Identification of quantum entanglement with Siamese convolutional neural networks and semi-supervised learning

Read original: arXiv:2210.07410 - Published 8/20/2024 by Jaros{l}aw Paw{l}owski, Mateusz Krawczyk

🧠

Overview

Quantum entanglement is a fundamental property used in various quantum information protocols and algorithms.
Identifying entanglement in systems larger than 2x3 qubits has been a challenge.
The researchers used deep convolutional neural networks, a type of supervised machine learning, to identify quantum entanglement in 3-qubit systems.
They trained the model on synthetic datasets, excluding challenging positive-under-partial-transposition entangled states (PPTES), and found the model could still accurately identify PPTES.
To further improve the model's ability to recognize PPTES, the researchers used entanglement-preserving symmetry operations through a triple Siamese network in a semi-supervised manner.
An ensemble of Siamese models was also constructed, leading to even better generalization, similar to finding separate types of entanglement witnesses for different classes of states.

Plain English Explanation

Quantum entanglement is a unique property where two or more quantum particles become deeply connected, even when they are physically separated. This property is essential for various quantum information technologies, such as quantum computing and quantum communication.

However, identifying entanglement in larger quantum systems has been a challenge. In this study, the researchers used a type of artificial intelligence called deep learning to tackle this problem. They trained a deep neural network model to recognize quantum entanglement in 3-qubit systems.

The researchers started by generating a large dataset of random quantum states, excluding a particular type of entangled state called positive-under-partial-transposition entangled states (PPTES). Surprisingly, even though the model was not trained on PPTES, it could still accurately identify them.

To further improve the model's ability to recognize PPTES, the researchers used a technique called Siamese networks. This allowed the model to learn the symmetry properties of entanglement, which helped it better identify different types of entangled states, including PPTES. The researchers also built an ensemble of these Siamese models, which led to even better performance, similar to how different types of entanglement witnesses can be used to identify different classes of entangled states.

Technical Explanation

The researchers used deep convolutional neural networks, a type of supervised machine learning, to identify quantum entanglement for any bipartition in a 3-qubit system. They demonstrated that training the model on synthetically generated datasets of random density matrices, excluding challenging positive-under-partial-transposition entangled states (PPTES), led to good model accuracy even for PPTES states, which were outside the training data.

To enhance the model's generalization on PPTES, the researchers applied entanglement-preserving symmetry operations through a triple Siamese network trained in a semi-supervised manner. This improved the model's accuracy and ability to recognize PPTES. Furthermore, by constructing an ensemble of Siamese models, even better generalization was observed, in analogy with the idea of finding separate types of entanglement witnesses for different classes of states.

Critical Analysis

The researchers have made a significant contribution to the field of quantum computing by developing a deep learning-based approach to identify quantum entanglement in larger systems. However, it is important to note that the study is limited to 3-qubit systems, and the generalization of the approach to larger systems is not yet clear.

Additionally, the exclusion of PPTES from the training data raises questions about the model's ability to handle these challenging states in real-world situations. While the researchers were able to improve the model's performance on PPTES through the use of Siamese networks and ensemble methods, further research may be needed to fully understand the limitations and potential biases of this approach.

It would also be valuable to see the researchers extend their work to other types of quantum systems and entanglement properties, as well as to explore the potential applications of this technology in practical quantum computing and communication scenarios.

Conclusion

The researchers have developed a promising deep learning-based approach to identifying quantum entanglement in 3-qubit systems. By training the model on synthetic data and applying Siamese networks and ensemble methods, they were able to improve the model's ability to recognize challenging PPTES states, which are important for various quantum information protocols.

This research represents an important step forward in the field of quantum computing, as the ability to accurately identify and characterize entanglement is crucial for the development of practical quantum technologies. The researchers' work also highlights the potential of machine learning techniques to tackle complex problems in quantum physics and engineering.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🧠

Identification of quantum entanglement with Siamese convolutional neural networks and semi-supervised learning

Jaros{l}aw Paw{l}owski, Mateusz Krawczyk

Quantum entanglement is a fundamental property commonly used in various quantum information protocols and algorithms. Nonetheless, the problem of identifying entanglement has still not reached a general solution for systems larger than $2times3$. In this study, we use deep convolutional NNs, a type of supervised machine learning, to identify quantum entanglement for any bipartition in a 3-qubit system. We demonstrate that training the model on synthetically generated datasets of random density matrices excluding challenging positive-under-partial-transposition entangled states (PPTES), which cannot be identified (and correctly labeled) in general, leads to good model accuracy even for PPTES states, that were outside the training data. Our aim is to enhance the model's generalization on PPTES. By applying entanglement-preserving symmetry operations through a triple Siamese network trained in a semi-supervised manner, we improve the model's accuracy and ability to recognize PPTES. Moreover, by constructing an ensemble of Siamese models, even better generalization is observed, in analogy with the idea of finding separate types of entanglement witnesses for different classes of states.

