A finite time analysis of distributed Q-learning
2405.14078
0
0
🤔
Abstract
Multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) has witnessed a remarkable surge in interest, fueled by the empirical success achieved in applications of single-agent reinforcement learning (RL). In this study, we consider a distributed Q-learning scenario, wherein a number of agents cooperatively solve a sequential decision making problem without access to the central reward function which is an average of the local rewards. In particular, we study finite-time analysis of a distributed Q-learning algorithm, and provide a new sample complexity result of $tilde{mathcal{O}}left( minleft{frac{1}{epsilon^2}frac{t_{text{mix}}}{(1-gamma)^6 d_{min}^4 } ,frac{1}{epsilon}frac{sqrt{|gS||gA|}}{(1-sigma_2(boldsymbol{W}))(1-gamma)^4 d_{min}^3} right}right)$ under tabular lookup
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores a distributed Q-learning algorithm for multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) scenarios, where a group of agents cooperatively solve a sequential decision-making problem without access to a central reward function.
- The researchers provide a finite-time analysis of the distributed Q-learning algorithm and derive a new sample complexity result under tabular lookup.
- The analysis provides insights into how the algorithm's performance is affected by factors like the mixing time of the Markov chain, the discount factor, and the minimum degree of the underlying graph.
Plain English Explanation
In this paper, the researchers are studying a type of machine learning problem called multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL). In MARL, there are multiple "agents" (like software programs or robots) that need to work together to solve a complex decision-making task.
The specific scenario the researchers look at is where these agents don't have access to a central "reward function" that tells them how well they're doing. Instead, each agent only knows its own local reward. The agents have to cooperatively figure out the best actions to take without that central information.
The researchers propose a distributed Q-learning algorithm to solve this problem. Q-learning is a type of reinforcement learning algorithm that helps agents learn which actions are best in different situations. In the distributed version, the agents share information with each other to collectively learn the optimal actions.
The main contribution of this paper is a mathematical analysis that shows how well the distributed Q-learning algorithm performs. The researchers derive a sample complexity result, which tells us how much data (or "samples") the algorithm needs to converge to a good solution. This result depends on factors like how quickly the agents can share information (mixing time), the discount factor in the rewards, and the structure of the underlying communication network.
Overall, this work provides important theoretical insights into how distributed MARL algorithms can be designed and analyzed to solve complex, cooperative decision-making problems in a scalable way.
Technical Explanation
The paper considers a distributed Q-learning scenario, where a group of agents cooperatively solve a sequential decision-making problem without access to a central reward function. Instead, each agent only has access to its own local rewards.
The researchers propose a distributed Q-learning algorithm, where the agents share information with each other to collectively learn the optimal actions to take. They provide a finite-time analysis of this algorithm and derive a new sample complexity result under tabular lookup.
The sample complexity bound is expressed as:
$\tilde{\mathcal{O}}\left( \min\left{\frac{1}{\epsilon^2}\frac{t_{\text{mix}}}{(1-\gamma)^6 d_{\min}^4 } ,\frac{1}{\epsilon}\frac{\sqrt{|S||A|}}{(1-\sigma_2(\boldsymbol{W}))(1-\gamma)^4 d_{\min}^3}\right}\right)$
This bound depends on several key parameters:
- $\epsilon$: the desired accuracy of the solution
- $t_{\text{mix}}$: the mixing time of the Markov chain underlying the problem
- $\gamma$: the discount factor in the rewards
- $d_{\min}$: the minimum degree of the underlying communication graph among the agents
- $|S|$, $|A|$: the sizes of the state and action spaces, respectively
- $\sigma_2(\boldsymbol{W})$: the second largest singular value of the weight matrix $\boldsymbol{W}$ describing the communication network
The analysis shows how the algorithm's performance is affected by these factors, providing insights into the design and deployment of distributed MARL systems.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a rigorous theoretical analysis of a distributed Q-learning algorithm for MARL, which is an important contribution to the field. The sample complexity result derived in the paper offers insights into how various problem parameters, such as the mixing time, discount factor, and communication graph structure, influence the algorithm's convergence.
However, the analysis is limited to the tabular setting, where the state and action spaces are assumed to be finite. In many real-world applications, the state and action spaces can be large or even continuous, which would require the use of function approximation techniques. Extending the analysis to more general function approximation settings, such as neural networks, would be a valuable next step.
Additionally, the paper assumes that the agents have perfect information about the problem parameters, such as the mixing time and the minimum degree of the communication graph. In practice, these parameters may not be known a priori, and the algorithm would need to be robust to uncertainty in the problem setup.
Furthermore, the paper focuses on the cooperative setting, where all agents share the same goal. In many real-world scenarios, the agents may have conflicting or partially overlapping objectives, leading to more complex strategic interactions. Analyzing distributed MARL algorithms in these competitive or partially cooperative settings would be an important direction for future research.
Despite these limitations, this paper makes an important contribution to the theoretical understanding of distributed MARL algorithms, and the insights derived can inform the design of more practical and scalable MARL systems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a theoretical analysis of a distributed Q-learning algorithm for multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) scenarios, where a group of agents cooperatively solve a sequential decision-making problem without access to a central reward function.
The key contribution is a new sample complexity result that characterizes the performance of the distributed Q-learning algorithm under tabular lookup. The analysis shows how the algorithm's convergence is affected by factors such as the mixing time of the Markov chain, the discount factor, and the structure of the communication network among the agents.
