Risk of Harm in VR Dating from the Perspective of Women and LGBTQIA+ Stakeholders
2405.05914
0
0
🧠
Abstract
Virtual reality (VR) dating introduces novel opportunities for romantic interactions, but it also raises concerns about new harms that typically occur separately in traditional dating apps and general-purpose social VR environments. Given the subjectivity in which VR dating experiences can be considered harmful it is imperative to involve user stakeholders in anticipating harms and formulating preventative designs. Towards this goal with conducted participatory design workshops with 17 stakeholders identified as women and/or LGBTQIA+; demographics that are at elevated risk of harm in online dating and social VR. Findings reveal that participants are concerned with two categories of harm in VR dating: those that occur through the transition of interaction across virtual and physical modalities, and harms stemming from expectations of sexual interaction in VR.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the unique challenges and potential harms of virtual reality (VR) dating, which combines online dating with immersive virtual experiences.
- The researchers conducted participatory design workshops with 17 stakeholders, focusing on women and LGBTQIA+ individuals who face elevated risks in online dating and social VR environments.
- The findings reveal two key categories of harm: those that occur when interactions transition between virtual and physical modalities, and harms stemming from expectations of sexual interaction in VR.
Plain English Explanation
The paper examines the potential issues that can arise when people engage in dating and romantic interactions within virtual reality (VR) environments. VR dating introduces new opportunities for connections, but it also raises concerns about novel harms that are not typically seen in traditional online dating or general-purpose social VR platforms.
Given the subjective nature of what can be considered harmful in VR dating, the researchers recognized the importance of involving user stakeholders to anticipate these risks and inform preventative design approaches. They focused on participants who identify as women and/or members of the LGBTQIA+ community, as these demographics are at a higher risk of experiencing harm in online dating and social VR spaces.
The researchers found that participants were worried about two main categories of harm in VR dating. The first involves the challenges that can arise when interactions transition between the virtual and physical worlds. The second type of harm relates to the expectations around sexual interactions that may emerge within the VR dating context.
Technical Explanation
The researchers conducted participatory design workshops with 17 stakeholders who were identified as women and/or members of the LGBTQIA+ community. This demographic was selected because they are at an elevated risk of harm in online dating and social VR environments.
The workshops revealed two key categories of harm that participants were concerned about in the context of VR dating. The first category involves the challenges that can occur when interactions transition between the virtual and physical modalities, such as expectations around avatar crossing and the potential for physical harms stemming from this transition.
The second category of harm relates to the expectations around sexual interaction that may arise in VR dating environments. Participants expressed concerns about the potential for coercion and the difficulty of establishing consent in VR, as well as the risk of harassment and other unwanted sexual advances.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides valuable insights into the unique challenges and potential harms associated with VR dating, particularly for marginalized communities that face heightened risks in online and VR spaces. However, the study is limited in its scope, focusing only on a small sample of stakeholders in a participatory design workshop.
While the findings highlight important considerations for the design of VR dating platforms, the researchers acknowledge that the subjective nature of harm in this context makes it challenging to develop universal solutions. Additional research is needed to better understand the diverse perspectives and experiences of VR dating users, as well as to explore the efficacy of various proactive interventions and inclusive design strategies.
Conclusion
This study sheds light on the unique challenges and potential harms associated with VR dating, which combines the complexities of online dating with the immersive and embodied nature of virtual environments. By involving user stakeholders, the researchers were able to identify two key categories of harm: those related to the transition between virtual and physical interactions, and those stemming from expectations around sexual activity in VR.
