Goal-oriented Estimation of Multiple Markov Sources in Resource-constrained Systems

2311.07346

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 6/4/2024 by Jiping Luo, Nikolaos Pappas

🔎

Abstract

This paper investigates goal-oriented communication for remote estimation of multiple Markov sources in resource-constrained networks. An agent decides the updating times of the sources and transmits the packet to a remote destination over an unreliable channel with delay. The destination is tasked with source reconstruction for actuation. We utilize the metric textit{cost of actuation error} (CAE) to capture the state-dependent actuation costs. We aim for a sampling policy that minimizes the long-term average CAE subject to an average resource constraint. We formulate this problem as an average-cost constrained Markov Decision Process (CMDP) and relax it into an unconstrained problem by utilizing textit{Lyapunov drift} techniques. Then, we propose a low-complexity textit{drift-plus-penalty} (DPP) policy for systems with known source/channel statistics and a Lyapunov optimization-based deep reinforcement learning (LO-DRL) policy for unknown environments. Our policies significantly reduce the number of uninformative transmissions by exploiting the timing of the important information.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper investigates efficient communication strategies for remote estimation of multiple Markov sources in resource-constrained networks.
  • The goal is to minimize the long-term average "cost of actuation error" (CAE) subject to an average resource constraint.
  • The authors formulate the problem as an average-cost constrained Markov Decision Process (CMDP) and propose two policies: a drift-plus-penalty (DPP) policy for known environments and a Lyapunov optimization-based deep reinforcement learning (LO-DRL) policy for unknown environments.

Plain English Explanation

The paper explores how an agent can effectively communicate with a remote destination to reconstruct the state of multiple dynamic systems (Markov sources) while using limited resources. The key idea is to selectively transmit only the most important information, rather than sending updates constantly.

The agent has to decide when to send updates about the sources, which are then transmitted over an unreliable communication channel to the remote destination. The destination uses this information to reconstruct the source states, which are then used for actuation (controlling the system).

The authors define a "cost of actuation error" (CAE) metric to capture the state-dependent costs of poor actuation. Their goal is to find a sampling policy that minimizes the long-term average CAE, while also satisfying an average resource constraint (e.g., energy, bandwidth).

To solve this optimization problem, the authors formulate it as a constrained Markov Decision Process (CMDP). They then propose two policies: one for known environments (DPP) and one for unknown environments (LO-DRL). These policies intelligently decide when to send updates, avoiding unnecessary transmissions and focusing on the most important information.

Technical Explanation

The authors model the problem as a remote estimation of multiple Markov sources in resource-constrained networks. An agent decides the update times of the sources and transmits packets to a remote destination over an unreliable channel with delay. The destination reconstructs the source states for actuation.

The authors utilize the cost of actuation error (CAE) to capture the state-dependent actuation costs. They aim to find a sampling policy that minimizes the long-term average CAE subject to an average resource constraint.

The problem is formulated as an average-cost constrained Markov Decision Process (CMDP). To solve it, the authors relax the constraint using Lyapunov drift techniques.

Two policies are proposed:

  1. A drift-plus-penalty (DPP) policy for systems with known source/channel statistics.
  2. A Lyapunov optimization-based deep reinforcement learning (LO-DRL) policy for unknown environments.

These policies intelligently decide when to send updates, avoiding uninformative transmissions and focusing on the most important information.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a comprehensive approach to the problem of remote estimation in resource-constrained networks. The authors' formulation of the problem as a constrained MDP and their use of Lyapunov drift techniques are well-grounded in the literature.

One potential limitation is the assumption of Markov sources, which may not always hold in real-world scenarios. Additionally, the performance of the proposed policies may depend heavily on the accuracy of the source/channel models, which may not be known a priori in many applications.

The authors acknowledge these limitations and suggest extensions to more general source and channel models as potential avenues for future research. Additionally, the empirical evaluation of the policies on realistic use cases would be valuable to assess their practical applicability and performance.

Overall, the paper presents an interesting and technically sound approach to the problem of remote estimation in resource-constrained networks, with potential for further refinement and adaptation to a wider range of real-world applications.

Conclusion

This paper introduces efficient communication strategies for remote estimation of multiple Markov sources in resource-constrained networks. By formulating the problem as a constrained Markov Decision Process and proposing two novel policies (DPP and LO-DRL), the authors demonstrate how selective and intelligent transmission of updates can significantly improve the long-term performance, as measured by the cost of actuation error.

