Exploring Proactive Interventions toward Harmful Behavior in Embodied Virtual Spaces
2405.05920
0
0
🎯
Abstract
Technological advancements have undoubtedly revolutionized various aspects of human life, altering the ways we perceive the world, engage with others, build relationships, and conduct our daily work routines. Among the recent advancements, the proliferation of virtual and mixed reality technologies stands out as a significant leap forward, promising to elevate our experiences and interactions to unprecedented levels. However, alongside the benefits, these emerging technologies also introduce novel avenues for harm and misuse, particularly in virtual and embodied spaces such as Zoom and virtual reality (VR) environments. The immersive nature of virtual reality environments raises unique challenges regarding psychological and emotional well-being. While VR can offer captivating and immersive experiences, prolonged exposure to virtual environments may lead to phenomena like cybersickness, disorientation, and even psychological distress in susceptible individuals. Additionally, the blurring of boundaries between virtual and real-world interactions in VR raises ethical concerns regarding consent, harassment, and the potential for virtual experiences to influence real-life behavior. Additionally, the increasing integration of artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning algorithms in virtual spaces introduces risks related to algorithmic bias, discrimination, and manipulation. In VR environments, AI-driven systems may inadvertently perpetuate stereotypes, amplify inequalities, or manipulate user behavior through personalized content recommendations and targeted advertising, posing ethical dilemmas and societal risks.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Advancements in virtual and mixed reality technologies have revolutionized human experiences and interactions.
- However, these emerging technologies also introduce new challenges and risks, particularly in virtual and embodied spaces like Zoom and VR environments.
- Key concerns include psychological and emotional well-being, ethical issues around consent and harassment, and risks related to algorithmic bias and manipulation in AI-driven virtual spaces.
Plain English Explanation
Virtual and mixed reality technologies have dramatically changed the way we perceive the world, connect with others, and carry out our daily routines. These advancements have the potential to take our experiences to new heights. However, they also come with unique challenges and dangers, especially in virtual environments like Zoom calls and virtual reality (VR) experiences.
The immersive nature of VR can lead to issues like motion sickness, disorientation, and even psychological distress in some people. Additionally, the blurring of boundaries between virtual and real-world interactions raises ethical concerns about consent, harassment, and how our virtual experiences might influence our real-life behavior.
The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning in virtual spaces also introduces risks. These AI systems could inadvertently perpetuate stereotypes, amplify inequalities, or manipulate user behavior through personalized recommendations and targeted advertising. This poses ethical dilemmas and societal risks that need to be addressed.
Technical Explanation
The provided research highlights the potential harm and misuse of virtual and mixed reality technologies, particularly in virtual and embodied spaces like Zoom and VR environments. The immersive nature of VR environments can lead to phenomena like cybersickness, disorientation, and psychological distress in susceptible individuals, as discussed in the paper "From Virtual Gains to Real Pains: Potential Harms of Embodied VR."
Additionally, the blurring of boundaries between virtual and real-world interactions in VR raises ethical concerns regarding consent, harassment, and the potential for virtual experiences to influence real-life behavior, as explored in "Understanding Emotional Hijacking in the Metaverse" and "Understanding and Mitigating Harmful Design in User-Generated Virtual Environments."
The increasing integration of AI and machine learning algorithms in virtual spaces introduces risks related to algorithmic bias, discrimination, and manipulation, as discussed in "Moderating Embodied Cyber Threats Using Generative AI" and "Risk of Harm in VR Dating from the Perspective of Women." These AI-driven systems may inadvertently perpetuate stereotypes, amplify inequalities, or manipulate user behavior through personalized content recommendations and targeted advertising, posing ethical dilemmas and societal risks.
Critical Analysis
The research highlights valid concerns about the potential harms and misuse of virtual and mixed reality technologies, particularly in the context of VR environments and AI-driven virtual spaces. The discussion of issues like cybersickness, disorientation, and psychological distress is well-supported and raises important considerations for the design and deployment of these technologies.
The ethical concerns around consent, harassment, and the influence of virtual experiences on real-life behavior are also significant and deserve further exploration and mitigation strategies. The potential for AI-driven systems to perpetuate biases, discriminate, and manipulate user behavior is a valid and concerning issue that merits deeper investigation and the development of robust safeguards.
