Generalized Unbiased Scene Graph Generation
0
🛸
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Existing Unbiased Scene Graph Generation (USGG) methods focus on addressing predicate-level imbalance, but overlook the more pervasive issue of concept-level imbalance
- Concept-level imbalance refers to the long-tailed distribution of subject-object combinations within predicates, which poses a greater challenge than predicate-level imbalance
- The paper introduces a new research problem called Generalized Unbiased Scene Graph Generation (G-USGG) that addresses both predicate-level and concept-level imbalance
Plain English Explanation
Scene graph generation is a computer vision task that aims to understand the relationships between objects in an image. Existing methods have focused on addressing the problem where common relationships (like "on top of") are predicted much more often than rare relationships (like "riding").
However, the paper argues that there is an even more fundamental issue that these methods overlook - the imbalance in the specific combinations of objects that form relationships. For example, within the "on top of" relationship, some object pairings (like "person on chair") are much more common than others (like "book on table"). This concept-level imbalance is more challenging to address than the predicate-level imbalance, because the possible combinations of objects are inherently complex.
To tackle this problem, the paper introduces a new research direction called Generalized Unbiased Scene Graph Generation (G-USGG). The key idea is to develop methods that can learn to predict a balanced set of both common and rare object-relationship combinations, not just a balanced set of relationship types.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a novel framework called Multi-Concept Learning (MCL) to address the concept-level imbalance in scene graph generation. MCL first quantifies the concept-level imbalance by representing each predicate class as multiple "concept-prototypes" that capture the diverse subject-object combinations within that class.
MCL then uses a Concept Regularization (CR) technique to effectively learn these concept-prototypes during training. Additionally, the paper introduces a Balanced Prototypical Memory (BPM) module that guides the scene graph model to generate balanced representations for the different concept-prototypes.
Extensive experiments on benchmark scene graph generation datasets demonstrate that the MCL framework can significantly improve the performance of existing models in two key aspects: 1) predicate-level unbiased relation recognition and 2) concept-level compositional generalization. This leads to new state-of-the-art results, showing the effectiveness of addressing both predicate-level and concept-level imbalance in scene graph generation.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for the importance of addressing concept-level imbalance in scene graph generation, which has been overlooked by prior work. The proposed MCL framework is a model-agnostic strategy that can be readily applied to enhance the performance of existing scene graph generation models.
One potential limitation is that the paper focuses on evaluating the framework on static image datasets, whereas real-world scene understanding often involves dynamic, video-based scenes. Extending the approach to handle temporal information and complex video scenes could be an interesting direction for future research.
Additionally, while the paper demonstrates the effectiveness of MCL, the exact reasons for its performance gains could be further investigated. A deeper analysis of how the Concept Regularization and Balanced Prototypical Memory components contribute to the improved compositional generalization could provide valuable insights.
Conclusion
This paper makes an important contribution by introducing the Generalized Unbiased Scene Graph Generation (G-USGG) problem, which addresses the more fundamental challenge of concept-level imbalance in addition to the previously studied predicate-level imbalance. The proposed Multi-Concept Learning (MCL) framework provides a principled solution to this problem, leading to state-of-the-art scene graph generation performance on benchmark datasets.
The insights from this research could have broader implications for other vision-and-language tasks that require understanding the complex relationships between objects and concepts. Tackling concept-level imbalance is a crucial step towards developing more robust and generalizable scene understanding models that can better capture the richness and diversity of the real world.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛸
0
Generalized Unbiased Scene Graph Generation
Xinyu Lyu, Lianli Gao, Junlin Xie, Pengpeng Zeng, Yulu Tian, Jie Shao, Heng Tao Shen
Existing Unbiased Scene Graph Generation (USGG) methods only focus on addressing the predicate-level imbalance that high-frequency classes dominate predictions of rare ones, while overlooking the concept-level imbalance. Actually, even if predicates themselves are balanced, there is still a significant concept-imbalance within them due to the long-tailed distribution of contexts (i.e., subject-object combinations). This concept-level imbalance poses a more pervasive and challenging issue compared to the predicate-level imbalance since subject-object pairs are inherently complex in combinations. Hence, we introduce a novel research problem: Generalized Unbiased Scene Graph Generation (G-USGG), which takes into account both predicate-level and concept-level imbalance. To the end, we propose the Multi-Concept Learning (MCL) framework, which ensures a balanced learning process across rare/ uncommon/ common concepts. MCL first quantifies the concept-level imbalance across predicates in terms of different amounts of concepts, representing as multiple concept-prototypes within the same class. It then effectively learns concept-prototypes by applying the Concept Regularization (CR) technique. Furthermore, to achieve balanced learning over different concepts, we introduce the Balanced Prototypical Memory (BPM), which guides SGG models to generate balanced representations for concept-prototypes. Extensive experiments demonstrate the remarkable efficacy of our model-agnostic strategy in enhancing the performance of benchmark models on both VG-SGG and OI-SGG datasets, leading to new state-of-the-art achievements in two key aspects: predicate-level unbiased relation recognition and concept-level compositional generability.