The key insights from this work can inform the design of communication protocols and control systems for a variety of applications, such as distributed sensor networks, remote monitoring, and robotic control, where resource constraints and reliable state estimation are critical. Further research is needed to extend the methods to more general source and channel models, as well as to evaluate their performance in real-world scenarios.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

Decentralized Learning Strategies for Estimation Error Minimization with Graph Neural Networks

Decentralized Learning Strategies for Estimation Error Minimization with Graph Neural Networks

Xingran Chen, Navid NaderiAlizadeh, Alejandro Ribeiro, Shirin Saeedi Bidokhti

YC

0

Reddit

0

We address the challenge of sampling and remote estimation for autoregressive Markovian processes in a multi-hop wireless network with statistically-identical agents. Agents cache the most recent samples from others and communicate over wireless collision channels governed by an underlying graph topology. Our goal is to minimize time-average estimation error and/or age of information with decentralized scalable sampling and transmission policies, considering both oblivious (where decision-making is independent of the physical processes) and non-oblivious policies (where decision-making depends on physical processes). We prove that in oblivious policies, minimizing estimation error is equivalent to minimizing the age of information. The complexity of the problem, especially the multi-dimensional action spaces and arbitrary network topologies, makes theoretical methods for finding optimal transmission policies intractable. We optimize the policies using a graphical multi-agent reinforcement learning framework, where each agent employs a permutation-equivariant graph neural network architecture. Theoretically, we prove that our proposed framework exhibits desirable transferability properties, allowing transmission policies trained on small- or moderate-size networks to be executed effectively on large-scale topologies. Numerical experiments demonstrate that (i) Our proposed framework outperforms state-of-the-art baselines; (ii) The trained policies are transferable to larger networks, and their performance gains increase with the number of agents; (iii) The training procedure withstands non-stationarity even if we utilize independent learning techniques; and, (iv) Recurrence is pivotal in both independent learning and centralized training and decentralized execution, and improves the resilience to non-stationarity in independent learning.

Read more

4/5/2024

Exploiting Data Significance in Remote Estimation of Discrete-State Markov Sources

Exploiting Data Significance in Remote Estimation of Discrete-State Markov Sources

Jiping Luo, Nikolaos Pappas

YC

0

Reddit

0

We consider the semantics-aware remote estimation of a discrete-state Markov source with normal (low-priority) and alarm (high-priority) states. Erroneously announcing a normal state at the destination when the source is actually in an alarm state (i.e., missed alarm error) incurs a significantly higher cost than falsely announcing an alarm state when the source is in a normal state (i.e., false alarm error). Moreover, successive reception of an estimation error may cause significant lasting impact, e.g., maintenance cost and misoperations. Motivated by this, we assign different costs to different estimation errors and introduce two new age metrics, namely the Age of Missed Alarm (AoMA) and the Age of False Alarm (AoFA), to account for the lasting impact incurred by different estimation errors. Notably, the two age processes evolve dependently and can distinguish between different types of estimation errors and different synced states. The aim is to achieve an optimal trade-off between the cost of estimation error, lasting impact, and communication utilization. The problem is formulated as an average-cost, countably infinite state-space Markov decision process (MDP). We show that the optimal policy exhibits a switching-type structure, making it amenable to policy storage and algorithm design. Notably, when the source is symmetric and states are equally important, the optimal policy has identical thresholds, i.e., threshold-type. Theoretical and numerical results underscore that our approach extends the current understanding of the Age of Incorrect Information (AoII) and the cost of actuation error (CAE), showing that they are specific instances within our broader framework.

Read more

6/27/2024

🔄

Goal-Oriented Multiple Access Connectivity for Networked Intelligent Systems

Pouya Agheli, Nikolaos Pappas, Marios Kountouris

YC

0

Reddit

0

We design a self-decision goal-oriented multiple access scheme, where sensing agents observe a common event and individually decide to communicate the event's attributes as updates to the monitoring agents, to satisfy a certain goal. Decisions are based on the usefulness of updates, generated under uniform, change- and semantics-aware acquisition, as well as statistics and updates of other agents. We obtain optimal activation probabilities and threshold criteria for decision-making under all schemes, maximizing a grade of effectiveness metric. Alongside studying the effect of different parameters on effectiveness, our simulation results show that the self-decision scheme may attain at least 92% of optimal performance.

Read more

6/17/2024

🌿

Optimal Update Policy for the Monitoring of Distributed Sources

Eric Graves, Jake B. Perazzone, Kevin Chan

YC

0

Reddit

0

When making decisions in a network, it is important to have up-to-date knowledge of the current state of the system. Obtaining this information, however, comes at a cost. In this paper, we determine the optimal finite-time update policy for monitoring the binary states of remote sources with a reporting rate constraint. We first prove an upper and lower bound of the minimal probability of error before solving the problem analytically. The error probability is defined as the probability that the system performs differently than it would with full system knowledge. More specifically, an error occurs when the destination node incorrectly determines which top-K priority sources are in the ``free'' state. We find that the optimal policy follows a specific ordered 3-stage update pattern. We then provide the optimal transition points for each stage for each source.

Read more

5/21/2024