8/20/2024

QuanTest: Entanglement-Guided Testing of Quantum Neural Network Systems

Jinjing Shi, Zimeng Xiao, Heyuan Shi, Yu Jiang, Xuelong Li

Quantum Neural Network (QNN) combines the Deep Learning (DL) principle with the fundamental theory of quantum mechanics to achieve machine learning tasks with quantum acceleration. Recently, QNN systems have been found to manifest robustness issues similar to classical DL systems. There is an urgent need for ways to test their correctness and security. However, QNN systems differ significantly from traditional quantum software and classical DL systems, posing critical challenges for QNN testing. These challenges include the inapplicability of traditional quantum software testing methods to QNN systems due to differences in programming paradigms and decision logic representations, the dependence of quantum test sample generation on perturbation operators, and the absence of effective information in quantum neurons. In this paper, we propose QuanTest, a quantum entanglement-guided adversarial testing framework to uncover potential erroneous behaviors in QNN systems. We design a quantum entanglement adequacy criterion to quantify the entanglement acquired by the input quantum states from the QNN system, along with two similarity metrics to measure the proximity of generated quantum adversarial examples to the original inputs. Subsequently, QuanTest formulates the problem of generating test inputs that maximize the quantum entanglement adequacy and capture incorrect behaviors of the QNN system as a joint optimization problem and solves it in a gradient-based manner to generate quantum adversarial examples. results demonstrate that QuanTest possesses the capability to capture erroneous behaviors in QNN systems. The entanglement-guided approach proves effective in adversarial testing, generating more adversarial examples.

8/27/2024

A Laplacian-based Quantum Graph Neural Network for Semi-Supervised Learning

Hamed Gholipour, Farid Bozorgnia, Kailash Hambarde, Hamzeh Mohammadigheymasi, Javier Mancilla, Andre Sequeira, Joao Neves, Hugo Proenc{c}a

Laplacian learning method is a well-established technique in classical graph-based semi-supervised learning, but its potential in the quantum domain remains largely unexplored. This study investigates the performance of the Laplacian-based Quantum Semi-Supervised Learning (QSSL) method across four benchmark datasets -- Iris, Wine, Breast Cancer Wisconsin, and Heart Disease. Further analysis explores the impact of increasing Qubit counts, revealing that adding more Qubits to a quantum system doesn't always improve performance. The effectiveness of additional Qubits depends on the quantum algorithm and how well it matches the dataset. Additionally, we examine the effects of varying entangling layers on entanglement entropy and test accuracy. The performance of Laplacian learning is highly dependent on the number of entangling layers, with optimal configurations varying across different datasets. Typically, moderate levels of entanglement offer the best balance between model complexity and generalization capabilities. These observations highlight the crucial need for precise hyperparameter tuning tailored to each dataset to achieve optimal performance in Laplacian learning methods.

8/14/2024

Quantum consistent neural/tensor networks for photonic circuits with strongly/weakly entangled states

Nicolas Allegra

Modern quantum optical systems such as photonic quantum computers and quantum imaging devices require great precision in their designs and implementations in the hope to realistically exploit entanglement and reach a real quantum advantage. The theoretical and experimental explorations and validations of these systems are greatly dependent on the precision of our classical simulations. However, as Hilbert spaces increases, traditional computational methods used to design and optimize these systems encounter hard limitations due to the quantum curse of dimensionally. To address this challenge, we propose an approach based on neural and tensor networks to approximate the exact unitary evolution of closed entangled systems in a precise, efficient and quantum consistent manner. By training the networks with a reasonably small number of examples of quantum dynamics, we enable efficient parameter estimation in larger Hilbert spaces, offering an interesting solution for a great deal of quantum metrology problems.

6/5/2024