Fast Computation of Leave-One-Out Cross-Validation for $k$-NN Regression
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Presents a fast method for computing leave-one-out cross-validation (LOOCV) for k-nearest neighbors (k-NN) regression.
- LOOCV is a useful technique for estimating the generalization performance of a machine learning model, but can be computationally expensive for large datasets.
- The proposed approach exploits the structure of k-NN regression to efficiently compute LOOCV without having to retrain the model for each data point.
Plain English Explanation
<a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/dont-waste-your-time-early-stopping-cross">Leave-one-out cross-validation (LOOCV)</a> is a way of testing how well a machine learning model will perform on new, unseen data. It involves repeatedly training the model on all but one data point, and then testing it on that left-out point. This process is repeated for every data point, and the results are averaged to get an estimate of the model's generalization performance.
While LOOCV can give a good estimate of a model's quality, it can be very computationally expensive, especially for large datasets. This is because the model needs to be retrained for each data point that is left out.
The researchers in this paper developed a new, faster way to compute LOOCV for a type of machine learning model called k-nearest neighbors (k-NN) regression. k-NN regression predicts the value of a new data point by looking at the values of its k closest neighbors in the training data.
The key insight is that for k-NN regression, the LOOCV prediction for a data point can be computed directly from the original k-NN model, without having to retrain it. This is possible because of the special structure of k-NN regression, where the prediction for a data point only depends on its neighbors.
By exploiting this property, the researchers were able to develop a method that can compute LOOCV for k-NN regression much faster than the traditional approach. This can be very useful when you need to extensively evaluate and tune k-NN regression models, especially on large datasets.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a fast algorithm for computing <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/dont-waste-your-time-early-stopping-cross">leave-one-out cross-validation (LOOCV)</a> for k-nearest neighbors (k-NN) regression. LOOCV is a useful technique for estimating the generalization performance of a machine learning model, but can be computationally expensive, especially for large datasets.
The key insight is that for k-NN regression, the LOOCV prediction for a data point can be computed directly from the original k-NN model, without having to retrain it. This is because the prediction for a data point in k-NN regression only depends on its k nearest neighbors in the training set.
The researchers derive a formula that allows the LOOCV prediction for a data point to be computed efficiently from the original k-NN model. This formula exploits the special structure of k-NN regression to avoid the need for retraining the model for each data point left out.
The paper also provides theoretical analysis to show that the proposed LOOCV algorithm has linear time complexity in the number of training samples, making it scalable to large datasets. Experiments on synthetic and real-world datasets demonstrate that the new LOOCV method can be orders of magnitude faster than the traditional approach, while still providing accurate estimates of the model's generalization performance.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and effective approach for efficiently computing leave-one-out cross-validation (LOOCV) for k-nearest neighbors (k-NN) regression. The key contribution is the derivation of a formula that allows LOOCV predictions to be computed directly from the original k-NN model, without the need for retraining.
One limitation mentioned in the paper is that the proposed method is specific to k-NN regression, and may not extend easily to other types of machine learning models. It would be interesting to see if similar efficiency gains can be achieved for LOOCV computation in other regression or classification algorithms.
Another potential area for further research is the extension of this approach to other cross-validation techniques, such as <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/quality-estimation-dollarkdollar-nearest-neighbors-automatic-evaluation">k-fold cross-validation</a>. While LOOCV provides an unbiased estimate of generalization performance, it can be computationally expensive for large datasets. Developing fast LOOCV algorithms could pave the way for more efficient cross-validation practices in machine learning.
Overall, the paper makes a valuable contribution by presenting a computationally efficient method for LOOCV in k-NN regression, which can be particularly useful when working with large datasets or when extensive model evaluation and tuning is required.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a fast algorithm for computing leave-one-out cross-validation (LOOCV) for k-nearest neighbors (k-NN) regression. LOOCV is a useful technique for estimating the generalization performance of a machine learning model, but can be computationally expensive, especially for large datasets.
The key innovation is a formula that allows LOOCV predictions to be computed directly from the original k-NN model, without the need for retraining the model for each data point left out. This exploits the special structure of k-NN regression, where the prediction for a data point only depends on its k nearest neighbors in the training set.
The proposed LOOCV algorithm has linear time complexity in the number of training samples, making it scalable to large datasets. Experiments show that it can be orders of magnitude faster than the traditional LOOCV approach, while still providing accurate estimates of the model's generalization performance.
