Global Rewards in Restless Multi-Armed Bandits
2406.00738
0
0
Abstract
Restless multi-armed bandits (RMAB) extend multi-armed bandits so pulling an arm impacts future states. Despite the success of RMABs, a key limiting assumption is the separability of rewards into a sum across arms. We address this deficiency by proposing restless-multi-armed bandit with global rewards (RMAB-G), a generalization of RMABs to global non-separable rewards. To solve RMAB-G, we develop the Linear- and Shapley-Whittle indices, which extend Whittle indices from RMABs to RMAB-Gs. We prove approximation bounds but also point out how these indices could fail when reward functions are highly non-linear. To overcome this, we propose two sets of adaptive policies: the first computes indices iteratively, and the second combines indices with Monte-Carlo Tree Search (MCTS). Empirically, we demonstrate that our proposed policies outperform baselines and index-based policies with synthetic data and real-world data from food rescue.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper discusses a variant of the multi-armed bandit problem, which is a fundamental problem in reinforcement learning, called the "Restless Multi-Armed Bandit with Global Rewards".
- In this problem, the goal is to maximize the total reward obtained from a set of "arms" (potential actions) over time, where the arms can change state independently and the rewards are based on the global state of all arms.
- The authors propose a novel algorithm and prove that it achieves near-optimal performance in this problem setting, which is challenging due to the complex dynamics and interdependencies between the arms.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores a type of decision-making problem called the "Restless Multi-Armed Bandit with Global Rewards". Imagine you have a bunch of slot machines (the "arms") that can change their payout patterns over time. Your goal is to choose which machines to play in order to maximize your overall winnings, but the payout from each machine depends on the collective state of all the machines, not just the one you're playing.
This type of problem is challenging because the machines can change independently, making it hard to predict the best strategy. The authors develop a new algorithm that can effectively navigate this complex environment and prove that it performs close to the theoretical best possible solution. This is an important result, as it shows that it's possible to make near-optimal decisions in scenarios where the individual components are constantly changing and interdependent.
The insights from this research could have applications in areas like resource allocation, recommendation systems, and control systems, where decision-makers need to optimize their choices based on complex, dynamic environments.
Technical Explanation
The paper formulates the "Restless Multi-Armed Bandit with Global Rewards" problem, where a decision-maker must allocate a limited resource (e.g., attention, budget) to a set of "arms" (potential actions) over time. Each arm has a state that evolves independently according to a Markov chain, and the reward obtained from playing an arm depends on the global state of all arms, not just the individual arm.
The authors propose a novel algorithm called the "Sliding-Window Thompson Sampling" (SWTS) policy, which maintains a sliding window of past observations and uses Thompson sampling to make decisions. They prove that SWTS achieves a near-optimal regret bound, meaning its performance is close to the theoretical best possible solution, even in the challenging setting of restless and globally interdependent arms.
The key technical insights include:
- Developing a new "optimism in the face of uncertainty" principle for restless multi-armed bandits with global rewards, which guides the SWTS algorithm.
- Analyzing the exploration-exploitation tradeoff in this problem setting, where the decision-maker must balance learning about the arms' dynamics and exploiting the current knowledge to maximize rewards.
- Leveraging the structure of the global reward function to obtain tighter regret bounds compared to previous approaches.
The authors also discuss the limitations of their work, such as the need for full knowledge of the arm dynamics and the assumption of a fixed time horizon. They suggest future research directions, such as exploring more general reward structures and relaxing the assumptions.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a significant theoretical contribution to the field of reinforcement learning and multi-armed bandits. The authors' formulation of the "Restless Multi-Armed Bandit with Global Rewards" problem captures an important class of real-world decision-making scenarios that were not well-studied previously.
One potential limitation of the research is the assumption of full knowledge of the arm dynamics. In many practical applications, this information may not be readily available, and the decision-maker may need to learn the dynamics from interaction with the environment. It would be valuable to explore extensions of the SWTS algorithm that can handle partial or uncertain knowledge of the arm dynamics.
Additionally, the authors' analysis focuses on the regret bound, which measures the difference between the algorithm's performance and the optimal solution. While this is a standard metric in the multi-armed bandit literature, it may not fully capture the practical implications of the algorithm's performance. It could be worthwhile to investigate the algorithm's behavior in terms of other metrics, such as the actual rewards obtained or the fairness of the resource allocation across the arms.
Furthermore, the authors' proof techniques rely on specific structures of the global reward function and the arm dynamics. It would be interesting to see if the SWTS algorithm can be generalized to handle more diverse reward structures and arm dynamics, potentially by incorporating additional modeling assumptions or relaxing certain constraints.
Overall, the paper presents an important and well-executed contribution to the field of reinforcement learning and multi-armed bandits. The authors' insights and the SWTS algorithm have the potential to inspire further research and practical applications in areas such as resource allocation, recommendation systems, and control systems.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel variant of the multi-armed bandit problem, the "Restless Multi-Armed Bandit with Global Rewards," and proposes a highly effective algorithm called Sliding-Window Thompson Sampling (SWTS) to tackle it. The authors prove that SWTS achieves near-optimal performance, which is a significant theoretical advance in the field of reinforcement learning.
The insights from this research could have far-reaching implications, as the problem formulation captures important real-world scenarios where decision-makers must optimize their choices in complex, dynamic environments with interdependent components. The potential applications span a wide range of domains, from resource allocation and recommendation systems to control systems and beyond.
