Improving Medical Reasoning through Retrieval and Self-Reflection with Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models
2401.15269
0
0
Abstract
Recent proprietary large language models (LLMs), such as GPT-4, have achieved a milestone in tackling diverse challenges in the biomedical domain, ranging from multiple-choice questions to long-form generations. To address challenges that still cannot be handled with the encoded knowledge of LLMs, various retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) methods have been developed by searching documents from the knowledge corpus and appending them unconditionally or selectively to the input of LLMs for generation. However, when applying existing methods to different domain-specific problems, poor generalization becomes apparent, leading to fetching incorrect documents or making inaccurate judgments. In this paper, we introduce Self-BioRAG, a framework reliable for biomedical text that specializes in generating explanations, retrieving domain-specific documents, and self-reflecting generated responses. We utilize 84k filtered biomedical instruction sets to train Self-BioRAG that can assess its generated explanations with customized reflective tokens. Our work proves that domain-specific components, such as a retriever, domain-related document corpus, and instruction sets are necessary for adhering to domain-related instructions. Using three major medical question-answering benchmark datasets, experimental results of Self-BioRAG demonstrate significant performance gains by achieving a 7.2% absolute improvement on average over the state-of-the-art open-foundation model with a parameter size of 7B or less. Overall, we analyze that Self-BioRAG finds the clues in the question, retrieves relevant documents if needed, and understands how to answer with information from retrieved documents and encoded knowledge as a medical expert does. We release our data and code for training our framework components and model weights (7B and 13B) to enhance capabilities in biomedical and clinical domains.
Create account to get full access
Background
Proprietary & Open Language Models
Language models are machine learning models trained on vast amounts of text data to generate human-like language. Proprietary language models are developed and owned by companies, while open language models are publicly available.
Proprietary models are often more advanced but inaccessible to the general public. Open models allow for greater transparency and community research, but may lag behind in performance.
The paper discusses using retrieval-augmented large language models, which combine a language model with the ability to search and retrieve relevant information from a knowledge base. This allows the model to reason about problems by drawing on external knowledge in addition to its own language understanding.
Medical Reasoning and Challenges
Effective medical reasoning requires integrating multiple sources of information - medical knowledge, patient data, and contextual factors. This is challenging for language models, which may struggle to maintain coherence, reference relevant information, and justify their reasoning.
The paper aims to improve medical reasoning by enabling language models to self-reflect on their reasoning process and retrieve supporting evidence from a knowledge base.
Technical Explanation
The researchers developed a retrieval-augmented language model architecture called RAMed that can perform medical question answering tasks. RAMed consists of:
- A large language model for generating responses.
- A retrieval module that can search an external knowledge base and retrieve relevant passages.
- A self-reflection module that analyzes the model's reasoning process and potential biases.
During inference, RAMed first generates an initial response, then reflects on its reasoning and retrieves additional evidence from the knowledge base to refine and justify its answer. This iterative process aims to improve the model's medical reasoning capabilities.
The researchers evaluated RAMed on several medical question answering benchmarks and found it outperformed standard language models. The self-reflection and retrieval components were shown to contribute to improved performance.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a promising approach for enhancing language models' medical reasoning abilities. However, there are some limitations and areas for further research:
- The knowledge base used is relatively small and curated, so the model's performance may be constrained by the available information.
- The self-reflection mechanism is relatively simple and could be expanded to provide deeper insight into the model's reasoning process.
- The model was only evaluated on factual question answering tasks, and its performance on more open-ended or contextual medical reasoning tasks is unclear.
Further research could explore scaling the knowledge base, developing more sophisticated self-reflection mechanisms, and evaluating the model on a wider range of medical reasoning tasks.
Conclusion
This paper presents a retrieval-augmented language model architecture that aims to improve medical reasoning by enabling self-reflection and evidence retrieval. The model outperformed standard language models on medical question answering tasks, highlighting the potential of this approach.
By combining language understanding with external knowledge and self-evaluation, the researchers have taken an important step towards building more robust and transparent medical AI systems. Further advancements in this direction could lead to significant improvements in the reliability and interpretability of AI-powered medical decision support.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
BiomedRAG: A Retrieval Augmented Large Language Model for Biomedicine
Mingchen Li, Halil Kilicoglu, Hua Xu, Rui Zhang
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) have swiftly emerged as vital resources for different applications in the biomedical and healthcare domains; however, these models encounter issues such as generating inaccurate information or hallucinations. Retrieval-augmented generation provided a solution for these models to update knowledge and enhance their performance. In contrast to previous retrieval-augmented LMs, which utilize specialized cross-attention mechanisms to help LLM encode retrieved text, BiomedRAG adopts a simpler approach by directly inputting the retrieved chunk-based documents into the LLM. This straightforward design is easily applicable to existing retrieval and language models, effectively bypassing noise information in retrieved documents, particularly in noise-intensive tasks. Moreover, we demonstrate the potential for utilizing the LLM to supervise the retrieval model in the biomedical domain, enabling it to retrieve the document that assists the LM in improving its predictions. Our experiments reveal that with the tuned scorer,textsc{ BiomedRAG} attains superior performance across 5 biomedical NLP tasks, encompassing information extraction (triple extraction, relation extraction), text classification, link prediction, and question-answering, leveraging over 9 datasets. For instance, in the triple extraction task, textsc{BiomedRAG} outperforms other triple extraction systems with micro-F1 scores of 81.42 and 88.83 on GIT and ChemProt corpora, respectively.
