Firefighters' Perceptions on Collaboration and Interaction with Autonomous Drones: Results of a Field Trial
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
• This paper explores firefighters' perceptions of collaborating and interacting with autonomous drones during emergency interventions. • The researchers conducted a field trial to understand firefighters' experiences and attitudes towards using drones in firefighting operations. • The study provides insights into the benefits, challenges, and opportunities for integrating autonomous drones into firefighting workflows.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a study that looked at how firefighters feel about working with autonomous drones during emergencies. The researchers did a field trial, which means they tested it out in real-world conditions, to see how firefighters reacted to using drones to help with their jobs.
The main findings were that firefighters see some benefits to using drones, like being able to get a better view of a situation from above. However, they also had some concerns, like making sure the drones don't get in the way or cause any problems. The study gives insights into both the good and bad parts of using drones for firefighting, and how firefighters think this technology could be improved to work better with their needs.
Technical Explanation
The researchers conducted a field trial to understand firefighters' perceptions of collaborating and interacting with autonomous drones during emergency interventions. They recruited 16 firefighters from a local fire department to participate in the study, which involved a series of simulated fire scenarios where the firefighters worked alongside an autonomous drone.
During the trials, the firefighters were asked to complete various tasks, such as search and rescue operations, while the drone provided aerial support and real-time information. The researchers collected data through observations, interviews, and questionnaires to gain insights into the firefighters' experiences, attitudes, and concerns regarding the use of autonomous drones in firefighting operations.
The study revealed that firefighters generally had a positive view of the potential benefits of using drones, such as improved situational awareness, enhanced safety, and more efficient resource allocation. However, they also expressed concerns about the reliability and integration of the drone technology, as well as the potential for interference with their existing workflows and decision-making processes.
The paper discusses the key themes that emerged from the field trial, including the importance of clear communication and coordination between firefighters and the drone, the need for intuitive control interfaces, and the challenge of maintaining situational awareness when working with an autonomous system. The researchers also highlight the potential for future developments in drone technology to address some of the identified challenges and further improve the collaboration between firefighters and autonomous drones.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a valuable contribution to the field of emergency response robotics by exploring the perspectives of end-users, in this case, firefighters, on the use of autonomous drones. The field trial approach allows for a more realistic assessment of the opportunities and challenges associated with integrating this technology into firefighting operations.
One potential limitation of the study is the relatively small sample size, which may limit the generalizability of the findings. Additionally, the study was conducted in a simulated environment, and it would be useful to explore how firefighters' perceptions and experiences may differ in real-world emergency situations.
Further research could investigate the impact of factors such as the level of drone autonomy, the specific tasks and scenarios, and the integration of the drone technology with other firefighting equipment and procedures. Exploring the perspectives of other emergency responders, such as police or medical personnel, could also provide additional insights into the broader implications of using autonomous drones in emergency response operations.
Conclusion
This study offers important insights into firefighters' perceptions of collaborating with autonomous drones during emergency interventions. The findings suggest that while firefighters recognize the potential benefits of this technology, there are also significant challenges that need to be addressed to facilitate effective integration and collaboration.
The paper highlights the need for continued research and development to address the identified concerns, such as ensuring reliable performance, intuitive control interfaces, and seamless integration with existing firefighting workflows. Addressing these challenges can help unlock the full potential of autonomous drones to enhance the safety and efficiency of firefighting operations, ultimately benefiting both firefighters and the communities they serve.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Firefighters' Perceptions on Collaboration and Interaction with Autonomous Drones: Results of a Field Trial
Moyi Li, Dzmitry Katsiuba, Mateusz Dolata, Gerhard Schwabe
Applications of drones in emergency response, like firefighting, have been promoted in the past decade. As the autonomy of drones continues to improve, the ways in which they are integrated into firefighting teams and their impact on crews are changing. This demands more understanding of how firefighters perceive and interact with autonomous drones. This paper presents a drone-based system for emergency operations with which firefighters can interact through sound, lights, and a graphical user interface. We use interviews with stakeholders collected in two field trials to explore their perceptions of the interaction and collaboration with drones. Our result shows that firefighters perceived visual interaction as adequate. However, for audio instructions and interfaces, information overload emerges as an essential problem. The potential impact of drones on current work configurations may involve shifting the position of humans closer to supervisory decision-makers and changing the training structure and content.
