposes a method by which to improve these properties.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores ways to make artificial neural networks (ANNs) more robust and generalizable, which is important for their use in applications like robotics.
- The researchers propose an algorithm that introduces morphological variations during the evolutionary training process to discover generalist controllers that can handle a wide range of changes without needing information about the morphology or adapting their parameters.
- The results show that generalist controllers can control a range of morphological variations, but with a cost of underperforming compared to specialist controllers on a specific morphology.
Plain English Explanation
Artificial neural networks (ANNs) are machine learning models inspired by the human brain that have proven effective for a variety of tasks. However, the study of how robust and generalizable these evolved ANNs are has been limited. This is a problem, especially in robotics, where the controllers (neural network controllers) used to control the robots need to be able to handle unexpected changes to the robot's physical structure (morphology) or environment during operation.
To address this, the researchers developed an algorithm that introduces morphological variations during the training process. This allows them to discover generalist controllers that can handle a wide range of morphological changes without needing any information about the specific morphology or having to adapt their parameters.
The researchers found that these generalist controllers are able to control a variety of different morphologies, but they tend to perform slightly worse on any specific morphology compared to a controller that was specialized for that particular morphology. This is a trade-off between having a controller that works well on a wide range of situations versus one that is optimized for a specific situation.
This research contributes to a better understanding of how to make ANNs more robust and generalizable, which is important for their use in real-world applications like robotics and adaptive control systems that need to operate reliably in changing environments. It also suggests new ways to evolve flexible neural network architectures that can adapt to different situations.
Technical Explanation
The researchers propose an algorithm that aims to enhance the robustness and generalizability of ANN controllers by introducing morphological variations during the evolutionary training process. This is done by randomly perturbing the physical parameters of the simulated robot, such as the size, shape, and connectivity of its body parts, over the course of training.
By exposing the ANN controllers to a diverse range of morphological variations, the researchers were able to discover generalist controllers that could handle a wide variety of changes without needing any specific information about the morphology or having to adapt their internal parameters. This is in contrast to more specialized controllers that perform well on a particular morphology but struggle when faced with significant changes.
The researchers conducted extensive experiments in simulation to analyze the trade-offs between specialist and generalist controllers. The results showed that the generalist controllers were able to control a range of morphological variations, but with a slight cost in performance compared to the specialists on any given morphology.
This research contributes to a better understanding of the robustness and generalizability of evolved ANN controllers, which is crucial for their deployment in real-world applications like robotics, where unexpected changes in morphology or environment can potentially lead to system failures if the controllers are unable to adapt.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a valuable contribution to the field by addressing the limited understanding of the robustness and generalizability of evolved ANN controllers. The proposed algorithm, which introduces morphological variations during training, is a promising approach to discover more flexible and adaptable controllers.
However, the authors acknowledge that the study is limited to simulation environments, and further research is needed to validate the approach in real-world robotic systems. Additionally, the trade-off between specialist and generalist controllers observed in the experiments may not hold true for all types of tasks and morphologies, and more research is needed to understand the underlying factors that influence this balance.
It would also be interesting to explore the scalability of the proposed approach, as the computational resources required to train a diverse set of morphological variations could become prohibitive for more complex robotic systems. Techniques like knowledge distillation or modular architectures may help address this challenge.
Overall, this research represents an important step towards improving the robustness and generalizability of ANN controllers, which is a crucial aspect for their successful deployment in real-world applications like robotics.
Conclusion
This paper proposes an algorithm that introduces morphological variations during the evolutionary training process of artificial neural networks (ANNs) to enhance their robustness and generalizability. The key findings show that this approach can lead to the discovery of generalist controllers that can handle a wide range of morphological changes without needing specific information about the morphology or adapting their parameters.
The trade-off is that these generalist controllers tend to perform slightly worse on any specific morphology compared to a specialist controller. However, this research contributes to a better understanding of how to make ANN controllers more adaptable and reliable, which has important implications for their use in applications like robotics, where unexpected changes in the environment or the robot's physical structure can pose a significant challenge.
