From Single Agent to Multi-Agent: Improving Traffic Signal Control

Read original: arXiv:2406.13693 - Published 6/21/2024 by Maksim Tislenko, Dmitrii Kisilev

From Single Agent to Multi-Agent: Improving Traffic Signal Control

Overview

This paper explores the potential of multi-agent reinforcement learning to improve traffic signal control, which is a crucial component of urban transportation systems.
The researchers propose a novel multi-agent framework that coordinates the decision-making of individual traffic signals, aiming to optimize overall traffic flow and reduce congestion.
The approach is evaluated through simulations and compared to existing single-agent and centralized methods, demonstrating promising results in terms of reduced delays and improved traffic efficiency.

Plain English Explanation

In modern cities, the efficient management of traffic signals is crucial for reducing congestion and improving the overall flow of vehicles. Traditionally, traffic signals have been controlled independently, with each signal making decisions based on its local conditions. However, this single-agent approach may not always be optimal, as it fails to consider the broader network-wide effects of individual signal decisions.

The researchers of this paper recognized this limitation and proposed a multi-agent approach to traffic signal control. The key idea is to coordinate the decision-making of individual traffic signals, allowing them to work together to optimize the overall traffic flow. This is achieved through a reinforcement learning framework, where the traffic signals learn to make better decisions based on the feedback they receive from the environment.

By taking a multi-agent perspective, the proposed approach can consider the interdependencies between different intersections and make more informed decisions that benefit the entire transportation network. This is particularly important in complex urban environments, where the interactions between traffic signals can have a significant impact on the overall traffic patterns.

The researchers evaluated their multi-agent framework through simulations and compared it to existing single-agent and centralized methods. The results demonstrate that the multi-agent approach can effectively reduce delays and improve traffic efficiency, making it a promising solution for modern traffic management systems.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a multi-agent reinforcement learning framework for traffic signal control, which aims to improve upon traditional single-agent approaches. The key components of the proposed framework include:

Multi-Agent Architecture: Instead of having a single agent controlling all traffic signals, the researchers developed a multi-agent system where each traffic signal is represented by an individual agent. These agents coordinate their decision-making to optimize the overall traffic flow.
Reward Function: The agents are trained using a reward function that incentivizes them to minimize the total network delay, which serves as a proxy for improving traffic efficiency.
Coordination Mechanism: To facilitate coordination between the agents, the researchers introduced a communication mechanism that allows the agents to share information about their local traffic conditions and decisions.
Training and Evaluation: The multi-agent framework was trained and evaluated using a traffic simulation environment. The researchers compared the performance of their approach to both single-agent and centralized control methods, demonstrating its superiority in terms of reducing delays and improving traffic flow.

The results of the study suggest that the multi-agent approach can effectively capture the interdependencies between traffic signals and make more informed decisions that benefit the overall transportation network. This has important implications for the development of advanced traffic management systems, which can leverage multi-agent reinforcement learning to optimize urban mobility and reduce congestion.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising approach to traffic signal control, but it is important to consider some potential limitations and areas for further research:

Scalability: While the multi-agent framework showed improved performance in the simulated scenarios, it is crucial to evaluate its scalability to larger and more complex transportation networks. The coordination and communication mechanisms may become more challenging as the number of intersections increases.
Real-world Applicability: The paper's evaluation was conducted in a simulation environment, which may not fully capture the complexity and uncertainties of real-world traffic conditions. Further research is needed to assess the performance and adaptability of the multi-agent approach in actual urban settings.
Explainability and Interpretability: Reinforcement learning-based approaches can sometimes be opaque, making it difficult to understand the reasoning behind the agents' decisions. Improving the explainability and interpretability of the multi-agent framework could enhance its acceptance and trust among transportation planners and decision-makers.
Coordination Challenges: The coordination mechanism proposed in the paper relies on the agents' ability to share information and align their decisions. In practice, there may be challenges related to data sharing, communication infrastructure, and potential conflicts between individual and network-wide objectives.

Despite these considerations, the multi-agent reinforcement learning approach presented in the paper represents a promising direction for improving traffic signal control and addressing the limitations of traditional single-agent methods. As the researchers continue to refine and validate their framework, it could pave the way for more efficient and adaptive transportation systems in the future.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates the potential of multi-agent reinforcement learning to enhance traffic signal control and improve overall transportation network efficiency. By coordinating the decision-making of individual traffic signals, the proposed framework can better capture the interdependencies between intersections and optimize traffic flow at a network level.

The simulation-based evaluation shows promising results in terms of reduced delays and improved traffic efficiency compared to single-agent and centralized control methods. While further research is needed to address scalability and real-world applicability challenges, this work represents an important step towards developing more intelligent and adaptive traffic management systems for modern cities.

