HACMan: Learning Hybrid Actor-Critic Maps for 6D Non-Prehensile Manipulation

Read original: arXiv:2305.03942 - Published 7/16/2024 by Wenxuan Zhou, Bowen Jiang, Fan Yang, Chris Paxton, David Held

🔎

Overview

Introduces a reinforcement learning approach called Hybrid Actor-Critic Maps for Manipulation (HACMan) for 6D non-prehensile manipulation of objects using point cloud observations
Proposes a temporally-abstracted and spatially-grounded object-centric action representation for non-prehensile manipulation
Evaluates HACMan on a 6D object pose alignment task in simulation and the real world, demonstrating strong generalization to unseen object categories

Plain English Explanation

HACMan is a new approach for teaching robots to manipulate objects without grasping them. This type of "non-prehensile" manipulation can enable more complex interactions, but it also makes it harder for the robot to reason about how its movements will affect the object.

The key innovation in HACMan is the way it represents the robot's actions. Instead of just specifying where to grasp the object, HACMan allows the robot to select a point on the object's surface to make contact with, and then describe how it will move after making that contact. This "hybrid" discrete-continuous action representation gives the robot more flexibility to perform intricate non-prehensile skills.

HACMan uses reinforcement learning to train the robot on a challenging 6D object pose alignment task, where the goal is to precisely position and orient an object to match a target pose. The researchers tested HACMan in simulation and the real world, and found that it could successfully manipulate a wide variety of objects, including ones it had never seen before. Compared to alternative approaches, HACMan achieved success rates more than three times higher on the hardest version of the task.

The ability to manipulate objects without grasping them, using dynamic and contact-rich non-prehensile skills, could enable robots to perform more sophisticated and dexterous interactions in the real world. The HACMan approach represents an important step towards developing more flexible and capable robot manipulation capabilities.

Technical Explanation

The core of the HACMan approach is a novel action representation for 6D non-prehensile manipulation. Instead of just specifying a gripper position and orientation, the robot selects a contact location on the object's surface and a set of motion parameters describing how it will move after making contact. This "hybrid" discrete-continuous action space allows for more complex and dynamic non-prehensile skills, compared to previous approaches like learning parameterized manipulation primitives or tactile-driven non-prehensile manipulation.

The researchers modified an off-policy reinforcement learning algorithm to learn this hybrid action representation using point cloud observations of the object. They evaluated HACMan on a challenging 6D object pose alignment task, where the goal is to precisely position and orient an object to match a target pose. This task requires complex non-prehensile skills, and the researchers tested it in both simulation and the real world.

On the hardest version of the task, with randomized initial poses, randomized 6D goals, and diverse object categories, HACMan demonstrated strong generalization to unseen object categories without a performance drop. In simulation, the policy achieved an 89% success rate on unseen objects, and in the real world it achieved a 50% success rate with zero-shot transfer.

Compared to alternative action representations like AG2Manip and TAC-Man, HACMan achieved a success rate more than three times higher on the hardest version of the task. This demonstrates the benefits of the hybrid discrete-continuous action representation for enabling complex and dynamic non-prehensile manipulation skills.

Critical Analysis

The HACMan paper presents a compelling approach for non-prehensile manipulation, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:

The real-world experiments were conducted on a single robotic platform, so it's unclear how well the approach would generalize to different robot hardware and configurations. Further real-world testing on diverse robotic systems would help validate the system's broader applicability.
The object pose alignment task, while challenging, may not capture the full complexity of real-world manipulation scenarios. Evaluation on a wider range of non-prehensile manipulation tasks, such as object rearrangement or tool use, could provide additional insights into the strengths and limitations of the HACMan approach.
The paper does not address the sample efficiency of the reinforcement learning training process, which is an important practical consideration for real-world deployment. Investigating techniques to improve sample efficiency, such as incorporating demonstrations or tactile feedback, could make the HACMan approach more practical.

Overall, the HACMan paper represents an important contribution to the field of non-prehensile manipulation, demonstrating the potential of hybrid discrete-continuous action representations to enable more dexterous and versatile robot skills. Further research and real-world testing could help refine and expand the capabilities of this approach.

Conclusion

The HACMan paper introduces a novel reinforcement learning approach for 6D non-prehensile manipulation of objects using point cloud observations. The key innovation is a temporally-abstracted and spatially-grounded object-centric action representation that allows the robot to select a contact location on the object's surface and describe how it will move after making contact.

Evaluating HACMan on a challenging 6D object pose alignment task, the researchers showed that it can achieve strong generalization to unseen object categories, with success rates more than three times higher than alternative action representations. This demonstrates the potential of the hybrid discrete-continuous action space to enable complex and dynamic non-prehensile manipulation skills.

