Generating Counterfactual Trajectories with Latent Diffusion Models for Concept Discovery
2404.10356
0
0
Abstract
Trustworthiness is a major prerequisite for the safe application of opaque deep learning models in high-stakes domains like medicine. Understanding the decision-making process not only contributes to fostering trust but might also reveal previously unknown decision criteria of complex models that could advance the state of medical research. The discovery of decision-relevant concepts from black box models is a particularly challenging task. This study proposes Concept Discovery through Latent Diffusion-based Counterfactual Trajectories (CDCT), a novel three-step framework for concept discovery leveraging the superior image synthesis capabilities of diffusion models. In the first step, CDCT uses a Latent Diffusion Model (LDM) to generate a counterfactual trajectory dataset. This dataset is used to derive a disentangled representation of classification-relevant concepts using a Variational Autoencoder (VAE). Finally, a search algorithm is applied to identify relevant concepts in the disentangled latent space. The application of CDCT to a classifier trained on the largest public skin lesion dataset revealed not only the presence of several biases but also meaningful biomarkers. Moreover, the counterfactuals generated within CDCT show better FID scores than those produced by a previously established state-of-the-art method, while being 12 times more resource-efficient. Unsupervised concept discovery holds great potential for the application of trustworthy AI and the further development of human knowledge in various domains. CDCT represents a further step in this direction.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the use of latent diffusion models to generate counterfactual trajectories for concept discovery in the context of dermoscopy image analysis.
- The authors propose a method to generate diverse counterfactual examples that can provide insights into the underlying concepts learned by the model.
- The approach leverages the latent space of a pretrained diffusion model to perturb the input and generate counterfactual trajectories, which are then analyzed to uncover relevant visual concepts.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers in this paper are interested in understanding the inner workings of AI models used for medical image analysis, specifically in the context of analyzing skin lesion images (known as dermoscopy). They want to explore ways to make these models more transparent and interpretable, so that we can better understand how they reach their conclusions.
To do this, the researchers use a type of AI model called a "latent diffusion model." This model has an internal representation of the input images that captures the key features and concepts. The researchers then use this internal representation to generate "counterfactual" examples - images that are slightly different from the original, but still similar enough to be recognizable.
By analyzing how the model's predictions change as these counterfactual examples are generated, the researchers can start to uncover the visual concepts that the model is using to make its decisions. This can provide valuable insights into the model's decision-making process and help researchers and clinicians better understand and trust the model's outputs.
The potential benefits of this approach include [link to "Explainablility CounterfactualsConcept Based Explanations Latent Diffusion Models Dermoscopy Concept Discovery"]. Additionally, the techniques developed in this paper could be applied to other domains beyond medical imaging, such as [link to "Towards Characterizing Domain Counterfactuals with Invertible Latent Causal Models", "Do Counterfactual Examples Complicate Adversarial Training?", "Latent-based Diffusion Model for Long-Tailed Recognition", "WildFusion: Learning 3D-Aware Latent Diffusion Models", "WCDT: World-Centric Diffusion Transformer for Traffic Scene"].
Technical Explanation
The key technical contributions of this paper are:
-
Counterfactual Trajectory Generation: The authors propose a method to generate diverse counterfactual trajectories in the latent space of a pretrained diffusion model. This involves perturbing the latent representation of an input image and using the diffusion model to generate a sequence of counterfactual images along this trajectory.
-
Concept Discovery: The authors analyze the generated counterfactual trajectories to uncover the visual concepts that are most relevant to the model's decision-making process. This is done by identifying the regions of the image that change the most along the counterfactual trajectory and associating them with the corresponding changes in the model's predictions.
-
Evaluation on Dermoscopy Images: The authors evaluate their approach on a dataset of dermoscopy images, demonstrating its ability to generate interpretable counterfactual trajectories and uncover clinically relevant visual concepts.
The technical details of the model architecture, training procedure, and evaluation metrics are provided in the paper. Overall, this work represents a promising approach for increasing the transparency and interpretability of AI models used in medical imaging applications.
Critical Analysis
The authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for further research in this work:
- The generated counterfactual trajectories may not always correspond to clinically meaningful concepts, and more work is needed to ensure the relevance of the discovered concepts.
- The approach relies on the availability of a pretrained diffusion model, which may not always be feasible, especially for specialized medical imaging domains.
- The evaluation is limited to a single dataset, and more extensive testing is needed to assess the generalizability of the approach.
Additionally, it is worth considering the potential biases and ethical implications of using these types of interpretability techniques in high-stakes medical decision-making. While the authors' aim of increasing model transparency is laudable, care must be taken to ensure that the discovered concepts are truly representative and not subject to systematic biases.
[Link to "Towards Characterizing Domain Counterfactuals with Invertible Latent Causal Models", "Do Counterfactual Examples Complicate Adversarial Training?", "Latent-based Diffusion Model for Long-Tailed Recognition", "WildFusion: Learning 3D-Aware Latent Diffusion Models", "WCDT: World-Centric Diffusion Transformer for Traffic Scene"]
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach for generating counterfactual trajectories using latent diffusion models, with the aim of uncovering the visual concepts that drive the decision-making of AI models in medical image analysis. The authors demonstrate the potential of this technique on a dermoscopy dataset, but acknowledge the need for further research to ensure the clinical relevance and generalizability of the discovered concepts.
