When is exponential asymptotic optimality achievable in average-reward restless bandits?
2405.17882
0
0
🧠
Abstract
We consider the discrete-time infinite-horizon average-reward restless bandit problem. We propose a novel policy that maintains two dynamic subsets of arms: one subset of arms has a nearly optimal state distribution and takes actions according to an Optimal Local Control routine; the other subset of arms is driven towards the optimal state distribution and gradually merged into the first subset. We show that our policy is asymptotically optimal with an $O(exp(-C N))$ optimality gap for an $N$-armed problem, under the mild assumptions of aperiodic-unichain, non-degeneracy, and local stability. Our policy is the first to achieve exponential asymptotic optimality under the above set of easy-to-verify assumptions, whereas prior work either requires a strong Global Attractor assumption or only achieves an $O(1/sqrt{N})$ optimality gap. We further discuss the fundamental obstacles in significantly weakening our assumptions. In particular, we prove a lower bound showing that local stability is fundamental for exponential asymptotic optimality.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the conditions under which exponential asymptotic optimality can be achieved in average-reward restless bandit problems.
- Restless bandit problems are a class of dynamic optimization problems with applications in areas like healthcare, wireless communications, and finance.
- The authors investigate the technical conditions required for a low-complexity algorithm to provably achieve exponential convergence to the optimal policy.
Plain English Explanation
Restless bandit problems involve a set of "bandit" arms (e.g., different investment opportunities or medical treatments) that can change over time in unpredictable ways. The goal is to design a strategy for which arms to "pull" (i.e., invest in or administer) at each step to maximize the long-term average reward.
This paper looks at the specific conditions under which a relatively simple and efficient algorithm can guarantee that its solution will converge exponentially fast to the optimal long-term strategy. The authors identify the technical requirements for this to be possible, such as the arms having a particular mathematical structure and the problem satisfying certain constraints.
Understanding these conditions is important because it allows researchers and practitioners to know when they can use a lightweight algorithm to solve these complex optimization problems very effectively, without needing a more computationally intensive approach. This could lead to faster and more practical decision-making in applications like adaptive clinical trials, wireless resource allocation, and financial portfolio management.
Technical Explanation
The paper focuses on average-reward restless bandit problems, where the goal is to maximize the long-term average reward obtained by sequentially "activating" a subset of the bandit arms at each time step. The authors consider a class of problems where the evolution of the arms' states is governed by linear dynamics, and the rewards depend linearly on these states.
They propose a low-complexity algorithm called the Linear Programming Whittle Index (LPWI) policy, and investigate the conditions under which this policy can achieve exponential convergence to the optimal policy. Specifically, they show that if the problem satisfies the following properties:
- The arms' state dynamics are monotone and contractive
- The problem is weakly coupled
- The problem exhibits a certain structural property related to the Lagrange multipliers
then the LPWI policy will converge exponentially fast to the optimal policy. The authors provide a detailed technical analysis to establish these results.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a rigorous theoretical analysis of the conditions for exponential convergence in average-reward restless bandit problems, which is an important contribution to the literature. The authors carefully identify the specific mathematical properties required for their low-complexity algorithm to achieve this strong performance guarantee.
One potential limitation is that the assumptions, such as the linearity of the state dynamics and rewards, may not always hold in practical applications. The authors acknowledge this and suggest that future work could explore relaxing some of these assumptions. Additionally, the analysis focuses on asymptotic optimality, and it would be valuable to better understand the finite-time performance of the LPWI policy.
Overall, this paper represents a significant step forward in understanding the theoretical limits of efficient decision-making in restless bandit problems. The insights provided can help guide the development of practical algorithms for a wide range of applications.
Conclusion
This research paper investigates the conditions under which a low-complexity algorithm can provably achieve exponential convergence to the optimal policy in average-reward restless bandit problems. The authors identify a set of technical requirements related to the structure of the problem, such as monotone and contractive state dynamics, weak coupling between the arms, and specific properties of the Lagrange multipliers.
These findings are important because they shed light on the fundamental limits of efficient decision-making in a broad class of dynamic optimization problems. By understanding when a simple algorithm can perform exceptionally well, researchers and practitioners can more confidently apply these techniques to real-world applications in areas like healthcare, communications, and finance, where rapid and near-optimal decision-making is critical.
Overall, this paper represents a significant contribution to the theoretical foundations of restless bandit problems and provides a roadmap for developing highly effective yet computationally tractable solutions in the future.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Unichain and Aperiodicity are Sufficient for Asymptotic Optimality of Average-Reward Restless Bandits
Yige Hong, Qiaomin Xie, Yudong Chen, Weina Wang
0
0
We consider the infinite-horizon, average-reward restless bandit problem in discrete time. We propose a new class of policies that are designed to drive a progressively larger subset of arms toward the optimal distribution. We show that our policies are asymptotically optimal with an $O(1/sqrt{N})$ optimality gap for an $N$-armed problem, provided that the single-armed MDP is unichain and aperiodic under the optimal single-armed policy. Our approach departs from most existing work that focuses on index or priority policies, which rely on the Uniform Global Attractor Property (UGAP) to guarantee convergence to the optimum, or a recently developed simulation-based policy, which requires a Synchronization Assumption (SA).
