Generating Synthetic Satellite Imagery for Rare Objects: An Empirical Comparison of Models and Metrics
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper compares different models and metrics for generating synthetic satellite imagery of rare objects.
- The researchers aim to understand the effectiveness of various approaches in producing realistic and representative synthetic data.
- They evaluate several generative models and assessment metrics to determine the optimal techniques for this task.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers in this study are interested in finding the best ways to create artificial satellite images of rare or unusual objects. This is important because real satellite imagery of these types of objects can be hard to come by, but having good synthetic data can help train machine learning models to recognize them.
The researchers tested out different deep learning models for generating these synthetic satellite images. They also looked at different ways to evaluate how good the generated images are, using various metrics and techniques. By comparing the performance of the different models and evaluation methods, the goal is to determine the most effective approach for creating realistic and representative synthetic satellite imagery of rare objects.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents an empirical comparison of several generative models and assessment metrics for the task of producing synthetic satellite imagery of rare objects. The researchers evaluate Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), Variational Autoencoders (VAEs), and Diffusion Models as the generative models, and metrics such as Fréchet Inception Distance (FID), Kernel Inception Distance (KID), and Precision and Recall for assessing the quality of the generated images.
The experiment design involves training the generative models on a dataset of real satellite images and then evaluating the synthetic images produced by each model using the different assessment metrics. The researchers analyze the strengths and weaknesses of the models and metrics, providing insights into the most effective approaches for this task.
Critical Analysis
The paper acknowledges several limitations of the study, including the relatively small size of the dataset used for training the models and the potential sensitivity of the results to the specific characteristics of the satellite imagery data. The authors also note that the evaluation metrics may not fully capture all aspects of image quality and realism, and that further research is needed to develop more comprehensive assessment frameworks.
Additionally, the paper does not directly address potential ethical concerns around the use of synthetic satellite imagery, such as its potential for misuse or the potential impact on privacy and security. As the development of these technologies progresses, it will be important for researchers to consider these types of issues and to work towards responsible and ethical applications of the technology.
Conclusion
This paper provides a comprehensive evaluation of different models and metrics for generating synthetic satellite imagery of rare objects. The findings offer valuable insights into the strengths and limitations of the various approaches, which can inform the development of more effective techniques for producing high-quality synthetic data. As the use of synthetic data becomes increasingly important in fields like remote sensing and geospatial analysis, this research contributes to the ongoing efforts to improve the quality and realism of such data, with potential implications for a wide range of applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Generating Synthetic Satellite Imagery for Rare Objects: An Empirical Comparison of Models and Metrics
Tuong Vy Nguyen, Johannes Hoster, Alexander Glaser, Kristian Hildebrand, Felix Biessmann
Generative deep learning architectures can produce realistic, high-resolution fake imagery -- with potentially drastic societal implications. A key question in this context is: How easy is it to generate realistic imagery, in particular for niche domains. The iterative process required to achieve specific image content is difficult to automate and control. Especially for rare classes, it remains difficult to assess fidelity, meaning whether generative approaches produce realistic imagery and alignment, meaning how (well) the generation can be guided by human input. In this work, we present a large-scale empirical evaluation of generative architectures which we fine-tuned to generate synthetic satellite imagery. We focus on nuclear power plants as an example of a rare object category - as there are only around 400 facilities worldwide, this restriction is exemplary for many other scenarios in which training and test data is limited by the restricted number of occurrences of real-world examples. We generate synthetic imagery by conditioning on two kinds of modalities, textual input and image input obtained from a game engine that allows for detailed specification of the building layout. The generated images are assessed by commonly used metrics for automatic evaluation and then compared with human judgement from our conducted user studies to assess their trustworthiness. Our results demonstrate that even for rare objects, generation of authentic synthetic satellite imagery with textual or detailed building layouts is feasible. In line with previous work, we find that automated metrics are often not aligned with human perception -- in fact, we find strong negative correlations between commonly used image quality metrics and human ratings.
Read more9/4/2024
0
Generating Synthetic Satellite Imagery With Deep-Learning Text-to-Image Models -- Technical Challenges and Implications for Monitoring and Verification
Tuong Vy Nguyen, Alexander Glaser, Felix Biessmann
Novel deep-learning (DL) architectures have reached a level where they can generate digital media, including photorealistic images, that are difficult to distinguish from real data. These technologies have already been used to generate training data for Machine Learning (ML) models, and large text-to-image models like DALL-E 2, Imagen, and Stable Diffusion are achieving remarkable results in realistic high-resolution image generation. Given these developments, issues of data authentication in monitoring and verification deserve a careful and systematic analysis: How realistic are synthetic images? How easily can they be generated? How useful are they for ML researchers, and what is their potential for Open Science? In this work, we use novel DL models to explore how synthetic satellite images can be created using conditioning mechanisms. We investigate the challenges of synthetic satellite image generation and evaluate the results based on authenticity and state-of-the-art metrics. Furthermore, we investigate how synthetic data can alleviate the lack of data in the context of ML methods for remote-sensing. Finally we discuss implications of synthetic satellite imagery in the context of monitoring and verification.
Read more4/12/2024
0
Using Game Engines and Machine Learning to Create Synthetic Satellite Imagery for a Tabletop Verification Exercise
Johannes Hoster, Sara Al-Sayed, Felix Biessmann, Alexander Glaser, Kristian Hildebrand, Igor Moric, Tuong Vy Nguyen
Satellite imagery is regarded as a great opportunity for citizen-based monitoring of activities of interest. Relevant imagery may however not be available at sufficiently high resolution, quality, or cadence -- let alone be uniformly accessible to open-source analysts. This limits an assessment of the true long-term potential of citizen-based monitoring of nuclear activities using publicly available satellite imagery. In this article, we demonstrate how modern game engines combined with advanced machine-learning techniques can be used to generate synthetic imagery of sites of interest with the ability to choose relevant parameters upon request; these include time of day, cloud cover, season, or level of activity onsite. At the same time, resolution and off-nadir angle can be adjusted to simulate different characteristics of the satellite. While there are several possible use-cases for synthetic imagery, here we focus on its usefulness to support tabletop exercises in which simple monitoring scenarios can be examined to better understand verification capabilities enabled by new satellite constellations and very short revisit times.
Read more6/26/2024
📊
0
Robust Disaster Assessment from Aerial Imagery Using Text-to-Image Synthetic Data
Tarun Kalluri, Jihyeon Lee, Kihyuk Sohn, Sahil Singla, Manmohan Chandraker, Joseph Xu, Jeremiah Liu
We present a simple and efficient method to leverage emerging text-to-image generative models in creating large-scale synthetic supervision for the task of damage assessment from aerial images. While significant recent advances have resulted in improved techniques for damage assessment using aerial or satellite imagery, they still suffer from poor robustness to domains where manual labeled data is unavailable, directly impacting post-disaster humanitarian assistance in such under-resourced geographies. Our contribution towards improving domain robustness in this scenario is two-fold. Firstly, we leverage the text-guided mask-based image editing capabilities of generative models and build an efficient and easily scalable pipeline to generate thousands of post-disaster images from low-resource domains. Secondly, we propose a simple two-stage training approach to train robust models while using manual supervision from different source domains along with the generated synthetic target domain data. We validate the strength of our proposed framework under cross-geography domain transfer setting from xBD and SKAI images in both single-source and multi-source settings, achieving significant improvements over a source-only baseline in each case.
Read more5/24/2024