However, the paper could have delved deeper into specific use cases, empirical data, and potential solutions to address these challenges. Additionally, the research could have explored the broader societal implications and the role of policymakers, industry, and academia in shaping the responsible development and deployment of virtual and mixed reality technologies.
Conclusion
The provided research highlights the significant advancements in virtual and mixed reality technologies and the corresponding challenges and risks that have emerged. Key concerns include the impact on psychological and emotional well-being, ethical issues around consent and harassment, and the risks posed by AI-driven systems in virtual spaces.
While these technologies offer exciting new possibilities, it is crucial that researchers, developers, and policymakers work collaboratively to address these concerns and ensure the responsible and ethical development of virtual and mixed reality experiences. By doing so, we can harness the transformative potential of these technologies while mitigating the potential harms and safeguarding the well-being of individuals and society as a whole.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤖
Moderating Embodied Cyber Threats Using Generative AI
Keyan Guo, Freeman Guo, Hongxin Hu
0
0
The advancement in computing and hardware, like spatial computing and VR headsets (e.g., Apple's Vision Pro) [1], has boosted the popularity of social VR platforms (VRChat, Rec Room, Meta HorizonWorlds) [2, 3, 4]. Unlike traditional digital interactions, social VR allows for more immersive experiences, with avatars that mimic users' real-time movements and enable physical-like interactions. However, the immersive nature of social VR may introduce intensified and more physicalized cyber threats-we define as embodied cyber threats, including trash-talking, virtual groping, and such virtual harassment and assault. These new cyber threats are more realistic and invasive due to direct, virtual interactions, underscoring the urgent need for comprehensive understanding and practical strategies to enhance safety and security in virtual environments.
5/10/2024
🤿
From Virtual Gains to Real Pains: Potential Harms of Immersive Exergames
Sebastian Cmentowski, Sukran Karaosmanoglu, Frank Steinicke
0
0
Digitalization and virtualization are parts of our everyday lives in almost all aspects ranging from work, education, and communication to entertainment. A novel step in this direction is the widespread interest in extended reality (XR) [2]. The newest consumer-ready head-mounted displays (HMD) such as Meta Quest 3 or Apple Vision Pro, have reached unprecedented levels of visual fidelity, interaction capabilities, and computational power. The built-in pass-through features of these headsets enable both virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) with the same devices. However, the immersive nature of these experiences is not the only groundbreaking difference from established forms of media.
5/10/2024
🧠
Risk of Harm in VR Dating from the Perspective of Women and LGBTQIA+ Stakeholders
Devin Tebbe, Meryem Barkallah, Braeden Burger, Douglas Zytko
0
0
Virtual reality (VR) dating introduces novel opportunities for romantic interactions, but it also raises concerns about new harms that typically occur separately in traditional dating apps and general-purpose social VR environments. Given the subjectivity in which VR dating experiences can be considered harmful it is imperative to involve user stakeholders in anticipating harms and formulating preventative designs. Towards this goal with conducted participatory design workshops with 17 stakeholders identified as women and/or LGBTQIA+; demographics that are at elevated risk of harm in online dating and social VR. Findings reveal that participants are concerned with two categories of harm in VR dating: those that occur through the transition of interaction across virtual and physical modalities, and harms stemming from expectations of sexual interaction in VR.
5/10/2024
🤔
Understanding and Mitigating Harmful Design in User-Generated Virtual Worlds
Zinan Zhang, Xinning Gui, Yubo Kou
0
0
Virtual space offers innovative ways for individuals to engage with one another in a digital setting. Prominent virtual social platforms, such as Facebook Spaces, VR Chat, and AltspaceVR, facilitate social connections, allowing users to interact seamlessly. Additionally, certain video games, like Second Life and World of Warcraft, are set within these virtual spaces as well, providing immersive player experiences. As the popularity of virtual space grows, various companies have begun to democratize the process of creating these spaces, shifting the development from skilled professionals to hobbyist creators. Platforms like Minecraft, Roblox, and RecRoom enable users to create and publish their own virtual environments, hosting a wide range of interactions and narratives. This shift echoes the rise of user-generated content, where content creators create and publish content on platforms, such as social media platforms [6]. For example, YouTubers upload videos on YouTube and Reddit users post text-based content on Reddit. For a long time, user-generated content has predominantly contained text, videos, and images. However, with the emergence of virtual spaces, some platforms now allow creators to create and publish their own virtual spaces, leading to the emergence of user-generated virtual worlds.
5/10/2024