5/6/2024
Tool Calling: Enhancing Medication Consultation via Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models
Zhongzhen Huang, Kui Xue, Yongqi Fan, Linjie Mu, Ruoyu Liu, Tong Ruan, Shaoting Zhang, Xiaofan Zhang
0
0
Large-scale language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success across various language tasks but suffer from hallucinations and temporal misalignment. To mitigate these shortcomings, Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has been utilized to provide external knowledge to facilitate the answer generation. However, applying such models to the medical domain faces several challenges due to the lack of domain-specific knowledge and the intricacy of real-world scenarios. In this study, we explore LLMs with RAG framework for knowledge-intensive tasks in the medical field. To evaluate the capabilities of LLMs, we introduce MedicineQA, a multi-round dialogue benchmark that simulates the real-world medication consultation scenario and requires LLMs to answer with retrieved evidence from the medicine database. MedicineQA contains 300 multi-round question-answering pairs, each embedded within a detailed dialogue history, highlighting the challenge posed by this knowledge-intensive task to current LLMs. We further propose a new textit{Distill-Retrieve-Read} framework instead of the previous textit{Retrieve-then-Read}. Specifically, the distillation and retrieval process utilizes a tool calling mechanism to formulate search queries that emulate the keyword-based inquiries used by search engines. With experimental results, we show that our framework brings notable performance improvements and surpasses the previous counterparts in the evidence retrieval process in terms of evidence retrieval accuracy. This advancement sheds light on applying RAG to the medical domain.
4/30/2024
🛸
New!MKRAG: Medical Knowledge Retrieval Augmented Generation for Medical Question Answering
Yucheng Shi, Shaochen Xu, Tianze Yang, Zhengliang Liu, Tianming Liu, Xiang Li, Ninghao Liu
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs), although powerful in general domains, often perform poorly on domain-specific tasks like medical question answering (QA). Moreover, they tend to function as black-boxes, making it challenging to modify their behavior. To address the problem, our study delves into retrieval augmented generation (RAG), aiming to improve LLM responses without the need for fine-tuning or retraining. Specifically, we propose a comprehensive retrieval strategy to extract medical facts from an external knowledge base, and then inject them into the query prompt for LLMs. Focusing on medical QA using the MedQA-SMILE dataset, we evaluate the impact of different retrieval models and the number of facts provided to the LLM. Notably, our retrieval-augmented Vicuna-7B model exhibited an accuracy improvement from 44.46% to 48.54%. This work underscores the potential of RAG to enhance LLM performance, offering a practical approach to mitigate the challenges of black-box LLMs.
7/1/2024
Empowering Large Language Models to Set up a Knowledge Retrieval Indexer via Self-Learning
Xun Liang, Simin Niu, Zhiyu li, Sensen Zhang, Shichao Song, Hanyu Wang, Jiawei Yang, Feiyu Xiong, Bo Tang, Chenyang Xi
0
0
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) offers a cost-effective approach to injecting real-time knowledge into large language models (LLMs). Nevertheless, constructing and validating high-quality knowledge repositories require considerable effort. We propose a pre-retrieval framework named Pseudo-Graph Retrieval-Augmented Generation (PG-RAG), which conceptualizes LLMs as students by providing them with abundant raw reading materials and encouraging them to engage in autonomous reading to record factual information in their own words. The resulting concise, well-organized mental indices are interconnected through common topics or complementary facts to form a pseudo-graph database. During the retrieval phase, PG-RAG mimics the human behavior in flipping through notes, identifying fact paths and subsequently exploring the related contexts. Adhering to the principle of the path taken by many is the best, it integrates highly corroborated fact paths to provide a structured and refined sub-graph assisting LLMs. We validated PG-RAG on three specialized question-answering datasets. In single-document tasks, PG-RAG significantly outperformed the current best baseline, KGP-LLaMA, across all key evaluation metrics, with an average overall performance improvement of 11.6%. Specifically, its BLEU score increased by approximately 14.3%, and the QE-F1 metric improved by 23.7%. In multi-document scenarios, the average metrics of PG-RAG were at least 2.35% higher than the best baseline. Notably, the BLEU score and QE-F1 metric showed stable improvements of around 7.55% and 12.75%, respectively. Our code: https://github.com/IAAR-Shanghai/PGRAG.
5/28/2024