Generalized Independent Noise Condition for Estimating Causal Structure with Latent Variables
2308.06718
0
0
↗️
Abstract
We investigate the task of learning causal structure in the presence of latent variables, including locating latent variables and determining their quantity, and identifying causal relationships among both latent and observed variables. To this end, we propose a Generalized Independent Noise (GIN) condition for linear non-Gaussian acyclic causal models that incorporate latent variables, which establishes the independence between a linear combination of certain measured variables and some other measured variables. Specifically, for two observed random vectors $bf{Y}$ and $bf{Z}$, GIN holds if and only if $omega^{intercal}mathbf{Y}$ and $mathbf{Z}$ are independent, where $omega$ is a non-zero parameter vector determined by the cross-covariance between $mathbf{Y}$ and $mathbf{Z}$. We then give necessary and sufficient graphical criteria of the GIN condition in linear non-Gaussian acyclic models. Roughly speaking, GIN implies the existence of a set $mathcal{S}$ such that $mathcal{S}$ is causally earlier (w.r.t. the causal ordering) than $mathbf{Y}$, and that every active (collider-free) path between $mathbf{Y}$ and $mathbf{Z}$ must contain a node from $mathcal{S}$. Interestingly, we find that the independent noise condition (i.e., if there is no confounder, causes are independent of the residual derived from regressing the effect on the causes) can be seen as a special case of GIN. With such a connection between GIN and latent causal structures, we further leverage the proposed GIN condition, together with a well-designed search procedure, to efficiently estimate Linear, Non-Gaussian Latent Hierarchical Models (LiNGLaHs), where latent confounders may also be causally related and may even follow a hierarchical structure. We show that the causal structure of a LiNGLaH is identifiable in light of GIN conditions. Experimental results show the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the problem of learning causal structure in the presence of latent variables.
- It proposes a Generalized Independent Noise (GIN) condition for linear non-Gaussian acyclic causal models that incorporate latent variables.
- The GIN condition establishes the independence between a linear combination of certain measured variables and some other measured variables.
- The paper provides necessary and sufficient graphical criteria for the GIN condition and shows that the independent noise condition is a special case of GIN.
- It further leverages the GIN condition to efficiently estimate Linear, Non-Gaussian Latent Hierarchical Models (LiNGLaHs), where latent confounders may be causally related and follow a hierarchical structure.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers wanted to understand how to identify the causal relationships between variables, even when there are hidden or unobserved variables involved. This is an important problem because in many real-world situations, there may be factors that we can't directly measure, but that still influence the relationships between the things we can observe.
To address this, the researchers proposed a new mathematical condition called the Generalized Independent Noise (GIN) condition. The GIN condition says that if two sets of observed variables are independent of each other, after accounting for the effects of some other set of observed variables, then this implies the existence of a set of hidden variables that causally influence the first two sets of variables.
Interestingly, the researchers found that a previously known condition, called the independent noise condition, is actually a special case of the GIN condition. This means that the GIN condition is a more general and powerful way of understanding the causal relationships between observed and hidden variables.
The researchers then used the GIN condition to develop a method for efficiently estimating a specific type of causal model, called a Linear, Non-Gaussian Latent Hierarchical Model (LiNGLaH). In these models, the hidden variables can be causally related to each other and even form a hierarchical structure. The researchers showed that the causal structure of a LiNGLaH model can be identified using the GIN condition.
Overall, this research provides a new theoretical framework and practical tool for discovering causal relationships in the presence of hidden variables, which is an important problem in many areas of science and data analysis.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a Generalized Independent Noise (GIN) condition for linear non-Gaussian acyclic causal models that incorporate latent variables. The GIN condition states that for two observed random vectors Y and Z, GIN holds if and only if a linear combination of Y and Z are independent.
The paper then provides necessary and sufficient graphical criteria for the GIN condition. Roughly, GIN implies the existence of a set S that is causally earlier than Y, and every active (collider-free) path between Y and Z must contain a node from S. Interestingly, the independent noise condition is shown to be a special case of GIN.
The researchers further leverage the GIN condition, along with a search procedure, to efficiently estimate Linear, Non-Gaussian Latent Hierarchical Models (LiNGLaHs), where latent confounders may be causally related and follow a hierarchical structure. The paper shows that the causal structure of a LiNGLaH is identifiable under the GIN condition.
Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel theoretical framework for causal discovery with latent variables, which is an important and challenging problem. The GIN condition provides a powerful way to identify the presence of latent variables and their causal relationships, building on and generalizing previous work on the independent noise condition.
One potential limitation of the approach is that it relies on the assumption of linear, non-Gaussian acyclic causal models. While this class of models is quite general, there may be real-world situations where the causal relationships are non-linear or involve feedback loops. Extensions to more flexible model classes could further broaden the applicability of the method.
Additionally, the paper does not provide extensive empirical evaluation of the method's performance on real-world datasets with complex latent variable structures. Thorough testing on a diverse set of benchmarks would help strengthen the evidence for the method's effectiveness and practical relevance.
Overall, this research represents an important theoretical advance in the field of causal discovery with latent variables. The GIN condition and its connection to the independent noise condition provide a deeper understanding of the underlying principles governing causal identification in the presence of unobserved confounders. Further development and empirical evaluation of these ideas could lead to significant progress in this important area of causal inference.
