Human-in-the-Loop Visual Re-ID for Population Size Estimation
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a novel approach for estimating the number of clusters in a dataset using human input and a similarity-driven nested importance sampling technique.
- The method allows users to interactively guide the clustering process and provide feedback to refine the cluster count estimation.
- The proposed approach aims to address the challenge of determining the optimal number of clusters, which is a common issue in unsupervised learning.
Plain English Explanation
Clustering is a widely used technique in data analysis to group similar data points together. However, determining the right number of clusters, known as the "cluster count," can be challenging, especially in complex datasets. This paper introduces a new method that combines human input and a statistical sampling technique to estimate the cluster count more effectively.
The key idea is to let the user provide feedback on the clustering results and use that information to refine the estimation process. The method starts by randomly sampling data points and grouping them into an initial set of clusters. The user then reviews these clusters and indicates which ones are similar or dissimilar. This user feedback is used to guide a nested importance sampling algorithm, which iteratively adjusts the cluster count to better match the user's understanding of the data.
By incorporating human expertise into the clustering process, the method can overcome the limitations of purely algorithmic approaches and converge on a cluster count that aligns with the user's intuition about the dataset. This approach can be particularly useful when working with large or complex datasets where the optimal number of clusters is not immediately apparent.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a human-in-the-loop approach for estimating the number of clusters in a dataset. The method starts by randomly sampling a subset of data points and performing an initial clustering. The user then reviews the resulting clusters and provides feedback on which ones are similar or dissimilar.
This user feedback is incorporated into a nested importance sampling algorithm, which iteratively adjusts the cluster count to better match the user's understanding of the data. The algorithm uses a similarity-driven sampling strategy to focus on the regions of the data space where the user's feedback indicates the clustering could be improved.
The sampling process involves two nested loops: an outer loop that updates the cluster count and an inner loop that refines the cluster assignments based on the user's feedback. The algorithm continues to refine the cluster count and assignments until the user is satisfied with the results or a predefined stopping criterion is met.
The authors evaluate the proposed method on several synthetic and real-world datasets, demonstrating its ability to converge to the correct cluster count more accurately and efficiently than traditional clustering algorithms. They also show that the method can adapt to the user's preferences and provide insights that may not be captured by purely algorithmic approaches.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach for incorporating human expertise into the clustering process, which can be particularly valuable when working with complex or high-dimensional datasets. By allowing the user to provide feedback and guide the clustering, the method can overcome the limitations of automatic clustering algorithms and converge on a cluster count that better aligns with the user's understanding of the data.
However, the paper does not address the potential biases or subjectivity that may arise from the user's feedback. It is important to consider how the method would handle disagreements between multiple users or how to ensure the feedback is representative of the overall dataset. Additionally, the paper does not explore the scalability of the method to very large datasets or its performance on datasets with complex, non-convex cluster shapes.
Further research could investigate ways to quantify the reliability and consistency of the user feedback, as well as techniques to handle diverse user preferences or incorporate uncertainty into the cluster count estimation. Additionally, exploring the integration of this method with other clustering algorithms or visualization techniques could enhance its practical utility and acceptance within the data analysis community.
Conclusion
The proposed human-in-the-loop approach for estimating the number of clusters in a dataset represents a promising step towards more intuitive and user-friendly clustering methods. By incorporating human expertise and feedback into the clustering process, the method can overcome the limitations of purely algorithmic approaches and converge on a cluster count that better aligns with the user's understanding of the data.
While the paper raises some interesting questions about the potential biases and scalability of the method, it demonstrates the value of leveraging human-computer interaction techniques in the context of unsupervised learning. As the field of data analysis continues to evolve, methods like this one may play an increasingly important role in empowering users to explore and make sense of complex datasets more effectively.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Human-in-the-Loop Visual Re-ID for Population Size Estimation
Gustavo Perez, Daniel Sheldon, Grant Van Horn, Subhransu Maji
Computer vision-based re-identification (Re-ID) systems are increasingly being deployed for estimating population size in large image collections. However, the estimated size can be significantly inaccurate when the task is challenging or when deployed on data from new distributions. We propose a human-in-the-loop approach for estimating population size driven by a pairwise similarity derived from an off-the-shelf Re-ID system. Our approach, based on nested importance sampling, selects pairs of images for human vetting driven by the pairwise similarity, and produces asymptotically unbiased population size estimates with associated confidence intervals. We perform experiments on various animal Re-ID datasets and demonstrate that our method outperforms strong baselines and active clustering approaches. In many cases, we are able to reduce the error rates of the estimated size from around 80% using CV alone to less than 20% by vetting a fraction (often less than 0.002%) of the total pairs. The cost of vetting reduces with the increase in accuracy and provides a practical approach for population size estimation within a desired tolerance when deploying Re-ID systems.
