Identifying Factors to Help Improve Existing Decomposition-Based PMI Estimation Methods
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper investigates factors that can help improve existing decomposition-based PMI (Post-Mortem Interval) estimation methods.
- PMI estimation is crucial in forensic science to determine the time of death.
- Decomposition-based PMI estimation has limitations that need to be addressed.
- The study aims to identify key factors that can enhance the accuracy and reliability of these methods.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on improving techniques used in forensic science to estimate the time since a person's death, also known as the Post-Mortem Interval (PMI). Determining PMI is vital in criminal investigations, as it can provide important clues about when a person died.
One common method for estimating PMI is by studying the decomposition process of the body. However, this approach has some limitations that researchers are trying to address. The goal of this study is to identify key factors that can help make decomposition-based PMI estimation methods more accurate and reliable.
By understanding the various factors that influence the decomposition process, researchers hope to develop better tools and techniques for forensic investigators to more precisely determine the time of death. This could lead to significant improvements in the accuracy and reliability of PMI estimates, which would be valuable in solving criminal cases.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates ways to enhance the accuracy and reliability of decomposition-based PMI estimation methods. Decomposition is a key process used to determine the time since a person's death, but current techniques have limitations that need to be addressed.
The researchers conducted experiments to identify factors that could improve decomposition-based PMI estimation. They analyzed various environmental, biological, and chemical variables that influence the decomposition process, such as temperature, humidity, insect activity, and chemical composition of the body.
By understanding how these different factors impact the rate and pattern of decomposition, the researchers aim to develop more sophisticated models and algorithms for PMI estimation. This could involve integrating multiple data sources, accounting for regional or individual variations, and optimizing the analysis of decomposition-related evidence.
The insights from this study have the potential to significantly enhance the accuracy and reliability of PMI estimation in forensic investigations. More precise PMI determination can provide crucial timeline information to help solve criminal cases and support the justice system.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thoughtful analysis of the limitations in existing decomposition-based PMI estimation methods and proposes strategies to address them. The researchers have identified key factors that can influence the decomposition process and recognize the importance of accounting for these variables to improve PMI estimation.
However, the study acknowledges that some of these factors, such as individual biological differences and environmental conditions, can be highly complex and difficult to measure or control. Further research may be needed to fully understand the interactions and interdependencies between the various factors.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential ethical or privacy concerns that may arise from the increased use of decomposition data and related information in forensic investigations. As these techniques become more advanced, there may be a need to address issues around data ownership, consent, and the protection of personal information.
Overall, the research presented in this paper represents an important step towards enhancing the accuracy and reliability of PMI estimation, which could have significant implications for the field of forensic science and the criminal justice system. Continued exploration of the identified factors, as well as a consideration of the ethical implications, will be crucial for the successful implementation and adoption of these improved decomposition-based techniques.
Conclusion
This paper offers valuable insights into improving decomposition-based methods for estimating the Post-Mortem Interval (PMI), which is a critical tool in forensic science. By identifying key factors that influence the decomposition process, the researchers have laid the groundwork for developing more sophisticated and reliable PMI estimation techniques.
The findings from this study have the potential to significantly enhance the accuracy and precision of PMI determination, providing forensic investigators with more reliable timeline information to support criminal investigations and the justice system. As these methods continue to evolve, it will be important to address any ethical concerns and ensure the responsible and ethical use of this technology.
Overall, the research presented in this paper represents an important step forward in the field of forensic science, with the ultimate goal of improving the ability to determine the time of death and support the quest for justice.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
New!Identifying Factors to Help Improve Existing Decomposition-Based PMI Estimation Methods
Anna-Maria Nau, Phillip Ditto, Dawnie Wolfe Steadman, Audris Mockus
Accurately assessing the postmortem interval (PMI) is an important task in forensic science. Some of the existing techniques use regression models that use a decomposition score to predict the PMI or accumulated degree days (ADD), however, the provided formulas are based on very small samples and the accuracy is low. With the advent of Big Data, much larger samples can be used to improve PMI estimation methods. We, therefore, aim to investigate ways to improve PMI prediction accuracy by (a) using a much larger sample size, (b) employing more advanced linear models, and (c) enhancing models with factors known to affect the human decay process. Specifically, this study involved the curation of a sample of 249 human subjects from a large-scale decomposition dataset, followed by evaluating pre-existing PMI/ADD formulas and fitting increasingly sophisticated models to estimate the PMI/ADD. Results showed that including the total decomposition score (TDS), demographic factors (age, biological sex, and BMI), and weather-related factors (season of discovery, temperature history, and humidity history) increased the accuracy of the PMI/ADD models. Furthermore, the best performing PMI estimation model using the TDS, demographic, and weather-related features as predictors resulted in an adjusted R-squared of 0.34 and an RMSE of 0.95. It had a 7% lower RMSE than a model using only the TDS to predict the PMI and a 48% lower RMSE than the pre-existing PMI formula. The best ADD estimation model, also using the TDS, demographic, and weather-related features as predictors, resulted in an adjusted R-squared of 0.52 and an RMSE of 0.89. It had an 11% lower RMSE than the model using only the TDS to predict the ADD and a 52% lower RMSE than the pre-existing ADD formula. This work demonstrates the need (and way) to incorporate demographic and environmental factors into PMI/ADD estimation models.
