FedML-HE: An Efficient Homomorphic-Encryption-Based Privacy-Preserving Federated Learning System

Overview

• Federated Learning (FL) trains machine learning models on distributed devices without sharing local data, addressing privacy concerns
• However, the aggregated local models on the server can still reveal sensitive personal information through inversion attacks
• Privacy-preserving methods like homomorphic encryption (HE) are necessary for secure FL training
• Despite HE's privacy advantages, its applications have suffered from impractical overheads, especially for large foundation models

Plain English Explanation

FedML-HE: Practical Federated Learning with Efficient Homomorphic Encryption-based Secure Model Aggregation

Federated Learning (FL) is a way to train machine learning models without sharing people's private data. Instead of sending all the data to a central server, FL lets devices like phones or tablets train a model on their own data and then share just the updates to that model. This helps protect people's privacy.

However, even though the raw data isn't shared, the model updates on the server could still reveal sensitive information through complex attacks. To fix this, the paper introduces FedML-HE, a new FL system that uses a technique called homomorphic encryption (HE) to securely combine the model updates.

HE allows mathematical operations to be performed on encrypted data without decrypting it first. This means the server can work with the encrypted model updates without ever seeing the underlying private information. But previous HE-based FL systems had very high computational and communication costs, making them impractical, especially for large, complex machine learning models.

The key innovation in FedML-HE is that it only encrypts the most sensitive parts of the model, significantly reducing the overhead. This makes it much more feasible to use HE for securing FL, even with large foundation models like BERT. The authors show FedML-HE can reduce the overhead by up to 40 times compared to prior HE-based FL approaches.

Technical Explanation

FedML-HE is a practical federated learning system that uses efficient homomorphic encryption (HE)-based secure model aggregation. Federated learning trains machine learning models on distributed devices by aggregating local model updates instead of sharing local data, addressing privacy concerns. However, the aggregated local models on the server can still reveal sensitive personal information through inversion attacks.

To preserve privacy, FedML-HE proposes to selectively encrypt sensitive parameters during the federated learning process. This significantly reduces both the computation and communication overheads compared to applying HE to the entire model. The system demonstrates considerable overhead reduction, particularly for large foundation models (e.g., ~10x reduction for ResNet-50, and up to ~40x reduction for BERT), making HE-based federated learning much more practical and scalable.

The key technical contributions of FedML-HE include:

• Selective parameter encryption: Only encrypting the most sensitive parameters to minimize HE overhead
• Optimized HE-based secure aggregation: Leveraging techniques like Berrut approximation to further reduce HE costs
• System integration and deployment: Integrating the HE-based secure aggregation into a real-world federated learning framework (FedML)

Critical Analysis

The FedML-HE paper presents a promising approach to make homomorphic encryption-based secure model aggregation practical for federated learning, especially for large foundation models. By selectively encrypting sensitive parameters, the system is able to dramatically reduce the computational and communication overheads compared to prior HE-based FL methods.

However, the paper does not provide a thorough analysis of the privacy guarantees offered by the selective encryption approach. While the authors claim it preserves privacy, the specific privacy properties and the potential risks of partial parameter encryption are not fully explored. Additional research may be needed to rigorously evaluate the privacy-preserving capabilities of this technique.

Furthermore, the paper focuses on the efficiency and scalability of the HE-based aggregation, but does not discuss other potential challenges in federated learning, such as client heterogeneity, model convergence, or the impact of client dropout. These factors could also affect the practical deployment and performance of FedML-HE in real-world scenarios.

Finally, the evaluation is limited to a few benchmark tasks and models. Applying FedML-HE to a wider range of federated learning applications, especially those involving sensitive user data, would help further validate the system's capabilities and limitations.

Conclusion

The FedML-HE paper presents a significant advancement in making homomorphic encryption-based secure aggregation practical for federated learning, particularly for large-scale foundation models. By selectively encrypting sensitive parameters, the system is able to dramatically reduce the computational and communication overheads, overcoming a major barrier to the widespread adoption of privacy-preserving federated learning.

The key innovation of FedML-HE is its ability to balance privacy preservation and system efficiency, demonstrating the potential for scalable HE-based federated learning deployment. As machine learning models become larger and more powerful, preserving user privacy will be critical. The techniques introduced in this paper represent an important step towards realizing the benefits of federated learning while ensuring the protection of sensitive personal information.