While the analysis is limited to the tabular setting, this work provides valuable insights into the design and analysis of distributed MARL algorithms, which are crucial for developing scalable and effective solutions to complex, multi-agent decision-making problems. Further research is needed to extend these insights to more general function approximation settings and to explore the implications of partial cooperation or competition among the agents.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
Distributed Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning Based on Graph-Induced Local Value Functions
Gangshan Jing, He Bai, Jemin George, Aranya Chakrabortty, Piyush K. Sharma
0
0
Achieving distributed reinforcement learning (RL) for large-scale cooperative multi-agent systems (MASs) is challenging because: (i) each agent has access to only limited information; (ii) issues on convergence or computational complexity emerge due to the curse of dimensionality. In this paper, we propose a general computationally efficient distributed framework for cooperative multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) by utilizing the structures of graphs involved in this problem. We introduce three coupling graphs describing three types of inter-agent couplings in MARL, namely, the state graph, the observation graph and the reward graph. By further considering a communication graph, we propose two distributed RL approaches based on local value-functions derived from the coupling graphs. The first approach is able to reduce sample complexity significantly under specific conditions on the aforementioned four graphs. The second approach provides an approximate solution and can be efficient even for problems with dense coupling graphs. Here there is a trade-off between minimizing the approximation error and reducing the computational complexity. Simulations show that our RL algorithms have a significantly improved scalability to large-scale MASs compared with centralized and consensus-based distributed RL algorithms.
4/15/2024
eQMARL: Entangled Quantum Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning for Distributed Cooperation over Quantum Channels
Alexander DeRieux, Walid Saad
0
0
Collaboration is a key challenge in distributed multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) environments. Learning frameworks for these decentralized systems must weigh the benefits of explicit player coordination against the communication overhead and computational cost of sharing local observations and environmental data. Quantum computing has sparked a potential synergy between quantum entanglement and cooperation in multi-agent environments, which could enable more efficient distributed collaboration with minimal information sharing. This relationship is largely unexplored, however, as current state-of-the-art quantum MARL (QMARL) implementations rely on classical information sharing rather than entanglement over a quantum channel as a coordination medium. In contrast, in this paper, a novel framework dubbed entangled QMARL (eQMARL) is proposed. The proposed eQMARL is a distributed actor-critic framework that facilitates cooperation over a quantum channel and eliminates local observation sharing via a quantum entangled split critic. Introducing a quantum critic uniquely spread across the agents allows coupling of local observation encoders through entangled input qubits over a quantum channel, which requires no explicit sharing of local observations and reduces classical communication overhead. Further, agent policies are tuned through joint observation-value function estimation via joint quantum measurements, thereby reducing the centralized computational burden. Experimental results show that eQMARL with ${Psi}^{+}$ entanglement converges to a cooperative strategy up to $17.8%$ faster and with a higher overall score compared to split classical and fully centralized classical and quantum baselines. The results also show that eQMARL achieves this performance with a constant factor of $25$-times fewer centralized parameters compared to the split classical baseline.
5/29/2024
Efficient Reinforcement Learning for Global Decision Making in the Presence of Local Agents at Scale
Emile Anand, Guannan Qu
0
0
We study reinforcement learning for global decision-making in the presence of many local agents, where the global decision-maker makes decisions affecting all local agents, and the objective is to learn a policy that maximizes the rewards of both the global and the local agents. Such problems find many applications, e.g. demand response, EV charging, queueing, etc. In this setting, scalability has been a long-standing challenge due to the size of the state/action space which can be exponential in the number of agents. This work proposes the $texttt{SUB-SAMPLE-Q}$ algorithm where the global agent subsamples $kleq n$ local agents to compute an optimal policy in time that is only exponential in $k$, providing an exponential speedup from standard methods that are exponential in $n$. We show that the learned policy converges to the optimal policy in the order of $tilde{O}(1/sqrt{k}+epsilon_{k,m})$ as the number of sub-sampled agents $k$ increases, where $epsilon_{k,m}$ is the Bellman noise, by proving a novel generalization of the Dvoretzky-Kiefer-Wolfowitz inequality to the regime of sampling without replacement. We also conduct numerical simulations in a demand-response setting and a queueing setting.
5/24/2024
🏅
Randomized Exploration in Cooperative Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning
Hao-Lun Hsu, Weixin Wang, Miroslav Pajic, Pan Xu
0
0
We present the first study on provably efficient randomized exploration in cooperative multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL). We propose a unified algorithm framework for randomized exploration in parallel Markov Decision Processes (MDPs), and two Thompson Sampling (TS)-type algorithms, CoopTS-PHE and CoopTS-LMC, incorporating the perturbed-history exploration (PHE) strategy and the Langevin Monte Carlo exploration (LMC) strategy respectively, which are flexible in design and easy to implement in practice. For a special class of parallel MDPs where the transition is (approximately) linear, we theoretically prove that both CoopTS-PHE and CoopTS-LMC achieve a $widetilde{mathcal{O}}(d^{3/2}H^2sqrt{MK})$ regret bound with communication complexity $widetilde{mathcal{O}}(dHM^2)$, where $d$ is the feature dimension, $H$ is the horizon length, $M$ is the number of agents, and $K$ is the number of episodes. This is the first theoretical result for randomized exploration in cooperative MARL. We evaluate our proposed method on multiple parallel RL environments, including a deep exploration problem (textit{i.e.,} $N$-chain), a video game, and a real-world problem in energy systems. Our experimental results support that our framework can achieve better performance, even under conditions of misspecified transition models. Additionally, we establish a connection between our unified framework and the practical application of federated learning.
4/17/2024