The findings highlight the importance of incorporating diverse perspectives and experiences into the design of VR dating platforms, in order to anticipate and mitigate potential harms. As the use of VR for interpersonal interactions continues to evolve, further research and collaboration with user communities will be crucial in shaping the future of this emerging field.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🎯
Exploring Proactive Interventions toward Harmful Behavior in Embodied Virtual Spaces
Ruchi Panchanadikar
0
0
Technological advancements have undoubtedly revolutionized various aspects of human life, altering the ways we perceive the world, engage with others, build relationships, and conduct our daily work routines. Among the recent advancements, the proliferation of virtual and mixed reality technologies stands out as a significant leap forward, promising to elevate our experiences and interactions to unprecedented levels. However, alongside the benefits, these emerging technologies also introduce novel avenues for harm and misuse, particularly in virtual and embodied spaces such as Zoom and virtual reality (VR) environments. The immersive nature of virtual reality environments raises unique challenges regarding psychological and emotional well-being. While VR can offer captivating and immersive experiences, prolonged exposure to virtual environments may lead to phenomena like cybersickness, disorientation, and even psychological distress in susceptible individuals. Additionally, the blurring of boundaries between virtual and real-world interactions in VR raises ethical concerns regarding consent, harassment, and the potential for virtual experiences to influence real-life behavior. Additionally, the increasing integration of artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning algorithms in virtual spaces introduces risks related to algorithmic bias, discrimination, and manipulation. In VR environments, AI-driven systems may inadvertently perpetuate stereotypes, amplify inequalities, or manipulate user behavior through personalized content recommendations and targeted advertising, posing ethical dilemmas and societal risks.
5/10/2024
🏷️
Exploring Vulnerabilities in Remote VR User Studies
Viktorija Paneva, Florian Alt
0
0
This position paper explores the possibilities and challenges of using Virtual Reality (VR) in remote user studies. Highlighting the immersive nature of VR, the paper identifies key vulnerabilities, including varying technical proficiency, privacy concerns, ethical considerations, and data security risks. To address these issues, proposed mitigation strategies encompass comprehensive onboarding, prioritized informed consent, implementing privacy-by-design principles, and adherence to ethical guidelines. Secure data handling, including encryption and disposal protocols, is advocated. In conclusion, while remote VR studies present unique opportunities, carefully considering and implementing mitigation strategies is essential to uphold reliability, ethical integrity, and security, ensuring responsible and effective use of VR in user research. Ongoing efforts are crucial for adapting to the evolving landscape of VR technology in user studies.
4/30/2024
👁️
Fostering Inclusive Virtual Reality Environments: Discussing Strategies for Promoting Group Dynamics and Mitigating Harassment
Niloofar Sayadi, Diego G'omez-Zar'a
0
0
The rapid evolution of social Virtual Reality (VR) platforms has significantly enhanced the way users interact and socialize in digital spaces, offering immersive experiences that closely mimic real-world interactions [1]. However, this technological advancement has brought new challenges, particularly in ensuring safety and preventing harassment [11]. Unlike traditional social media platforms, the immersive nature of social VR applications can intensify the impact of harassment, affecting users' emotions, experiences, and reactions at both mental and physical levels [2, 9]. Group dynamics can play a pivotal role in both preventing and mitigating harassment [9]. Literature in group dynamics has provided insights into fostering and nurturing communities, with special emphasis on how enabling leadership, coordination, and cohesion among individuals can enable inclusive and safer social spaces [4]. For this workshop, we propose to discuss group-centric approaches to address harassment in social VR. We will discuss group strategies such as matching, interactions, and reporting mechanisms aimed at promoting safer and more supportive social VR spaces. By leveraging the social structures among users, we aim to empower users and communities to collectively counteract harassment and ensure a positive social experience for all users.
5/10/2024
🤿
From Virtual Gains to Real Pains: Potential Harms of Immersive Exergames
Sebastian Cmentowski, Sukran Karaosmanoglu, Frank Steinicke
0
0
Digitalization and virtualization are parts of our everyday lives in almost all aspects ranging from work, education, and communication to entertainment. A novel step in this direction is the widespread interest in extended reality (XR) [2]. The newest consumer-ready head-mounted displays (HMD) such as Meta Quest 3 or Apple Vision Pro, have reached unprecedented levels of visual fidelity, interaction capabilities, and computational power. The built-in pass-through features of these headsets enable both virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) with the same devices. However, the immersive nature of these experiences is not the only groundbreaking difference from established forms of media.
5/10/2024