Gene Set Summarization using Large Language Models

Overview

• Molecular biologists often analyze lists of genes to understand their biological functions.
• This is typically done using statistical enrichment analysis, which measures whether certain biological function terms are over- or under-represented in the gene list.
• The researchers developed a method called SPINDOCTOR that uses large language models (LLMs) like GPT to summarize gene set function as an alternative to enrichment analysis.
• SPINDOCTOR can use different sources of gene functional information, including curated ontological annotations, narrative gene summaries, or direct model retrieval.

Plain English Explanation

Molecular biologists frequently work with lists of genes that come from high-throughput experiments or computational analysis. To understand the biological functions of these gene sets, they often perform a statistical technique called enrichment analysis. This looks at whether certain biological function terms (like "cell growth" or "immune response") are over- or under-represented in the gene list, based on a curated knowledge base like the Gene Ontology.

The researchers developed a new method called SPINDOCTOR that uses large language models (LLMs) like GPT to summarize the functions of gene sets. Instead of relying on a curated knowledge base, SPINDOCTOR can use different sources of gene function information, including structured text from ontology annotations, free-text gene summaries, or directly querying the LLM.

The researchers found that SPINDOCTOR can generate plausible and biologically valid summaries of gene set functions. However, the LLM-based approach has some key limitations. It cannot provide reliable statistical scores or p-values, and it often returns terms that are not actually statistically significant. Crucially, SPINDOCTOR struggled to identify the most precise and informative terms that standard enrichment analysis would find, likely because it has difficulty generalizing and reasoning using a structured ontology.

Overall, the results suggest that while LLM-based methods can provide useful complementary information, they are not yet ready to replace traditional enrichment analysis for interpreting gene lists. Manual curation of ontological knowledge remains an important part of this process.

Technical Explanation

The researchers developed SPINDOCTOR (Structured Prompt Interpolation of Natural Language Descriptions of Controlled Terms for Ontology Reporting), a method that uses GPT models to perform gene set function summarization as a complement to standard enrichment analysis. SPINDOCTOR can utilize different sources of gene functional information:

1. Structured text from curated ontological knowledge base (KB) annotations: SPINDOCTOR can extract descriptions of biological function terms from ontologies like the Gene Ontology (GO) and use these as prompts for the LLM.

2. Ontology-free narrative gene summaries: Instead of a structured ontology, SPINDOCTOR can use free-text gene function descriptions as input to the LLM.

3. Direct model retrieval: SPINDOCTOR can directly query the LLM for relevant function terms, without any explicit gene function knowledge.

The researchers found that these SPINDOCTOR methods were able to generate plausible and biologically valid summary GO term lists for gene sets. However, the GPT-based approaches had several key limitations:

• They could not deliver reliable statistical scores or p-values, often returning terms that were not statistically significant.
• They struggled to recapitulate the most precise and informative terms that standard enrichment analysis would identify, likely due to an inability to effectively generalize and reason using the structure of an ontology.
• The results were highly nondeterministic, with minor variations in the prompts resulting in radically different term lists.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge several important caveats and limitations of their SPINDOCTOR approach:

• The LLM-based methods are unable to provide the reliable statistical measures (like p-values) that are a crucial part of standard enrichment analysis. This makes it difficult to distinguish truly significant biological function terms from those that are just plausible-sounding.

• SPINDOCTOR struggled to identify the most informative and precise terms that enrichment analysis can uncover, likely because the language models have difficulty reasoning about the structured relationships and hierarchies in ontologies like GO.

• The high degree of nondeterminism in the results, where small changes to the prompts lead to very different output, suggests that these methods are not yet robust or reliable enough to replace expert curation.

While the researchers demonstrate some promising capabilities of using LLMs for gene set summarization, the results indicate that manual curation of ontological knowledge remains an essential part of interpreting gene lists. Further research is needed to develop LLM-based methods that can better leverage structured knowledge and provide the statistical rigor required for this type of analysis.

Conclusion

This paper explores the use of large language models like GPT to summarize the biological functions of gene sets as an alternative to traditional statistical enrichment analysis. The researchers developed SPINDOCTOR, a method that can utilize different sources of gene function information to generate summaries.

While SPINDOCTOR was able to produce plausible and biologically valid results, the language model-based approach had several key limitations. It could not provide reliable statistical measures, struggled to identify the most informative terms, and produced highly nondeterministic output. These findings suggest that, at least for now, LLM-based methods are not ready to replace the expert curation and structured reasoning required for interpreting gene lists.

The research highlights the ongoing challenges in applying large language models to the domain of molecular biology and computational biology more broadly. Further advancements will be needed to develop LLM-based techniques that can meaningfully complement or replace traditional knowledge-based approaches in this field.