Overall, this work represents an important step towards increasing the transparency and interpretability of AI systems in high-stakes domains like healthcare, which could ultimately lead to more trustworthy and effective decision support tools for clinicians and patients.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
CoLa-DCE -- Concept-guided Latent Diffusion Counterfactual Explanations
Franz Motzkus, Christian Hellert, Ute Schmid
0
0
Recent advancements in generative AI have introduced novel prospects and practical implementations. Especially diffusion models show their strength in generating diverse and, at the same time, realistic features, positioning them well for generating counterfactual explanations for computer vision models. Answering what if questions of what needs to change to make an image classifier change its prediction, counterfactual explanations align well with human understanding and consequently help in making model behavior more comprehensible. Current methods succeed in generating authentic counterfactuals, but lack transparency as feature changes are not directly perceivable. To address this limitation, we introduce Concept-guided Latent Diffusion Counterfactual Explanations (CoLa-DCE). CoLa-DCE generates concept-guided counterfactuals for any classifier with a high degree of control regarding concept selection and spatial conditioning. The counterfactuals comprise an increased granularity through minimal feature changes. The reference feature visualization ensures better comprehensibility, while the feature localization provides increased transparency of where changed what. We demonstrate the advantages of our approach in minimality and comprehensibility across multiple image classification models and datasets and provide insights into how our CoLa-DCE explanations help comprehend model errors like misclassification cases.
6/5/2024
Causal Diffusion Autoencoders: Toward Counterfactual Generation via Diffusion Probabilistic Models
Aneesh Komanduri, Chen Zhao, Feng Chen, Xintao Wu
0
0
Diffusion probabilistic models (DPMs) have become the state-of-the-art in high-quality image generation. However, DPMs have an arbitrary noisy latent space with no interpretable or controllable semantics. Although there has been significant research effort to improve image sample quality, there is little work on representation-controlled generation using diffusion models. Specifically, causal modeling and controllable counterfactual generation using DPMs is an underexplored area. In this work, we propose CausalDiffAE, a diffusion-based causal representation learning framework to enable counterfactual generation according to a specified causal model. Our key idea is to use an encoder to extract high-level semantically meaningful causal variables from high-dimensional data and model stochastic variation using reverse diffusion. We propose a causal encoding mechanism that maps high-dimensional data to causally related latent factors and parameterize the causal mechanisms among latent factors using neural networks. To enforce the disentanglement of causal variables, we formulate a variational objective and leverage auxiliary label information in a prior to regularize the latent space. We propose a DDIM-based counterfactual generation procedure subject to do-interventions. Finally, to address the limited label supervision scenario, we also study the application of CausalDiffAE when a part of the training data is unlabeled, which also enables granular control over the strength of interventions in generating counterfactuals during inference. We empirically show that CausalDiffAE learns a disentangled latent space and is capable of generating high-quality counterfactual images.
5/10/2024
Enhancing Counterfactual Explanation Search with Diffusion Distance and Directional Coherence
Marharyta Domnich, Raul Vicente
0
0
A pressing issue in the adoption of AI models is the increasing demand for more human-centric explanations of their predictions. To advance towards more human-centric explanations, understanding how humans produce and select explanations has been beneficial. In this work, inspired by insights of human cognition we propose and test the incorporation of two novel biases to enhance the search for effective counterfactual explanations. Central to our methodology is the application of diffusion distance, which emphasizes data connectivity and actionability in the search for feasible counterfactual explanations. In particular, diffusion distance effectively weights more those points that are more interconnected by numerous short-length paths. This approach brings closely connected points nearer to each other, identifying a feasible path between them. We also introduce a directional coherence term that allows the expression of a preference for the alignment between the joint and marginal directional changes in feature space to reach a counterfactual. This term enables the generation of counterfactual explanations that align with a set of marginal predictions based on expectations of how the outcome of the model varies by changing one feature at a time. We evaluate our method, named Coherent Directional Counterfactual Explainer (CoDiCE), and the impact of the two novel biases against existing methods such as DiCE, FACE, Prototypes, and Growing Spheres. Through a series of ablation experiments on both synthetic and real datasets with continuous and mixed-type features, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.
4/22/2024
Towards Characterizing Domain Counterfactuals For Invertible Latent Causal Models
Zeyu Zhou, Ruqi Bai, Sean Kulinski, Murat Kocaoglu, David I. Inouye
0
0
Answering counterfactual queries has important applications such as explainability, robustness, and fairness but is challenging when the causal variables are unobserved and the observations are non-linear mixtures of these latent variables, such as pixels in images. One approach is to recover the latent Structural Causal Model (SCM), which may be infeasible in practice due to requiring strong assumptions, e.g., linearity of the causal mechanisms or perfect atomic interventions. Meanwhile, more practical ML-based approaches using naive domain translation models to generate counterfactual samples lack theoretical grounding and may construct invalid counterfactuals. In this work, we strive to strike a balance between practicality and theoretical guarantees by analyzing a specific type of causal query called domain counterfactuals, which hypothesizes what a sample would have looked like if it had been generated in a different domain (or environment). We show that recovering the latent SCM is unnecessary for estimating domain counterfactuals, thereby sidestepping some of the theoretic challenges. By assuming invertibility and sparsity of intervention, we prove domain counterfactual estimation error can be bounded by a data fit term and intervention sparsity term. Building upon our theoretical results, we develop a theoretically grounded practical algorithm that simplifies the modeling process to generative model estimation under autoregressive and shared parameter constraints that enforce intervention sparsity. Finally, we show an improvement in counterfactual estimation over baseline methods through extensive simulated and image-based experiments.
4/16/2024