Read more7/17/2024
0
Fine-Grained Scene Graph Generation via Sample-Level Bias Prediction
Yansheng Li, Tingzhu Wang, Kang Wu, Linlin Wang, Xin Guo, Wenbin Wang
Scene Graph Generation (SGG) aims to explore the relationships between objects in images and obtain scene summary graphs, thereby better serving downstream tasks. However, the long-tailed problem has adversely affected the scene graph's quality. The predictions are dominated by coarse-grained relationships, lacking more informative fine-grained ones. The union region of one object pair (i.e., one sample) contains rich and dedicated contextual information, enabling the prediction of the sample-specific bias for refining the original relationship prediction. Therefore, we propose a novel Sample-Level Bias Prediction (SBP) method for fine-grained SGG (SBG). Firstly, we train a classic SGG model and construct a correction bias set by calculating the margin between the ground truth label and the predicted label with one classic SGG model. Then, we devise a Bias-Oriented Generative Adversarial Network (BGAN) that learns to predict the constructed correction biases, which can be utilized to correct the original predictions from coarse-grained relationships to fine-grained ones. The extensive experimental results on VG, GQA, and VG-1800 datasets demonstrate that our SBG outperforms the state-of-the-art methods in terms of Average@K across three mainstream SGG models: Motif, VCtree, and Transformer. Compared to dataset-level correction methods on VG, SBG shows a significant average improvement of 5.6%, 3.9%, and 3.2% on Average@K for tasks PredCls, SGCls, and SGDet, respectively. The code will be available at https://github.com/Zhuzi24/SBG.
Read more7/30/2024
0
Semantic Diversity-aware Prototype-based Learning for Unbiased Scene Graph Generation
Jaehyeong Jeon, Kibum Kim, Kanghoon Yoon, Chanyoung Park
The scene graph generation (SGG) task involves detecting objects within an image and predicting predicates that represent the relationships between the objects. However, in SGG benchmark datasets, each subject-object pair is annotated with a single predicate even though a single predicate may exhibit diverse semantics (i.e., semantic diversity), existing SGG models are trained to predict the one and only predicate for each pair. This in turn results in the SGG models to overlook the semantic diversity that may exist in a predicate, thus leading to biased predictions. In this paper, we propose a novel model-agnostic Semantic Diversity-aware Prototype-based Learning (DPL) framework that enables unbiased predictions based on the understanding of the semantic diversity of predicates. Specifically, DPL learns the regions in the semantic space covered by each predicate to distinguish among the various different semantics that a single predicate can represent. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our proposed model-agnostic DPL framework brings significant performance improvement on existing SGG models, and also effectively understands the semantic diversity of predicates.
Read more7/26/2024
0
Ensemble Predicate Decoding for Unbiased Scene Graph Generation
Jiasong Feng, Lichun Wang, Hongbo Xu, Kai Xu, Baocai Yin
Scene Graph Generation (SGG) aims to generate a comprehensive graphical representation that accurately captures the semantic information of a given scenario. However, the SGG model's performance in predicting more fine-grained predicates is hindered by a significant predicate bias. According to existing works, the long-tail distribution of predicates in training data results in the biased scene graph. However, the semantic overlap between predicate categories makes predicate prediction difficult, and there is a significant difference in the sample size of semantically similar predicates, making the predicate prediction more difficult. Therefore, higher requirements are placed on the discriminative ability of the model. In order to address this problem, this paper proposes Ensemble Predicate Decoding (EPD), which employs multiple decoders to attain unbiased scene graph generation. Two auxiliary decoders trained on lower-frequency predicates are used to improve the discriminative ability of the model. Extensive experiments are conducted on the VG, and the experiment results show that EPD enhances the model's representation capability for predicates. In addition, we find that our approach ensures a relatively superior predictive capability for more frequent predicates compared to previous unbiased SGG methods.
Read more8/27/2024