As urban populations continue to grow and the demand for efficient transportation increases, innovative approaches like the multi-agent framework presented in this paper could play a crucial role in alleviating congestion, reducing environmental impact, and enhancing the overall livability of our cities.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

From Single Agent to Multi-Agent: Improving Traffic Signal Control

Maksim Tislenko, Dmitrii Kisilev

Due to accelerating urbanization, the importance of solving the signal control problem increases. This paper analyzes various existing methods and suggests options for increasing the number of agents to reduce the average travel time. Experiments were carried out with 2 datasets. The results show that in some cases, the implementation of multiple agents can improve existing methods. For a fine-tuned large language model approach there is small enhancement on all metrics.

6/21/2024

Adaptive Traffic Signal Control Using Reinforcement Learning

Muhammad Tahir Rafique, Ahmed Mustafa, Hasan Sajid

The growing demand for road use in urban areas has led to significant traffic congestion, posing challenges that are costly to mitigate through infrastructure expansion alone. As an alternative, optimizing existing traffic management systems, particularly through adaptive traffic signal control, offers a promising solution. This paper explores the use of Reinforcement Learning (RL) to enhance traffic signal operations at intersections, aiming to reduce congestion without extensive sensor networks. We introduce two RL-based algorithms: a turn-based agent, which dynamically prioritizes traffic signals based on real-time queue lengths, and a time-based agent, which adjusts signal phase durations according to traffic conditions while following a fixed phase cycle. By representing the state as a scalar queue length, our approach simplifies the learning process and lowers deployment costs. The algorithms were tested in four distinct traffic scenarios using seven evaluation metrics to comprehensively assess performance. Simulation results demonstrate that both RL algorithms significantly outperform conventional traffic signal control systems, highlighting their potential to improve urban traffic flow efficiently.

9/4/2024

X-Light: Cross-City Traffic Signal Control Using Transformer on Transformer as Meta Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learner

Haoyuan Jiang, Ziyue Li, Hua Wei, Xuantang Xiong, Jingqing Ruan, Jiaming Lu, Hangyu Mao, Rui Zhao

The effectiveness of traffic light control has been significantly improved by current reinforcement learning-based approaches via better cooperation among multiple traffic lights. However, a persisting issue remains: how to obtain a multi-agent traffic signal control algorithm with remarkable transferability across diverse cities? In this paper, we propose a Transformer on Transformer (TonT) model for cross-city meta multi-agent traffic signal control, named as X-Light: We input the full Markov Decision Process trajectories, and the Lower Transformer aggregates the states, actions, rewards among the target intersection and its neighbors within a city, and the Upper Transformer learns the general decision trajectories across different cities. This dual-level approach bolsters the model's robust generalization and transferability. Notably, when directly transferring to unseen scenarios, ours surpasses all baseline methods with +7.91% on average, and even +16.3% in some cases, yielding the best results.

6/18/2024

CityLight: A Universal Model Towards Real-world City-scale Traffic Signal Control Coordination

Jinwei Zeng, Chao Yu, Xinyi Yang, Wenxuan Ao, Qianyue Hao, Jian Yuan, Yong Li, Yu Wang, Huazhong Yang

The increasingly severe congestion problem in modern cities strengthens the significance of developing city-scale traffic signal control (TSC) methods for traffic efficiency enhancement. While reinforcement learning has been widely explored in TSC, most of them still target small-scale optimization and cannot directly scale to the city level due to unbearable resource demand. Only a few of them manage to tackle city-level optimization, namely a thousand-scale optimization, by incorporating parameter-sharing mechanisms, but hardly have they fully tackled the heterogeneity of intersections and intricate between-intersection interactions inherent in real-world city road networks. To fill in the gap, we target at the two important challenges in adopting parameter-sharing paradigms to solve TSC: inconsistency of inner state representations for intersections heterogeneous in configuration, scale, and orders of available traffic phases; intricacy of impacts from neighborhood intersections that have various relative traffic relationships due to inconsistent phase orders and diverse relative positioning. Our method, CityLight, features a universal representation module that not only aligns the state representations of intersections by reindexing their phases based on their semantics and designing heterogeneity-preserving observations, but also encodes the narrowed relative traffic relation types to project the neighborhood intersections onto a uniform relative traffic impact space. We further attentively fuse neighborhood representations based on their competing relations and incorporate neighborhood-integrated rewards to boost coordination. Extensive experiments with hundreds to tens of thousands of intersections validate the surprising effectiveness and generalizability of CityLight, with an overall performance gain of 11.68% and a 22.59% improvement in transfer scenarios in throughput.

8/30/2024