While the HACMan approach shows promise, there are opportunities for further research to address potential limitations, such as expanding the evaluation to diverse robotic platforms and task domains. Nonetheless, this work represents an important step towards developing more flexible and capable robot manipulation capabilities that can interact with the world in more sophisticated ways.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🔎

HACMan: Learning Hybrid Actor-Critic Maps for 6D Non-Prehensile Manipulation

Wenxuan Zhou, Bowen Jiang, Fan Yang, Chris Paxton, David Held

Manipulating objects without grasping them is an essential component of human dexterity, referred to as non-prehensile manipulation. Non-prehensile manipulation may enable more complex interactions with the objects, but also presents challenges in reasoning about gripper-object interactions. In this work, we introduce Hybrid Actor-Critic Maps for Manipulation (HACMan), a reinforcement learning approach for 6D non-prehensile manipulation of objects using point cloud observations. HACMan proposes a temporally-abstracted and spatially-grounded object-centric action representation that consists of selecting a contact location from the object point cloud and a set of motion parameters describing how the robot will move after making contact. We modify an existing off-policy RL algorithm to learn in this hybrid discrete-continuous action representation. We evaluate HACMan on a 6D object pose alignment task in both simulation and in the real world. On the hardest version of our task, with randomized initial poses, randomized 6D goals, and diverse object categories, our policy demonstrates strong generalization to unseen object categories without a performance drop, achieving an 89% success rate on unseen objects in simulation and 50% success rate with zero-shot transfer in the real world. Compared to alternative action representations, HACMan achieves a success rate more than three times higher than the best baseline. With zero-shot sim2real transfer, our policy can successfully manipulate unseen objects in the real world for challenging non-planar goals, using dynamic and contact-rich non-prehensile skills. Videos can be found on the project website: https://hacman-2023.github.io.

7/16/2024

HACMan++: Spatially-Grounded Motion Primitives for Manipulation

Bowen Jiang, Yilin Wu, Wenxuan Zhou, Chris Paxton, David Held

Although end-to-end robot learning has shown some success for robot manipulation, the learned policies are often not sufficiently robust to variations in object pose or geometry. To improve the policy generalization, we introduce spatially-grounded parameterized motion primitives in our method HACMan++. Specifically, we propose an action representation consisting of three components: what primitive type (such as grasp or push) to execute, where the primitive will be grounded (e.g. where the gripper will make contact with the world), and how the primitive motion is executed, such as parameters specifying the push direction or grasp orientation. These three components define a novel discrete-continuous action space for reinforcement learning. Our framework enables robot agents to learn to chain diverse motion primitives together and select appropriate primitive parameters to complete long-horizon manipulation tasks. By grounding the primitives on a spatial location in the environment, our method is able to effectively generalize across object shape and pose variations. Our approach significantly outperforms existing methods, particularly in complex scenarios demanding both high-level sequential reasoning and object generalization. With zero-shot sim-to-real transfer, our policy succeeds in challenging real-world manipulation tasks, with generalization to unseen objects. Videos can be found on the project website: https://sgmp-rss2024.github.io.

7/12/2024

⛏️

CORN: Contact-based Object Representation for Nonprehensile Manipulation of General Unseen Objects

Yoonyoung Cho, Junhyek Han, Yoontae Cho, Beomjoon Kim

Nonprehensile manipulation is essential for manipulating objects that are too thin, large, or otherwise ungraspable in the wild. To sidestep the difficulty of contact modeling in conventional modeling-based approaches, reinforcement learning (RL) has recently emerged as a promising alternative. However, previous RL approaches either lack the ability to generalize over diverse object shapes, or use simple action primitives that limit the diversity of robot motions. Furthermore, using RL over diverse object geometry is challenging due to the high cost of training a policy that takes in high-dimensional sensory inputs. We propose a novel contact-based object representation and pretraining pipeline to tackle this. To enable massively parallel training, we leverage a lightweight patch-based transformer architecture for our encoder that processes point clouds, thus scaling our training across thousands of environments. Compared to learning from scratch, or other shape representation baselines, our representation facilitates both time- and data-efficient learning. We validate the efficacy of our overall system by zero-shot transferring the trained policy to novel real-world objects. Code and videos are available at https://sites.google.com/view/contact-non-prehensile.

7/29/2024

Hand-Object Interaction Pretraining from Videos

Himanshu Gaurav Singh, Antonio Loquercio, Carmelo Sferrazza, Jane Wu, Haozhi Qi, Pieter Abbeel, Jitendra Malik

We present an approach to learn general robot manipulation priors from 3D hand-object interaction trajectories. We build a framework to use in-the-wild videos to generate sensorimotor robot trajectories. We do so by lifting both the human hand and the manipulated object in a shared 3D space and retargeting human motions to robot actions. Generative modeling on this data gives us a task-agnostic base policy. This policy captures a general yet flexible manipulation prior. We empirically demonstrate that finetuning this policy, with both reinforcement learning (RL) and behavior cloning (BC), enables sample-efficient adaptation to downstream tasks and simultaneously improves robustness and generalizability compared to prior approaches. Qualitative experiments are available at: url{https://hgaurav2k.github.io/hop/}.

9/14/2024