Graph Reinforcement Learning in Power Grids: A Survey

Read original: arXiv:2407.04522 - Published 8/27/2024 by Mohamed Hassouna, Clara Holzhuter, Pawel Lytaev, Josephine Thomas, Bernhard Sick, Christoph Scholz
Total Score

0

Graph Reinforcement Learning in Power Grids: A Survey

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • The paper provides a comprehensive survey of the current state of graph reinforcement learning (GRL) applications in power grid systems.
  • GRL combines graph neural networks and reinforcement learning to address various power grid challenges.
  • The survey covers key use cases, technical approaches, and critical analyses of existing GRL research in power grids.

Plain English Explanation

Power grids are complex networks of interconnected components, like power lines and substations. Managing these grids efficiently is crucial for reliable electricity supply. Graph reinforcement learning (GRL) is an emerging approach that combines two powerful techniques:

  1. Graph neural networks: These can model the complex relationships and interdependencies within power grid networks.
  2. Reinforcement learning: This allows AI systems to learn optimal control policies through trial-and-error, without relying on pre-defined rules.

By applying GRL to power grids, researchers aim to address challenges like fault detection, operational risk management, and flexible grid operation. The goal is to develop more intelligent, adaptive, and resilient power grid control systems.

Technical Explanation

The survey first outlines several key use cases for GRL in power grids, including:

  • Operational risk management: Using GRL to predict and mitigate operational risks, such as equipment failures or extreme weather events.
  • Flexible grid operation: Leveraging GRL to identify new grid configuration options and enable more flexible, adaptive grid operation.
  • Fault detection and localization: Applying GRL to quickly detect and locate grid faults, enabling faster response and restoration.
  • Optimal control and planning: Using GRL to optimize grid control policies and investment planning for the grid infrastructure.

The paper then delves into the technical details of GRL approaches, covering:

  • Graph neural network architectures for modeling power grid topologies and dynamics.
  • Reinforcement learning algorithms, such as Q-learning and policy gradients, for training intelligent control policies.
  • Techniques for integrating domain knowledge and grid physics into the GRL framework.

Finally, the survey provides a critical analysis of the current state of GRL research in power grids, discussing limitations and areas for future work, such as:

  • The need for more comprehensive benchmark datasets to evaluate GRL approaches.
  • Challenges in scaling GRL solutions to large-scale, real-world power grid systems.
  • Ensuring the robustness and reliability of GRL-based control systems, especially in mission-critical grid applications.

Critical Analysis

The survey highlights several important limitations and areas for further research in applying GRL to power grids:

  • Data availability and quality: The authors note the need for more comprehensive, standardized benchmark datasets to evaluate and compare GRL approaches. Existing power grid datasets may be limited in scope or lack the necessary detail.

  • Scalability and computational complexity: Scaling GRL solutions to large-scale, real-world power grids poses significant challenges, as the computational complexity can quickly become intractable. Techniques for improving the efficiency and scalability of GRL are needed.

  • Robustness and reliability: Given the mission-critical nature of power grid operations, it is essential that GRL-based control systems be highly robust and reliable. The survey emphasizes the importance of ensuring the safety and stability of these systems, even in the face of unexpected grid conditions or adversarial attacks.

  • Interpretability and explainability: Many GRL models can be opaque "black boxes," making it difficult to understand the reasoning behind their decisions. Developing more interpretable and explainable GRL approaches could improve trust and acceptance in power grid applications.

Overall, the survey provides a thorough and balanced assessment of the current state of GRL research in power grids, highlighting both the significant potential and the important challenges that must be addressed to realize the full benefits of this technology.

Conclusion

This comprehensive survey on graph reinforcement learning (GRL) in power grids outlines the key use cases, technical approaches, and critical analyses of existing research in this emerging field. GRL combines the power of graph neural networks and reinforcement learning to address complex challenges in power grid management, including operational risk prediction, flexible grid operation, fault detection, and optimal control.