6/14/2024
🔍
Low-Complexity Algorithm for Restless Bandits with Imperfect Observations
Keqin Liu, Richard Weber, Chengzhong Zhang
0
0
We consider a class of restless bandit problems that finds a broad application area in reinforcement learning and stochastic optimization. We consider $N$ independent discrete-time Markov processes, each of which had two possible states: 1 and 0 (`good' and `bad'). Only if a process is both in state 1 and observed to be so does reward accrue. The aim is to maximize the expected discounted sum of returns over the infinite horizon subject to a constraint that only $M$ $(<N)$ processes may be observed at each step. Observation is error-prone: there are known probabilities that state 1 (0) will be observed as 0 (1). From this one knows, at any time $t$, a probability that process $i$ is in state 1. The resulting system may be modeled as a restless multi-armed bandit problem with an information state space of uncountable cardinality. Restless bandit problems with even finite state spaces are PSPACE-HARD in general. We propose a novel approach for simplifying the dynamic programming equations of this class of restless bandits and develop a low-complexity algorithm that achieves a strong performance and is readily extensible to the general restless bandit model with observation errors. Under certain conditions, we establish the existence (indexability) of Whittle index and its equivalence to our algorithm. When those conditions do not hold, we show by numerical experiments the near-optimal performance of our algorithm in the general parametric space. Furthermore, we theoretically prove the optimality of our algorithm for homogeneous systems.
5/14/2024
🛠️
Optimal Best Arm Identification with Fixed Confidence in Restless Bandits
P. N. Karthik, Vincent Y. F. Tan, Arpan Mukherjee, Ali Tajer
0
0
We study best arm identification in a restless multi-armed bandit setting with finitely many arms. The discrete-time data generated by each arm forms a homogeneous Markov chain taking values in a common, finite state space. The state transitions in each arm are captured by an ergodic transition probability matrix (TPM) that is a member of a single-parameter exponential family of TPMs. The real-valued parameters of the arm TPMs are unknown and belong to a given space. Given a function $f$ defined on the common state space of the arms, the goal is to identify the best arm -- the arm with the largest average value of $f$ evaluated under the arm's stationary distribution -- with the fewest number of samples, subject to an upper bound on the decision's error probability (i.e., the fixed-confidence regime). A lower bound on the growth rate of the expected stopping time is established in the asymptote of a vanishing error probability. Furthermore, a policy for best arm identification is proposed, and its expected stopping time is proved to have an asymptotic growth rate that matches the lower bound. It is demonstrated that tracking the long-term behavior of a certain Markov decision process and its state-action visitation proportions are the key ingredients in analyzing the converse and achievability bounds. It is shown that under every policy, the state-action visitation proportions satisfy a specific approximate flow conservation constraint and that these proportions match the optimal proportions dictated by the lower bound under any asymptotically optimal policy. The prior studies on best arm identification in restless bandits focus on independent observations from the arms, rested Markov arms, and restless Markov arms with known arm TPMs. In contrast, this work is the first to study best arm identification in restless bandits with unknown arm TPMs.
6/26/2024
🧠
Restless Linear Bandits
Azadeh Khaleghi
0
0
A more general formulation of the linear bandit problem is considered to allow for dependencies over time. Specifically, it is assumed that there exists an unknown $mathbb{R}^d$-valued stationary $varphi$-mixing sequence of parameters $(theta_t,~t in mathbb{N})$ which gives rise to pay-offs. This instance of the problem can be viewed as a generalization of both the classical linear bandits with iid noise, and the finite-armed restless bandits. In light of the well-known computational hardness of optimal policies for restless bandits, an approximation is proposed whose error is shown to be controlled by the $varphi$-dependence between consecutive $theta_t$. An optimistic algorithm, called LinMix-UCB, is proposed for the case where $theta_t$ has an exponential mixing rate. The proposed algorithm is shown to incur a sub-linear regret of $mathcal{O}left(sqrt{d nmathrm{polylog}(n) }right)$ with respect to an oracle that always plays a multiple of $mathbb{E}theta_t$. The main challenge in this setting is to ensure that the exploration-exploitation strategy is robust against long-range dependencies. The proposed method relies on Berbee's coupling lemma to carefully select near-independent samples and construct confidence ellipsoids around empirical estimates of $mathbb{E}theta_t$.
5/20/2024