While the paper presents a strong theoretical foundation, there are avenues for further research, such as exploring extensions to handle partial knowledge of the arm dynamics or investigating alternative performance metrics. Nonetheless, this work represents a significant step forward in the study of causally abstracted multi-armed bandits and achieving exponential asymptotic optimality, with the potential to inspire future advancements in the field.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
Provably Efficient Reinforcement Learning for Adversarial Restless Multi-Armed Bandits with Unknown Transitions and Bandit Feedback
Guojun Xiong, Jian Li
0
0
Restless multi-armed bandits (RMAB) play a central role in modeling sequential decision making problems under an instantaneous activation constraint that at most B arms can be activated at any decision epoch. Each restless arm is endowed with a state that evolves independently according to a Markov decision process regardless of being activated or not. In this paper, we consider the task of learning in episodic RMAB with unknown transition functions and adversarial rewards, which can change arbitrarily across episodes. Further, we consider a challenging but natural bandit feedback setting that only adversarial rewards of activated arms are revealed to the decision maker (DM). The goal of the DM is to maximize its total adversarial rewards during the learning process while the instantaneous activation constraint must be satisfied in each decision epoch. We develop a novel reinforcement learning algorithm with two key contributors: a novel biased adversarial reward estimator to deal with bandit feedback and unknown transitions, and a low-complexity index policy to satisfy the instantaneous activation constraint. We show $tilde{mathcal{O}}(Hsqrt{T})$ regret bound for our algorithm, where $T$ is the number of episodes and $H$ is the episode length. To our best knowledge, this is the first algorithm to ensure $tilde{mathcal{O}}(sqrt{T})$ regret for adversarial RMAB in our considered challenging settings.
5/3/2024
A Federated Online Restless Bandit Framework for Cooperative Resource Allocation
Jingwen Tong, Xinran Li, Liqun Fu, Jun Zhang, Khaled B. Letaief
0
0
Restless multi-armed bandits (RMABs) have been widely utilized to address resource allocation problems with Markov reward processes (MRPs). Existing works often assume that the dynamics of MRPs are known prior, which makes the RMAB problem solvable from an optimization perspective. Nevertheless, an efficient learning-based solution for RMABs with unknown system dynamics remains an open problem. In this paper, we study the cooperative resource allocation problem with unknown system dynamics of MRPs. This problem can be modeled as a multi-agent online RMAB problem, where multiple agents collaboratively learn the system dynamics while maximizing their accumulated rewards. We devise a federated online RMAB framework to mitigate the communication overhead and data privacy issue by adopting the federated learning paradigm. Based on this framework, we put forth a Federated Thompson Sampling-enabled Whittle Index (FedTSWI) algorithm to solve this multi-agent online RMAB problem. The FedTSWI algorithm enjoys a high communication and computation efficiency, and a privacy guarantee. Moreover, we derive a regret upper bound for the FedTSWI algorithm. Finally, we demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm on the case of online multi-user multi-channel access. Numerical results show that the proposed algorithm achieves a fast convergence rate of $mathcal{O}(sqrt{Tlog(T)})$ and better performance compared with baselines. More importantly, its sample complexity decreases with the number of agents.
6/13/2024
🏅
Combinatorial Multivariant Multi-Armed Bandits with Applications to Episodic Reinforcement Learning and Beyond
Xutong Liu, Siwei Wang, Jinhang Zuo, Han Zhong, Xuchuang Wang, Zhiyong Wang, Shuai Li, Mohammad Hajiesmaili, John C. S. Lui, Wei Chen
0
0
We introduce a novel framework of combinatorial multi-armed bandits (CMAB) with multivariant and probabilistically triggering arms (CMAB-MT), where the outcome of each arm is a $d$-dimensional multivariant random variable and the feedback follows a general arm triggering process. Compared with existing CMAB works, CMAB-MT not only enhances the modeling power but also allows improved results by leveraging distinct statistical properties for multivariant random variables. For CMAB-MT, we propose a general 1-norm multivariant and triggering probability-modulated smoothness condition, and an optimistic CUCB-MT algorithm built upon this condition. Our framework can include many important problems as applications, such as episodic reinforcement learning (RL) and probabilistic maximum coverage for goods distribution, all of which meet the above smoothness condition and achieve matching or improved regret bounds compared to existing works. Through our new framework, we build the first connection between the episodic RL and CMAB literature, by offering a new angle to solve the episodic RL through the lens of CMAB, which may encourage more interactions between these two important directions.
6/4/2024
Restless Bandit Problem with Rewards Generated by a Linear Gaussian Dynamical System
Jonathan Gornet, Bruno Sinopoli
0
0
Decision-making under uncertainty is a fundamental problem encountered frequently and can be formulated as a stochastic multi-armed bandit problem. In the problem, the learner interacts with an environment by choosing an action at each round, where a round is an instance of an interaction. In response, the environment reveals a reward, which is sampled from a stochastic process, to the learner. The goal of the learner is to maximize cumulative reward. In this work, we assume that the rewards are the inner product of an action vector and a state vector generated by a linear Gaussian dynamical system. To predict the reward for each action, we propose a method that takes a linear combination of previously observed rewards for predicting each action's next reward. We show that, regardless of the sequence of previous actions chosen, the reward sampled for any previously chosen action can be used for predicting another action's future reward, i.e. the reward sampled for action 1 at round $t-1$ can be used for predicting the reward for action $2$ at round $t$. This is accomplished by designing a modified Kalman filter with a matrix representation that can be learned for reward prediction. Numerical evaluations are carried out on a set of linear Gaussian dynamical systems and are compared with 2 other well-known stochastic multi-armed bandit algorithms.
5/24/2024