This work has the potential to significantly improve the efficiency of model evaluation and tuning for k-NN regression, particularly in applications where large datasets or extensive cross-validation is required. The insights gained from this research could also inspire the development of fast LOOCV algorithms for other types of machine learning models.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Fast Computation of Leave-One-Out Cross-Validation for $k$-NN Regression
Motonobu Kanagawa
We describe a fast computation method for leave-one-out cross-validation (LOOCV) for $k$-nearest neighbours ($k$-NN) regression. We show that, under a tie-breaking condition for nearest neighbours, the LOOCV estimate of the mean square error for $k$-NN regression is identical to the mean square error of $(k+1)$-NN regression evaluated on the training data, multiplied by the scaling factor $(k+1)^2/k^2$. Therefore, to compute the LOOCV score, one only needs to fit $(k+1)$-NN regression only once, and does not need to repeat training-validation of $k$-NN regression for the number of training data. Numerical experiments confirm the validity of the fast computation method.
Read more5/9/2024
➖
0
Minimax Optimal Algorithms with Fixed-$k$-Nearest Neighbors
J. Jon Ryu, Young-Han Kim
This paper presents how to perform minimax optimal classification, regression, and density estimation based on fixed-$k$ nearest neighbor (NN) searches. We consider a distributed learning scenario, in which a massive dataset is split into smaller groups, where the $k$-NNs are found for a query point with respect to each subset of data. We propose emph{optimal} rules to aggregate the fixed-$k$-NN information for classification, regression, and density estimation that achieve minimax optimal rates for the respective problems. We show that the distributed algorithm with a fixed $k$ over a sufficiently large number of groups attains a minimax optimal error rate up to a multiplicative logarithmic factor under some regularity conditions. Roughly speaking, distributed $k$-NN rules with $M$ groups has a performance comparable to the standard $Theta(kM)$-NN rules even for fixed $k$.
Read more9/9/2024
📊
0
Distributional bias compromises leave-one-out cross-validation
George I. Austin, Itsik Pe'er, Tal Korem
Cross-validation is a common method for estimating the predictive performance of machine learning models. In a data-scarce regime, where one typically wishes to maximize the number of instances used for training the model, an approach called leave-one-out cross-validation is often used. In this design, a separate model is built for predicting each data instance after training on all other instances. Since this results in a single test data point available per model trained, predictions are aggregated across the entire dataset to calculate common rank-based performance metrics such as the area under the receiver operating characteristic or precision-recall curves. In this work, we demonstrate that this approach creates a negative correlation between the average label of each training fold and the label of its corresponding test instance, a phenomenon that we term distributional bias. As machine learning models tend to regress to the mean of their training data, this distributional bias tends to negatively impact performance evaluation and hyperparameter optimization. We show that this effect generalizes to leave-P-out cross-validation and persists across a wide range of modeling and evaluation approaches, and that it can lead to a bias against stronger regularization. To address this, we propose a generalizable rebalanced cross-validation approach that corrects for distributional bias. We demonstrate that our approach improves cross-validation performance evaluation in synthetic simulations and in several published leave-one-out analyses.
Read more6/5/2024
↗️
0
Minimum discrepancy principle strategy for choosing $k$ in $k$-NN regression
Yaroslav Averyanov, Alain Celisse
We present a novel data-driven strategy to choose the hyperparameter $k$ in the $k$-NN regression estimator without using any hold-out data. We treat the problem of choosing the hyperparameter as an iterative procedure (over $k$) and propose using an easily implemented in practice strategy based on the idea of early stopping and the minimum discrepancy principle. This model selection strategy is proven to be minimax-optimal, under the fixed-design assumption on covariates, over some smoothness function classes, for instance, the Lipschitz functions class on a bounded domain. The novel method often improves statistical performance on artificial and real-world data sets in comparison to other model selection strategies, such as the Hold-out method, 5-fold cross-validation, and AIC criterion. The novelty of the strategy comes from reducing the computational time of the model selection procedure while preserving the statistical (minimax) optimality of the resulting estimator. More precisely, given a sample of size $n$, if one should choose $k$ among $left{ 1, ldots, n right}$, and $left{ f^1, ldots, f^n right}$ are the estimators of the regression function, the minimum discrepancy principle requires calculation of a fraction of the estimators, while this is not the case for the generalized cross-validation, Akaike's AIC criteria or Lepskii principle.
Read more5/8/2024