Further research is needed to validate the approach in real-world robotic systems and explore ways to scale the training of diverse morphological variations. Nevertheless, this work represents an important step towards developing more robust and generalizable ANN controllers that can thrive in dynamic and unpredictable environments.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🧠
Growing Artificial Neural Networks for Control: the Role of Neuronal Diversity
Eleni Nisioti, Erwan Plantec, Milton Montero, Joachim Winther Pedersen, Sebastian Risi
0
0
In biological evolution complex neural structures grow from a handful of cellular ingredients. As genomes in nature are bounded in size, this complexity is achieved by a growth process where cells communicate locally to decide whether to differentiate, proliferate and connect with other cells. This self-organisation is hypothesized to play an important part in the generalisation, and robustness of biological neural networks. Artificial neural networks (ANNs), on the other hand, are traditionally optimized in the space of weights. Thus, the benefits and challenges of growing artificial neural networks remain understudied. Building on the previously introduced Neural Developmental Programs (NDP), in this work we present an algorithm for growing ANNs that solve reinforcement learning tasks. We identify a key challenge: ensuring phenotypic complexity requires maintaining neuronal diversity, but this diversity comes at the cost of optimization stability. To address this, we introduce two mechanisms: (a) equipping neurons with an intrinsic state inherited upon neurogenesis; (b) lateral inhibition, a mechanism inspired by biological growth, which controlls the pace of growth, helping diversity persist. We show that both mechanisms contribute to neuronal diversity and that, equipped with them, NDPs achieve comparable results to existing direct and developmental encodings in complex locomotion tasks
5/15/2024
📉
Towards Multi-Morphology Controllers with Diversity and Knowledge Distillation
Alican Mertan, Nick Cheney
0
0
Finding controllers that perform well across multiple morphologies is an important milestone for large-scale robotics, in line with recent advances via foundation models in other areas of machine learning. However, the challenges of learning a single controller to control multiple morphologies make the `one robot one task' paradigm dominant in the field. To alleviate these challenges, we present a pipeline that: (1) leverages Quality Diversity algorithms like MAP-Elites to create a dataset of many single-task/single-morphology teacher controllers, then (2) distills those diverse controllers into a single multi-morphology controller that performs well across many different body plans by mimicking the sensory-action patterns of the teacher controllers via supervised learning. The distilled controller scales well with the number of teachers/morphologies and shows emergent properties. It generalizes to unseen morphologies in a zero-shot manner, providing robustness to morphological perturbations and instant damage recovery. Lastly, the distilled controller is also independent of the teacher controllers -- we can distill the teacher's knowledge into any controller model, making our approach synergistic with architectural improvements and existing training algorithms for teacher controllers.
4/24/2024
🧠
CUDA-Accelerated Soft Robot Neural Evolution with Large Language Model Supervision
Lechen Zhang
0
0
This paper addresses the challenge of co-designing morphology and control in soft robots via a novel neural network evolution approach. We propose an innovative method to implicitly dual-encode soft robots, thus facilitating the simultaneous design of morphology and control. Additionally, we introduce the large language model to serve as the control center during the evolutionary process. This advancement considerably optimizes the evolution speed compared to traditional soft-bodied robot co-design methods. Further complementing our work is the implementation of Gaussian positional encoding - an approach that augments the neural network's comprehension of robot morphology. Our paper offers a new perspective on soft robot design, illustrating substantial improvements in efficiency and comprehension during the design and evolutionary process.
5/3/2024
Adaptive control of recurrent neural networks using conceptors
Guillaume Pourcel, Mirko Goldmann, Ingo Fischer, Miguel C. Soriano
0
0
Recurrent Neural Networks excel at predicting and generating complex high-dimensional temporal patterns. Due to their inherent nonlinear dynamics and memory, they can learn unbounded temporal dependencies from data. In a Machine Learning setting, the network's parameters are adapted during a training phase to match the requirements of a given task/problem increasing its computational capabilities. After the training, the network parameters are kept fixed to exploit the learned computations. The static parameters thereby render the network unadaptive to changing conditions, such as external or internal perturbation. In this manuscript, we demonstrate how keeping parts of the network adaptive even after the training enhances its functionality and robustness. Here, we utilize the conceptor framework and conceptualize an adaptive control loop analyzing the network's behavior continuously and adjusting its time-varying internal representation to follow a desired target. We demonstrate how the added adaptivity of the network supports the computational functionality in three distinct tasks: interpolation of temporal patterns, stabilization against partial network degradation, and robustness against input distortion. Our results highlight the potential of adaptive networks in machine learning beyond training, enabling them to not only learn complex patterns but also dynamically adjust to changing environments, ultimately broadening their applicability.
5/14/2024