Read more7/16/2024
0
Learning Commonality, Divergence and Variety for Unsupervised Visible-Infrared Person Re-identification
Jiangming Shi, Xiangbo Yin, Yaoxing Wang, Xiaofeng Liu, Yuan Xie, Yanyun Qu
Unsupervised visible-infrared person re-identification (USVI-ReID) aims to match specified people in infrared images to visible images without annotation, and vice versa. USVI-ReID is a challenging yet under-explored task. Most existing methods address the USVI-ReID problem using cluster-based contrastive learning, which simply employs the cluster center as a representation of a person. However, the cluster center primarily focuses on shared information, overlooking disparity. To address the problem, we propose a Progressive Contrastive Learning with Multi-Prototype (PCLMP) method for USVI-ReID. In brief, we first generate the hard prototype by selecting the sample with the maximum distance from the cluster center. This hard prototype is used in the contrastive loss to emphasize disparity. Additionally, instead of rigidly aligning query images to a specific prototype, we generate the dynamic prototype by randomly picking samples within a cluster. This dynamic prototype is used to retain the natural variety of features while reducing instability in the simultaneous learning of both common and disparate information. Finally, we introduce a progressive learning strategy to gradually shift the model's attention towards hard samples, avoiding cluster deterioration. Extensive experiments conducted on the publicly available SYSU-MM01 and RegDB datasets validate the effectiveness of the proposed method. PCLMP outperforms the existing state-of-the-art method with an average mAP improvement of 3.9%. The source codes will be released.
Read more5/28/2024
0
Synthesizing Efficient Data with Diffusion Models for Person Re-Identification Pre-Training
Ke Niu, Haiyang Yu, Xuelin Qian, Teng Fu, Bin Li, Xiangyang Xue
Existing person re-identification (Re-ID) methods principally deploy the ImageNet-1K dataset for model initialization, which inevitably results in sub-optimal situations due to the large domain gap. One of the key challenges is that building large-scale person Re-ID datasets is time-consuming. Some previous efforts address this problem by collecting person images from the internet e.g., LUPerson, but it struggles to learn from unlabeled, uncontrollable, and noisy data. In this paper, we present a novel paradigm Diffusion-ReID to efficiently augment and generate diverse images based on known identities without requiring any cost of data collection and annotation. Technically, this paradigm unfolds in two stages: generation and filtering. During the generation stage, we propose Language Prompts Enhancement (LPE) to ensure the ID consistency between the input image sequence and the generated images. In the diffusion process, we propose a Diversity Injection (DI) module to increase attribute diversity. In order to make the generated data have higher quality, we apply a Re-ID confidence threshold filter to further remove the low-quality images. Benefiting from our proposed paradigm, we first create a new large-scale person Re-ID dataset Diff-Person, which consists of over 777K images from 5,183 identities. Next, we build a stronger person Re-ID backbone pre-trained on our Diff-Person. Extensive experiments are conducted on four person Re-ID benchmarks in six widely used settings. Compared with other pre-training and self-supervised competitors, our approach shows significant superiority.
Read more6/11/2024
0
The Research of Group Re-identification from Multiple Cameras
Hao Xiao
Object re-identification is of increasing importance in visual surveillance. Most existing works focus on re-identify individual from multiple cameras while the application of group re-identification (Re-ID) is rarely discussed. We redefine Group Re-identification as a process which includes pedestrian detection, feature extraction, graph model construction, and graph matching. Group re-identification is very challenging since it is not only interfered by view-point and human pose variations in the traditional re-identification tasks, but also suffered from the challenges in group layout change and group member variation. To address the above challenges, this paper introduces a novel approach which leverages the multi-granularity information inside groups to facilitate group re-identification. We first introduce a multi-granularity Re-ID process, which derives features for multi-granularity objects (people/people-subgroups) in a group and iteratively evaluates their importances during group Re-ID, so as to handle group-wise misalignments due to viewpoint change and group dynamics. We further introduce a multi-order matching scheme. It adaptively selects representative people/people-subgroups in each group and integrates the multi-granularity information from these people/people-subgroups to obtain group-wise matching, hence achieving a more reliable matching score between groups. Experimental results on various datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach.
Read more7/23/2024