Conclusion
This paper proposes a Generalized Independent Noise (GIN) condition for linear non-Gaussian acyclic causal models with latent variables. The GIN condition establishes a connection between observed variable independence and the presence of latent causal structures, generalizing previous work on the independent noise condition.
The researchers leverage the GIN condition to efficiently estimate Linear, Non-Gaussian Latent Hierarchical Models (LiNGLaHs), where latent confounders may be causally related and follow a hierarchical structure. The causal structure of these models is shown to be identifiable under the GIN condition.
This research advances the theoretical understanding of causal discovery in the presence of latent variables and provides a practical tool for addressing this important problem. Further extensions and empirical evaluation could lead to significant progress in the field of causal inference.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Effective Causal Discovery under Identifiable Heteroscedastic Noise Model
Naiyu Yin, Tian Gao, Yue Yu, Qiang Ji
0
0
Capturing the underlying structural causal relations represented by Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs) has been a fundamental task in various AI disciplines. Causal DAG learning via the continuous optimization framework has recently achieved promising performance in terms of both accuracy and efficiency. However, most methods make strong assumptions of homoscedastic noise, i.e., exogenous noises have equal variances across variables, observations, or even both. The noises in real data usually violate both assumptions due to the biases introduced by different data collection processes. To address the issue of heteroscedastic noise, we introduce relaxed and implementable sufficient conditions, proving the identifiability of a general class of SEM subject to these conditions. Based on the identifiable general SEM, we propose a novel formulation for DAG learning that accounts for the variation in noise variance across variables and observations. We then propose an effective two-phase iterative DAG learning algorithm to address the increasing optimization difficulties and to learn a causal DAG from data with heteroscedastic variable noise under varying variance. We show significant empirical gains of the proposed approaches over state-of-the-art methods on both synthetic data and real data.
6/11/2024
Causal Effect Identification in LiNGAM Models with Latent Confounders
Daniele Tramontano, Yaroslav Kivva, Saber Salehkaleybar, Mathias Drton, Negar Kiyavash
0
0
We study the generic identifiability of causal effects in linear non-Gaussian acyclic models (LiNGAM) with latent variables. We consider the problem in two main settings: When the causal graph is known a priori, and when it is unknown. In both settings, we provide a complete graphical characterization of the identifiable direct or total causal effects among observed variables. Moreover, we propose efficient algorithms to certify the graphical conditions. Finally, we propose an adaptation of the reconstruction independent component analysis (RICA) algorithm that estimates the causal effects from the observational data given the causal graph. Experimental results show the effectiveness of the proposed method in estimating the causal effects.
6/5/2024
A General Causal Inference Framework for Cross-Sectional Observational Data
Yonghe Zhao, Huiyan Sun
0
0
Causal inference methods for observational data are highly regarded due to their wide applicability. While there are already numerous methods available for de-confounding bias, these methods generally assume that covariates consist solely of confounders or make naive assumptions about the covariates. Such assumptions face challenges in both theory and practice, particularly when dealing with high-dimensional covariates. Relaxing these naive assumptions and identifying the confounding covariates that truly require correction can effectively enhance the practical significance of these methods. Therefore, this paper proposes a General Causal Inference (GCI) framework specifically designed for cross-sectional observational data, which precisely identifies the key confounding covariates and provides corresponding identification algorithm. Specifically, based on progressive derivations of the Markov property on Directed Acyclic Graph, we conclude that the key confounding covariates are equivalent to the common root ancestors of the treatment and the outcome variable. Building upon this conclusion, the GCI framework is composed of a novel Ancestor Set Identification (ASI) algorithm and de-confounding inference methods. Firstly, the ASI algorithm is theoretically supported by the conditional independence properties and causal asymmetry between variables, enabling the identification of key confounding covariates. Subsequently, the identified confounding covariates are used in the de-confounding inference methods to obtain unbiased causal effect estimation, which can support informed decision-making. Extensive experiments on synthetic datasets demonstrate that the GCI framework can effectively identify the critical confounding covariates and significantly improve the precision, stability, and interpretability of causal inference in observational studies.
4/30/2024
Identifiable causal inference with noisy treatment and no side information
Antti Pollanen, Pekka Marttinen
0
0
In some causal inference scenarios, the treatment variable is measured inaccurately, for instance in epidemiology or econometrics. Failure to correct for the effect of this measurement error can lead to biased causal effect estimates. Previous research has not studied methods that address this issue from a causal viewpoint while allowing for complex nonlinear dependencies and without assuming access to side information. For such a scenario, this study proposes a model that assumes a continuous treatment variable that is inaccurately measured. Building on existing results for measurement error models, we prove that our model's causal effect estimates are identifiable, even without knowledge of the measurement error variance or other side information. Our method relies on a deep latent variable model in which Gaussian conditionals are parameterized by neural networks, and we develop an amortized importance-weighted variational objective for training the model. Empirical results demonstrate the method's good performance with unknown measurement error. More broadly, our work extends the range of applications in which reliable causal inference can be conducted.
5/7/2024