Read more9/17/2024
👀
0
Forensic Iris Image-Based Post-Mortem Interval Estimation
Rasel Ahmed Bhuiyan, Adam Czajka
Post-mortem iris recognition is an emerging application of iris-based human identification in a forensic setup. One factor that may be useful in conditioning iris recognition methods is the tissue decomposition level, which is correlated with the post-mortem interval (PMI), i.g., the number of hours that have elapsed since death. PMI, however, is not always available, and its precise estimation remains one of the core challenges in forensic examination. This paper presents the first known to us method of PMI estimation directly from forensic iris images. To assess the feasibility of the iris-based PMI estimation, convolutional neural networks-based models (VGG19, DenseNet121, ResNet152, and Inception_v3) were trained to predict the PMI from (a) near-infrared (NIR), (b) visible (RGB), and (c) multispectral forensic iris images. Models were evaluated following a 10-fold cross-validation in (S1) sample-disjoint, (S2) subject-disjoint, and (S3) cross-dataset scenarios. We found that using the multispectral data offers a spectacularly low mean absolute error (MAE) of approximately 3.5 hours in scenario (S1), a bit worse MAE of approximately 17.5 hours in scenario (S2), and an MAE of approximately 69.0 hours of in the scenario (S3). This suggests that if the environmental conditions are favorable (e.g., bodies are kept in low temperatures), forensic iris images provide features that are indicative of the PMI and can be automatically estimated. The source codes and model weights are made available with the paper.
Read more4/30/2024
0
Towards Automation of Human Stage of Decay Identification: An Artificial Intelligence Approach
Anna-Maria Nau, Phillip Ditto, Dawnie Wolfe Steadman, Audris Mockus
Determining the stage of decomposition (SOD) is crucial for estimating the postmortem interval and identifying human remains. Currently, labor-intensive manual scoring methods are used for this purpose, but they are subjective and do not scale for the emerging large-scale archival collections of human decomposition photos. This study explores the feasibility of automating two common human decomposition scoring methods proposed by Megyesi and Gelderman using artificial intelligence (AI). We evaluated two popular deep learning models, Inception V3 and Xception, by training them on a large dataset of human decomposition images to classify the SOD for different anatomical regions, including the head, torso, and limbs. Additionally, an interrater study was conducted to assess the reliability of the AI models compared to human forensic examiners for SOD identification. The Xception model achieved the best classification performance, with macro-averaged F1 scores of .878, .881, and .702 for the head, torso, and limbs when predicting Megyesi's SODs, and .872, .875, and .76 for the head, torso, and limbs when predicting Gelderman's SODs. The interrater study results supported AI's ability to determine the SOD at a reliability level comparable to a human expert. This work demonstrates the potential of AI models trained on a large dataset of human decomposition images to automate SOD identification.
Read more8/21/2024
📊
0
Optimized Dynamic Mode Decomposition for Reconstruction and Forecasting of Atmospheric Chemistry Data
Meghana Velegar, Christoph Keller, J. Nathan Kutz
We introduce the optimized dynamic mode decomposition algorithm for constructing an adaptive and computationally efficient reduced order model and forecasting tool for global atmospheric chemistry dynamics. By exploiting a low-dimensional set of global spatio-temporal modes, interpretable characterizations of the underlying spatial and temporal scales can be computed. Forecasting is also achieved with a linear model that uses a linear superposition of the dominant spatio-temporal features. The DMD method is demonstrated on three months of global chemistry dynamics data, showing its significant performance in computational speed and interpretability. We show that the presented decomposition method successfully extracts known major features of atmospheric chemistry, such as summertime surface pollution and biomass burning activities. Moreover, the DMD algorithm allows for rapid reconstruction of the underlying linear model, which can then easily accommodate non-stationary data and changes in the dynamics.
Read more4/22/2024