Read more5/17/2024
0
Hierarchical Framework for Optimizing Wildfire Surveillance and Suppression using Human-Autonomous Teaming
Mahdi Al-Husseini, Kyle Wray, Mykel Kochenderfer
The integration of manned and unmanned aircraft can help improve wildfire response. Wildfire containment failures occur when resources available to first responders, who execute the initial stages of wildfire management referred to as the initial attack, are ineffective or insufficient. Initial attack surveillance and suppression models have linked action spaces and objectives, making their optimization computationally challenging. The initial attack may be formulated as a multi-agent partially observable Markov decision process (MPOMDP). We divide the initial attack MPOMDP into surveillance and suppression processes with their respective planners operating on different, but constant, time scales. A hierarchical framework iterates between surveillance and suppression planners while also providing collision avoidance. This framework is exemplified by a set of multi-rotor unmanned aircraft surveying an initial attack fire while a manned helicopter suppresses the fire with a water bucket. Wildfire-specific solver extensions are formulated to reduce the otherwise vast action spaces. The hierarchical framework outperforms firefighting techniques and a myopic baseline by up to 242% for moderate wildfires and 60% for rapid wildfires when simulated in abstracted and actual case studies. We also validate the early dispatching of additional suppression assets using regression models to ensure wildfire containment to thresholds established by wildfire agencies.
Read more6/26/2024
0
Streamlining Forest Wildfire Surveillance: AI-Enhanced UAVs Utilizing the FLAME Aerial Video Dataset for Lightweight and Efficient Monitoring
Lemeng Zhao, Junjie Hu, Jianchao Bi, Yanbing Bai, Erick Mas, Shunichi Koshimura
In recent years, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) have played an increasingly crucial role in supporting disaster emergency response efforts by analyzing aerial images. While current deep-learning models focus on improving accuracy, they often overlook the limited computing resources of UAVs. This study recognizes the imperative for real-time data processing in disaster response scenarios and introduces a lightweight and efficient approach for aerial video understanding. Our methodology identifies redundant portions within the video through policy networks and eliminates this excess information using frame compression techniques. Additionally, we introduced the concept of a `station point,' which leverages future information in the sequential policy network, thereby enhancing accuracy. To validate our method, we employed the wildfire FLAME dataset. Compared to the baseline, our approach reduces computation costs by more than 13 times while boosting accuracy by 3$%$. Moreover, our method can intelligently select salient frames from the video, refining the dataset. This feature enables sophisticated models to be effectively trained on a smaller dataset, significantly reducing the time spent during the training process.
Read more9/4/2024
0
AI-based Drone Assisted Human Rescue in Disaster Environments: Challenges and Opportunities
Narek Papyan, Michel Kulhandjian, Hovannes Kulhandjian, Levon Hakob Aslanyan
In this survey we are focusing on utilizing drone-based systems for the detection of individuals, particularly by identifying human screams and other distress signals. This study has significant relevance in post-disaster scenarios, including events such as earthquakes, hurricanes, military conflicts, wildfires, and more. These drones are capable of hovering over disaster-stricken areas that may be challenging for rescue teams to access directly. Unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), commonly referred to as drones, are frequently deployed for search-and-rescue missions during disaster situations. Typically, drones capture aerial images to assess structural damage and identify the extent of the disaster. They also employ thermal imaging technology to detect body heat signatures, which can help locate individuals. In some cases, larger drones are used to deliver essential supplies to people stranded in isolated disaster-stricken areas. In our discussions, we delve into the unique challenges associated with locating humans through aerial acoustics. The auditory system must distinguish between human cries and sounds that occur naturally, such as animal calls and wind. Additionally, it should be capable of recognizing distinct patterns related to signals like shouting, clapping, or other ways in which people attempt to signal rescue teams. To tackle this challenge, one solution involves harnessing artificial intelligence (AI) to analyze sound frequencies and identify common audio signatures. Deep learning-based networks, such as convolutional neural networks (CNNs), can be trained using these signatures to filter out noise generated by drone motors and other environmental factors. Furthermore, employing signal processing techniques like the direction of arrival (DOA) based on microphone array signals can enhance the precision of tracking the source of human noises.
Read more7/16/2024