Heterogeneity: An Open Challenge for Federated On-board Machine Learning
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores the challenge of heterogeneity in federated on-board machine learning.
- Heterogeneity refers to the diversity of devices, data, and environments in real-world federated learning scenarios.
- This open challenge needs to be addressed for federated learning to be widely adopted.
Plain English Explanation
Federated learning is a way for many different devices, like smartphones or sensors, to collaboratively train a machine learning model without sharing their individual data. This can be very useful, for example, to build a better voice recognition model without needing to send all the voice recordings to a central server.
However, in the real world, these devices can be very different from each other. They may have different hardware capabilities, be used in different environments, and collect data in different ways. This heterogeneity, or diversity, is an open challenge that needs to be solved before federated learning can be widely adopted.
The paper explores this problem of heterogeneity and discusses ways to address it, so that federated learning can be more effective and practical in real-world applications.
Technical Explanation
The paper starts by highlighting the importance of federated learning for on-board machine learning, where models are trained directly on edge devices rather than in a centralized cloud. This approach can improve privacy, reduce bandwidth, and enable specialized use cases.
However, the authors note that real-world federated learning scenarios are characterized by high degrees of heterogeneity. This includes heterogeneity in:
The paper presents a survey of researchers and practitioners to better understand the current state of federated learning and the challenges posed by heterogeneity.
The technical discussion then covers potential approaches to address heterogeneity, such as adaptive model architectures, personalization techniques, and robust aggregation methods. The authors also highlight the need for benchmarks and evaluation frameworks to assess the performance of federated learning systems in heterogeneous settings.
Critical Analysis
The paper does a thorough job of outlining the challenge of heterogeneity in federated on-board machine learning. The survey results provide valuable insights into the perspectives of researchers and practitioners working in this field.
However, the paper does not delve deeply into specific solutions or provide a comprehensive evaluation of the various approaches mentioned. More in-depth analysis and empirical evidence would be helpful to assess the viability and trade-offs of different techniques for addressing heterogeneity.
Additionally, the paper could have explored potential societal implications and ethical considerations related to the widespread deployment of federated learning systems, particularly in areas where data privacy and algorithmic fairness are critical concerns.
Conclusion
This paper highlights the open challenge of heterogeneity in federated on-board machine learning, which is a crucial step towards the broader adoption of this promising approach. By addressing the diversity of devices, data, and environments, the research community can work towards more robust and reliable federated learning systems that can unlock the benefits of on-board machine learning in real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Heterogeneity: An Open Challenge for Federated On-board Machine Learning
Maria Hartmann, Gr'egoire Danoy, Pascal Bouvry
The design of satellite missions is currently undergoing a paradigm shift from the historical approach of individualised monolithic satellites towards distributed mission configurations, consisting of multiple small satellites. With a rapidly growing number of such satellites now deployed in orbit, each collecting large amounts of data, interest in on-board orbital edge computing is rising. Federated Learning is a promising distributed computing approach in this context, allowing multiple satellites to collaborate efficiently in training on-board machine learning models. Though recent works on the use of Federated Learning in orbital edge computing have focused largely on homogeneous satellite constellations, Federated Learning could also be employed to allow heterogeneous satellites to form ad-hoc collaborations, e.g. in the case of communications satellites operated by different providers. Such an application presents additional challenges to the Federated Learning paradigm, arising largely from the heterogeneity of such a system. In this position paper, we offer a systematic review of these challenges in the context of the cross-provider use case, giving a brief overview of the state-of-the-art for each, and providing an entry point for deeper exploration of each issue.
Read more8/14/2024
0
Navigating High-Degree Heterogeneity: Federated Learning in Aerial and Space Networks
Fan Dong, Henry Leung, Steve Drew
Federated learning offers a compelling solution to the challenges of networking and data privacy within aerial and space networks by utilizing vast private edge data and computing capabilities accessible through drones, balloons, and satellites. While current research has focused on optimizing the learning process, computing efficiency, and minimizing communication overhead, the heterogeneity issue and class imbalance remain a significant barrier to rapid model convergence. In this paper, we explore the influence of heterogeneity on class imbalance, which diminishes performance in Aerial and Space Networks (ASNs)-based federated learning. We illustrate the correlation between heterogeneity and class imbalance within grouped data and show how constraints such as battery life exacerbate the class imbalance challenge. Our findings indicate that ASNs-based FL faces heightened class imbalance issues even with similar levels of heterogeneity compared to other scenarios. Finally, we analyze the impact of varying degrees of heterogeneity on FL training and evaluate the efficacy of current state-of-the-art algorithms under these conditions. Our results reveal that the heterogeneity challenge is more pronounced in ASNs-based federated learning and that prevailing algorithms often fail to effectively address high levels of heterogeneity.
Read more9/19/2024
0
Advances in Robust Federated Learning: Heterogeneity Considerations
Chuan Chen, Tianchi Liao, Xiaojun Deng, Zihou Wu, Sheng Huang, Zibin Zheng
In the field of heterogeneous federated learning (FL), the key challenge is to efficiently and collaboratively train models across multiple clients with different data distributions, model structures, task objectives, computational capabilities, and communication resources. This diversity leads to significant heterogeneity, which increases the complexity of model training. In this paper, we first outline the basic concepts of heterogeneous federated learning and summarize the research challenges in federated learning in terms of five aspects: data, model, task, device, and communication. In addition, we explore how existing state-of-the-art approaches cope with the heterogeneity of federated learning, and categorize and review these approaches at three different levels: data-level, model-level, and architecture-level. Subsequently, the paper extensively discusses privacy-preserving strategies in heterogeneous federated learning environments. Finally, the paper discusses current open issues and directions for future research, aiming to promote the further development of heterogeneous federated learning.
Read more5/17/2024
0
SatFed: A Resource-Efficient LEO Satellite-Assisted Heterogeneous Federated Learning Framework
Yuxin Zhang, Zheng Lin, Zhe Chen, Zihan Fang, Wenjun Zhu, Xianhao Chen, Jin Zhao, Yue Gao
Traditional federated learning (FL) frameworks rely heavily on terrestrial networks, where coverage limitations and increasing bandwidth congestion significantly hinder model convergence. Fortunately, the advancement of low-Earth orbit (LEO) satellite networks offers promising new communication avenues to augment traditional terrestrial FL. Despite this potential, the limited satellite-ground communication bandwidth and the heterogeneous operating environments of ground devices-including variations in data, bandwidth, and computing power-pose substantial challenges for effective and robust satellite-assisted FL. To address these challenges, we propose SatFed, a resource-efficient satellite-assisted heterogeneous FL framework. SatFed implements freshness-based model prioritization queues to optimize the use of highly constrained satellite-ground bandwidth, ensuring the transmission of the most critical models. Additionally, a multigraph is constructed to capture real-time heterogeneous relationships between devices, including data distribution, terrestrial bandwidth, and computing capability. This multigraph enables SatFed to aggregate satellite-transmitted models into peer guidance, enhancing local training in heterogeneous environments. Extensive experiments with real-world LEO satellite networks demonstrate that SatFed achieves superior performance and robustness compared to state-of-the-art benchmarks.
Read more9/27/2024