HoTPP Benchmark: Are We Good at the Long Horizon Events Forecasting?

Overview

• This paper presents the HoTPP (Horizon-Temporal Point Process) benchmark, which aims to evaluate the performance of models in forecasting long-horizon events.
• The authors argue that existing benchmarks for temporal point process models focus on short-term forecasting, but many real-world applications require accurate predictions over longer time horizons.
• The HoTPP benchmark includes several datasets and evaluation metrics designed to assess a model's ability to forecast events at different time scales.

Plain English Explanation

The paper discusses a new benchmark called HoTPP (Horizon-Temporal Point Process) that is designed to evaluate how well machine learning models can predict events that will happen in the future, especially events that are far in the future.

Many existing benchmarks for these types of models only look at predicting events in the near future, but in the real world, there are often applications where we need to make accurate predictions over much longer time periods. The HoTPP benchmark includes different datasets and ways of measuring performance to specifically test a model's ability to forecast events over a long horizon.

The authors argue that this is an important capability to assess, as many real-world problems require making predictions about events that may happen weeks, months, or even years in the future. By creating this new benchmark, they hope to spur progress in developing models that can excel at long-term event forecasting.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces the HoTPP (Horizon-Temporal Point Process) benchmark, which is designed to evaluate the performance of temporal point process models on the task of long-horizon event forecasting.

Existing benchmarks for temporal point process models, such as those presented in Interpretable Neural Temporal Point Processes and Interaction Event Forecasting with Multi-Relational Recursive Hypergraphs, typically focus on short-term forecasting. However, many real-world applications require accurate predictions over longer time horizons, which the authors argue is not well-captured by current benchmarks.

To address this, the HoTPP benchmark includes several datasets that exhibit temporal dependencies over long time scales, such as stock market data, social media activity, and natural disasters. The benchmark also introduces new evaluation metrics that assess a model's ability to forecast events at different time horizons, from short-term to long-term.

The authors evaluate several state-of-the-art temporal point process models, including ROTHP: Rotary Position Embedding-based Transformer Hawkes and Neural Temporal Point Process for Forecasting Higher-Order, on the HoTPP benchmark. The results highlight the challenges of long-horizon event forecasting and the need for further research in this area.

Critical Analysis

The HoTPP benchmark presents a valuable contribution to the field of temporal point process modeling by focusing on the important but underexplored problem of long-horizon event forecasting. The authors make a compelling case for the real-world relevance of this task and the limitations of existing benchmarks.

One potential concern is the diversity and representativeness of the datasets included in the HoTPP benchmark. While the authors have selected a range of domains, it is unclear whether these datasets fully capture the breadth of challenges that may arise in long-term forecasting scenarios. There may be value in expanding the benchmark to include even more diverse data sources and use cases.

Additionally, the paper does not provide a deep analysis of the specific reasons why current state-of-the-art models struggle with long-horizon forecasting. Further investigation into the underlying causes and potential solutions could help guide future research in this area.

Despite these minor limitations, the HoTPP benchmark represents an important step forward in advancing the capabilities of temporal point process models. By challenging the research community to develop models that can excel at long-term forecasting, this work has the potential to drive significant progress in a critical area of applied machine learning.

Conclusion

The HoTPP benchmark presented in this paper addresses an important and underexplored problem in temporal point process modeling: the ability to accurately forecast events over long time horizons. By introducing new datasets and evaluation metrics focused on long-term forecasting, the authors aim to spur research in this direction and help bridge the gap between the current capabilities of these models and the real-world demands of many applications.

The results of the benchmark experiments highlight the challenges inherent in long-horizon event forecasting, and the paper's detailed technical explanation and critical analysis provide valuable insights for researchers working in this field. Overall, the HoTPP benchmark represents a significant contribution to the advancement of temporal point process modeling and its practical applications.