While the survey demonstrates the significant potential of GRL for transforming power grid operations, it also highlights important limitations and areas for future work, such as the need for better benchmark datasets, scalable algorithms, and robust, interpretable systems. Addressing these challenges will be crucial for the successful deployment of GRL-based solutions in real-world, mission-critical power grid applications.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Graph Reinforcement Learning in Power Grids: A Survey
Total Score

0

Graph Reinforcement Learning in Power Grids: A Survey

Mohamed Hassouna, Clara Holzhuter, Pawel Lytaev, Josephine Thomas, Bernhard Sick, Christoph Scholz

The rise of renewable energy and distributed generation requires new approaches to overcome the limitations of traditional methods. In this context, Graph Neural Networks are promising due to their ability to learn from graph-structured data. Combined with Reinforcement Learning, they can serve as control approaches to determine remedial network actions. This review analyses how Graph Reinforcement Learning (GRL) can improve representation learning and decision making in power grid use cases. Although GRL has demonstrated adaptability to unpredictable events and noisy data, it is primarily at a proof-of-concept stage. We highlight open challenges and limitations with respect to real-world applications.

Read more

8/27/2024

🧠

Total Score

0

Graph neural networks for power grid operational risk assessment under evolving grid topology

Yadong Zhang, Pranav M Karve, Sankaran Mahadevan

This article investigates the ability of graph neural networks (GNNs) to identify risky conditions in a power grid over the subsequent few hours, without explicit, high-resolution information regarding future generator on/off status (grid topology) or power dispatch decisions. The GNNs are trained using supervised learning, to predict the power grid's aggregated bus-level (either zonal or system-level) or individual branch-level state under different power supply and demand conditions. The variability of the stochastic grid variables (wind/solar generation and load demand), and their statistical correlations, are rigorously considered while generating the inputs for the training data. The outputs in the training data, obtained by solving numerous mixed-integer linear programming (MILP) optimal power flow problems, correspond to system-level, zonal and transmission line-level quantities of interest (QoIs). The QoIs predicted by the GNNs are used to conduct hours-ahead, sampling-based reliability and risk assessment w.r.t. zonal and system-level (load shedding) as well as branch-level (overloading) failure events. The proposed methodology is demonstrated for three synthetic grids with sizes ranging from 118 to 2848 buses. Our results demonstrate that GNNs are capable of providing fast and accurate prediction of QoIs and can be good proxies for computationally expensive MILP algorithms. The excellent accuracy of GNN-based reliability and risk assessment suggests that GNN models can substantially improve situational awareness by quickly providing rigorous reliability and risk estimates.

Read more

5/14/2024

🤿

Total Score

0

HUGO -- Highlighting Unseen Grid Options: Combining Deep Reinforcement Learning with a Heuristic Target Topology Approach

Malte Lehna, Clara Holzhuter, Sven Tomforde, Christoph Scholz

With the growth of Renewable Energy (RE) generation, the operation of power grids has become increasingly complex. One solution could be automated grid operation, where Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) has repeatedly shown significant potential in Learning to Run a Power Network (L2RPN) challenges. However, only individual actions at the substation level have been subjected to topology optimization by most existing DRL algorithms. In contrast, we propose a more holistic approach by proposing specific Target Topologies (TTs) as actions. These topologies are selected based on their robustness. As part of this paper, we present a search algorithm to find the TTs and upgrade our previously developed DRL agent CurriculumAgent (CAgent) to a novel topology agent. We compare the upgrade to the previous CAgent and can increase their L2RPN score significantly by 10%. Further, we achieve a 25% better median survival time with our TTs included. Later analysis shows that almost all TTs are close to the base topology, explaining their robustness

Read more

5/24/2024

State and Action Factorization in Power Grids
Total Score

1

State and Action Factorization in Power Grids

Gianvito Losapio, Davide Beretta, Marco Mussi, Alberto Maria Metelli, Marcello Restelli

The increase of renewable energy generation towards the zero-emission target is making the problem of controlling power grids more and more challenging. The recent series of competitions Learning To Run a Power Network (L2RPN) have encouraged the use of Reinforcement Learning (RL) for the assistance of human dispatchers in operating power grids. All the solutions proposed so far severely restrict the action space and are based on a single agent acting on the entire grid or multiple independent agents acting at the substations level. In this work, we propose a domain-agnostic algorithm that estimates correlations between state and action components entirely based on data. Highly correlated state-action pairs are grouped together to create simpler, possibly independent subproblems that can lead to distinct learning processes with less computational and data requirements. The algorithm is validated on a power grid benchmark obtained with the Grid2Op simulator that has been used throughout the aforementioned competitions, showing that our algorithm is in line with domain-expert analysis. Based on these results, we lay a theoretically-grounded foundation for using distributed reinforcement learning in order to improve the existing solutions.

Read more

9/10/2024